Airbnb vs Long Term Lets… Here’s How To Choose! - (2024)

Owning rental property has always been a popular way to create an alternative income stream.

Let’s face it, no-one wants to have all their eggs in one basket, totally reliant on what they earn from their day job!

Rental property isn’t the golden goose it once. Because of changes to mortgages – particularly the way that mortgage interest is dealt with and the way that tax has changed – it’s not necessarily the thing that everybody is looking at nowadays, like they were 20 years ago.

But for lots of people, it can still play a hugely important part in your overall wealth portfolio!

So if you’re thinking of investing in property – how DO you know whether a long term let or short term rentals like Airbnb are right for you?

Traditionally, most people chose long term lets. You’d buy a property and rent it out to a single family, who would hopefully live there for months or years at a time without any issues. They pay regular monthly rent as their family grows up and their children attend school. They look after the property and you have a good stable source of income.

It’s simple in theory.

But because of the changes in rules for a lot of people – especially if you are a business owner on a good salary and a higher rate taxpayer – owning property in this way is not as tax efficient as it was, which means that lots of people are now looking at furnished holiday lets (FHL) instead.

Short term rentals like Airbnb and VRBO are popular because the rules are different in terms of what you can claim against your tax and how the claiming for mortgage interest works.

For some people this is proving a better option but of course, both have got their advantages and disadvantages! So let’s have a deeper look at both.

Long Term Rentals – Advantages vs Disadvantages

The main advantage here is the stability of having regular monthly income and predictable cashflow.

Your tenants cover the property overheads (council tax, water, electricity etc) and there’s minimal maintenance (in theory!).

You don’t have to clean the place every week or worry about your online reviews. And of course, you don’t have the hassle of having to find new tenants all the time.

The earning potential may be less than with a furnished holiday let, but there is generally much less time and work day-to-day, once your long-term tenant is in situ.

Furnished Holiday Lets (FHL) – Advantages vs Disadvantages

The big draw here is obviously the potential to generate a lot more money!

Especially for beautiful holiday accommodation or if your property is in a nice place, like by the beach or a city where there are university graduations or theatres and attractions for people to visit.

But that income can be sporadic, compared to the stability of a long term let. Even with good occupancy rates, there are still likely to be weeks when it’s empty and times when your rates are considerably lower than in peak season, like the summer and school holidays.

Your overheads are likely to be considerably higher too – with cleaners coming in to do changeovers; fully furnishing the place; replacing supplies; maintaining everything (from the garden to the boiler to the mattress); marketing costs and third-party fees, and so on.

If you’re a higher rate taxpayer though, a furnished holiday let can be a brilliant way of having an extra income stream, especially if it’s in a place you love to visit. Almost like the best of both worlds! You buy a second property by the sea, go and stay there sometimes and when you’re not there, you let it out to other people to enjoy.

Furnished holiday let rules do mean that you need to rent the property out for a certain number of days each year, otherwise it doesn’t qualify.

And then there are a whole load of things that you can claim as expenses, but your accountant can help you with this!

The other BIG thing to consider is that if you’re buying a property to use as a furnished holiday let, you’ll need a different type of mortgage and a bigger deposit than if you are doing it as a long term rental.

This is because as we’ve said, long term rentals are more stable. You put a tenant in who stays for six months or longer and you know the income is guaranteed, which means your mortgage is covered. From a lenders point of view, they’re seen as less risky than FHLs.

Most holiday let mortgages only run to 65% of the loan to value – sometimes less – so the deposit you need will be larger. And it’s likely that lenders will want you to have a higher level of background income in terms of your own salary, because they need to know that if you don’t manage to let out your house in Whitstable for three weeks in August, you’ve personally got enough money to pay the mortgage on top of your own mortgage at home and all your other costs.

Whether short or long term lets are right for you, there’s no doubt that both can be great options when it comes to diversifying your income and building your wealth.

And if you’d love to invest in rental property – whether now or further down the line – just click here to check out my ‘Perfect Property Masterclass’ now!

Until next time,

Claire

p.s If you want a private, 100% confidential conversation to explore your options in more depth – just click here to book an appointment!

Airbnb vs Long Term Lets… Here’s How To Choose! - (2024)

FAQs

Do Airbnbs make more money than long-term rentals? ›

Short-term rentals, like Airbnb or Vrbo) offer higher cash flow and more frequent property inspections but demand significant involvement and come with higher risks.

What is the 90 day rule Airbnb? ›

Airbnb doesn't allow properties to be rented out for more than 90 nights per year. If your limit for bookings is reached, Airbnb will automatically close your property until the end of the calendar year.

Is long-term Airbnb a good idea? ›

Airbnb is a valuable resource for many types of travelers, but it can be especially valuable for those looking for long-term stays. Booking a monthly rental on Airbnb can save significant amounts of money over shorter-term bookings, but it may still cost more than using a local resource.

