What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (2024)

  1. All
  2. Financial Management
  3. Economics

Powered by AI and the LinkedIn community

1

Coercion and taxation

2

Voluntary contributions and donations

Be the first to add your personal experience

3

Excludability and pricing

4

Club goods and collective action

Be the first to add your personal experience

5

Regulation and subsidies

Non-excludable goods are goods that people can consume without paying for them, such as public roads, national defense, or clean air. Non-rival goods are goods that do not diminish in quantity or quality when more people use them, such as digital content, knowledge, or radio broadcasts. Both types of goods pose challenges for economic efficiency and social welfare, as they create incentives for free-riding and under-provision. How can these problems be overcome? Here are some possible solutions.

Top experts in this article

Selected by the community from 12 contributions. Learn more

What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (1)

Earn a Community Top Voice badge

Add to collaborative articles to get recognized for your expertise on your profile. Learn more

  • Todd P. Schwartz Executive Director at Tapestry Networks

    What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (3) What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (4) 4

  • What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (6) What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (7) 3

What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (8) What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (9) What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (10)

1 Coercion and taxation

One way to ensure that non-excludable goods are provided and paid for is to use the power of the state to coerce people to contribute. This can be done through taxation, which is a compulsory payment to the government that can be used to fund public goods and services. Taxation can also be used to correct negative externalities, which are costs imposed on others by the consumption or production of a good, such as pollution or congestion. However, taxation also has drawbacks, such as distortion of incentives, deadweight loss, and administrative costs.

Add your perspective

Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)

  • Todd P. Schwartz Executive Director at Tapestry Networks

    Some would say that Public Schools are funded by not just parents but by those who don't have children in school like the elderly. However, everyone in society benefits from an educated workforce that provides basic services and that generates innovations to drive productivity growth.

    Like

    What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (19) What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (20) 4

    • Report contribution
  • Dean Dudley Associate Professor of Economics at United States Military Academy

    By definition, everyone consumes a public good.The nonexcludability and nonrivalrous nature guarantees it.Think national security or property right protection and you will get the issue.

    Like

    What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (29) 1

    • Report contribution

Load more contributions

2 Voluntary contributions and donations

Another way to provide non-excludable goods is to rely on voluntary contributions and donations from individuals or groups who value the good and are willing to pay for it. This can be motivated by altruism, social norms, reciprocity, or reputation. For example, some people may donate to charities that provide public goods, such as health care, education, or environmental protection. However, voluntary contributions also have limitations, such as free-riding, coordination problems, and information asymmetries.

Add your perspective

Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)

Load more contributions

3 Excludability and pricing

A third way to deal with non-excludable goods is to make them excludable, or partially excludable, by using technology, legal rights, or contracts. This can allow the providers of the good to charge a price for access or use, and thus recover their costs and earn a profit. For example, some digital goods, such as music, movies, or software, can be protected by copyright, encryption, or subscription models. However, excludability and pricing also have challenges, such as enforcement costs, piracy, and equity concerns.

Add your perspective

Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)

  • The issue of excludability in this article does not mention the price gouging that tends to arise as an entity gathers more and more legal means to charge whatever it likes mostly through lobbying. Therefore price distortions tend to be common under this approach as it eventually tend not to be representative of the cost of production plus a reasonable return but that of how much power an entity wields in a particular industry. Not to mention that there is also a tendency for the industry to eventually have high barriers to entry created via legislation.

    Like

    What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (38) What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (39) 3

    • Report contribution
  • Garros Gong, M.Sc. Investment Strategist | Financial Analytics | Economics Data Scientist | Career Consultant

    By using decentralized identity systems, non-excludable goods such as online content or digital services could be made more excludable by restricting access only to verified users with a specific identity. This would help prevent free-riding and ensure that only those who have contributed to the provision of the good or service can access it.Meanwhile, decentralized identity systems also have the potential to address privacy and equity concerns. For example, decentralized identity systems can provide users with greater control over their personal data.

    Like

    What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (48) 1

    • Report contribution

Load more contributions

4 Club goods and collective action

A fourth way to overcome the free-rider problem is to create club goods, which are goods that are non-rival but excludable. Club goods are provided by private or public organizations that restrict access to members who pay a fee or meet certain criteria. For example, some club goods are cable TV, gym memberships, or private parks. Club goods can also be produced by collective action, which is the cooperation of a group of people who share a common interest or goal. For example, some collective action goods are irrigation systems, fisheries, or community gardens.

Add your perspective

Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)

Load more contributions

5 Regulation and subsidies

A fifth way to address the issue of non-rival goods is to use regulation and subsidies to encourage or discourage the production or consumption of the good. Regulation is a set of rules or standards imposed by the government or an authority that affect the behavior of economic agents. Subsidies are payments or benefits given by the government or an authority to support or promote a certain activity or sector. For example, some regulation and subsidies are patents, licenses, quotas, or grants.

Add your perspective

Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)

  • David Orozco

    Don't forget trade secrets, know how, and NDAs. Also, business and legal strategy play an important role. For example, a theory of intellectual property called value articulation pioneered at the Kellogg School of Management looks at the integration of knowledge (public goods) with branding (private asset value) to capture and retain loyal customers and prevent free riding.

    Like
    • Report contribution

Load more contributions

Economics What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (57)

Economics

+ Follow

Rate this article

We created this article with the help of AI. What do you think of it?

It’s great It’s not so great

Thanks for your feedback

Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.

