Illegal "Self-Help" Evictions [2023]: Definition & Penalty Amount (2024)

A self-help eviction is when landlords take it upon themselves (without a court order) to evict a tenant from their rental unit—but is it legal? Read on to find out where (or if) it’s legal, and what happens if a landlord chooses to do one.

Table of Contents:

  • What It Is – What qualifies as a “self-help” eviction
  • Legality – Determining whether a self-help eviction is legal in your state
  • Financial Costs – Performing a self-help eviction can be costly for landlords

What is a “Self-Help” Eviction?

Throwing a tenant (or their belongings) out of the rental unit is called a “self-help” eviction because the landlord has taken it upon themselves to remove the tenant from their rental unit instead of getting a court order to remove the tenant.

This is different from a cash for keys agreement where the tenant agrees to move out in exchange for cash or a check.

Valid Reasons to Evict a Tenant

In most states, any one of the following is a valid reason to evict a tenant:

  • Violating the terms of a written lease/rental agreement
  • Failing to pay rent when due
  • Material health/safety violations
  • Involvement in illegal activity on the rental property
  • Domestic violence against another tenant
  • Remaining in the rental unit after the lease term or agreed-upon rental period has expired

Read more

However, just because a tenant has done something worthy of eviction in your state, that doesn’t automatically mean a landlord has the right to simply kick the tenant out and throw all their belongings out into the street.

Actions That Qualify as Self-Help Evictions

The following actions are examples of a landlord or property owner performing a self-help eviction:

  • Changing the locks without telling the tenant(s)
  • Removing the tenant’s belongings from the rental unit when they’re not home
  • Shutting off the tenant’s utilities for the sole purpose of forcing the tenant to move out
  • Refusing to perform necessary repairs in an attempt to get the tenant to move out
  • Or otherwise preventing the tenant(s) from physically entering or living in the rental unit

Some of the ways landlords could prevent tenants from living in or entering the rental unit include:

  • Boarding up exterior doors/windows
  • Removing exterior doors/windows
  • Removing interior or exterior walls/portions of walls
  • Otherwise damaging the rental unit to make it unsafe to live in

While the above examples may seem extreme, these actions have been specifically banned in several states, so someone somewhere has probably tried them.

Why Do Some Landlords Perform Self-Help Evictions?

Some landlords feel that it’s cheaper and/or faster than pursuing an eviction action through the court system.

And, if the landlord is being retaliatory or discriminatory, they may want to avoid a hearing because they know the court would rule in the tenant’s favor.

Other landlords may just be unaware of the laws in their state regarding the eviction process and may not even realize that a self-help eviction is illegal.

When an Immediate Eviction is NOT a Self-Help Eviction

Several states have special procedures in place for tenants who pose a serious threat to the landlord or other tenants. Typically, tenants who are involved in certain types of illegal activity, perpetrators of domestic violence, or tenants who harm/threaten to harm others fall into this category.

In these states, written notice may not be required prior to evicting the tenant. In some states, law enforcement officials may be called in to immediately remove the tenant, while others hold expedited hearings to remove the tenant within a few days of the harmful/illegal behavior.

Read more

Are Self-Help Evictions Legal?

Only Mississippi actually allows self-help evictions, and possibly West Virginia.

Mississippi landlords may only pursue a self-help eviction if the rental agreement has expired and the tenant remains in the rental unit, as long as the self-help eviction isn’t primarily to retaliate against the tenant.

Read more

In West Virginia, if landlords are allowed to perform self-help evictions, they could only be done for lease violations and nonpayment of rent, not to remove a tenant at the expiration of the lease term/rental period.

Read more

Legal Consequences of Self-Help Evictions

Landlords in any other state attempting to do a self-help eviction may find themselves being sued by their tenants, paying large fines, and/or being forced to allow the tenant to move back into the rental unit, depending on the state.

In Missouri , a landlord performing an illegal eviction is guilty of forcible entry and detainer, and faces the same penalties that any tenant found guilty of forcible entry and detainer would.

Although self-help evictions are illegal in all but two states, only four states consider them to be criminal acts. Connecticut, Minnesota, and New York all classify self-help evictions as misdemeanors.

In addition, Massachusetts landlords could face up to six months in jail if found guilty of performing an illegal (self-help) eviction.

Financial Costs of Self-Help Evictions

As noted above, self-help evictions are illegal in 48 states.

In 12 states and the District of Columbia, the maximum amount of damages a tenant can receive for being illegally evicted is up to the judicial officer and not set by law.

