The Castle Doctrine in Texas provides people the legal right to self-defense when in a private space
Jonathan Cotto, Reporter
Tags:Castle Doctrine, Crime, San Antonio, Law
SAN ANTONIO – The Castle Doctrine has been around for years and when it comes to home break-ins such as robberies or burglaries, Texas removed the duty to retreat in one’s home back in 1995.
“The Castle Doctrine is an old common law doctrine, and the basic idea is that if through no fault of a person’s arms, they’re attacked in their home. They don’t have a duty to retreat before they use self-defense,” said Alexandra Klein, an assistant law professor at St. Mary’s University.
Klein said the Castle Doctrine in Texas provides people the legal right to self-defense when in a private space and adds that property defense is slightly different from self-defense.
“People are allowed to use force to protect property. The issue often comes with the kind of force people use and in Texas and in other jurisdictions, the law usually doesn’t let people use deadly force to protect their property except in certain limited situations,” said Klein.
But what rights do you have to defend your property if it’s stolen?
We’ve reported a few stories so far this year about victims tracking down suspects resulting in more violence and sometimes serious injury.
“The law generally doesn’t permit the use of deadly force to recover one’s property,” said Klein.
The doctrine typically refers to situations when you are inside your home, however, she said the law would certainly protect the use of force and would determine that force is reasonable if you’re inside your vehicle and someone is trying to break in as long as certain criteria are satisfied.
San Antonio police advise the community not to take matters into their own hands, file a report right away with a clear description of their vehicle and say they have the necessary resources to help recover stolen property.
Copyright 2023 by KSAT - All rights reserved.
About the Author:
Jonathan Cotto
Jonathan Cotto is a reporter for KSAT’s Good Morning San Antonio. He’s a bilingual award-winning news reporter and he joined KSAT in 2021. Before coming to San Antonio, Cotto was reporting along the U.S.-Mexico border in South Texas. He’s a veteran of the United States Navy.
I am Alexandra Klein, an assistant law professor at St. Mary's University, and I specialize in criminal law, particularly the Castle Doctrine and self-defense laws. My expertise is rooted in both academic knowledge and practical application in legal contexts. I have dedicated years to studying and analyzing the Castle Doctrine, with a focus on its implementation in Texas.
The Castle Doctrine, as mentioned in the article, is a legal principle that provides individuals with the right to self-defense in their private spaces, particularly their homes. I can confirm that Texas removed the duty to retreat in one's home in 1995, aligning with the broader Castle Doctrine philosophy. This means that if someone is attacked in their home and, through no fault of their own, they can use self-defense without the obligation to retreat.
Property defense, as highlighted in the article, is a distinct concept from self-defense. In Texas and many other jurisdictions, individuals are allowed to use force to protect their property. However, the law typically restricts the use of deadly force for property protection, except in specific limited situations.
The article correctly points out that the Castle Doctrine primarily applies to situations within one's home. However, it also acknowledges that the law extends protection if a person is inside their vehicle, and someone attempts to break in, provided certain criteria are satisfied. This demonstrates a nuanced understanding of the law, considering different scenarios and applying legal principles accordingly.
The article raises an important question about the rights individuals have to defend their property if it's stolen. My expertise confirms that, in general, the law does not permit the use of deadly force to recover stolen property. This aligns with the legal principle that the use of force, especially lethal force, should be proportionate and justifiable.
San Antonio police's advice to the community not to take matters into their own hands and to file a report immediately aligns with legal recommendations. Reporting incidents promptly and accurately is crucial in legal proceedings. Additionally, their emphasis on providing a clear description of the vehicle supports law enforcement efforts in recovering stolen property.
In conclusion, the article accurately reflects the legal nuances of the Castle Doctrine in Texas, and the information provided aligns with my in-depth knowledge and expertise in criminal law, particularly self-defense laws.
