'We’re all struggling.' In a culture shift, Americans are more open about their personal finance struggles. (2024)

With her family still waiting on an economic impact payment of $3,900, Stephanie Dann of Millsboro, Delaware, decided it was time to share about more than her latest failed attempt to reach the Internal Revenue Service.

So she created the "Still no Stimulus Check" Facebook page on April 29.

"I am a stay at home mom of 4 kiddos," Dann, 28, wrote Wednesday in a post to the more than 1,000 members. She added that her husband is a kitchen manager at Chick-fil-A and his hours have been cut during the coronavirus pandemic. "We are behind on our rent, car payment and electric bill. We have applied for assistance but (we're) afraid we might not meet the requirements."

Motivated by delays in receiving their stimulus checks, people like Dann have created online groups that have attracted tens of thousands of members – and they’re doing more than just venting at the IRS. They’re also connecting in a personal way and, like Dann, disclosing details of their lives that might have been considered too sensitive to discuss publicly before the pandemic.

"We were depending on this check to get caught up with our bills," Dann told USA TODAY, whose family is expecting a two-person federal stimulus check bolstered by the $500 per child bonus.

'We’re all struggling.' In a culture shift, Americans are more open about their personal finance struggles. (1)

Dann, who said she works one day at week at Chick-fil-A and handles mobile orders, said this is the first time she has created a private group on Facebook and that she did it to bring people together. Comments at "Still no Stimulus Check" reflect a potential shift toward more openness about personal financial matters.

Kimberly Dyer, who lives in Nashville and starts her day by checking the Facebook page. Dyer, along with Dann, serves as co-administrator of the private group

"We're hurting,'' said Dyer, 30. "It just doesn't make sense.''

The mother of one, said the $1,700 in stimulus funds she is waiting on are critical because she is a foster care coordinator who has taken a 50% pay cut during the pandemic. Recently, Dyer said, she found herself sharing with members of the Facebook group that she had fallen behind on her rent payments.

"That’s not something I would ever tell anyone," she said. "But it’s like we’re all in the same situation. We’re all struggling."

Anecdotal evidence suggests more people are seeking financial advice and talking about their plight more openly during the pandemic, said Geoffrey Brown, CEO of the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors.

Brown said financial advisers and financials planners are talking about the current situation as "excellent example of the intersection of money and psychology.''

"Meaning that in the past we’ve had economic crises where people have felt it in their pocketbook and there was a psychological component to that,'' Brown said. "But now you’re dealing with a health crisis and an economic crisis and I think it’s just really causing people to be a little bit more open, a little bit more forthcoming in how it’s effecting their lives in total.

"If this had happened 20 years ago, looking at it holistically we wouldn’t have had access to the communications mediums that we do now. So you couldn’t jump into a Facebook where you’re disclosing that sort of information."

'We’re all struggling.' In a culture shift, Americans are more open about their personal finance struggles. (2)

Lisa Gale of Springfield, Missouri, recently wrote in the "Still no Stimulus Check" group that she had 73 cents in her bank account and is living in a motel. (She told USA TODAY she is a vacation planner for Wyndham Destinations and has been unable to work during the pandemic.)

Kaydee Robinson of Oklahoma City wrote that she needs the stimulus funds in part because she is pregnant with her second child who is due June 7.

Amanda Butler Baldonado of East Layton, Utah, wrote that she and her husband have eight children, including three that have "severe medical needs," and she is an independent contractor who has been out of work since March 12. "We are barely surviving," she wrote.

Sharing your financial struggles can be daunting

Similarly, Alyssa Snyder, who started the Facebook page "Updated Not Stimulated," said she is wary of scammers who use tales of distress to solicit money.

"You have to decipher if it was a real story of not," said Snyder, 32, who lives in Washington Court, Ohio with her husband and two children. She said she recently received the $3,400 stimulus funds her family was due. "People have hearts and want to help people."

In fact, Snyder said, members of her private group donated about $500 in gift cards, along with gift baskets from members who make homemade skin care products and homemade lip gloss.

Rather than shuttering the group after most of the approximately 4,000 members received their stimulus funds, Snyder said, she renamed it "Consequential Strangers" and maintained the community.

"When I started this page, I didn’t think it would become anything like this," she said. "I was just trying to get answers and seeing if anybody was in the same situation I was in."

On another platform but with a similar thought, Andrew Gardiner of Stoors, Connecticut, said he was stunned to watch the "stimuluscheck" subreddit he created on Reddit attract more than 20,000 members.

'We’re all struggling.' In a culture shift, Americans are more open about their personal finance struggles. (3)

Gardiner, 24, who builds websites and does online marketing, said he received $1,200 in stimulus funds April 15 by direct deposit. But he has stayed active on the subreddit that he created to be a source of information and also has become something more.

Baby photos have been posted, someone offered to buy pizza for people who were hungry and the comments kept on flooding in.

"I WANT TO PUNCH THE IRS WEBSITE," wrote Dunkaroosarecool.

"Yep," wrote Reddit user uiguigoo. "I make 30k a year. … rent (was) due Friday and I've already missed two months. Can't be evicted (right now), but gonna leave voluntarily to avoid more late fees."

This week, user uiguigoo indicated they are still is waiting on stimulus funds.

"I don't care anymore," they wrote. "Already kicked out of my apartment. I'm living out of my car now. I'm already in debt due to late fees and missed payments. I'm already ruined. $1,200 won't do (anything) for me now."

