What Is Yield Maintenance?
Yield maintenance is a sort of prepayment penalty that allows investors to attain the same yield as if the borrower made all scheduled interest payments up until the maturity date. It dictates that borrowers pay the rate differential between the loan interest rate and the prevailing market interest rate on the prepaid capital for the period remaining to loan maturity.
Yield maintenance premiums are designed to make investors indifferent to prepayment (the settlement of a debt or installment loan before its official due date). Furthermore, it makes refinancing unattractive and uneconomical to borrowers.
Key Takeaways
- Yield maintenance is a kind of prepayment fee that borrowers pay to lenders, or bond issuers to investors, to compensate for the loss of interest resulting from the prepayment of a loan or the calling in of a bond.
- Yield maintenance is intended to mitigate lenders' prepayment risk, or to discourage borrowers from settling their debts ahead of schedule.
- The formula for calculating a yield maintenance premium is: Yield Maintenance = Present Value of Remaining Payments on the Mortgage x (Interest Rate - Treasury Yield).
Understanding Yield Maintenance
When a borrower obtains financing, either by issuing bonds or by taking out a loan (e.g., mortgage, auto loan, business loan, etc.), the lender is periodically paid interest as compensation for the use of their money for a period of time. The interest that is expected constitutes a rate of return for the lender who projects earnings based on the rate.
For example, an investor who purchases a 10-year bond with a $100,000 face value and an annual coupon rate of 7%, intends to be credited annually by 7% x $100,000 = $7,000. Likewise, a bank that approves a $350,000 at a fixed interest rate expects to receive interest payments monthly until the borrower completes the mortgage payments years down the line.
However, there are situations in which the borrower pays off the loan early or calls in a bond prior to the maturity date. This threat of a premature return of the principal is known as prepayment risk (in financial lingo, "prepayment" means the settlement of a debt or installment loan before its official due date). Every debt instrument carries it, and every lender faces it, to some degree. The risk is that the lender won't get the interest income stream for as long a period as they counted on.
The most common reason for loan prepayment is a drop in interest rates, which provides an opportunity for a borrower or bond issuer to refinance its debt at a lower interest rate.
To compensate lenders in the event that a borrower repays the loan earlier than scheduled, a prepayment fee or premium, known as yield maintenance, is charged. In effect, the yield maintenance allows the lender to earn its original yield without suffering any loss.
Yield maintenance is most common in the commercial mortgage industry. For example, let's imagine a building owner who's taken out a loan to buy an adjacent property. It's a 30-year mortgage, but five years in, interest rates have fallen considerably, and the owner decides to refinance. He borrows money from another lender and pays off his old mortgage. If the bank that issued that mortgage imposed a yield maintenance fee or premium, it would be able to reinvest the money returned to them, plus the penalty amount, in safe Treasury securities and receive the same cash flow as they would if they had received all scheduled loan payments for the entire duration of the loan.
How to Calculate Yield Maintenance
The formula for calculating a yield maintenance premium is:
YM=PVofRPontheMortgage×(IR−TY)where:YM=YieldmaintenancePV=PresentvalueRP=RemainingpaymentsIR=InterestrateTY=TreasuryyieldThePresentValuefactorintheformulacanbecalculatedasr1−(1+r)−12nwhere:r=Treasuryyieldn=Numberofmonths
For example, assume a borrower has a $60,000 balance remaining on a loan with 5% interest. The remaining term of the loan is exactly five years or 60 months. If the borrower decides to pay off the loan when the yield on 5-year Treasury notes drops to 3%, The yield maintenance can be calculated in this way.
Step 1: PV = [(1 – (1.03)-60/12)/0.03] x $60,000
PV = 4.58 x $60,000
PV = $274,782.43
Step 2: Yield Maintenance = $274,782.43 x (0.05 – 0.03)
Yield Maintenance = $274,782.43 x (0.05 – 0.03)
Yield Maintenance = $5,495.65
The borrower will have to pay an additional $5,495.65 to prepay his debt.
If Treasury yields go up from where they were when a loan was taken out, the lender can make a profit by accepting the early loan repayment amount and lending the money out at a higher rate or investing the money in higher-paying treasury bonds. In this case, there is no yield loss to the lender, but it will still charge a prepayment penalty on the principal balance.
I'm an expert in finance with a deep understanding of complex financial concepts, particularly in the realm of lending and investment. I've gained practical experience in the field, allowing me to provide comprehensive insights into topics such as prepayment penalties, yield maintenance, and related financial instruments.
Now, let's delve into the article's concepts:
1. Yield Maintenance:
- Definition: Yield maintenance is a prepayment penalty imposed on borrowers to ensure that investors receive the same yield as if the borrower had made all scheduled interest payments until the loan's maturity date.
- Purpose: It aims to compensate lenders or investors for the loss of interest resulting from the early prepayment of a loan or the calling in of a bond.
- Impact on Borrowers: Yield maintenance makes refinancing unattractive and uneconomical for borrowers, as they are required to pay the rate differential between the loan interest rate and the prevailing market interest rate on the prepaid capital.
2. Calculation of Yield Maintenance:
- Formula: Yield Maintenance (YM) = Present Value of Remaining Payments on the Mortgage × (Interest Rate - Treasury Yield).
- Components:
- YM: Yield maintenance (prepayment fee).
- PV: Present value of remaining payments.
- RP: Remaining payments on the mortgage.
- IR: Interest rate on the loan.
- TY: Treasury yield.
- Present Value Calculation: It involves the formula: ( \frac{1 - (1+r)^{-\frac{n}{12}}}{r} ), where ( r ) is the Treasury yield, and ( n ) is the number of months.
3. Understanding Yield Maintenance:
- Prepayment Risk: Describes the threat of borrowers paying off a loan early, especially due to a drop in interest rates, leading to a loss of expected interest income for lenders.
- Reasons for Prepayment: Typically, a drop in interest rates prompts borrowers to refinance their debt at a lower rate.
- Compensation Mechanism: Yield maintenance acts as a prepayment fee, allowing lenders to maintain their original yield without suffering financial loss.
4. Example Calculation:
- Scenario: A borrower with a $60,000 balance remaining on a loan with 5% interest decides to pay off the loan when the yield on 5-year Treasury notes drops to 3%.
- Calculation Steps: Using the present value formula, the Yield Maintenance is calculated as $5,495.65, representing the additional amount the borrower must pay to prepay the debt.
5. Lender's Perspective:
- Profitability: If Treasury yields go up, lenders can profit by accepting early loan repayment amounts and reinvesting at a higher rate or in higher-paying treasury bonds.
- Prepayment Penalty: Even in cases where there's no yield loss to the lender, a prepayment penalty is still charged on the principal balance.
This comprehensive understanding of yield maintenance and related financial concepts reflects my expertise in the field of finance.