That means there’s no cap on how much a judicial officer could order a landlord to pay a tenant for trying to remove them from the rental unit illegally.

The 12 states with no limit on damages are:

  • Arkansas
  • Colorado
  • Georgia
  • Indiana
  • Louisiana
  • Missouri
  • New Jersey
  • Pennsylvania
  • Utah
  • Vermont
  • Wisconsin
  • Wyoming

In the other 36 states, there’s a cap on the amount of damages tenants can receive that’s set by state law.

The chart below breaks down the maximum allowable amounts in these 36 states.

StateMaximum Damages Tenant May Recover
Alabama1) 3 months’ rent or actual damages, whichever is greater, plus attorney’s fees

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

Alaska1) 1.5 times the amount of actual damages, plus attorney’s fees

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

Arizona1) 2 months’ rent or double the amount of actual damages, whichever is greater

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant

CaliforniaActual damages plus attorney fees AND $100 for each day the tenant is kept out of the rental unit
Connecticut1) 2 months’ rent or double the amount of actual damages, whichever is greater

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

Delaware1) Triple damages or an amount equal to 3 times the per diem rent for the amount of time the tenant was out of the rental unit, whichever is greater

2) Costs of the lawsuit (excluding attorney’s fees)

FloridaActual damages or 3 months’ rent, whichever is greater, plus attorney’s fees and court costs
Hawaii1) 2 months’ rent, court costs and attorney’s fees

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant

Idaho3 times the amount of actual damages
Illinois1) No rent owed during the time utilities are shut off

2) $300 or $5,000 divided by all tenants, whichever is less

Iowa1) Actual damages plus double the monthly rent payment and attorney’s fees

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

Kansas1) 1.5 times the monthly rent or actual damages, whichever is greater

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant

Kentucky1) 3 months’ rent plus attorney’s fees

2) Pre-paid rent must be returned to tenant

Maine1) Actual damages or $250, whichever is greater

2) Court costs and attorney’s fees

MarylandActual damages plus attorney’s fees and court costs
Massachusetts1) $300 fine

2) Actual damages or 3 months’ rent, whichever is greater

3) Court costs and attorney’s fees

MichiganActual damages or $200, whichever is greater
Minnesota1) $500 or triple the amount of actual damages, whichever is greater

2) Attorney’s fees

Montana1) Triple damages or 3 months’ rent, whichever is greater

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

Nebraska1) 3 months’ rent

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

Nevada1) Actual damages or $2,500 OR both

2) Court costs

New Hampshire1) $3,000 or actual damages, whichever is greater

2) Court costs and attorney’s fees

New Mexico1) Double the monthly rent

2) Court costs and attorney’s fees

New York$10,000 per violation
North CarolinaActual damages
North Dakota3 times the amount of actual damages
OhioActual damages plus attorney’s fees
Oklahoma1) 2 times the amount of actual damages or double the monthly rent, whichever is greater

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

Oregon1) 2 times the amount of actual damages or double the monthly rent, whichever is greater

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

Rhode Island1) 3 times the amount of actual damages or triple the monthly rent, whichever is greater

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

3) Attorney’s fees

South Carolina1) 3 months’ rent or twice the amount of actual damages plus attorney’s fees

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant

South Dakota1) 2 months’ rent

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

Tennessee1) Actual damages plus attorneys’ fees

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant plus any pre-paid rent

Texas1) One month’s rent plus $1,000

2) Actual damages

3) Attorney’s fees and court costs

Virginia1) Actual damages plus attorney’s fees

2) Security deposit must be returned to tenant

WashingtonActual damages plus attorney’s fees and court costs

As indicated in the chart above, some states allow tenants who have been illegally evicted to receive their security deposit and/or pre-paid rent as part of the damages owed to them by the landlord.

However, tenants in those states must decide whether they want to return to the rental unit (and allow the landlord to retain the security deposit and/or pre-paid rent), or if they want to live somewhere else and receive the security deposit and/or pre-paid rent from the landlord as part of the court settlement.

Landlords who choose to perform a self-help eviction could end up losing more than just a bad tenant—they may end up paying fines, court costs, attorney’s fees, and damages to their illegally evicted tenants. And, after all that, they may just find that the court has ordered them to allow the tenant to move back into the rental unit.

For tenants who violate lease provisions, fail to pay rent on time, or are involved in illegal activity, it’s best to follow the laws of whatever state the rental unit is in and legally evict a tenant, even if it does take a little more time than a self-help eviction.