IM_NOT_BALD_YET chimed in: "I’m just here to cheer you all on. Fingers crossed!"

This story originated from a reader email. If you'd like to share your financial story, you can email us at moneyforum@usatoday.com

Follow Josh Peter on Twitter: @joshlpeter11.

'We’re all struggling.' In a culture shift, Americans are more open about their personal finance struggles. (2024)

FAQs

Why are so many Americans struggling financially? ›

36% of U.S. adults have more credit card debt than emergency savings, as of January 2023, the highest percentage since 2011. Concerns over job security add additional financial stress. 33% of American workers were worried about their job security, as of April 2023.

How do Americans feel about their personal finances? ›

The Axios Vibes survey found that 63% of all Americans say that their current financial situation is "good," and 19% said their finances are "very good." With low unemployment and possible interest rate cuts in 2024, this could be a sign that more Americans are feeling positive about their earning power and borrowing ...

How many Americans struggle with personal finance? ›

One-Third of Americans Said They're Struggling or in Crisis

When asked about the overall state of their personal finances, 34% of Americans said they're either struggling or in crisis. That's over 88 million U.S. adults and an increase of 4 percentage points from last quarter.

What are the main reasons Americans have financial problems? ›

Make sure you check out the linked resources that could help you prevent and/or eliminate a specific financial stressor.
  • Too much debt/Not enough money to pay debts. ...
  • Lack of money/Low wages. ...
  • College expenses. ...
  • Cost of owning/Renting a home. ...
  • High cost of living/Inflation. ...
  • Retirement savings. ...
  • Taxes. ...
  • Unemployment/Loss of Job.

Why Americans are in so much debt? ›

It began rising at a fast rate in the 1980's and was accelerated through events like the Iraq Wars and the 2008 Great Recession. Most recently, the debt made another big jump thanks to the pandemic with the federal government spending significantly more than it took in to keep the country running.

Why do immigrants struggle financially? ›

Many carry debt incurred during their migration and look for loans or work to pay it off, both of which often require a bank account. Yet displaced individuals often lack the know-how to navigate the formal and complex financial systems in high-income countries.

Is the average American struggling financially? ›

Almost 40% of American adults report they struggle to make ends meet each month, an increase from 34.4% in 2022 and 26.7% in 2021.

Do Americans struggle with money? ›

If you are facing financial stress right now, you are not alone. According to a recent Ramsey Solutions study, 34% of survey respondents indicated that they were either facing financial struggles or were actively in crisis.

How do financial struggles impact a person's life? ›

They can lead to relationship problems, physical health problems and mental health issues, such as depression or anxiety. You can minimise the impact of financial stress by looking after your health and seeking support from loved ones or professionals.

Do a lot of people struggle financially? ›

More than three in four Americans (77%) report feeling anxious about their financial situation, according to a new Mind over Money survey by Capital One and The Decision Lab. Financial worries include a broad range of issues from savings and retirement to affording a house or child's education.

Why do people worry about money? ›

Financial anxiety stems from an uncertainty of what the future holds. It's a fear of not having the resources available to meet your needs or face challenges that lie ahead.

What is the biggest financial worry of most individuals? ›

Concern has consistently been highest over having enough money for retirement, with 66% worried in the latest measure. Worry about maintaining your standard of living is next, at 57%, followed by worry about paying one's normal monthly bills (42%) and paying one's rent or mortgage (37%).

What percent of people who make $100,000 live paycheck to paycheck? ›

Living paycheck to paycheck by income

According to a recent PYMNTS report, as of November 2022, 76 percent of U.S. adults who make less than $50,000 are living paycheck to paycheck, compared to 65.9 percent of those making $50,000 to $100,000 and 47.1 percent making more than $100,000.

What is the biggest financial problem in America? ›

Percentage of Americans who have mentioned the high cost of living or inflation as the most important financial problem facing their family since 2005. The latest 35% reading is the highest on record and a slight uptick from last year's 32%. Inflation is the top financial problem named among all demographic groups.

What percent of Americans live paycheck to paycheck? ›

A majority, 65%, say they live paycheck to paycheck, according to CNBC and SurveyMonkey's recent Your Money International Financial Security Survey, which polled 498 U.S. adults. That's a slight increase from last year's results, which found that 58% of Americans considered themselves to be living paycheck to paycheck.

Is the US economy in trouble? ›

U.S. deficits have run roughly 2% of GDP higher than the IMF expected back in late 2022. They will be the highest, by far, among major advanced economies for the foreseeable future. In the long run, deficits inflate future interest bills and crowd out private investment.

How is the average American doing financially? ›

Average Net Worth of an American Family

Both median and average family net worth surged between 2019 and 2022, according to the U.S. Federal Reserve. Average net worth increased by 23% to $1,063,700, the Fed reported in October 2023, the most recent year it published the data.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Arielle Torp

Last Updated:

Views: 6219

Rating: 4 / 5 (61 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Arielle Torp

Birthday: 1997-09-20

Address: 87313 Erdman Vista, North Dustinborough, WA 37563

Phone: +97216742823598

Job: Central Technology Officer

Hobby: Taekwondo, Macrame, Foreign language learning, Kite flying, Cooking, Skiing, Computer programming

Introduction: My name is Arielle Torp, I am a comfortable, kind, zealous, lovely, jolly, colorful, adventurous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.