Tell us more

Report this article

More articles on Economics

No more previous content

  • What do you do if your mentee in Economics is struggling with complex economic theories?
  • You've been working in finance, but you're interested in economics. What's the best way to make the switch?
  • What are the different ways to evaluate financial performance?
  • How can you build resilient agri-food supply chains?
  • What are the most effective ways to implement expansionary monetary policies? 6 contributions

No more next content

See all

Explore Other Skills

  • Payment Systems
  • Technical Analysis
  • Venture Capital
  • Financial Technology

More relevant reading

  • Management How can your non-profit effectively manage intellectual property for maximum impact?
  • Social Impact You're a nonprofit leader. How do you measure social impact effectively?
  • Volunteering How can you avoid conflicts of interest when volunteering?
  • Non-profit Leadership How can you inspire community members to take ownership of their issues?

Are you sure you want to delete your contribution?

Are you sure you want to delete your reply?

What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? (2024)

FAQs

What are the best ways to overcome the free-rider problem in non-excludable goods? ›

Solutions to the Free Riding Problem

Communities can turn their public resource into a private or club resource, charging dues to make sure everyone who uses it contributes to it. Communities can impose a small fee on everyone. This will limit over-consumption and, over time, may even spur altruistic behavior.

What are the solutions to free rider problem? ›

Solutions to the Free Riding Problem

Communities can turn their public resource into a private or club resource, charging dues to make sure everyone who uses it contributes to it. Communities can impose a small fee on everyone. This will limit over-consumption and, over time, may even spur altruistic behavior.

What would be the most effective way to overcome the free rider problem? ›

The free rider problem can be overcome through measures that ensure the users of a public good pay for it. Such measures include government actions, social pressures, and collecting payments—in specific situations where markets have discovered a way to do so.

What is non-excludable free rider problem? ›

This can occur when the benefits of a good or service are non-excludable, meaning that it is not possible to prevent someone from using or enjoying the good or service, regardless of whether or not they have paid for it.

Which of the following might help to solve a free rider problem? ›

You can solve the free rider problem by privatizing a public good or by government regulation.

What is the positive externality free rider problem? ›

The "free rider problem" occurs in situations in which a person derives a "positive externality" from the actions of another—that is, a benefit that he did not pay for.

What is the free rider problem quizlet? ›

What is the "free rider problem"? Individuals have an incentive not to take direct action if they can benefit without making any direct contribution.

Can private providers overcome the free rider problem? ›

When Is Private Provision Likely to Overcome the Free Rider Problem? 1) Some Individuals Care More than Others: Private provision is particularly likely to surmount the free rider problem when individuals are not identical, and when some individuals have an especially high demand for the public good.

What are goods which are both non excludable and non rivalrous called? ›

Public goods are non-excludable and non-rival. Examples of public goods are public parks and the air we breathe. Access to parks and air is not restricted and they can be consumed or possessed by multiple users.

Is a free good non-excludable? ›

While non-excludable goods are free for the use of everyone, making them public, rivalrous goods are private goods wherein people may compete for their consumption of it. For example, a person who buys a car can only use it for himself and restrict others from using it.

Why does the free rider problem arise when goods are non-excludable like certain public goods? ›

How the Free Rider Problem Occurs: The free rider problem arises from the combination of non-excludability and non-rivalrous consumption: Free Access to Benefits: Because public goods are non-excludable, individuals can access and benefit from them without paying.

Which of these is an example of a non-excludable benefit? ›

If the consumer can use a good or service without paying for it, then that good or service will be called a non-excludable good. A public library: A public library is a non-excludable good. Everyone can use the public library without paying for it.

What factors contribute to the free rider problem quizlet? ›

What factors contribute to the free-rider problem? Individuals may think that they'd be foolish to pay for, or incur a personal cost, when they may get the good or resource for free. Individuals may think their contributions are too small to make a difference.

How do public television stations like PBS try to overcome the free rider problem? ›

Public television stations, like PBS, try to overcome the free rider problem by employing various methods, such as organizing fundraising events, offering memberships and subscriptions with exclusive benefits, obtaining government funding, securing corporate sponsorships and underwriting, and selling merchandise.

What is a free rider problem for kids? ›

Here's an example we're all familiar with. You have a group assignment in class, and there's always that one kid who doesn't do any work but gets the same grade as you. That's a "free rider problem." It's a term used to describe when someone gets the benefit of a good or service without incurring a cost for it.

Why does the free rider problem induce the government to provide public goods? ›

The free-rider problem forces the government to provide the public goods since the private business producers cannot produce them then offer them for sale in the market like private commodities. Once the government produces the public goods, people can consume them and thus have no reason to pay.

What is the free rider problem in national defense? ›

When a person enjoys the benefits of a public good without contributing to the cost of it, they are known as a free-rider. National Defense suffers from the free-rider problem, if a person does not pay for national defence, they cannot be exempt from its benefits (i.e. being protected from an attack).

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Reed Wilderman

Last Updated:

Views: 6273

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Reed Wilderman

Birthday: 1992-06-14

Address: 998 Estell Village, Lake Oscarberg, SD 48713-6877

Phone: +21813267449721

Job: Technology Engineer

Hobby: Swimming, Do it yourself, Beekeeping, Lapidary, Cosplaying, Hiking, Graffiti

Introduction: My name is Reed Wilderman, I am a faithful, bright, lucky, adventurous, lively, rich, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.