Illegal "Self-Help" Evictions [2023]: Definition & Penalty Amount (2024)

FAQs

What is the penalty for illegal eviction in California? ›

A landlord who illegally evicts a tenant may be liable for several civil penalties including $100 a day under Civil Code Section 789.3(c), as well as a one-time penalty of $2000 under Civil Code Section 1940.2, and any additional damages the tenant may suffer such as relocation or temporary housings expenses.

What is the penalty for illegal eviction in NYC? ›

The maximum penalty for illegal evictions under NY Code 26-251 is 1 year in prison and a fine of $1000.00 or double the gain from the crime, whichever is greater. An additional civil penalty of between $1000.00 and $10,000.00 may be imposed.

Which of the following is an example of a self-help eviction? ›

Examples of illegal "self-help" evictions include changing the locks, taking the tenant's belongings, removing the front door, or turning off the heat or electricity.

What is self-help eviction Georgia? ›

Self-Help eviction is when the landlord evicts someone from their home without going through the courts. In the State of Georgia, someone cannot legally be forced out of your place of residence unless the landlord has followed specific rules and laws to evict.

How much can I sue a landlord for wrongful eviction in California? ›

In California, punitive damages can be up to $100 per day of violation and at least $250 per separate violation.

What is the new eviction law in California? ›

The new policy will block evictions until February 2024 for tenants who have unauthorized pets or who added residents who aren't listed on leases. Landlords will also have to serve a 30-day “notice to cure” before evicting a tenant for unauthorized occupants or pets, giving the tenant the opportunity to fix the issue.

How long can you not pay rent before eviction NYC? ›

Eviction for Nonpayment of Rent

The notice must state that the tenant has 14 days to pay rent or move out of the rental unit. If the tenant does not pay the rent or move out of the rental unit within the 14 days, the landlord can begin eviction proceedings against the tenant (see N.Y. Real Prop. Acts § 711(2)).

How long does an eviction stay on your record in NYC? ›

The Effect of Evictions on Credit History

Evictions can also be reported to credit reporting agencies and may appear on a person's credit report as a public record. The duration of time that evictions stay on a person's credit history is generally seven years from the date the eviction was filed.

How much does it cost to evict someone in NY? ›

The Sheriff's Office handles evictions that involve the enforcement of a court order or warrant. The fee for performing an eviction is $140.

How long does an eviction stay on your record in California? ›

How Long Does an Eviction Stay on Your Record? An eviction itself doesn't appear on your credit report. However, any unpaid rent and fees could be sent to collections and remain on your credit report for seven years from the original delinquency date.

How long can a tenant stay after eviction notice in California? ›

After the Writ of Execution has been served to the tenants, they will be given a grace period of 5 days to vacate the property. The sheriff will execute the eviction and forcibly remove them if they remain in the property after the grace period given to them.

What is an example of self help in law? ›

An example of self-help is repossession. As long as it does not involve unlawful actions or a breach of the peace, self-help is legal. Self-help is not the same as self-defense and may not be exercised in circ*mstances that might reasonably be expected to lead to violence or a breach of the peace.

What does self evicted mean? ›

Self-Evicted Tenant means a household that has voluntarily vacated their rental unit, including units vacated in violation of a lease agreement.

What are the squatters rights in Georgia? ›

Squatters may claim legal ownership of the property they are occupying after a certain amount of time has passed through a process called adverse possession. In Georgia, squatters may claim adverse possession after 20 years of continuous occupation or just seven years with a color of title.

What happens when the sheriff comes to evict you in Georgia? ›

The sheriff puts a Georgia eviction notice on the front door to notify the tenants that the dispossessory action has been filed by the landlord and the tenant notice period to respond is seven days. If the tenant fails in their legal obligation and does not respond, we can get the Writ of Possession from the judge.

What is an illegal eviction in Georgia? ›

Landlords cannot evict a tenant without receiving a court order. It is illegal for a landlord to try to evict a tenant through any other means, such as shutting off utilities (see OCGA § 44-7-14.1) or changing the locks at the rental unit. Such actions are called self-help evictions.

How long does a landlord have to sue a tenant for damages California? ›

Generally, a landlord has up to 4 to 6 years to sue for damages as long as they have proof of the damage incurred by the tenant and records of the cost of repairs.

What are your rights as a tenant without a lease in California? ›

Even if you don't have a lease, a California landlord can't kick you to a curb without warning. If the landlord wants you gone, he's required to give you at least 30 days' notice on a month-to-month tenancy. There are exceptions, though -- circ*mstances in which the landlord can give you just three days to get out.

