Try Title vs. Quieting Title: What’s the difference? | JD Supra (2024)

Try Title vs. Quieting Title: What’s the difference? | JD Supra (1)

[co-author: Travis Nadalni]*

If you aren’t quite sure about the difference between trespass to try title and suit to quiet title, Lockhart as Tr. of Lockhart Fam. Bypass Tr. v. Chisos Mins., LLC explains. But first, …

The facts

Warren Lockhart died. His Will gave his residuary estate to the “Trustee(s) of the Bypass Trust created under the Lockhart Family Trust Agreement.” The residuary estate included mineral and royalty interests in Section 38 in Howard County. His widow Jean was appointed independent executor.

On the day they signed the Will, Warren and Jean executed a Restatement of the Lockhart Family Trust. Upon the death of the first die, the trust estate was to be divided into two separate trusts, one of which was the Bypass Trust. The Section 38 interests were allocated to the Bypass Trust. Upon the death of the survivor the remaining trust estate was to be divided among six beneficiaries.

Jean then executed a Distribution Deed with special warranty transferring the Section 38 interests individually and as executor of Warren’s Estate. Despite references to the mineral estate, the property description included the surface estate only. A First Correction Deed and Second Correction Deed were executed and filed of record to correct the legal description. All three deeds were effective as of October 22, 2002. Neither Correction Deed was signed by the grantees. The interests were later conveyed to Chisos Minerals and others.

Jean sued Chisos and the others for trespass to try title, rescission and cancellation of the Second Correction Deed, and to quiet title. The court denied Jean’s motion for summary judgment, granted Chisos’, quieted Title to the Section 38 interests, and ordered that Jean take nothing. The court emphasized the often-misunderstood distinction between a trespass to try title claim and an action to quiet title.

What’s the Difference?

A trespass to try title action is the method of determining title to lands. It is typically used to clear problems in the chain of title or to recover land unlawfully held from a rightful owner. In fact, Texas courts have recently interpreted this cause of action to be the exclusively remedy for resolving competing claims to ownership of real property.

An action to quiet title, on the other hand, challenges an adverse interest that impacts title and possssion only indirectly. Any claim or potential claim to ownership of property is a “cloud.” The party that owns the property can dispute the “cloud” by claiming that it is invalid or unenforceable. In such instance, the title holder can file an action to “quiet title” to remove the cloud from the title. This action relies on the invalidity of the defendant’s claim to the property. The action has the equitable effect of declaring invalid or ineffective the defendant’s claim to title.

Put simply, a trespass to try title claim is a legal procedure for challenging the ownership of property, while an action to quiet title is an equitable remedy for establishing one’s right to ownership of real property against other adverse claimants.

Action to Quiet Title:

To prevail on an action to quiet title, the plaintiff must show:

(1) an interest in a specific property;

(2) title to the property is affected by a claim by the defendant; AND

(3) the claim, although facially valid, is invalid or unenforceable.

Trespass to Try Title

To prevail on a trespass to try title claim, the plaintiff must first establish that the real property interest is the proper subject for a trespass to try title action. To do this, the plaintiff must show an actual possession of the real property; constructive possession will not suffice. Then, the plaintiff may recover by provding or proving:

(1) a regular chain of conveyances from the sovereign;

(2) a superior title out of a common source;

(3) title by limitations; OR

(4) prior possession that has not been abandoned.

The plaintiff must ultimately recover upon the strength of her own title—not the weakness of the defense.

Jean’s trespass to try title claim was not actionable because the Section 38 interest was non-possessory (But on Chisos’ motion for summary judgment, Chisos bore the burden to raise the issue).

Trespass to try title adjudicates title or the right of possession of real property. Because Chisos only asserted ownership of a nonpossessory royalty and reversionary interest, Jean’s suit was not actionable. Yet, Chisos’ take-nothing relief was only proper if it either conclusively negated Jean’s action or conclusively established an affirmative defense to that action. Chisos failed to do so, and the court precluded Chisos from raising the non-possessory argument on appeal.

Three strikes and yer out on appeal

Her swing-for-the-fences appeal argued that the deeds were not effective for other reasons: (1) She did not sign in her capacity as trustee; thus, the deeds did not convey any interest held by the trustee. (2) The deeds were merely a quitclaim. (3) The Correction Deeds made material changes to the Distribution Deed and thus failed to comply with the Texas Correction Instrument Statutes. The opinion explains why these assertiions failed.

