Building Up vs Building Out with Room Additions: What to Consider When Adding a Room to Your House (2024)

You may already know that adding a room addition to your home can add big value in the long run. Room additions can also be exactly what you need to take your home from average to your absolute dream home. Both reasons for adding an addition can be advantageous if you love your neighborhood, school district and the bones of your home.

You may also already be prepared for the general cost of a room addition and have a budget ready to go. Along with knowing your purpose for adding an addition, keeping a budget in mind is helpful as you begin to plan.

Once you know your reason for wanting an addition, and have an idea for budget, it’s time to decide whether to build up (on top of your existing home) or build out (on the ground floor of your property).

Building Up vs Building Out with Room Additions: What to Consider When Adding a Room to Your House (1)

Building Up vs Building Out With Room Additions

Building up vs building out your room addition depends on a number of factors, including your property size, local zoning laws, your budget and what type of room you want to add. Here are a few items to consider when thinking through building up vs building out a new room addition.

Cost and Convenience

In general, building up tends to be less costly than building out. When you factor in things like digging and pouring a new foundation, building out typically carries a higher price tag (though this isn’t always true, and certainly depends on the size of the room and its purpose).

It’s important to consider you and your family’s convenience during the renovation as well. You will likely need to move out of your home for a month or two (or more!) during a large build-up room addition. If you don’t have friends or family nearby, you’ll incur additional lodging costs while you wait out the construction.

Building out a room addition typically means you can still stay in your home, but you’ll have to deal with dust and noise throughout the project. However, the contractor can complete the majority of the build out before cutting into the wall that joins your existing home and the new room.

Work with a professional remodeling company that is willing to speak with you about not just your budgetary costs for your room addition, but what construction will mean for your living arrangements and day-to-day convenience. A great builder will make sure to work quickly so that you can return to living in the comfort of your finished home as soon as possible.

Square Footage

Building up means that the size of your room addition is largely dependent on your home’s existing footprint. With smaller homes, you may not get the payoff in square footage you were hoping for when you build up.

Building out could be a great option for more square footage if you live on a larger property. Smaller yards, though, will limit the size of your build, especially if zoning laws prohibit your dwelling from standing too close to a neighbor’s property line.

Make sure to consider how much square footage building up or out will yield. It might be worth expanding your footprint out instead of up in order to gain the spaciousness you want.

Type of Room

The type of room addition and its function will also determine if you should build up or out. Kitchens and main living spaces (e.g. larger family rooms) tend to be better suited for the ground floor. Extra bedrooms usually work better on an upper floor.

You should also think through what you need to add to the room to make it functional. Kitchens need extra wiring, plumbing and lighting, which is often easier to build out on the ground floor. Bedrooms and offices typically only require electrical and HVAC to function with the rest of the home. Building up is usually compatible with these functional room additions.

Zoning Laws

Your neighborhood or county may have specific restrictions that prohibit building up. For example, some parts of the country restrict how tall residential dwellings can be. If you live in an area with these types of zoning laws, building up may not be possible if you’re hoping to add a third floor or a second floor with high ceilings.

There may also be laws that require that your home remain a certain number of feet from your property line or your neighbor’s home. Building out may not be an option if you have a smaller yard or your home sits close to your neighbor.

A good builder will always be knowledgeable about your zoning laws and will submit permitting for you during your project.

Should I Build Up or Out for My Room Addition?

Talk to your builder about the best option for your home, neighborhood and budget. Building a room addition is a big investment, and careful planning is important to ensure you get the most for your time and money. Work with someone who will deliver a high-quality room addition on time and on budget that you can enjoy for years to come.

Design and Build a New Room Addition in Columbus, Ohio

Dave Fox is an employee owned company who makes our clients our number one priority. We build high-quality room additions for homeowners in Central Ohio and deliver the best value through exceptional craftsmanship, excellent materials and ethical business practices. Contact us today to learn more about our process for designing and building room additions.

Building Up vs Building Out with Room Additions: What to Consider When Adding a Room to Your House (2024)

FAQs

Is it cheaper to add on out or up? ›

In general, building up tends to be less costly than building out. When you factor in things like digging and pouring a new foundation, building out typically carries a higher price tag (though this isn't always true, and certainly depends on the size of the room and its purpose).

What to consider when adding an addition to a house? ›

Questions to Ask Before Adding On
  1. How would you design your house if you were building it new? ...
  2. Will the addition add value to your home? ...
  3. Is there a lower-cost way to get what you want? ...
  4. Are there any zoning restrictions to consider? ...
  5. How will your addition tie into the house?

Is it better to add on or build up? ›

Building up is always the least expensive option for increasing your home's square-footage because it requires less material and labor. For example, if you have 1,000 sq. feet on the main level and want to add 1,000 sq. feet as a second floor, all you have to do is add more wood and framing labor.

