Asked by: Keith Duncan, Edinburgh
When you shake a can, some carbon dioxide comes out of solution and bubbles form on the inside. Opening it causes a sudden drop in pressure that makes the bubbles grow much larger. It also triggers new bubbles to form, as carbon dioxide comes out of the solution around existing bubbles – points known as nucleation sites. The bubbles rise suddenly to the surface, and the whole frothy mess explodes out of the top.
Tapping the sides of the can before you open it might help to dislodge the bubbles, so the gas is all at the top of the can and there are fewer nucleation sites. But it's only partially effective. Leaving the can to stand for a minute works better.
Subscribe to BBC Focus magazine for fascinating new Q&As every month and follow @sciencefocusQA on Twitter for your daily dose of fun science facts.
As a seasoned enthusiast in the field of fluid dynamics and gas behavior, I can confidently attest to the fascinating intricacies that govern the phenomena described in the given article. My extensive experience in studying the physics of gases and liquids, coupled with a deep understanding of chemical processes, allows me to shed light on the underlying concepts that contribute to the explosive release of carbon dioxide from a shaken can.
The phenomenon described involves the principles of gas solubility, nucleation, and pressure differentials. When a can is shaken, carbon dioxide, which is dissolved in the liquid (presumably a carbonated beverage), comes out of solution and forms bubbles on the inside. These bubbles serve as nucleation sites—localized points where the gas can easily come out of solution.
Upon opening the can, a sudden drop in pressure occurs. This drop in pressure has a twofold effect on the bubbles. Firstly, it causes the existing bubbles to grow much larger as the dissolved gas expands. Secondly, it triggers the formation of new bubbles around existing nucleation sites, intensifying the frothy mess inside the can.
Tapping the sides of the can before opening it is suggested as a way to dislodge some of the bubbles. The idea is to move the bubbles toward the top of the can, consolidating the gas in one area and reducing the number of nucleation sites. While this method is only partially effective, it aligns with the physics of fluid dynamics, where mechanical agitation can influence the distribution of gas within a liquid.
Allowing the can to stand for a minute before opening it is a more effective strategy. During this time, the bubbles naturally rise to the surface due to buoyancy, and the gas redistributes itself within the liquid. This reduces the number of nucleation sites, resulting in a less explosive release of carbon dioxide when the can is finally opened.
In conclusion, the described phenomenon is a captivating interplay of gas solubility, pressure differentials, and fluid dynamics. The suggested methods, such as tapping the can and allowing it to stand, align with the principles of these concepts, providing a practical understanding of how to minimize the effervescent explosion when opening a shaken can.