Your overly long and in-the-weeds musial interlude(s): a 95-year old blues original, a treatment from an unlikely source, and a special version.

*Summer Associate

[View source.]

Try Title vs. Quieting Title: What’s the difference? | JD Supra (2024)

FAQs

Try Title vs. Quieting Title: What’s the difference? | JD Supra? ›

Put simply, a trespass to try title claim is a legal procedure for challenging the ownership of property, while an action to quiet title is an equitable remedy for establishing one's right to ownership of real property against other adverse claimants. (3) the claim, although facially valid, is invalid or unenforceable.

What is the difference between a suit to quiet title and a trespass to try title in Texas? ›

An action to quiet title is different from a trespass to try title because a trespass to try title is a legal procedure for challenging the ownership of a certain property, but in a suit to quiet title, a claimant seeks to remove a defect in their chain of title such as an improper deed and so on.

What is the meaning of quieting of title? ›

A quiet title action is a special legal proceeding to determine ownership of real property. A party with a claim of ownership to land can file an action to quiet title, which serves as a sort of lawsuit against anyone and everyone else who has a claim to the land.

Who is most likely to use a quiet title suit? ›

Quiet title actions are common following mortgage lender disputes, the death of title owners, cases of adverse possession, and long periods of time where the property is unoccupied. A quiet title action may not give the new owner the same level of protection against the previous owner.

What are title disputes over real estate interests which are resolved by a quiet title action? ›

Quiet title actions aim to resolve disputes over real estate ownership by removing any “clouds” on the title to real estate. These “clouds” can include items such as liens on the property, title disputes, boundary disputes, claims by previous owners, and other claims of ownership to the property.

When would a suit to quiet title typically be filed? ›

It is used when there is a dispute over the title for a piece of property; it is designed to “quiet” claims to the property in question and decide who has ownership. You can also file for a quiet title action when there are breaks in the chain of ownership, such as when you purchase property in an estate sale.

What is a suit to try title in Texas? ›

In a trespass-to-try-title action, the plaintiff is required to prove his or her title by proving (1) a regular chain of title of conveyances from the sovereign to the plaintiff; (2) a superior title to that of the defendant out of a common source; (3) title by limitations; or (4) prior possession which has not been ...

What is an example of a quiet title action? ›

As an example of a quiet title, there could be a Contractor whose primary job is flipping a house, meaning that Contractor A purchases a home for a low price, makes necessary home improvements, and then turns around and sells the home for a profit.

What is a suit to quiet title in Texas? ›

A suit to quiet title provides an equitable remedy to clear a title of an invalid, unenforceable charge against it. Tex. Prop. Code Ann. §§ 22.001 to 22.004, 22.021 to 22.024, 22.041 to 22.045.

What are the elements of quiet title? ›

Necessary Elements of a Quiet Title Claim
  • A description of the property that is the subject of the action. ...
  • The title of the Plaintiff as to which a determination of quiet title is sought.
  • The adverse claims to the Plaintiff's title. ...
  • The date as of which the determination is sought.

How do you become successful in quiet title action? ›

§761.020], a quiet title action must be well-supported. To file a successful quiet title action claim, you will need to provide a detailed description of the property at issue in the title dispute. Beyond that, you also should gather and organize all relevant property records.

What are the elements of the quiet title cause of action? ›

An element of a cause of action for quiet title is “the adverse claims to the title of the plaintiff against which a determination is sought.” (Orcilla v. Big Sur, Inc. (2016) 244 Cal. App.

What document shows legal alienation of a property? ›

Voluntary alienation, either as a sale or a gift, must be executed by the use of a deed to transfer title. The deed is a written document that conveys transfer of title in real estate.

What is quieting used for? ›

Quieting title basically silences any adverse title claims. This is done by settling the claim or by judicial decree. This is often completed through court actions that are similar to civil litigation cases. Most of the time, the procedure, evidence, and people involved are fairly straightforward.

What can buyers do to protect themselves from title issues when purchasing property? ›

An owner's title insurance policy is what protects you after you buy the property. It protects you in case any liens or claims are filed or discovered after the property becomes yours. Title insurance is a one-time fee often included with closing costs when you buy your home.