What is the first step in adding a room to a house? ›

Here is a list of 5 general steps to a home addition process:
  1. Explore your options and assess your budget. ...
  2. Select a Contractor, or a Design + Build Firm. ...
  3. Finalize Design, Material Selections and Obtain Permits/Approvals. ...
  4. Preparing the Site and Start Construction! ...
  5. Move in and Beyond.

What is the most expensive part of a home addition? ›

The Framing

A home's framing is its skeleton. Because so much material and skilled labor is required, this is an incredibly expensive part of building a home. While framing may not be as expensive as the foundation or lot, it is typically more costly than other items.

What room adds most value to a house? ›

Kitchen remodels: Kitchens are easily one of the most important rooms in a home, so it's no surprise people value a smart, modernized space, says Fisher. On average, kitchen remodels lead to a 72 percent ROI. The average cost of a kitchen remodel is between $25,000 and $40,000.

What are the mistakes to avoid with an addition? ›

The 5 Home Addition Mistakes You Can Easily Avoid
  • Too Many Compromises. Cutting a few corners may seem like an easy way to keep costs under control, but it's rarely effective. ...
  • Increased Costs Due to Change Orders. ...
  • Not Adding a Cushion to Your Budget. ...
  • Relying Too Heavily on Trends. ...
  • Choosing the Wrong Contractor.
May 10, 2019

Does adding a room to a house increase the value? ›

More often than not, adding a bedroom increases the value of a home for when you sell. For every bedroom that's added to a home, expect the price of a home to go up between $30,000 and $50,000.

Does adding a room to your house add value? ›

The short answer is yes — home additions typically add value to your home. However, you must also keep the cost in mind. The Remodeling 2021 Cost vs.

How much does it cost to build a 10x12 room? ›

How Much Does It Cost to Add on a Room by Square Foot?
Room SizeAverage Prices
20'x20'$32,000 – $80,000
12'x12'$11,520 – $28,800
10'x12'$9,600 – $24,000
400 sq. ft.$32,000 – $80,000
3 more rows
Oct 10, 2022

What is a bump out addition? ›

A bump-out addition expands a room but falls short of the size, complexity or cost of a home addition. Most bump-outs expand a room by another two or three feet but some can be as large as a room.

Why are home additions so expensive? ›

Building out is often more expensive since a new foundation will need to be laid, and there may be structural issues to address to make sure the roofline and walls remain strong with the new addition. Talk with your contractor about which option works best for the property and budget.

Can you add an addition without foundation? ›

Unless you're building up or bumping out, every addition requires some sort of masonry foundation dug down below the frost line so it won't get pushed around by freezing temperatures.

What is it called when you add a room to a house? ›

A room addition or bump out is a single room structure built onto the side of a house. It is usually meant for a single function, such as a bedroom or bathroom. Sometimes it only expands the size of a single room in the existing house. A room addition or house bump out is an addition scaled far down.

How do you plan an addition? ›

Stages Involved in Planning a Home Addition
  1. Define your goal(s). ...
  2. Ask the right questions. ...
  3. Understand the different types of home addition projects. ...
  4. Visit your local zoning department. ...
  5. Collaborate with vetted contractors. ...
  6. Create your plan. ...
  7. Get your permits.
Dec 13, 2021

What type of home addition is cheapest? ›

Finishing a basem*nt, attic, or garage is one of the more inexpensive ways to add a room to your home as you won't need to add a foundation, roof, or structural elements.

What is the biggest expense on buildings? ›

The highest cost you'll experience in the building budget for your home is when it's time to frame. This is the skeleton of your home, and it takes a lot of lumber to build the bones. When purchasing high quality lumber, estimates can cost $25,000 for a modest size home to more than $80,000 and up for larger homes.

What room in the house is the most expensive to remodel? ›

The Kitchen. This likely comes as no surprise, but kitchens are by far one of the most expensive rooms to remodel in a home. Not only is plumbing and electrical work quite a doozy, but installing, painting or building new cabinets or kitchen islands is incredibly labor intensive and expensive.

What decreases home value? ›

What hurts property value can be things specific to your house — such as deferred maintenance issues, outdated kitchens and bathrooms, or a noisy location — or by outside factors such as your local real estate market or the state of the overall economy.

What are the 2 most important rooms in a house? ›

The kitchen and the master bathroom. Buyers tend to show more interest in these rooms than any other in a home.

Which room is a selling point of a home? ›

If you're a seller with a tight timeline (and budget), you'll want to focus on these rooms first. The rooms buyers most closely inspect (and judge) in a house are the kitchen and master bath. These are the interior spaces where the most value can be added during a sale, so they need to look their best.