What are the new rent laws in California 2023? ›

Under the provisions of the TPA, landlords are allowed to increase rents each year by 5% plus the applicable average increase in the cost of living in order to allow for inflation. There is a maximum increase of 10% allowed in any given year, thus the Act's provision is often referred to as a “rent cap.”

What happens after 3 day eviction notice California? ›

If the tenant does not pay the rent within 3 days of receiving the 3-day period, he or she must still move out in 30 days. If the tenant does not move out after the 30 days, then the landlord has to file an unlawful detainer case.

Do I have 30 days to move after an eviction in California? ›

In California, eviction actions are called unlawful detainer cases in court. Under state law, a landlord must give their tenant at least 30 days' notice that they need to move out and specify when their tenancy will end.

How long does a landlord have to sue for unpaid rent in NY? ›

Effective April 7, 2022, the New York statute of limitations for debt/rent collection lawsuits arising out of a consumer credit transaction is reduced from six years to three years.

Do I have to pay rent after eviction notice NYC? ›

This notice gives the tenant fourteen days to either pay rent in full or vacate the premises. If the tenant does not pay the rent or vacate and surrender the premises, the landlord can then file a summary nonpayment proceeding with the court at the end of the fourteen days pursuant to N.Y.

How long does it take to get evicted for not paying rent in California? ›

The eviction process can take 30 - 45 days, or longer. The time starts from when you have eviction court forms delivered to your tenant to the time they must move out. Choose any box, below, to learn more about the eviction process and get step-by-step instructions.

Do evictions show up on credit karma? ›

If you've experienced an eviction, the removal process and judgement won't appear on your credit reports. However, there are some potential consequences of an eviction that may still appear on your credit reports and impact your scores.

What is the legal eviction process in New York State? ›

Overview. In New York State, an eviction of a tenant is lawful only if an owner has brought a court proceeding and obtained a judgment of possession from the court. A sheriff, marshal or constable can carry out a court ordered eviction. An owner may not evict a tenant by use of force or unlawful means.

How do I stop an eviction in NY? ›

Even if the judge signs a Warrant of Eviction, you may still be able to stop the eviction. If you are being evicted for “Nonpayment of Rent,” you can stop the eviction by paying all of the rent that is owed. You can do this any time up until the Warrant of Eviction is executed.

Is a 3 day eviction notice legal in NY? ›

3-Day Notice

The first kind of New York Eviction Notice is called a “Demand for Rent.” A 3-Day Demand for Rent is required under the New York eviction process in cases of nonpayment of rent.

What are squatters rights in NYC? ›

New York's squatters' law allows homeless people and anyone else who attempts to establish residence on someone else's property, limited rights that will help them avoid a trespassing charge. In addition, squatters help their case to remain on the property properly maintain it while they are living there.

What are the benefits of renting a home? ›

Benefits of renting often include:
  • Rent payments tend to be lower than a comparable house payment.
  • Utility costs may be included in rental fee, creating additional savings.
  • Relocation is easier.
  • Maintenance and repairs are not your responsibility.
  • Credit requirements are less strict.

What is Experian rentbureau? ›

Collects rent payment history data from property owners and residential real estate managers, electronic rent payment services and collection companies, and makes that information available to the multifamily housing industry through tenant screening companies.

What are the benefits of renting an apartment? ›

  • 1) No Maintenance Costs or Repair Bills.
  • 2) Access to Amenities.
  • 3) No Real Estate Taxes.
  • 4) No Down Payment.
  • 5) More Flexibility As to Where to Live.
  • 6) Few Concerns About Decreasing Property Value.
  • 7) Flexibility to Downsize.
  • 8) Fixed Rent Amount.

How much money does a landlord have to give a tenant to move out in California? ›

If your landlord evicts you for one of these reasons, they must first give you one month's rent or waive one month's rent to help you move out. What notice does the landlord have to provide me?

How long are evictions taking in California in 2023? ›

It typically takes at least 30 to 45 days to evict a tenant in California, from the time you start the process to the day they move out.

Can I evict a tenant in California in 2023? ›

Starting April 1, 2023, landlords are required to serve tenants with a written 30-Day Notice prior to filing an eviction based on nonpayment of rent for rent accrued between July 1, 2022 and March 31, 2023.

What is considered self-help? ›

Self-help or self-improvement is a self-guided improvement—economically, physically, intellectually, and emotionally—often with a substantial psychological basis.