Which of the following would be a serious cloud on title? ›

Examples of clouds on title include a property's address being misspelled in a deed conveying title, a mortgage lien whose repayment hasn't been officially recorded, a deed which has been signed but hasn't been properly recorded, an easem*nt that has not been properly recorded, unpaid property taxes, a failure to ...

What general jurisdiction is a quiet title? ›

A quiet title action must be brought in the superior court of the county in which the real property is located. This is usually in the general, unlimited civil jurisdiction department of the local superior court.

Which party at closing requires the property to be free and clear of encumbrances and requires title insurance and hazard insurance? ›

The lender requires the property to be free and clear of encumbrances, and will require title insurance and hazard insurance to protect the lender's investment (the loan).

What are the two forms of owner's title insurance? ›

Two basic types of title insurance policies are available to owners of real property in California: (1) a standard coverage policy and (2) an extended coverage policy.

Is trespassing to try title adverse possession in Texas? ›

The only issues involved in a Texas trespass to try title lawsuit are title and possession. The claimant must “rely on the strength of his or her own title and not any weakness of the defendant's title.” The claimant should seek an order that voids any adverse claim to vest clear title in the name of the claimant.

What is the maximum amount for a civil suit in Texas? ›

What is the maximum amount of money you can be awarded in Justice Court? In Justice Court, the most you can recover in damages is $20,000, including any attorneys' fees. Texas Justice Court Training Center video, and read Texas Rules of Civil Procedure 500-507 Part V.

What happens if you don't pay a civil suit in Texas? ›

If you are sued and can't pay, the creditor can get a judgment in court against you for the money you owe, plus interest. Being “judgment proof” means that your property and income can't be seized by creditors, because it is “exempt” by law from the creditor's claims.

Why would a property owner file a quiet title suit quizlet? ›

Why would a property owner file a quiet title suit? A buyer has signed a contract to purchase a property but is uncertain of the condition of the title.

What is the habendum clause in a deed? ›

Usually, the habendum clause states the property is transferred without restrictions. This means the new owner has absolute ownership of the property upon satisfying their conditions (usually payment in full) and has the right to sell or bequeath the property to an heir and so on.

What is a granting clause? ›

Granting Clause:

The clause in the deed that lists the grantor and the grantee and states that the property is being transferred between the parties.

How much does a quiet title cost in Texas? ›

With the average cost of a quiet title action being in excess of $4,500 and taking a minimum of 6 months to complete, a quiet title action may not be the best strategy for your investing.

How much does a quiet title action cost in Texas? ›

The cost of a quiet title action ranges from $1,500 to $5,000 for an uncontested lawsuit. Contested (or litigated) quiet title actions can cost much more. Cost mainly depends on the complexity of the title issue and whether the action is opposed.

What is trespass to try title in Texas? ›

TRESPASS TO TRY TITLE. (a) A trespass to try title action is the method of determining title to lands, tenements, or other real property. (b) The action of ejectment is not available in this state.

What does a writ of attachment do? ›

A writ of attachment is commonly used by a plaintiff to secure a contingent lien on a defendant's property in the event that the plaintiff obtains a judgment against the defendant. There are various types of attachments including garnishment, sequestration and replevin.

What is the meaning of claim of title? ›

A claim of title is when someone believes they own a piece of property, even if they don't have the legal right to it. This can happen when someone takes possession of land without permission from the true owner, or when someone intends to take over land regardless of who actually owns it.

What's the term for a notice given directly to and received by a person? ›

Actual notice is a notice that is given directly to a party or is personally received by a party informing them of a case that could affect their interests.

How to be successful in life? ›

13 steps to be successful in life
  1. Find a passion. To be successful, it is important to define what you want in life. ...
  2. Show commitment. ...
  3. Learn from the journey. ...
  4. Have fun along the way. ...
  5. Think positively. ...
  6. Be honest with yourself. ...
  7. Take away distractions. ...
  8. Depend on yourself.
Jan 31, 2023

Which is not one of the three channels of probate deliberation? ›

Which is NOT one of the three channels of probate deliberation? Interstate proceeding. Which of the following best describes actual notice? It is knowledge received or imparted through direct experience.

