We Finally Know Why Ancient Roman Concrete Outlasts Our Own (2024)

We Finally Know Why Ancient Roman Concrete Outlasts Our Own (1)

Why are millennia-old ancient Roman piers still standing strong as veritable concrete islands, while modern concrete structures built only decades ago crumble from an onslaught of wind and waves? The answer lies in an until-now undocumented Roman recipe.

Researchers at the University of Utah discovered that as seawater filters through piers and breakwaters made of age-old Roman concrete, the structures actually become increasingly stronger because of the growth of interlocking minerals — including some minerals that are rare or expensive to cultivate in lab settings.

We Finally Know Why Ancient Roman Concrete Outlasts Our Own (2)

The study, published in the journal American Mineralogist, found that as seawater percolates through the concrete in the piers and breakwaters, it dissolves parts of the volcanic ash that was used in construction. This allows new minerals like Al-tobermorite and phillipsite to grow from the leached fluids. These minerals, similar in shape to the crystals in volcanic rocks, then formed interlocking plates in gaps within the ancient concrete, making the concrete stronger over time.

This is pretty much the opposite of what happens to modern concrete structures, which are worn down by the elements and become increasingly cracked and brittle as pores and gaps are compromised by infiltrating seawater.

So why aren't we using Roman-style concrete? For one, we don't know the recipe. We may think we're at the height of human knowledge, but the ancients did possess precious knowledge that has been lost to time.

Although University of Utah geologist and lead study author Marie Jackson has pored through ancient Roman texts, she hasn't yet discovered a precise method for mixing the marine mortar. "The recipe was completely lost," said Jackson, who is working with geological engineers to recreate the right mix, in a press release.

We Finally Know Why Ancient Roman Concrete Outlasts Our Own (3)

There's also a load-bearing issue. "Ancient" is the key word in these Roman structures, which took a long, long time to develop their strength from seawater. Young cement built using a Roman recipe would probably not have the compressive strength to handle modern use — at least not initially.

But that doesn't mean concocting a concrete mix using Roman engineering savvy wouldn't be useful. The concrete could potentially be used to replace other corrodible building materials — like steel and modern concrete — in newly constructed tidal lagoons, for instance, and other sea or sea-adjacent structures.

Now That's Interesting

What's the difference between concrete and cement? Concrete is a mixture of cement — a mineral powder — and water that is formed into a paste, then mixed with sand and rocks.

Advertisem*nt

We Finally Know Why Ancient Roman Concrete Outlasts Our Own (2024)

FAQs

We Finally Know Why Ancient Roman Concrete Outlasts Our Own? ›

Ancient artisans built it all out of a concrete mix that displays “self-healing” properties. That's right — MIT, Harvard University, and Italian and Swiss labs all think ancient Roman concrete has outlasted modern concrete by millennia because it can repair itself after hardening.

Why ancient Roman concrete outlasts our own? ›

Roman concrete's resistance to seawater erosion is attributed to its unique interaction with the environment, where seawater percolates through the concrete and promotes the growth of rare minerals like aluminous tobermorite and phillipsite.

Why don t we build with Roman concrete? ›

You may wonder why we don't use Roman concrete today if that is the case; well, one of the reasons as to why is because, although it gets stronger over time and withstands erosion from water, when this cement is still young and has not had time to develop its strength from seawater, it likely does not have the ...

Did Roman concrete repair itself? ›

The lime clasts had aided in a chemical process that resulted in “self-healing.” Meanwhile, an identical chunk of concrete without the lime-clast structure never healed, and the water just kept flowing through the sample.

Do we know how Roman concrete was made? ›

By 200 B.C.E., concrete was used in the majority of their construction projects. Roman concrete consisted of a mixture of a white powder known as slaked lime, small particles and rock fragments called tephra ejected by volcanic eruptions, and water.

What is the biggest problem with Roman concrete? ›

It was a formidable tool of Roman engineering know-how. Yet, for all its advantages, concrete had one major defect: it was unsightly. Once the wooden formwork was removed, it showed an ugly surface. In the beginning, its use was mainly restricted to substructures where noone would see it.

