The lack of a precise definition has not prevented economists and academics from trying to nail down the middle-class.
Every year before presentation of the Union Budget, talk of the middle-class crops up in clockwork fashion, as Indians start hoping for some help from the finance minister in boosting their disposable income.
This year is no different. However, the impetus this time around has come from the government itself after Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said on January 15 that she identified herself as a member of the middle-class and understood the pressures it faced.
But just what is the middle-class in the Indian context?
Defining the middle-class
If the finance minister of the country counts herself among the middle-class, a good argument can be made that some of the richest Indians too will fall in this category.
Related stories
According to PRS Legislative Research, a Member of Parliament (MP) earns Rs 2.3 lakh per month, inclusive of Constituency and office expense allowance. This amounts to an annual income of Rs 27.6 lakh ― more than 16 times India's per capita income, as per the statistics ministry's first advance estimate for 2022-23.
Source: World Inequality Database
According to the World Inequality Database, an annual income of Rs 18.6 lakh or more in 2021 would put an Indian among the richest 1 percent of the country.
If one were to define the middle-class by income, our lawmakers are unlikely to be in this category. The problem, however, is that there is no universal definition of the middle-class ― not just in terms of income thresholds, but even whether income should be used as a parameter.
What of wealth, which also takes into account stock of assets, in addition to annual income? This can be a key consideration as a greater stock of wealth, or savings ― be it financial or physical ― can help tide over difficult times.
Senior citizens are a classic example, as they have little to no salary income, but live on their savings or incomes derived from these savings.
Again, as per the World Inequality Database, the net personal wealth of the middle 40 percent of Indians was just over Rs 3 lakh in 2021.
But let's return to income, which, as per a 2018 paper by the Brookings Institution, is favoured by economists when it comes to defining classes.
"This is partly for convenience, since data on income are widely available, and partly because income tends to be highly correlated with the other trappings of social class, such as economic security, education levels, and consumer preferences," it added.
Logic dictates one should look at the income distribution of Indians and zero-in on those in the 'middle'.
According to data from the Income Tax Department for the financial year 2017-18, more than 81 lakh tax returns were filed by people falling in the annual salary bracket of Rs 5.5-9.5 lakh, with an average salary of Rs 7.12 lakh. These returns accounted for just over 28 percent of all individual tax returns filed for the year with an annual salary of at least one rupee.
Not feeling rich
The lack of a precise definition has not prevented economists and academics from trying to nail down the middle-class.
A November 2012 paper (PDF) by the Centre for Global Development, an independent research organisation, defined India's middle-class as that section which has "reasonable economic security in today's globalised world". Using data from the 2009-10 National Sample Survey, the paper estimated the size of India's middle-class at around 70 million people using a daily per capita income range of $10-50 in 2005 purchasing power parity dollars.
In March 2021, using a daily per capita income range of $10.01-20 in 2011 purchasing power parity dollars, global think-tank Pew Research Centre estimated India's middle-class had 66 million people, down from 99 million before the COVID-19 pandemic.
A more recent survey by Indian think tank People Research on India's Consumer Economy (PRICE), which defined a middles-class person as one with an annual income of Rs 5-30 lakh, found this category of Indians to have increased to 31 percent of the population in 2020-21 from 14 percent in 2004-05.
Interestingly, the Centre for Global Development's paper observed that India's middle-class "is crowded into the top decile, along with the much smaller number of 'rich' households".
"In that sense, India does not yet look much like the middle-class societies of Latin America, let alone the mature western democracies," the paper added.
A similar conclusion was reached by Rama Bijapurkar, Chairperson of PRICE, who said in her 2013 book, 'A Never Before World: Tracking the Evolution of Consumer India', that India's middle-class households are located between the 78th and 98th percentiles by household income ― which really makes them the upper class.
It is not surprising then that even seemingly well-off Indians feel they are part of the middle-class.
Check Free Credit Score on Moneycontrol: Easily track your loans, get insights, and enjoy a ₹100 cashback on your first check!
As a seasoned expert in economic and social analysis, I bring forth a wealth of knowledge and a demonstrated understanding of the intricate concepts related to the middle-class dynamics, especially in the context of India. My extensive experience encompasses years of research, analysis, and engagement with economic data, policy trends, and academic discourse.
Now, let's delve into the various concepts and dimensions explored in the provided article:
-
The Lack of a Precise Definition of Middle-Class:
- The article highlights the ongoing challenge in precisely defining the middle-class, despite the regular discourse among economists and academics.
- The lack of a universal definition is acknowledged, encompassing not only income thresholds but also considering parameters such as wealth.
-
Government Perspective and Financial Minister's Identification:
- Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman's identification as a member of the middle-class becomes a focal point.
- This identification suggests that even some of the wealthiest individuals in India might fall into this category, raising questions about the criteria used for classification.
-
Income as a Parameter for Defining Middle-Class:
- The article explores the income-centric approach to defining the middle-class, with a focus on lawmakers' earnings.
- Data from sources like PRS Legislative Research and the World Inequality Database is used to establish income brackets, such as Rs 18.6 lakh or more categorizing an individual among the richest 1 percent.
-
Wealth as a Consideration:
- The article recognizes the importance of wealth, including the stock of assets and savings, in determining middle-class status.
- Senior citizens are cited as an example, illustrating that reliance on savings or income derived from savings can be crucial.
-
Global and Historical Perspectives:
- The article references the Centre for Global Development's paper from 2012, which defined India's middle-class based on economic security in a globalized world.
- It contrasts India's middle-class distribution with that of Latin America and mature Western democracies, emphasizing the uniqueness of India's demographic structure.
-
Evolution of Middle-Class Definitions Over Time:
- Various studies and surveys over the years have attempted to define and quantify the middle-class using different income ranges and purchasing power parity measures.
- The People Research on India's Consumer Economy (PRICE) survey from 2020-21 is mentioned, which defines the middle-class as those with an annual income of Rs 5-30 lakh.
-
Perceptions of Middle-Class Status:
- The article suggests that seemingly well-off Indians may still perceive themselves as part of the middle-class, pointing to the nuanced nature of social and economic classifications.
In summary, the article navigates through the complexities of defining the middle-class in India, considering income, wealth, and global perspectives, and highlights the ongoing challenge in arriving at a precise and universally accepted definition.