What is the statute of limitations on a quiet title in California? ›

4 years for claims based on the cancellation of an instrument; and. 5 years for claims based on adverse possession.

What happens after quiet title? ›

Following the quiet title action, the plaintiff will be in full possession of the property in perpetuity, as will be the plaintiff's heirs, and they will also be protected from any further claims of ownership made against the property by other outside entities.

What is the importance of title keeping quiet? ›

The title 'Keeping Quiet' has a message in itself of what can happen as a result of keeping quiet. It stresses the importance of introspection, solitude and of stopping our work or any activity for some time. The title throws light on the power of quietness in resolving our personal issues.

Which document is used to provide a summary of the title history? ›

What Is an Abstract Of Title? Abstract of title is a record of the title history of a property or other significant asset, including transfers, liens, and legal actions that are connected to the property.

What is a suit to quiet title? ›

A quiet title action is a special legal proceeding to determine ownership of real property. A party with a claim of ownership to land can file an action to quiet title, which serves as a sort of lawsuit against anyone and everyone else who has a claim to the land.

What type of deed is most commonly used? ›

General warranty deed: A general warranty deed is the most common type of deed used to transfer fee simple ownership of a property. Unlike a quitclaim deed, a general warranty deed does confirm a grantor's ownership and a legal right to sell.

Which of the following is the best evidence of the condition of title? ›

Title insurance. In the absence of Torrens registration, a title insurance policy is commonly accepted as the best evidence of marketable title.

What is a quiet title suit in Texas? ›

In order to seek quiet title, the plaintiff must plead and prove three elements: the plaintiff's rightful ownership of the property, a claim or encumbrance which disputes that rightful ownership, thereby questioning the validity of the title, and a statement that the claim or encumbrance is invalid or unenforceable.

What is the significance of the title trespass? ›

A trespass to try title action is the method of determining title to lands. It is typically used to clear problems in the chain of title or to recover land unlawfully held from a rightful owner.

What is considered my property in Texas trespassing? ›

Issuing a notice to vacate the premises can be given in many ways. The owner or representative of the owner may leave a written note or speak to the defendant directly. Breaching walls, a fence, or some other structure that clearly defines property limits constitutes illegal trespass.

Can you physically remove a trespasser in Texas? ›

Texas law states that property owners are able to use force to terminate trespassing or theft if they deem it necessary; however, force and deadly force are two different actions. Shooting the trespasser is considered deadly force since the bullet can easily end the person's life.

How long does a trespass last in Texas? ›

How long are CTN's good for? CTN's are good for one year from the date of issue.

How long do you have to occupy land before it becomes yours in Texas? ›

How Long Must Trespasser Possess the Land. The default period for adverse possession in Texas is a decade—referred to as a 10-year statute of limitations.

What are the 5 requirements for adverse possession Texas? ›

Code § 16.026, the trespasser can bring suit within ten years without any sort of tax payments or "color of title." However, the claimant must be able to establish all other standard elements of adverse possession – open, exclusive, continual, actual and hostile possession of the land.

Does paying property tax give ownership in Texas? ›

In Texas, paying someone else's property taxes doesn't lead to ownership of a property. According to Texas law, the property belongs to the person with the “clear title,” which means it is free of any claims or disputes of ownership, and no one else can make a legal claim.

What is the most common defense to trespass is that the trespass was justified? ›

Consent is the most common defense to a trespass to land claim.

What are the two types of trespass to land? ›

Under intentional torts, there are two types of trespass: (1) trespass to chattels and (2) trespass to land. Trespass to land is an unlawful entry or use of another person's land without the owner's permission or reasonable excuse.

What is the property code 22.001 in Texas? ›

Section 22.001 - Trespass to Try Title (a) A trespass to try title action is the method of determining title to lands, tenements, or other real property. (b) The action of ejectment is not available in this state. Acts 1983, 68th Leg., p.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tyson Zemlak

Last Updated:

Views: 6126

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tyson Zemlak

Birthday: 1992-03-17

Address: Apt. 662 96191 Quigley Dam, Kubview, MA 42013

Phone: +441678032891

Job: Community-Services Orchestrator

Hobby: Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Metalworking, Fashion, Vehicle restoration, Shopping, Photography

Introduction: My name is Tyson Zemlak, I am a excited, light, sparkling, super, open, fair, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.