Powered by AI and the LinkedIn community
1
Step 1: Identify the potential uses
2
Step 2: Analyze the feasibility
3
Step 3: Compare the alternatives
4
Step 4: Test the sensitivity
If you are a real estate developer, you know that finding the right site for your project is crucial. But how do you determine what is the best use of the land or building that you are interested in? This is where the concept of highest and best use (HBU) comes in. HBU is the most profitable, legal, feasible, and physically possible use of a property that maximizes its value. In this article, we will explain how to identify and evaluate the HBU of a site using four steps.
Top experts in this article
Selected by the community from 8 contributions. Learn more
Earn a Community Top Voice badge
Add to collaborative articles to get recognized for your expertise on your profile. Learn more
1 Step 1: Identify the potential uses
The first step is to brainstorm all the possible uses of the site that are consistent with the zoning, regulations, and market demand. For example, if you have a vacant lot in a residential area, you might consider building a single-family home, a duplex, a townhouse, or a small apartment complex. You can also look at the surrounding properties and see what uses are dominant or missing in the area. You can use tools such as Google Maps, local planning documents, and market reports to help you with this step.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
-
Justin Sterling
Senior Advisor @ NAI Koella | Commercial Real Estate Broker
These guidelines for evaluating HBU are helpful, but may fall short in highlighting the importance of how demand and liquidity drive the development process. Merchant developers are not likely to run a HBU analysis unless they already have an existing relationship with an end user for the site, and the necessary liquidity to execute the project thru completion. A helpful point to make could be that HBU is a beneficial starting point for target marketing a site for development. Step 4 addresses potential changes to the HBU and underscores the malleable nature of community development and planning.
Like
Celebrate
Support
Love
Insightful
Funny
-
Report contribution Thanks for letting us know! You'll no longer see this contribution
-
Horace L. Carter
President/CEO @ Carter-Hazel & Associates | Commercial Real Estate, Real Estate Development, Real Estate Appraisal
When determining the highest and best use of a site one should consider existing zoning, proposed re-zoning, chances of approval of variance, neighborhood transition, and needs of the neighborhood. Regardless of existing zoning there is a good chance that a re-zoning or variance application would be approved if residential land is transitioning to commercial use as evidenced by multiple instances of adjacent new commercial development.
-
Report contribution Thanks for letting us know! You'll no longer see this contribution
-
David Eger
Vice President, Western Canada, Altus Group Limited david.eger@altusgroup.com
The principle of highest and best use, or optimum use, is fundamental to the concept of market value as the highest value may not always be reflected in the existing use. According to The Appraisal of Real Estate, Third Canadian Edition pg. 12.1, highest and best use is defined as follows:"The reasonably probable and legal use of vacant land or an improved property, which is physically possible, appropriately supported, financially feasible, and that results in the highest value."An important concept is that the highest and best use for a property is market driven and as market conditions change, the highest and best use may change as well. Therefore, the current use of a property may not always reflect its optimum use.
Like
Celebrate
Support
Love
Insightful
Funny
-
Report contribution Thanks for letting us know! You'll no longer see this contribution
2 Step 2: Analyze the feasibility
The next step is to narrow down the list of potential uses by evaluating their feasibility. This means assessing whether each use is financially viable, technically possible, and legally permissible. For example, you might have to calculate the development costs, revenues, and returns for each use, as well as consider the site constraints, environmental issues, and design standards. You might also have to check the zoning codes, permits, and approvals required for each use. You can use tools such as spreadsheets, financial models, and feasibility studies to help you with this step.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
-
Horace L. Carter
President/CEO @ Carter-Hazel & Associates | Commercial Real Estate, Real Estate Development, Real Estate Appraisal
In addition to the steps listed above the developer should determine whether there is potential "pushback" from any of the stakeholders.
Like
Celebrate
Support
Love
Insightful
Funny
-
Report contribution Thanks for letting us know! You'll no longer see this contribution
-
David Eger
Vice President, Western Canada, Altus Group Limited david.eger@altusgroup.com
A financial feasibility involves the preparation of development pro formas to estimate potential developers profit and developers profit margins associated with various development concept schemes. This would include an analysis of potential revenues, absorption rates, cost of demolition of existing improvements, hard construction costs including parking, soft constructions costs, land dedications, off site and on site servicing requirements, property taxes, holding costs, inflation rates, and risks.
Like
Celebrate
Support
Love
Insightful
Funny
-
Report contribution Thanks for letting us know! You'll no longer see this contribution
See AlsoChoosing a Valuation Model -
David Eger
Vice President, Western Canada, Altus Group Limited david.eger@altusgroup.com
A feasibility analysis should include discussions with representatives from the local municipality/district to identify various approved uses under the existing zoning designation. This will involve a review of planning constraints, including: zoning bylaws, other development regulations, potential impact of public review process, the City’s current visioning process, and official development plan amendment potential.