What is the downside of doing Airbnb? ›

More maintenance. Being an Airbnb host also means that you need to take care of all the maintenance tasks related to your rental investment property. This includes making repairs when necessary, restocking amenities when needed, and keeping the place clean between each guest's stay.

What type of property makes the most money on Airbnb? ›

Unique Stays Are a Top Investment Property Type

According to AirDNA research, the fastest growing unique stay Airbnb properties in 2023 were: Riad*: +149.4% Tower: +135.9% Shipping container: +106.2%

Do Airbnb hosts like long stays? ›

Encouraging guests to book longer stays could help you achieve higher occupancy with lower guest turnover and a more predictable income.

What is the 80 20 rule Airbnb? ›

Or the 80/20 rule? It says that 20% of your efforts result in 80% of your outcomes. For Airbnb property managers, 20% of your Airbnb listings result in 80% of your income.

Is there a 25+ rule for Airbnb? ›

Why Does Airbnb Have an Age Policy? The Airbnb platform introduced this specific rule about guests younger than 25 a few years ago to help reduce unauthorized house parties. While these parties are a rare occurrence, some of them have been linked to fatalities.

How do I avoid 90 day limit on Airbnb? ›

Ultimately, however, the best way to get around the limit is to err on the side of caution and apply for permission from the council. Some landlords may choose to exceed the 90-day limit on Airbnb, risking fines for breaking the rules.

What is the longest you can rent an Airbnb for? ›

Airbnb will accept a 90 day booking but it falls under their long term cancellation policy. The renter would be charged the first month rent and then Airbnb would take the payments out monthly.

How much do Airbnb hosts make on average per month? ›

What Is the Average Airbnb Host Salary by State
StateAnnual SalaryMonthly Pay
California$37,509$3,125
North Carolina$37,432$3,119
Massachusetts$37,405$3,117
Oklahoma$37,372$3,114
46 more rows

Are Airbnbs cheaper if you stay longer? ›

How the Airbnb Long Stay Discount Works. When you book a stay of 28 days or longer on Airbnb, it is considered a long-term stay. The great thing about renting on Airbnb for at least one month is that you get an added monthly discount – I've seen discounts up to 50% off the normal price.

Why people don't use Airbnb? ›

There are several reasons why people may choose not to use Airbnb as a guest or a host, including: Lack of privacy: Some people may prefer the privacy and amenities of a traditional hotel room or vacation rental over the shared space of an Airbnb.

Why I no longer use Airbnb? ›

But over the past few years, the appeal of using Airbnb has been diminishing. Due to exorbitant cleaning fees, the stress of having to coordinate with hosts, issues upon arrival and the opportunity to stay in hotels for much less, many travelers have now sworn off the site.

Why people choose Airbnb over hotels? ›

Why do people choose Airbnb over hotels? People may choose an Airbnb over a hotel for a number of different reasons, including more customized accommodations, extra space, amenities for large groups, and cost savings.

Is renting through Airbnb profitable? ›

Becoming an Airbnb host is most definitely profitable given the industry growth rate. A 2021 study estimated that there are over 2.58 million rental properties in the United States that are seasonally occupied.

How profitable are Airbnb rentals? ›

Average Annual Host Revenue By State (United States):2021/2020
STATEAVERAGE ANNUAL HOST EARNINGS 2021AVERAGE ANNUAL HOST EARNINGS 2020
California$54,461$33,718
Florida$53,209$28,012
South Carolina$49,641$28,547
Utah$48,568$36,206
6 more rows

Can you really make a lot of money with Airbnb? ›

On average, hosts in the United States make more than $13,800 per year, according to Airbnb, but those numbers vary. Some hosts buy or lease a number of apartments or homes and rent them out full time. Your earning potential depends on: How much you charge for your space.

Is Airbnb doing well financially? ›

Q4 revenue was $2.2 billion, up 17% year-over-year.

Revenue increased to $2.2 billion in Q4 2023 from $1.9 billion in Q4 2022, driven by solid growth in Nights and Experiences Booked, a modest increase in Average Daily Rate (“ADR”) and an FX tailwind.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Mrs. Angelic Larkin

Last Updated:

Views: 5586

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Mrs. Angelic Larkin

Birthday: 1992-06-28

Address: Apt. 413 8275 Mueller Overpass, South Magnolia, IA 99527-6023

Phone: +6824704719725

Job: District Real-Estate Facilitator

Hobby: Letterboxing, Vacation, Poi, Homebrewing, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Cabaret

Introduction: My name is Mrs. Angelic Larkin, I am a cute, charming, funny, determined, inexpensive, joyous, cheerful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.