What is the answer to an addition problem? ›

The answer to an addition problem is called the sum.

What are some common mistakes in planning? ›

This week, let's look at the first six common mistakes.
  • The timeframe of the plan is too long. ...
  • Too many strategic goals. ...
  • Goals not tied to measurable outcomes. ...
  • Employees are unaware of the goals. ...
  • Key vendors and partners not considered. ...
  • Plan leaves too much room for interpretation.
Mar 24, 2012

Does a bathroom or bedroom add more value? ›

Homes with more bathrooms sell for more money,” says Aaron Hendon, a real estate agent with Christine & Company in Seattle. “It will also appeal to more buyers. Buyers with kids will almost always want more than one bath.”

Does turning a bonus room into a bedroom add value? ›

One of the most cost-effective ways to add value with an additional bedroom is to divide a bonus room. This means that you'll be using finished space and installing a non-load-bearing wall, perhaps additional electricity, a closet, and a window.

How much is a bonus room worth in an appraisal? ›

How much value does a finished bonus room add? If the idea of additional living space wasn't incentive enough, a finished bonus room is also a worthwhile investment that can add between $10,000 and $30,000 to the value of your home.

Does adding a bathroom in basem*nt increase home value? ›

By finishing your basem*nt and adding a bathroom, it will no longer feel like a basem*nt. Instead, it will feel like a comfortable living space where you and your family can relax and spend quality time. Adding a bathroom to your basem*nt makes it livable space, which increases the overall market value of your home.

How do you finance a second story addition? ›

Money Moments: How to finance a home addition
  1. Home equity line of credit. Often called HELOC, this type of financing can be a first or second mortgage that taps into the equity you've earned. ...
  2. Home equity loan. ...
  3. Cash-out refinance. ...
  4. Personal loan. ...
  5. Personal line of credit. ...
  6. Credit card. ...
  7. Cash.
Oct 6, 2022

How much would it cost to build a 12x12 room? ›

To add a 12 by 12 foot room to a house, you might typically pay between $11,520 and $28,800 (£8,386 and £20,964) to build out.

How much does it cost to build a 10x20 room? ›

Room Addition Cost Calculator
Room SizeAverage Cost
10×20$25,600
12×12$18,432
16×16$32,768
20×20$51,200
1 more row

How much does it cost to build a 12x16 building? ›

How Much Will It Cost to Build a 12×16 Shed? A DIY build of a 12×16 shed can cost anywhere from $2,000 -$4,000 depending upon how many materials and tools you already have on hand.

What is the difference between a bump out and a room addition? ›

A bump out is an extra space that is far smaller than a full addition. It may be the same size as a single room, but sometimes it does not match the size of a room addition.

What is the maximum bump out? ›

If your house's finished floor is above the grade of the landscape outside, your contractor can build a bump out of up to about 3 feet deep, and as long as 10 to 12 feet. That may be enough to add an eating area to your kitchen or a separate tub and shower to your master bathroom.

What is a micro-addition? ›

A micro-addition can be added where your existing structure allows, and can be as small as just a couple of feet. This means you can make any room feel bigger without having to do any foundation work, saving you time and money.

How much does it cost to add 500 square feet to a house? ›

Home additions cost an average of $80 to $200 per square foot. So, you can expect to pay between $40,000 and $100,000 to add a 500-square-foot room to your home.

How hard is it to add a room to a house? ›

But adding or expanding a room isn't much easier than moving. You have contractors to hire, important decisions to make and a lot of money to spend. If you decide to add a room to your home, it will soon be filled with dust, plaster, nails and other construction materials.

How deep should a footing be for an addition? ›

Depth of Footings

Footings should extend to a minimum depth of 12 inches below previously undisturbed soil. Footings also must extend at least 12 inches below the frost line (the depth to which the ground freezes in winter) or must be frost-protected.

How do I add an extra bedroom to my house? ›

Add a New Internal Wall

The simplest and most affordable way to add another bedroom to your home is to construct a new internal wall to divide an existing room. This can be a real help if you have a large existing bedroom, and is perfect for creating two smaller rooms for children.

Is it bad if a house doesn't have a foundation? ›

Without a stable foundation, the Big Bad Wolf would have blown all of them down. A house built on an unstable foundation can have a number of serious problems, including cracks in drywall, sticking and poorly operating doors and windows, sloping floors, water intrusion, and moisture damage such as wood rot and mold.

Is it cheaper to build up or out? ›

In general, building up tends to be less costly than building out. When you factor in things like digging and pouring a new foundation, building out typically carries a higher price tag (though this isn't always true, and certainly depends on the size of the room and its purpose).

