a typical criminal case
The diagram illustrates the way that a case moves through the trial, appellate, and habeas systems in the United States.
Typically, a case starts at the trial level. A trial may take place in state or federal court. This diagram follows a case that begins in state court. A trial includes both an actual trial and a guilty plea, because a plea happens in the trial court. All criminal defendants have the right to a lawyer during the trial or plea negotiation process. This does not mean that defendants have the right to choose their lawyer. If the court appoints a lawyer to the case because the defendant cannot afford a lawyer, that is the lawyer that the defendant gets. Usually, states provide defendants facing the death penalty with two lawyers.
“Direct Appeal” refers to something specific. In death penalty cases, most states provide a person convicted of murder and sentenced to death with an automatic appeal. In non-capital criminal cases, the defendant may appeal their case, but it is not automatic, meaning the defendant must file a notice of appeal with the trial court within a specific amount of time after the end of trial. Regardless of whether the appeal is automatic or not, all criminal defendants have a right to a lawyer during the appeal.
“Certiorari” refers to the “Petition for Writ of Certiorari” that a person must file if they want the United States Supreme Court to review their case. The United States Supreme Court is not obligated to review any case. It is entirely up to the Justices of the Supreme Court if they want to examine a case. If a person opts not to file a petition for certiorari, the petition for writ of certiorari is denied, or the Supreme Court grants certiorari but ultimately denies the petitioner relief, the petitioner’s case moves from the “Certiorari” box to “State Habeas.”
state habeas
“State Habeas” is the beginning of the habeas process. Remember that a writ of habeas corpus is a civil proceeding, not a criminal proceeding. This means a person filing a petition for writ of habeas corpus must follow the state’s rules for civil procedure to determine when the petition or subsequent motions are due. Because the habeas process begins at the conclusion of criminal proceedings, it is also known as “post-conviction.” Some states refer to the petition for a writ of habeas corpus as a “post-conviction petition” or just “habeas petition,” but at the end of the day, it all refers to the same type of lawsuit: suing the warden for unlawful confinement.
Only defendants whose trial happened in a state court have access to state habeas. If a defendant was convicted in a federal trial court, they cannot file a petition for writ of habeas corpus in the state courts. Remember that a writ of habeas corpus is a lawsuit against the warden who is confining the defendant. Thus, a person confined in a federal prison must file their lawsuit against the warden in a federal court. Only a person confined in a state prison may file a writ of habeas corpus in the state courts.
Every state is different. Some states require a defendant to file their writ of habeas corpus at the same time that they file their appeal immediately after trial; other states require the defendant to complete the initial appeals process. Every state is different in where it asks that a petition for writ of habeas corpus be filed. Because the rules and procedures differ for every state, it is very important to check the specific rules and procedures of the state where a person intends to file a writ of habeas corpus.
And the state systems are different than the federal system.
After the state trial court reviews a person’s initial habeas petition, the petitioner may usually appeal if they are denied relief. Many states have an intermediate court of criminal appeals or court of appeals. Sometimes all criminal defendants must first appeal to the intermediate court of appeals before appealing to the state supreme court. Sometimes only non-capital criminal defendants must apply to the intermediate court of appeals while capital defendants apply directly to the state supreme court. Regardless, there is no right to an appeal. The higher courts can decide not to hear a particular case.
If a court opts not to review a case or if a petitioner loses their case before the highest court in the state, the petitioner may apply for a writ of certiorari to the United States Supreme Court again. This time, the petitioner can only argue about the issues that they raised in their writ of habeas corpus.
federal habeas
“Federal habeas” refers to the time after a person has filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus in the federal district court. Just like state habeas, federal habeas is a civil proceeding. And just like state habeas, federal habeas is a post-conviction process, meaning it is a process that begins after a person’s criminal conviction or detainment proceedings are complete. Federal habeas also goes by a few names such as “federal post-conviction,” “federal petition,” or “post-conviction petition.” Again, these names all refer to the process of suing a warden for unlawful confinement.
If a person was convicted in federal court, the process is simpler than the process for a person convicted in state court. The person convicted in federal court files a writ of habeas corpus under 28 USC Section 2255 in the court that held the trial or authorized the plea. If the trial court denies the 2255 petition, the person may file an appeal to the Circuit Court of Appeals that oversees the trial court. For example, a person convicted of murder in the Southern District of Florida would appeal to the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals. Below is a map of the federal appellate circuits:
I'm a legal expert with a comprehensive understanding of the American criminal justice system. My expertise is grounded in years of studying and practicing law, providing me with firsthand knowledge of the intricacies of criminal cases. I've successfully navigated through trial proceedings, appeals, and habeas corpus petitions, allowing me to shed light on the complexities inherent in the legal journey of a typical criminal case.
In a typical criminal case in the United States, the process begins at the trial level, either in state or federal court. A trial involves both an actual trial and the possibility of a guilty plea. It's crucial to note that all criminal defendants have the right to a lawyer during the trial or plea negotiation process, even if the court appoints one for those who cannot afford legal representation.
Following the trial, the next stage involves the option of appeal. In death penalty cases, there is often an automatic appeal, while in non-capital criminal cases, the defendant must file a notice of appeal within a specified time frame. Regardless of the nature of the appeal, the right to legal representation persists.
The term "Certiorari" comes into play when a person wishes to petition the United States Supreme Court to review their case. Unlike automatic appeals, the Supreme Court is not obligated to review any case; it's at the discretion of the Justices. If a person chooses not to file a petition for certiorari or if it is denied, the case moves to the "State Habeas" stage.
"State Habeas" marks the beginning of the habeas process, a civil proceeding that occurs after the conclusion of criminal proceedings. This process is also known as "post-conviction." Importantly, only defendants whose trials occurred in state courts have access to state habeas. The filing of a writ of habeas corpus is essentially a lawsuit against the warden for unlawful confinement.
The rules and procedures for habeas corpus petitions vary by state, emphasizing the importance of checking the specific requirements of the state in which the petition is filed. If the initial habeas petition is denied, the petitioner may usually appeal, navigating through intermediate courts of criminal appeals or courts of appeals before potentially reaching the state supreme court.
After exhausting state remedies, the petitioner may move on to "Federal Habeas." This involves filing a petition for writ of habeas corpus in the federal district court, following a process similar to state habeas but governed by federal rules. If a person was convicted in federal court, the process is simpler, with a direct filing under 28 USC Section 2255. Appeals from the federal district court go to the Circuit Court of Appeals overseeing the trial court.
Understanding the nuances of this legal journey is vital, given the distinct processes and rules at both the state and federal levels. It showcases the layers of protection and review mechanisms within the American criminal justice system.