What is the law disfavors self-help? ›

California law disfavors and expressly prohibits a landlord from entering into self-help remedies. For example, a landlord cannot just show up and change the locks when a tenant has not paid rent. Shutting off a tenant's utilities is another form of self-help which a landlord cannot engage in.

What is a self-help remedy? ›

1 Self-help remedies have been defined as “legally permissible conduct that individuals. undertake absent the compulsion of law and without the assistance of a government official. in efforts to prevent or remedy a civil wrong.”

What is an illegal lockout California? ›

Civil Code § 789.3 prohibits a landlord from changing the locks, shutting off the water or utilities, moving a tenant's belongings into the yard or street, or removing exterior doors or windows, in order to force a tenant out.

Can a landlord evict you without going to court in California? ›

Under California law, the only lawful way to evict a tenant is to file a case in court. As a tenant, you have a right to remain in your home until a court orders you to move out.

What happens when the sheriff comes to evict you in California? ›

Any property of the tenant left on the premises will be turned over to the landlord for storage. After the eviction is completed, the Sheriff will provide the landlord with a receipt for possession and send the writ together the Sheriff's return to the issuing court. A proof of service is not issued.

How long can an eviction stay on your record in California? ›

How Long Does an Eviction Stay on Your Record? An eviction itself doesn't appear on your credit report. However, any unpaid rent and fees could be sent to collections and remain on your credit report for seven years from the original delinquency date.

Can I sue my landlord for renting an illegal apartment California? ›

Most likely, the owner will be fined for violating local zoning requirements. Eviction liability. The landlord will be required to evict the tenant from the illegal unit. If this is the case, the tenant will have the right to sue the landlord for violating the terms of the rental agreement.

What can happen to a landlord if they lock out a tenant in California? ›

Under California Civil Code 789.3, you can sue your landlord for punitive damages, plus attorney fees for each day you are locked out of your apartment.

How do I stop a sheriff lockout in California? ›

Ask for more time to move. If you lose your eviction case, you need to move out (at the latest) 5 days after the sheriff posts a Notice to Vacate on your door. If you need more time to move, you can ask the court for a stay of execution. You will need to show the court that you have a good reason for needing more time.

What is considered a no fault eviction California? ›

A “no fault” reason is defined as any eviction where the notice to end the tenancy is not based on any alleged fault by the tenant. This protection applies irrespective of whether the tenant has experienced any COVID-19-related difficulties and regardless of household income until March 31, 2023.

What is a no fault just cause eviction in California? ›

No-fault Just Causes are: (1) Intent to occupy the property by the owner or spouse, domestic partner, children, grandchildren, parents or grandparents; (2) Withdrawal from the rental market; (3) Compliance with order from the government to vacate; (4) Intent to demolish or substantially remodel.

How long does it take to evict someone in California right now? ›

If your tenant won't fix the problem or move out, you'll have to go through the court to get an order for them to move out. The eviction process can take 30 - 45 days, or longer. The time starts from when you have eviction court forms delivered to your tenant to the time they must move out.

Can you fight an eviction notice California? ›

Defenses you can use in an eviction court case. If you want to file an Answer (form UD-105) to an eviction lawsuit and defend yourself in court, you'll need to give a defense (the legal reason you shouldn't be evicted). You can have more than one defense.

Can you get an eviction removed in California? ›

If your tenant moves out before you've gone to trial, you have to cancel or close (dismiss) your eviction court case. If they owe you money you can file in small claims court or civil court to try to collect the money.

How long can you not pay rent before eviction in California? ›

If the tenant doesn't pay rent when it is due, the landlord can give the tenant a three-day notice to pay rent or quit (move out). This notice informs the tenant that the tenant has three days to pay rent in full or move out.

What is the longest an eviction can take? ›

Constable returns possession of property to landlord.

Evicting a tenant in California can take around five to eight weeks, depending on the type of eviction. If tenants request a continuance or jury trial, the process can take longer.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kieth Sipes

Last Updated:

Views: 6224

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (47 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kieth Sipes

Birthday: 2001-04-14

Address: Suite 492 62479 Champlin Loop, South Catrice, MS 57271

Phone: +9663362133320

Job: District Sales Analyst

Hobby: Digital arts, Dance, Ghost hunting, Worldbuilding, Kayaking, Table tennis, 3D printing

Introduction: My name is Kieth Sipes, I am a zany, rich, courageous, powerful, faithful, jolly, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.