What kind of rooms to put in a house? ›

Relax in a Lounge Space
  • Playroom.
  • Home Office.
  • Extra Living Room.
  • Bar.
  • Home Office.
  • Game Room.
  • Home Theater.
  • Music Room.
May 18, 2023

How much does it cost to make another room in your house? ›

According to HomeAdvisor.com, the average cost of building an additional room onto your house runs $80 – $200 per square foot. The discrepancy depends on the layout, your home's style and the materials used.

What are the stages of an addition? ›

Steps To Building an Addition to a House
  • Determine the Budget and Scope. ...
  • Secure Funding. ...
  • Select a General Contractor. ...
  • Work With an Architect (Where Appropriate) ...
  • Obtain Permits and Prepare the Site. ...
  • Build the Foundation. ...
  • Frame the Structure. ...
  • Add the Sheathing and Roofing.
Nov 8, 2022

Does adding on to a house add value? ›

The short answer is yes — home additions typically add value to your home. However, you must also keep the cost in mind. The Remodeling 2021 Cost vs.

Is it cheaper to add on to house or move? ›

While a home addition requires you to live in a construction zone (to some extent) until it's completed, it's much less stressful and less expensive than going through the process of looking for a home, packing your belongings, selling your house and moving to a new neighborhood.

How big can a bump out addition be? ›

As small as 2 feet: Bump outs may extend as far as 10 to 15 feet from the house, but they can also be tiny pop-outs that are no deeper than 2 feet. Cantilevers: Small bump outs often are cantilevered (unsupported by posts) from the house. This is typically limited to about 2 feet in depth.

How much does it cost to add 400 square feet to a house? ›

Add 400 Square Feet to a House

addition averages $40,000 to $120,000. Additions of this size are large enough for multi-use spaces. This could mean a kitchen and dining room or a master bedroom with an attached bathroom.

What actually increases property value? ›

Supply and demand. The basic law of supply and demand have a major effect on the housing market. Simply put, as the housing supply decreases or as demand rises, creating an inventory shortage, home values go up. A real estate inventory shortage means that there are fewer sellers than there are buyers.

Does adding a bedroom and bathroom increase home value? ›

Appraisal

They'll look at square footage and bedroom counts. For appraisers, it's not the number of bedrooms that matters, but the amount of square footage that impacts a home's value. While this does vary from market to market, typically a bedroom addition adds appraisal value only if it increases the square footage.

What is the cheapest way to add space to your home? ›

Finishing a basem*nt, attic, or garage is one of the more inexpensive ways to add a room to your home as you won't need to add a foundation, roof, or structural elements.

What is the difference between build up and build out? ›

In building out, the vast majority of the additions will involve increasing the building's footprint at the ground level (horizontally). In building up, additions can happen without necessarily increasing the footprint. You can add one or more stories to your establishment (vertically).

Is it worth it to add a room to a house? ›

Great High Cost-Value Ratio

It is typically cheaper to build an addition than to buy or build a new home that equals the space of your existing house plus an addition. At the very least, the closing costs involved with selling your old house and buying the new house would push this option over the top.

Do you need a foundation for a bump-out addition? ›

What is a bump-out addition? Typically, a bump-out addition is cantilevered off the existing foundation, similar to a balcony, making foundation work unnecessary. And, a micro-addition doesn't need to be tied into the existing roofline. Both of these qualities save both time and money, while still adding extra space.

What is the difference between a bumpout and an addition? ›

What Is a Bump-Out Addition? A bump-out is a minor addition to a house that increases its total square footage but doesn't reach the scale of a full addition with multiple rooms. A bump-out can be as small as two or three feet that push out the side of the house, or as large as a single room.

How much does it cost to add 1500 square feet to a house? ›

For a home that is 1,500 square feet, that means your costs can be anywhere from $225,000 to $450,000 in most areas, with the possibility of going all the way to $900,000. If you have an attic, turning that into a liveable second floor is a much more affordable option.

How many square feet is a 12x12 room? ›

So if a bedroom is 12 feet wide and 12 feet long, it is 144 square feet total (12 x 12 = 144 sqft). Basically, the square footage of the room is the total area or size of the space.

How much does it cost to add 1 000 square feet to a house? ›

How much does it cost to add 1000 square feet to a house? Based on a cost of $80 and $200 per square foot (£627 and £1,567 per square metre), you can expect to pay between $80,000 and $200,000 (£58,244 and £145,589) to add 1000 square feet to a house.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. Nancy Dach

Last Updated:

Views: 5956

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. Nancy Dach

Birthday: 1993-08-23

Address: 569 Waelchi Ports, South Blainebury, LA 11589

Phone: +9958996486049

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Web surfing, Scuba diving, Mountaineering, Writing, Sailing, Dance, Blacksmithing

Introduction: My name is Prof. Nancy Dach, I am a lively, joyous, courageous, lovely, tender, charming, open person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.