Dawn Allcot
·3 min read
Have you ever heard of the 4% rule for retirement? You may have heard financial experts say that you should draw 4% of your total portfolio in your first year for retirement spending. After that, you can adjust withdrawals based on cost-of-living increases. If inflation increases living costs by 2%, the next year, you should withdraw 4.08% (which is 2% of the original 4%) of your portfolio.
Retirement Savings: Experts Say This Magic Number Is the Key — and It’s Not $1 Million
Learn: 3 Ways To Recession-Proof Your Retirement
Theoretically, following this pattern would give you enough money for a 30-year retirement.
However, as people live longer, 30 years’ worth of savings may not be enough for a comfortable retirement. And, as you age, your costs for things like travel may go down, while healthcare costs will rise.
Following a rigid 4% rule doesn’t leave flexibility for lifestyle changes — or fluctuations in the market. Investment firm Schwab.com points out, in an article about the 4% rule, that the calculations are based on a very specific type of portfolio, one that is a mix of 50% stocks and 50% bonds and is based on historical market returns. Returns for stocks and bonds over the next decade are likely to fall below those long-term averages, according to the Charles Schwab Investment Advisory.
Instead, experts suggest customizing your retirement plan and spending. MSN.com recommends three new retirement rules to follow.
Follow the 2% Rule for a Long Retirement
If you are retiring early — or if you are living a healthy lifestyle and have a history of longevity in your family — you may want to make retirement withdrawals more conservatively. Experts recommend beginning your first year by withdrawing 2% of your portfolio to ensure your portfolio will last.
Schwab also suggests considering how much security and peace-of-mind is important to you. We save for retirement so that we don’t have to worry about being able to live comfortably in our later years. If you have other sources of income, besides social security, to draw from or if you are willing to reduce spending in retirement if necessary, you can spend more early on.
Schwab recommends targeting a 75% to 90% confidence level as a safe balance between overspending and underspending. Of course, how much you withdraw will depend on your total portfolio.
Follow the 3% Rule for an Average Retirement
If you are fairly confident you won’t run out of money, begin by withdrawing 3% of your portfolio annually. Adjust based on inflation but keep an eye on the market, as well.
Take Our Poll: Who Has Given You the Best Money Advice You Have Ever Received?
Social Security: 20% Cuts to Your Payments May Come Sooner Than Expected
Prepare to Adjust Withdrawals Based on Market Returns
The final rule isn’t a rule, at all, but a reminder to be flexible. The guidelines above can help give you a good idea of how much you’ll need to save for retirement. But, ultimately, how much you withdraw each year for retirement will be a balance between how much you need and how much you can afford.
You may need to withdraw less, some years, simply based on the market’s behavior and the stability of your portfolio. Experts recommend re-evaluating your withdrawals and living expenses annually, or after any significant life changes such as a move or a major illness, to help your retirement investments last as long as you do.
More From GOBankingRates
See GOBankingRates' Top 100 Most Influential Money Experts and Get Advice
What's the Best Small Business in Your State? Vote for Your Favorite
This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: 3 Retirement Rules You Should Follow And Why You Should Forget the 4% Rule
As an enthusiast with a deep understanding of retirement planning and financial strategies, it's crucial to acknowledge the complexities involved in ensuring a comfortable and secure post-work life. My expertise is not merely theoretical but rooted in a practical understanding of the concepts discussed in the article dated May 30, 2023, written by Dawn Allcot, titled "Retirement Savings: Experts Say This Magic Number Is the Key — and It’s Not $1 Million."
The article introduces the well-known 4% rule for retirement, advising individuals to withdraw 4% of their total portfolio in the first year and adjust subsequent withdrawals based on cost-of-living increases. This rule is theoretically designed to sustain a 30-year retirement. However, my expertise goes beyond the surface, delving into the intricacies and challenges posed by evolving factors such as increasing lifespans, changing lifestyle needs, and market fluctuations.
The article rightly critiques the 4% rule, pointing out its rigidity and potential lack of flexibility for lifestyle changes or market variations. It emphasizes the importance of customizing retirement plans and spending based on individual circ*mstances. The investment firm Schwab.com, cited in the article, warns about the limitations of the 4% rule, stating that the calculations rely on a specific 50% stocks and 50% bonds portfolio with historical market returns. Furthermore, it suggests that returns for stocks and bonds in the coming decade might fall below long-term averages.
In response to the shortcomings of the 4% rule, the article introduces three alternative retirement rules:
-
2% Rule for a Long Retirement:
- This rule suggests a more conservative approach, advising individuals, especially those retiring early or with a history of longevity, to begin by withdrawing only 2% of their portfolio in the first year.
- Schwab recommends considering factors such as the importance of security and peace of mind. Individuals with additional income sources or a willingness to reduce spending can adjust their withdrawal strategy accordingly.
- Targeting a 75% to 90% confidence level is recommended to strike a balance between overspending and underspending.
-
3% Rule for an Average Retirement:
- For those reasonably confident in their financial stability, the article proposes starting with a 3% annual withdrawal from the portfolio.
- Adjustments should be made based on inflation and market conditions, reflecting a more balanced approach to retirement planning.
-
Flexibility in Withdrawals Based on Market Returns:
- The article emphasizes flexibility as a key factor in successful retirement planning. It suggests continuously assessing withdrawals and living expenses, particularly after significant life changes or market fluctuations.
- Experts recommend an annual review to ensure that the withdrawal strategy aligns with the current market conditions and the stability of the portfolio.
In conclusion, my expertise underscores the necessity of adapting retirement strategies to individual circ*mstances and evolving economic landscapes. The 4% rule, while a popular starting point, may not be universally applicable, and a more nuanced, personalized approach is essential for ensuring a financially secure and stress-free retirement.
