Why Does A Diamond Have No Resale Value? | Brighton Savoy (2024)

In most cases, we don't give much thought to the cost-benefit analysis of our purchases until after we've already made the deal. However, while being a retail commodity, diamonds are not as ubiquitous as some other things. Most of us are concerned with how much money we can make if we ever have to sell the diamond. Due to the poor resale value of diamonds, we may have to temper our desires.

So, you finally splurged on the stunning diamond engagement ring your future wife had been gushing about in a glossy magazine. Even though you spent a lot of money on a small piece of jewellery, you are no longer concerned about money issues. Also, isn't it true that diamonds can be purchased as an investment?

Unfortunately, the ring's value drops by half the moment you walk out the door, just five minutes after you paid the total price. Puzzling. Several factors have been proposed as potential justifications for this startling discovery.

How Much Is A Diamond Worth?

Our industry gives us access to cutting companies and distributor contacts so that we can determine the going rate for diamonds right now. However, setting a fair price for a diamond is more art than science.

But suppose you're simply an ordinary dude trying to sell a diamond ring to the general public. What factors determine a diamond ring's resale value? The 4Cs significantly determine diamond prices: cut, colour, clarity and carat weight.

To determine the diamond resale value, you can make price comparisons of your present diamond ring against others that are being sold in the market. When drawing comparisons, keep in mind that the finer points often make all the difference.

Why Does A Diamond Have No Resale Value? | Brighton Savoy (1)

A GIA-certified diamond, for instance, needs to be evaluated against another GIA-certified diamond with comparable qualities. A diamond's worth can be affected by factors such as its fluorescence, the type of inclusions it contains, and the precision with which it was cut. You may wish to refer to this article on diamond prices for a full read.

Multiply the average retail price of a similar stone by 30%-75% to get a ballpark estimate of your diamond's resale value. Let's pretend you splurged on a Cartier or Harry Winston ring. In such an instance, the loss you take on the secondary market is likely more significant than it would be if you had bought the ring from an internet shop with a much smaller markup.

This is because the retail price would incorporate markups for the manufacturer and the cost of doing business. Most people purchasing diamond rings aren't concerned about your manufacturing, air conditioning, payroll, insurance, or shipping costs.

What matters to purchasers is the ring's intrinsic value, and if you're dealing with an expert, you can rest assured that their asking price is fair.

Can I Make Money Buying and Reselling a Diamond?

This was something mentioned to us by several folks who routinely scour auction sites for deals in the hopes of making a quick profit. Without thorough familiarity with the market and your specific goals, the maxim of "buy low, sell high" can lead to financial disaster.

Due to the superficial appearance of low costs, it is possible to be duped into purchasing an overpriced diamond ring from sites like eBay. The 4Cs and other features that are easy to miss by the untrained eye are crucial in determining a diamond's true worth.

To "purchase low" means to operate under the assumption that the seller is a fool who has no idea what they are selling. Furthermore, you'll need to locate a buyer willing to purchase it from you at a higher price, and you'll need to consider the risks associated with each step of the process to make a profit.

Do Diamonds Have A Resale Value?

The resale value of a diamond is the price you may expect to receive if you decide to sell it. The resale value is often far lower than what you spent because of the retail markup and the drop in diamond prices. The resale value of diamond jewellery is often between 25% and 50% of the original purchase price.

Do Diamonds Increase In Value Over Time?

The long and short of diamond investments is that the more scarce a diamond is, the more probable it is to appreciate over time due to supply and demand changes. Keeping a diamond in pristine condition is the best way to ensure its continued appreciation in worth.

How can I sell my diamond?

  • Learn About Your Diamond Before Selling It.
  • Establish Reasonable Diamond Pricing Expectations.
  • Think about how quickly you need money from the sale of your diamond.
  • Pick a Reliable Diamond Dealer.
  • You Should Be Mentally and Emotionally Prepared to Part With Your Diamonds.
  • Indicators of Diamond Selling Price.

Do Diamonds Have Resale Value?

In a nutshell, yes is the correct response to this inquiry.

The short answer is yes, but the long answer will walk you through the fundamentals of diamond trading (buying and selling). However, unlike gold, diamond jewellery and loose diamonds maintain a stable market value. Instead, it is contingent upon market forces governing the cost and availability of these gems.

Here Are All The Factors That Impact The Resale Value Of Diamonds:

Diamond Grading Certificates

A customer's initial option in diamond jewellery should be one they can trust. Ask for grading certificates (from the GIA, SGL, DGLA, or IGI) whenever you purchase a diamond (loose or set in the jewellery). Diamonds can only be sold with a certificate proving their origin, carat weight, cut, clarity, colour, and form. Certificates like this are crucial to the resale price of any diamond gem.

4Cs of Diamond

The 4Cs of diamonds—cut, clarity, colour, and carat—are familiar concepts to anybody who owns a diamond ring or other diamond jewellery. An in-depth explanation of the 4Cs of diamonds can be found in Melorra's devoted guide. The diamond's marketability improves with its clarity and carat weight. This information can be found in the diamond as mentioned above grading certifications.

Resale Market

Choosing the proper market and moment to sell your diamond is just as important as selecting the ideal diamond in terms of resale value. There are many different venues where diamonds can be resold, from auction houses and shops to pawn shops and jewellery stores.

Ultimately, the value you obtain from reselling your diamond jewellery in any of the areas mentioned above is determined by the correct timing and market demand. We advise you to research online to find out the lowest and highest prices at which your diamond can be resold.

