What are the advantages and disadvantages of using comparable transactions to calculate control premium? (2024)

When you want to value a business, you may need to consider the control premium, which is the extra amount that a buyer would pay to acquire a majority stake and gain control over the company. One way to estimate the control premium is to use comparable transactions, which are recent deals involving similar companies in the same industry. But what are the advantages and disadvantages of this method? In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of using comparable transactions to calculate control premium.

Top experts in this article

Experts who add quality contributions will have a chance to be featured. Learn more

Earn a Community Top Voice badge

Add to collaborative articles to get recognized for your expertise on your profile. Learn more

One of the main advantages of using comparable transactions is that they reflect the actual market conditions and expectations at the time of the deal. Unlike other methods, such as discounted cash flow or market multiples, comparable transactions do not rely on projections, assumptions, or historical data that may be outdated or inaccurate. By using comparable transactions, you can capture the synergies, strategic motives, and competitive dynamics that influence the control premium in a specific sector or niche.

However, using comparable transactions also has some drawbacks. One of the major challenges is finding enough relevant and reliable data to perform the analysis. You may not have access to the details of the deal, such as the purchase price, the financing structure, or the terms and conditions. You may also have to adjust for differences in size, growth, profitability, risk, and other factors that affect the valuation of the target and the acquirer. Moreover, you may face the problem of selection bias, which means that you only observe the transactions that actually occurred, and not the ones that failed or were rejected.

If you decide to use comparable transactions to calculate control premium, you need to follow some steps. First, you need to identify a sample of comparable transactions that occurred in the same industry and time period as the target company. Second, you need to collect and verify the data on the deal prices, the equity values, and the enterprise values of the target and the acquirer. Third, you need to calculate the implied control premium for each transaction, which is the percentage difference between the deal price per share and the market price per share of the target before the announcement. Fourth, you need to calculate the average or median control premium for the sample, and apply it to the target company's market value.

Using comparable transactions to calculate control premium has some limitations that you should be aware of. First, you should not assume that the control premium is constant or uniform across different transactions, sectors, or markets. The control premium may vary depending on the specific characteristics and circ*mstances of each deal, such as the synergies, the competition, the regulatory environment, or the bargaining power. Second, you should not rely solely on comparable transactions as the only source of information or evidence for the control premium. You should also use other methods, such as discounted cash flow or market multiples, to cross-check and validate your results.

To use comparable transactions effectively and accurately, you should follow some tips and best practices. First, you should use a large and diverse sample of comparable transactions to reduce the impact of outliers, anomalies, or errors. Second, you should use the most recent and relevant transactions to reflect the current market conditions and expectations. Third, you should adjust for any differences or discrepancies between the target and the acquirer, such as size, growth, profitability, risk, or capital structure. Fourth, you should use multiple sources of data and information to verify and corroborate your findings.

Using comparable transactions to calculate control premium is a common and useful method in business valuation. However, it also has some advantages and disadvantages that you should weigh carefully. By following the steps, limitations, and tips discussed in this article, you can use comparable transactions more effectively and confidently.

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Business Valuation