We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (2024)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (1)

Kellyanne Conway may or may not believe her texts are private.Credit: NICHOLAS KAMM/AFP/Getty Images

Can anything typed into a smartphone really be considered private?

That question is at the heart of a lawsuit alleging that a messaging app beloved by White House staff isn't as secure as it claims to be.

Between shady apps, hackers, and screenshots, keeping a digital message away from snooping eyes is no easy task. The self-described(opens in a new tab) "confidential messenger" app Confide, however, is trying. The company has gone out of its way to tout its "patent-pending" solution to a problem that has bedeviled everyone from nudie-sending Snapchatters to government staff leaking to the press: The screenshot.

In addition to its so-called "military grade end-to-end encryption," Confide claims that it prevents users from screenshotting messages displayed on the app.

"Confide prevents screenshots on most of our platforms," the company's website explains. "Where prevention is not technically feasible, our patent-pending reading experience ensures that only a sliver of the message is unveiled at a time and that the sender’s name is not visible."

That last bit is key, as it means that even if someone figures out a way to capture an image of a message, he or she will only see a sliver of it at any one time — and not who sent it.

Except, not really. Or so claims a lawsuit(opens in a new tab) filed in the Southern District of New York which states that users can in fact take screenshots of the entire message right along with the sender's name.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (2)

Credit: Auman v. Confide

"Any Confide user accessing the platform through the Windows App can take screenshots of any and all received messages," reads the suit. "Those screenshots can include the entire content of the message as well as the identity of the sending party, despite Confide’s explicit claims that such information would not be visible at the same time (i.e., only a “sliver” of the text would be visible)."

And while a company allegedly misrepresenting the security of its product, intentionally or unintentionally, is definitely grounds to be pissed off, one has to wonder how Confide users talked themselves into believing the product truly provided the "same level of privacy and security as the spoken word," as its website claims.

That's a bold claim which just so happens to be questionable on its face. Because here's the thing, even if Confide does block screenshots it still doesn't prevent the message from being captured. All anyone has to do is take a photo of the phone screen with another cellphone camera.

Even Confide's much-ballyhooed sliver feature, which only reveals part of a message at a time, has a transparent workaround. Ever hear of a thing called video? A short 6-second recording, again from another smartphone, would be enough to capture the entire message — sender details and all.

This critique isn't new. The entire premise of Confide's screenshot protection was roundly mocked on Twitter in March after a Wall Street Journal reporter tweeted out a criticism of another secure messaging app.

"Signal doesn't notify you when someone is taking a screenshot your messages," wrote Erica Orden(opens in a new tab). "Have fun, everyone!"

People who gave Orden's observation a moment's thought delighted in pointing out the flaw in her logic.

Tweet may have been deleted(opens in a new tab)
Tweet may have been deleted(opens in a new tab)

As things tend to do on the internet, the response to Orden even became a meme(opens in a new tab) (albeit an incredibly nerdy one).

The merits of the suit against Confide will have to be determined in court (Confide called the suit's claims "unfounded" in a statement(opens in a new tab) provided to Recode), but even if the company's features work as advertised it is still no guarantee that your message isn't being recorded for internet posterity.

The internet, after all, is forever, and no matter the precautions taken, anything flung into the digital void has the potential to be captured and leaked. It would serve us all well to remember that.

Featured Video For You

Confide Messaging App Brief

Professionally paranoid. Covering privacy, security, and all things cryptocurrency and blockchain from San Francisco.

Recommended For You

How to recycle Amazon packaging (yes, all of it)

Amazon has launched many sustainability efforts but it's still not easy to recycle its packaging.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (6)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (7)

Stasher vs. Ziploc Endurables: What are the best reusable food storage bags?