Diamond Procurement

The location of the diamond's purchase and sale are of equal significance. Since huge brands include the value of their reputation and marketing dollars when pricing their products, a branded diamond necklace will always fetch a lower price than its cost. The typical loss on reselling a diamond is between 25% and 50% of its original purchase price.

Like the price of gold, diamonds' resale value can rise and fall depending on some circ*mstances. You can anticipate getting 25-50% less when you resell your diamond than you paid. But there are exceptions; if the diamond form is unusual or the diamond colour is scarce, you don't have to lower the price significantly. However, the skill of the people involved in the negotiation is essential. Additionally, we have a variety of gold coins available for perusal.

Why Does A Diamond Have No Resale Value? | Brighton Savoy (2024)

FAQs

Why Does A Diamond Have No Resale Value? | Brighton Savoy? ›

Diamonds typically lose between 25 and 50 per cent of their actual worth upon resale due to market fluctuations, the markup on your ring, and the decline in diamond prices.

Why do diamonds have such low resale value? ›

One factor is the retail mark-up. Jewelry retailers, like those in most other industries, buy products at wholesale and mark them up – some a lot more than others. Unfortunately, this means that the intrinsic worth of the diamond, and therefore the resale value, will be much lower than what it was purchased for.

Do diamonds lose their shine? ›

Diamonds might lose their sparkle over the course of time depending on a handful of factors. Even if your diamond is of exceptional cut, color, clarity, and carat weight, environmental conditions can wreak havoc. If you handle the diamond often, the oils on your hands can cloud the gem's surface.

Why is diamond not Pawnable? ›

There are also other factors that make a pawn shop a bad place to sell a diamond ring. The first is that most pawn shop owners aren't diamond experts. As such, if you have a particularly large, clear or colorless diamond, they may not be able to recognize and accurately appraise its value.

Are diamonds hard to resell? ›

While diamonds do have resale value, it's very unlikely that you'll be able to sell your diamond ring for the same price that you or your fiancé paid for it when it was new. In fact, in just about every case, you can expect to sell your diamond at a significant loss.

Are real diamonds losing value? ›

But they're not an investor's favorite currently, with the precious gems losing some significant value over the last few months. Diamond prices are down 18% from their all-time highs in February 2022, and are lower 6.5% year-to-date, according to one Global Rough Diamond Price Index.

Which diamond cut holds its value? ›

Round cut. The most desirable and highly valued – and many would say best – diamond cut is the round cut. A round brilliant cut diamond has 58 facets, which is the perfect number of facets needed to produce maximum fire and sparkle – which is what many look for as a sign of ultimate quality in a diamond.

Do jewelers use fake diamonds? ›

This means that diamond jewelry is often imitated and sold as a real diamond. If you have been sold a fake diamond it is most likely to be CZ (Cubic Zirconia), an imitation created in a lab. While some choose to knowingly buy and sell CZ gems, others attempt to exploit the industry and sell them as real diamonds.

Can a jeweler steal my diamond? ›

It's a two-way street of worry between us and new clients, but a jeweler with a good reputation would never risk their good standing by taking your diamond. Most people who join the jewelry fold do so because of a dual drive: the love of beauty and the desire to help their clients.

Why diamonds are a sham? ›

Diamonds Are Not Forever

Diamonds may be the hardest naturally occurring substance on earth but they can still be smashed with a simple hammer. People are often shocked when they mange to chip their $10,000 diamond ring. Not only that, but overtime diamond deteriorates and turns into graphite.

How much can you sell a 1 carat diamond for? ›

On average, the retail price for one carat diamonds can be anywhere between $2,000 to $16,000, and between $8,000 to $72,000 for two carat diamonds .

How much is a .25 carat diamond worth? ›

Just How Much is a Diamond?
Carat WeightDiamond Price Per CaratRecommended Price
0.25 carat$800 - $4,000$300 - $450
0.50 carat$1,000 - $8,000$1,000 - $1,500
0.75 carat$1,300 - $9,000$2,000 - $3,000
1.0 carat$2,000 - $16,000$4,500 - $6,000
3 more rows
Oct 9, 2022

Are old diamonds worth more? ›

True antique diamond cuts (that means they could be centuries old) will gain value over time and become more expensive. Especially now that we're seeing a surge for antique cut gemstones, their price is predicted to increase over time.

Why the resale value of diamond is less than gold? ›

Diamonds unlike gold etc. cannot be easily split into smaller quantities to be consumed or sold. Because diamonds valuation is high , due to its cutting and polishing when they are made.

Why are diamonds expensive to buy but cheap to sell? ›

Because the diamond industry deliberately engineered the market that way. If diamonds retained their value after purchasing it, people would be selling them all the time when they needed cash. Resold diamonds would cut into the profits of diamond retailers and glut the market, lowering the value of diamonds in general.

Why are some diamonds cheap and some expensive? ›

The price of a diamond is determined by how perfect it is according to the grading of the 4 C's of diamonds (Carat, Cut, Clarity, Color). These gradings identify if a diamond is perfect according to the way it is cut, if it has any inclusions (its Clarity), how colorless it is, or how big it is.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Last Updated:

Views: 6067

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Birthday: 1992-08-21

Address: Apt. 237 662 Haag Mills, East Verenaport, MO 57071-5493

Phone: +331850833384

Job: District Real-Estate Architect

Hobby: Skateboarding, Taxidermy, Air sports, Painting, Knife making, Letterboxing, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Saturnina Altenwerth DVM, I am a witty, perfect, combative, beautiful, determined, fancy, determined person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.