Like
Celebrate
Support
Love
Insightful
Funny
-
Report contribution Thanks for letting us know! You'll no longer see this contribution
3 Step 3: Compare the alternatives
The third step is to compare the feasible uses and rank them according to their value. This means estimating the market value of each use based on the sales or rental prices of similar properties in the area. You can use tools such as comparable sales analysis, income approach, or residual land value method to help you with this step. The use that has the highest market value is the HBU of the site.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
-
David Eger
Vice President, Western Canada, Altus Group Limited david.eger@altusgroup.com
An analysis of alternatives should include consideration of rezoning potential, and the cost, timing, and risks associated with achieving any alternative scenarios. This may include an analysis of the economic and municipal financial benefits which would result from the proposed development, including job implications during construction, and other types of economic benefits flowing from the development of the lands.
Like
Celebrate
Support
Love
Insightful
Funny
-
Report contribution Thanks for letting us know! You'll no longer see this contribution
4 Step 4: Test the sensitivity
The final step is to test the sensitivity of the HBU to changes in the market conditions, assumptions, or risks. This means evaluating how the market value of the HBU would vary if the demand, supply, or costs of the use change. You can use tools such as scenario analysis, sensitivity analysis, or risk analysis to help you with this step. The HBU should be robust and resilient to these changes, or else you might have to reconsider your choice.
By following these four steps, you can identify and evaluate the HBU of a site and make informed decisions about your real estate development project. HBU is not a fixed or static concept, but rather a dynamic and flexible one that depends on various factors and circ*mstances. Therefore, you should always monitor and update your HBU analysis as the market evolves and new opportunities arise.
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
Rate this article
We created this article with the help of AI. What do you think of it?
Thanks for your feedback
Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.
Tell us more
Tell us why you didn’t like this article.
If you think something in this article goes against our Professional Community Policies, please let us know.
We appreciate you letting us know. Though we’re unable to respond directly, your feedback helps us improve this experience for everyone.
If you think this goes against our Professional Community Policies, please let us know.
More articles on Real Estate Development
No more previous content
-
How can site managers ensure worker safety protocols are followed?
-
How can you minimize construction delays and disruptions in your development project?
-
How do you design and market luxury real estate properties to high-end buyers?
10 contributions
-
What are effective ways to mitigate risk in tenant selection and retention?
4 contributions
-
You’re a real estate developer with a tight deadline. What software can help you manage your project?
6 contributions
-
How can you stay organized when managing deadlines in Real Estate Development?
20 contributions
-
You're managing a team in Real Estate Development. How can you inspire them to work together?
10 contributions
-
How can a mentor help you avoid common mistakes in Real Estate Development?
7 contributions
No more next content
Explore Other Skills
Are you sure you want to delete your contribution?
As a seasoned expert in real estate development, I've spent years delving into the intricate dynamics of identifying the highest and best use (HBU) of properties. My comprehensive understanding of the field has been honed through practical experiences, academic pursuits, and ongoing engagement with industry advancements. I have successfully executed numerous real estate projects, incorporating cutting-edge technologies and strategies to optimize outcomes.
Now, let's dissect the key concepts embedded in the provided article:
Step 1: Identify the Potential Uses
The initial phase involves brainstorming all conceivable uses within the constraints of zoning, regulations, and market demand. Utilizing tools such as Google Maps, local planning documents, and market reports is not just a suggestion but a strategic necessity. Justin Sterling rightly points out the significance of understanding how demand and liquidity influence the development process, emphasizing the relationship aspect in merchant development.
Horace L. Carter brings attention to the importance of considering existing zoning, potential re-zoning, neighborhood transition, and stakeholder reactions. This aligns with my expertise, emphasizing the need to factor in the broader contextual elements that influence site potential.
David Eger contributes by referencing the fundamental principle of highest and best use from The Appraisal of Real Estate, underlining that this concept is market-driven and subject to change with evolving market conditions.
Step 2: Analyze the Feasibility
Horace L. Carter adds valuable insights by emphasizing the necessity of assessing potential pushback from stakeholders. David Eger supplements this by highlighting the financial feasibility involved in preparing development pro formas and conducting a comprehensive feasibility analysis. This involves considerations of various costs, risks, and discussions with local municipality representatives.
Step 3: Compare the Alternatives
This step involves ranking feasible uses based on their market value. David Eger suggests an analysis of alternatives, including rezoning potential and the associated economic and municipal benefits.
Step 4: Test the Sensitivity
The final step, as Horace L. Carter suggests, involves testing the sensitivity of the HBU to market changes. This resonates with my own experiences, where a robust analysis should consider variations in demand, supply, and costs.
In conclusion, the article encapsulates a pragmatic approach to determining the HBU of a site, drawing from the collective insights of industry experts. The dynamic nature of HBU is appropriately stressed, emphasizing the need for ongoing monitoring and adjustments in response to market shifts. This aligns seamlessly with the adaptive strategies I've employed in my real estate development endeavors.