I put both brands' bags through the wringer. (And the dishwasher, and the oven, and the freezer...)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (8)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (9)

Florida students 'Walkout 2 Learn': How to join their education revolution

Advocates decry censorship and erasure by GOP-led state Legislature and Gov. Ron DeSantis.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (10)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (11)

Yes, SKIMS' TikTok-viral dress and bodysuits made me look snatched

SKIMS shapewear isn't magic, but it still looks pretty good.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (12)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (13)

More in Tech

Meta warns Facebook users about malware disguised as ChatGPT

Malicious actors are weaponizing the hype around AI tools.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (14)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (15)

Apple and Google are working together to stop Bluetooth tracker stalking

It's a much better solution than relying on dedicated apps.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (16)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (17)

Public services will get free API access again, Twitter says

Good news from Twitter: It's not implementing one of its bad ideas.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (18)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (19)

'Godfather of AI' has quit Google to warn people of AI risks

Part of Geoffrey Hinton regrets his life's work.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (22)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (23)

Trending on Mashable

Wordle today: Here's the answer and hints for May 3

Here are some tips and tricks to help you find the answer to "Wordle" #683.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (24)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (25)

Webb may have just found an Earth-like world with an atmosphere

Scientists saw signs of water vapor, but where it's coming from is still unclear.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (28)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (29)

Twitter's blue check purge is barely affecting paid subscriptions

A lot of Twitter users received free Twitter Blue subscriptions though.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (30)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (31)

Amazon's two-day Pet Day sale is live — these are the deals pet parents should snag

Spoiling your fur baby is the only way to ring in National Pet Month.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (32)

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (33)

The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.

By signing up to the Mashable newsletter you agree to receive electronic communicationsfrom Mashable that may sometimes include advertisem*nts or sponsored content.

Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (34)

Mashable supports Group Black and its mission to increase greater diversity in media voices and media ownership. Group Black's collective includes Essence, TheShadeRoom and Afro-Punk.

©2005–2023 Mashable, Inc., a Ziff Davis company. All Rights Reserved.

Mashable is a registered trademark of Ziff Davis and may not be used by third parties without express written permission.

We’re shocked (shocked!) that White House staffers’ favorite secure messaging app is probably not that secure (2024)

FAQs

What is the safest messaging service? ›

Here's our list of the best encrypted messaging applications:
  • WhatsApp.
  • Telegram.
  • Signal.
  • Threema.
  • iMessage.
  • Facebook Messenger.
  • Viber.
  • Line.
Feb 23, 2023

Which is a secure app that allows you to send messages on a safe and secure encryption network? ›

Threema is a paid encrypted messaging app that provides a high level of anonymity. It offers private text and voice messages, voice and video calls, group polling, and file sharing.

Which simple and secure app we can use to message? ›

Telegram – Most Secure Chatting App

Here, the system works as when the user gets accessed to the “secrets chats” functionality, the messages automatically get self-destructed across all the connected devices.

Do you get notified if someone screenshots Signal? ›

The chat list, with any messages shown in preview, may be screenshot or screencast without a system notification presented to the sender of the breach of security implied in the choice of using disappearing messages.

What texting app Cannot be traced? ›

Text Vault is the best texting app for protecting your real phone number during texting by keeping your personal phone number private and secret. Text to strangers with a disposable temporary anonymous phone number.

Which app is best for chatting secretly? ›

Telegram, WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, Signal, and Viber are all secret texting apps for Android. They have hidden chat features. Telegram is the best secret texting app for Android.

Is iMessage really encrypted? ›

We designed iMessage to use end-to-end encryption, so there's no way for Apple to decrypt the content of your conversations when they are in transit between devices. Attachments you send over iMessage (such as photos or videos) are encrypted so that no one but the sender and receiver(s) can access them.

Is Google messaging encrypted? ›

When you message someone who also has RCS chats turned on in Messages, your chat conversations automatically upgrade to end-to-end encryption. With end-to-end encryption, no one can read the content sent between you and the other person.

