Feds face a smaller but significant pay gap with private sector (2024)

Federal employees earn on average 26.71 percent less than private sector counterparts, according to research released by the Federal Salary Council Nov. 5, a slightly smaller divide than the 31.8 percent difference the same study found in April 2018.

“The pay gap is real, and it has having real consequences in cities and towns across America,” National Treasury Employees Union National President and council member Tony Reardon said in a news release.

“Important federal jobs go unfilled because skilled workers can make more money in the private sector, which hurts the government’s ability to serve taxpayers.”

Despite the significant gap reported by the Federal Salary Council, whether or not federal employees actually see a pay disparity with the private sector is an issue that has caused intense debate, as an April 2017 Congressional Budget Office study noted that feds with a high school diploma make 34 percent more than their private sector counterparts.

The Trump administration has used the CBO study to justify proposals to freeze federal pay both in 2019 and 2020.

The discrepancy in whether feds make more or less than the private sector may come down to how each study is conducted.

The Federal Salary Council estimate is produced by taking a random sampling of private-sector positions in a given area and comparing them with similar positions on the GS scale. The process, in theory, replicates what a federal employee could expect to make should they choose to take a private-sector job in the same location and with the same skills requirements.

The CBO study, on the other hand, relies on comparisons of education level, rather than job descriptions.

Determining the true gap also gets more complicated when factoring in locality pay — which is offered to offset costs for feds that live in expensive areas — and government benefits.

But, according to agency representatives that spoke at the Federal Salary Council’s Nov. 5 hearing, medical and other high-skill positions in the government are remaining empty because agencies are not able to match the high salaries that the private sector offers in cities such as Charleston, South Carolina, or Atlantic City, New Jersey.

President Donald Trump relented from his position of freezing federal pay entirely for 2020 to agreeing to a 2.6 percent across-the-board increase for basic pay. That increase would not impact locality pay, which Trump said would cost the government $24 billion in one year if it were brought up to the level that the standard equation for yearly adjustments requires.

In its 2020 appropriations legislation, the House pushed for a .5 percent increase for locality pay, in line with the adjustment for 2019.

“Approving a 3.1 percent pay raise and adding more locality pay areas is not going to close the gap or make federal employees rich, but it is going to help people afford to take care of their families and serve their country, doing work that is crucial to our security, our economy and our public health,” Reardon said.

About JessieBur

Jessie Bur covers federal IT and management.

In Other News

Load More

Feds face a smaller but significant pay gap with private sector (2024)

FAQs

Does federal government pay more than private sector? ›

In recent years, data comparing federal government and private sector compensation from the Bureau of Labor Statistics had indicated that the gap has slowly trended downward, with federal workers earning 22.47% less on average than private sector workers in similar jobs in 2021.

Is there a federal vs private pay gap? ›

Washington D.C. – Federal employee salaries in 2022 have fallen further behind the private sector, according to new data released Friday by the Federal Salary Council. Federal employees on average earned 24.09 percent less this year than their counterparts in the private sector. In 2021, the gap was 22.47 percent.

What is the pay gap for the federal government? ›

The 5.6% average pay gap is a slight improvement from the 5.9% gap in 2021. And it's significantly smaller than it was 30 years ago — 24.5%. The current gender pay gap in the federal sector is also smaller than the 16% gap in the private sector. Graph from the Office of Personnel Management.

Is the federal employee pay increase approved for 2023? ›

The figure marks an increase over the 4.6% pay hike feds received in 2023, and would be the highest proposed pay hike federal workers have seen since the Carter administration implemented a 9.1% average pay increase in 1980.

Why are private sector salaries so much higher than government salaries? ›

While there are caveats in making compensation comparisons across workers, these data suggest the key reason for this enormous pay gap is that private sector pay is disciplined by the normal market forces of supply and demand, whereas public sector pay is disciplined, if you can call it that, only to the extent that ...