Why was Roman concrete stronger than ours? ›

The research team discovered that while modern concrete is made to be inert, the Roman version interacts with the environment. When seawater interacts with the mixture, it forms rare minerals aluminous tobermorite and phillipsite which are believed to strengthen the material.

Was Roman concrete lost? ›

We do know that Emperor Hadrian's engineers adjusted the concrete recipes, using more volcanic ash than rock to make the dome lighter, and more rock aggregate in the walls for heavier reinforcement. But when the Roman Empire fell in 476 CE, the unprecedented Roman recipe for concrete was lost to the world.

How long does Roman concrete last? ›

It also has a reduced environmental footprint due to its lower cooking temperature and much longer lifespan. Usable examples of Roman concrete exposed to harsh marine environments have been found to be 2000 years old with little or no wear.

What is the secret ingredient in Roman concrete? ›

A calcium-rich lime clast (in red), which is responsible for the unique self-healing properties in this ancient material, is clearly visible in the lower region of the image. The hot mixing allows lime clasts—characteristically brittle nanoparticulate, an easily fractured and reactive calcium source—to develop.

Can concrete last 1000 years? ›

Modern concrete—used in everything from roads to buildings to bridges—can break down in as few as 50 years. But more than a thousand years after the western Roman Empire crumbled to dust, its concrete structures are still standing.

What made Roman concrete so strong? ›

When the ancient Romans made mortar, they heated up the lime to turn it into a substance called "quicklime" – a very reactive chemical sibling to limestone. And, because they introduced water to the quicklime during mixing, the heat it produced set up a chemical foundation that could strengthen the concrete later.

How does concrete heal itself? ›

Self-healing is a well-established and well-known property of concrete due to its innate autogenous healing properties [1]. After a period of time, fissures may mend due to the ongoing hydration of clinker minerals or carbonation of calcium hydroxide (Ca(OH)2).

Who invented concrete before the Romans? ›

6500BC – UAE: The earliest recordings of concrete structures date back to 6500BC by the Nabataea traders in regions of Syria and Jordan. They created concrete floors, housing structures, and underground cisterns. 3000 BC – Egypt and China: Egyptians used mud mixed with straw to bind dried bricks.

Does concrete get stronger with age? ›

Literatures have shown that concrete's compressive strength developed as the concrete's age increases [11], [12], [13], [14] this is attributed to the ongoing chemical reactions during the curing process, which continue to evolve over time, leading to changes in the concrete's microstructure [15], [16].

Does salt water make concrete stronger? ›

Meanwhile, ancient Roman concrete is still standing strong after thousands of years, and not only does it resist damage, but the salt water actually makes it stronger. X-ray examinations have found the key to the mixture's incredible longevity, which could help improve modern recipes.

How did Roman concrete influence us today? ›

The sports stadiums we see today, with their oval shapes and tiered seating, derive from the basic idea the Romans developed. The arches of the Colosseum are made out of cement, a remarkably strong building material the Romans made with what they had at hand: volcanic ash and volcanic rock.

What was up with Roman concrete? ›

Roman concrete differs from modern concrete in that the aggregates often included larger components; hence, it was laid rather than poured. Roman concretes, like any hydraulic concrete, were usually able to set underwater, which was useful for bridges and other waterside construction.

Is Roman concrete actually better than modern? ›

Roman concrete, in many cases, has proven to be longer-lasting than its modern equivalent, which can deteriorate within decades.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Tuan Roob DDS

Last Updated:

Views: 6189

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (42 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Tuan Roob DDS

Birthday: 1999-11-20

Address: Suite 592 642 Pfannerstill Island, South Keila, LA 74970-3076

Phone: +9617721773649

Job: Marketing Producer

Hobby: Skydiving, Flag Football, Knitting, Running, Lego building, Hunting, Juggling

Introduction: My name is Tuan Roob DDS, I am a friendly, good, energetic, faithful, fantastic, gentle, enchanting person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.