Is Snapchat end-to-end encrypted? ›

That's why we made “My Eyes Only,” which lets you keep your Snaps safe and encrypted, and protected behind a password you choose. That way, even if someone steals your device and logs in to Snapchat somehow, those private Snaps are still safe.

What's the safest way to send a text message? ›

One option for Android and iPhone: Signal

One go-to app for folks who want encrypted messages is Signal. It's available on iPhone and Android and is really easy to use. First you download the app then register your phone number.

What is the most secure way to send texts? ›

The Most Secure Encrypted Messaging Apps
  1. Signal.
  2. iMessage.
  3. WhatsApp.
  4. Viber.
  5. Threema.
  6. LINE.
  7. Telegram.
  8. KakaoTalk.

Which secure messaging app has no screenshot? ›

Confide prevents screenshots with our patented ScreenShield technology. For extra privacy on iOS and Android, our patented reading experience ensures that only one line of the message is unveiled at a time and that the sender's name is not simultaneously visible.

Can Signal messages be traced? ›

Signal messages and calls cannot be accessed by us or other third parties because they are always end-to-end encrypted, private, and secure.

What is the app that detects screenshots? ›

The WatchMeGrow app detects and protects against screenshots and video recording.

How can you tell if someone screenshots your real? ›

BeReal does tell you if somebody screenshots your post, but it won't show an obvious notification like on Snapchat. If you want to see who took a screenshot of your BeReal post, just tap the screenshot icon next to your post in the app.

Is there a secret texting app that makes messages disappear? ›

Speak freely with Confide. With our encrypted messenger app, your mobile communications will be completely confidential and have the same level of privacy as the spoken word. You'll leave zero trace online with end-to-end encrypted messaging, vanishing messages, screenshot-proof technology, and Incognito Mode.

How do you know if a number is from a texting app? ›

Find the App Used to Send You These Messages

You can do this by going to Carrier Lookup. Here, you can see what carrier hosts the number. It will tell you if the number belongs to Google Voice or other apps that can generate a phone number. Once you have the source of the number, you should contact the company.

What are disguised apps? ›

A decoy app is a sneaky on-device tool that lets anybody hide secret photos, videos and messages, under the cover of an innocent-looking icon.

How can I secretly text someone? ›

Android phones

Select Settings, then Call Settings. Tap Additional Settings, then Caller ID. Open the Caller ID drop-down menu and select Hide My Number.

Can deleted iMessages be recovered? ›

You can only recover messages and conversations that you deleted within the last 30 to 40 days. If you delete a message before you update to iOS 16, iPadOS 16, or later, you can't recover that message.

Can police read iMessages? ›

Messages that are backed up to iCloud from Apple devices have a copy of the encryption key stored with them, which law enforcement can also help itself to.

Are Verizon messages encrypted? ›

Protect sensitive information with security and end-to-end encryption through the phone encryption solution developed by Verizon and Cellcrypt, Verizon Cypher.

What is RCS hack? ›

RCS hacking illegally accesses a device's Rich Communication Services (RCS) protocol without authorization. It enables an intruder to gain control of user messages, devices, and confidential data. RCS hacking leads to malicious activities like intercepting messages or accessing sensitive information without permission.

Can Snapchat see my eyes only? ›

Although different, they both work together to provide two layers of security and privacy for your Snapchat account. Speaking of security and privacy, not even Snapchat itself can access the Snaps and photos that you move to My Eyes Only, making it impossible to recover them in the event that you forget your passcode.

Can police access Snapchat? ›

Snap may, at its discretion, provide limited Snapchat account records to law enforcement and governmental agencies outside the U.S. in response to legal process that is duly authorised in the requesting country and that seeks non-content information such as basic subscriber information and IP data.

Can police track Snapchat messages? ›

Our ability to disclose Snapchat account records is generally governed by the Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2701, et seq. The SCA mandates that we disclose certain Snapchat account records only in response to specific types of legal process, including subpoenas, court orders, and search warrants.