Are government benefits better than private sector? ›

Benefits: Government benefits can exceed private sector benefits packages. 1 Employees often have superior health care plans with lower costs and favorable retirement plans. Government and private sector benefit packages both get worse in prolonged recessions, but government benefits remain better.

What is the real reason for the pay gap? ›

Much of the gender pay gap has been explained by measurable factors such as educational attainment, occupational segregation and work experience. The narrowing of the gap over the long term is attributable in large part to gains women have made in each of these dimensions.

Do federal employees get paid less? ›

Federal employees' wages are falling further behind those in the private sector, according to new data from the Federal Salary Council. The council reported that in 2022, federal workers earned 24.09% less in wages alone than their private sector counterparts. In 2021, the pay gap by the same measurement was 22.47%.

What is the difference between public sector and private sector employees? ›

The primary difference between public- and private-sector jobs is that public-sector jobs are generally within a government agency, while private-sector jobs are those where employees work for non-governmental agencies. This includes jobs within individual businesses and other types of company organizations.

Does the private sector pay more? ›

Private sector jobs often have the potential to pay more than government jobs. While government jobs may offer job security and benefits, such as comprehensive health insurance and generous retirement plans, they often have slow growth rates and provide limited opportunities for salary increases.

Does Equal Pay Act apply to federal employees? ›

The California Labor Code sections, including the California Equal Pay Act, apply to all employers, regardless of their size, but do not protect federal government employees.

Is the pay gap increasing or decreasing? ›

Women, on average, were paid 20.3% less than men in 2019. By 2022, that gap widened to 22.2%. Similarly, the regression-adjusted wage gap, which has been stagnant for most of the last 20+ years, widened slightly from 22.6% to 22.9%.

What is the pay cap for GS 2023? ›

5304 and special rates under 5 U.S.C. 5305 for most GS employees are capped at the rate for level IV of the Executive Schedule (EX-IV), which is $183,500 in 2023.

Will federal employees get a cost-of-living raise? ›

A committee-published summary of the defense policy bill said the legislation provides an average 5.2% pay raise for both members of the military and Defense Department civilian workers, in line with the proposal set forth in Biden's fiscal 2024 budget request.

Are federal employees getting a COLA in 2023? ›

For 2023, the COLA surged to 8.7%, and federal retirees saw the highest inflation increase in their benefits since the early 1980s. Now, inflation rates are slowly leveling out after reaching a four-decade high in 2022, and in response, the COLA is projected to be much more modest.

How much do government workers make compared to private sector workers? ›

Federal employees' salaries lag their private-sector counterparts in comparable jobs by 22.47 percent on average, an advisory group said in a Friday report that noted the “pay gap” has held steady over the last two years.

Are federal employees paid less? ›

Federal employees' wages are falling further behind those in the private sector, according to new data from the Federal Salary Council. The council reported that in 2022, federal workers earned 24.09% less in wages alone than their private sector counterparts. In 2021, the pay gap by the same measurement was 22.47%.

Is it better to work for the federal government? ›

Working in the federal government can provide financial security, peace of mind and a chance to serve your community. Whether you are considering a job in the federal government or just needed a refresher on your benefits, you should know that government work changes the lives of so many employees and their families.

What government position pays the most? ›

Top 100 Federal Occupations in 2022
RankOccupation TitleAverage Pay
1Medical Officer$258,715.74
2Securities Compliance Examiner$204,930.83
3Dental Officer$195,671.57
4Patent Administrator$180,721.99
96 more rows

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Frankie Dare

Last Updated:

Views: 6400

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Frankie Dare

Birthday: 2000-01-27

Address: Suite 313 45115 Caridad Freeway, Port Barabaraville, MS 66713

Phone: +3769542039359

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Baton twirling, Stand-up comedy, Leather crafting, Rugby, tabletop games, Jigsaw puzzles, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Frankie Dare, I am a funny, beautiful, proud, fair, pleasant, cheerful, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.