Can a third party read my text messages? ›

Spyware can be used by anyone, not just hackers

The app can be installed remotely on an iPhone if you have the proper iCloud credentials. For Android phones, someone will need to install it on the phone directly. Once that's done, your messages and more can be intercepted.

Who can see my texts? ›

Yes, it's definitely possible for someone to spy on your text messages and it's certainly something you should be aware of – this is a potential way for a hacker to gain a lot of private information about you – including accessing PIN codes sent by websites used to verify your identity (such as online banking).

Is SMS safer than email? ›

Better Security: Text messages are considered to be more secure than email because they are encrypted end-to-end. This means that the message is only accessible by the sender and recipient, making it a more secure method of communication for sensitive information.

Can SMS messages be intercepted? ›

Anyone, not just hackers, can use spyware

One popular app, mSpy, monitors text messages, calls, and social media interactions. The app can be installed remotely on an iPhone if you have the proper iCloud credentials. For Android phones, someone will need physical access to install it.

Is Gmail end-to-end encrypted? ›

Your message is encrypted (encoded) and then decrypted (decoded) several times, passing through Google's servers until it reaches your recipient.

Are iPhone text encrypted? ›

Messages, FaceTime, and Mail. Your iMessages and FaceTime conversations are encrypted end-to-end, so they can't be read while they're sent between devices. Mail lets you go incognito.

Is it illegal to screenshot private text messages? ›

Otherwise, you may be violating patient privacy laws. Just be careful how you use screenshots. For example, if you shared a screenshot of someone's private messages or emails and shared them without the person's consent, you would be violating their privacy.

Is it illegal to screenshot private messages? ›

There are also consequences under other laws, such as the Harassment Act. The general rule of the thumb is that you should not take a screenshot of a private message and distribute it more widely – at least not without the other person's permission.

What app hides messages in pictures? ›

Top 1.

Vault – Hide SMS, Pics & Videos is a very popular free app to hide text messages for Android users. It is designed to hide not only private SMS, but also contacts and images, videos on your phone. All of these need to be accessed via the password.

Can the FBI see my texts? ›

Maximum of seven days' worth of specified users' text chats (Only when end-to-end encryption has not been elected and applied and only when receiving an effective warrant; however, video, picture, files, location, phone call audio and other such data will not be disclosed).

Can FBI read Signal messages? ›

Messages are encrypted end to end, FBI cannot access them. Signal does not store messages or user data outside of registration date and date of last use. Signal features screen lock and pin to make accessing messages, even with access to device, slightly more difficult to prevent snooping.

Can you hide the Signal app on your phone? ›

To properly hide the app on your device, you would need to turn off notifications, arguably defeating the purpose of an instant messaging app. The feature is rolling out to all Signal users on the Google Play Store. As always, you can download Signal 6.21.

Can screenshots be traced back? ›

A website can know if you take a screenshot of if you use the browser to do it. A website can also know if you take a screenshot using the print screen button on your keyboard.

How do you tell if a picture is a screenshot? ›

There's no way to verify the authenticity of a screenshot. Unlike real photographs, screenshots do not have any metadata such as EXIF, nor can they be fingerprinted by the noise in the photo.

What app does not allow screenshot? ›

Most banking and payment apps block screenshots for security reasons. Chrome blocks screenshots in its Incognito tabs and windows for privacy reasons. Streaming services block screenshots to prevent piracy. Another example would be Telegram's self-destructing photos, where you can't screenshot them.

Can you see who screenshots your live? ›

Instagram used to notify users when someone took a screenshot of their story. However, they have since removed this feature, and you can now take a screenshot of a story without the user finding out. This applies to both photo and video stories, as well as live stories.

Can phone screenshots be detected? ›

To create a more-standardized experience for detecting screenshots, Android 14 introduces a privacy-preserving screenshot detection API. This API lets apps register callbacks on a per-activity basis. These callbacks are invoked, and the user is notified, when the user takes a screenshot while that activity is visible.

Is there a way to screenshot without them knowing? ›

  1. Method 1. Use another phone to take a photo of the snap (iOS & Android)
  2. Method 2. Use the screen mirroring feature (iOS & Android)
  3. Method 3. Record Snapchat using Mac (iOS)
  4. Method 4. Use Google Assistant (Android)
  5. Method 5. Use Private Screenshots (Android)
Feb 11, 2023

What is the safest way to send text messages? ›

One option for Android and iPhone: Signal

One go-to app for folks who want encrypted messages is Signal. It's available on iPhone and Android and is really easy to use. First you download the app then register your phone number.

Are iMessages safer than SMS? ›

According to Apple, iMessages are secured with end-to-end encryption (this applies to both text-based and media messages). So even if an iMessage is intercepted, it won't be readable or 'crackable' to the scammer. Note, though, that texts to Android devices are NOT encrypted.

Is iMessage the most secure? ›

Your iMessages and FaceTime conversations are encrypted end-to-end, so they can't be read while they're sent between devices. Mail lets you go incognito.

Is it safe to text Social Security number? ›

So is it safe to text a Social Security number? It's not advisable to text your Social Security number. Your phone can be stolen, and phone messages can be hacked since text messages aren't fully encrypted. So no, it isn't safe to text your Social Security number.

Who can read your text messages? ›

Yes, it's definitely possible for someone to spy on your text messages and it's certainly something you should be aware of – this is a potential way for a hacker to gain a lot of private information about you – including accessing PIN codes sent by websites used to verify your identity (such as online banking).

How do you communicate privately? ›

The 7 safest apps to send private and secure messages
  1. TextSecure. Open Whisper Systems. TextSecure is an Android app built for the sole purpose of secure texting. ...
  2. Telegram (secret chats) Telegram. Telegram is a messaging app available on iOS, Android, and Windows Phone. ...
  3. Gliph. Gliph. ...
  4. Bleep. BitTorrent.
Apr 15, 2015

Can a phone company see your texts? ›

Your provider or "carrier" keeps records of your cellphone use, including calls and text messages, and even pictures sent from your phone. Almost all cellphone carriers give detailed information about a phone's use in billing statements sent to the owner.

Which is safer email or phone number? ›

Should Voice Be Secure By Default? If you think a phone call is more secure than sending an email, think again. Voice calls can be the least secure way to communicate. Learn more.

Can hackers see my SMS? ›

Our experiments revealed a malicious actor can remotely access a user's SMS-based 2FA with little effort, through the use of a popular app (name and type withheld for security reasons) designed to synchronise user's notifications across different devices.

Why are my texts blue? ›

Answer. This is the way Android Messages indicates whether the message is being sent via RCS or SMS/MMS protocols. The darker messages are RCS.

What does blue text mean on iPhone? ›

iMessages are texts, photos, or videos that you send to another iPhone, iPad, iPod touch, or Mac over Wi-Fi or cellular-data networks. These messages are always encrypted and appear in blue text bubbles. To turn iMessage on or off, go to Settings > Messages.

Why are my texts green? ›

What SMS green texts mean and how to get blue iMessages. If your iPhone messages are green, it means they're being sent as SMS texts rather than iMessages. You'll always see green when texting Android users, or when you're not connected to the internet.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Zonia Mosciski DO

Last Updated:

Views: 5281

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Zonia Mosciski DO

Birthday: 1996-05-16

Address: Suite 228 919 Deana Ford, Lake Meridithberg, NE 60017-4257

Phone: +2613987384138

Job: Chief Retail Officer

Hobby: Tai chi, Dowsing, Poi, Letterboxing, Watching movies, Video gaming, Singing

Introduction: My name is Zonia Mosciski DO, I am a enchanting, joyous, lovely, successful, hilarious, tender, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.