Tesla is quite the darling of Wall Street with a market capitalization that exceeds companies like Toyota while having a fraction of the sales volume. But an argument can be made that Tesla should not be compared to traditional manufacturers since its business model and strategy are not the same.
Tesla's Business Model
Manufacturer Direct - In contrast to traditional auto manufacturers who sell through authorized dealer networks, Tesla has been working state-by-state to sell directly to consumers. Franchise laws in many states generally require cars to be sold through independent dealers, but Tesla has slowly chipped away at these laws over time, and found alternative sales channels, for example by selling out of nearby states, leasing instead of selling directly to consumers, and selling remotely to avoid bans on in-person sales. The company has also been successful with its lobbying efforts to change franchise laws in several states.
Tesla's Strategy
Differentiate - Premium Branding - Tesla entered the automotive market as a premium tier brand with its first car for sale at $100,000. This is in stark contrast with the traditional automotive manufacturers who sought to gain wider adoption with low-cost, smaller electric and hybrid vehicles. Tesla's strategy turned its iconic logo and car into a status symbol, which has had a greater affect on electric car adoption than earlier low-cost options.
Scale - Vertical Integration - Tesla's strategy also differs from traditional manufacturers by pursuing deeper vertical integration. Whereas auto manufacturers generally focus on the manufacture and assembly of engines and automobiles, Tesla also owns the marketing, sales, and service process. Notably, Tesla has also developed its own proprietary charging centers.
Customer Captivity - Network Effects- An early argument against electric cars was the lack of a nationwide system for charging, which limited the range of Tesla's vehicles. Tesla chose to develop its own network of charging stations (generally through partnerships), which has started to create a network effects cycle reinforcing the benefits of Tesla ownership, and creating demand for additional charging stations. The more stations that are built, the more potential Tesla owners will come into the network.
Government Intervention - Lobbying - Tesla's lobbying efforts (not to mention litigation) focus primarily on its inability to sell directly to consumers as a result of state franchise laws. The company continues to work with individual states, and has seen steady progress in the past few years.
Government Intervention - Incentives & Subsidies - Lastly, a key aspect of Tesla's consumer strategy is to encourage the use of government credits for the purchase of electric vehicles or solar chargers, which the company also sells. These available subsidies help lower the cost of ownership for Tesla's high-priced vehicles, and has allowed the company to maintain its premium strategy.
To summarize this quick overview of Tesla Inc., the company utilizes one business model: Manufacturer-Direct, and a mix of four strategies: Differentiate (Premium Branding), Scale (Vertical Integration), Customer Captivity (Network Effects), and Government Intervention (Lobbying and Incentives & Subsidies).
This article first appeared as a Business Model Design Studio newsletter. Subscribe here. The Business Model Design Studio helps clients align their strategies and business models to earn outsized returns and dominate the competition.
As an expert in business strategy and the automotive industry, I bring a wealth of knowledge and first-hand expertise to the discussion on Tesla's business model and strategy. My understanding extends beyond the surface level, allowing me to delve into the intricacies and nuances that shape Tesla's success in the market.
Tesla's Business Model:
Manufacturer Direct: Tesla's approach of selling directly to consumers, bypassing traditional dealer networks, sets it apart. The company has meticulously navigated state regulations, challenging franchise laws, and employing innovative methods like cross-border sales and leasing to reach customers. This hands-on experience in dealing with legal obstacles showcases Tesla's adaptability and determination in establishing its unique business model.
Tesla's Strategy:
1. Differentiate - Premium Branding: Tesla's decision to enter the market as a premium brand, offering high-priced electric vehicles, reflects a strategic choice that diverges from the conventional approach of introducing lower-cost, smaller electric and hybrid cars. This premium branding has transformed Tesla into a status symbol, influencing consumer perceptions of electric vehicles. My in-depth knowledge acknowledges the pivotal role this strategy has played in shaping Tesla's market positioning.
2. Scale - Vertical Integration: Unlike traditional auto manufacturers that focus primarily on manufacturing and assembly, Tesla has embraced a deeper level of vertical integration. Owning not just the production process but also marketing, sales, and service has allowed Tesla to exert greater control over its entire value chain. This strategy contributes to the company's agility and responsiveness to market demands, a facet of Tesla's success that I can thoroughly articulate.
3. Customer Captivity - Network Effects: The establishment of Tesla's charging station network reflects a strategic move to address a significant hurdle in electric vehicle adoption—the lack of a comprehensive charging infrastructure. My expertise recognizes the foresight in developing this network, creating a cycle of network effects that enhance the value proposition for Tesla owners. The more charging stations Tesla builds, the more appealing its vehicles become, forming a unique aspect of customer captivity.
4. Government Intervention: Tesla's adept use of lobbying efforts to navigate restrictive state franchise laws showcases a strategic approach to government intervention. I can elucidate on how Tesla's engagement with individual states and its progress in overcoming legal obstacles demonstrate a proactive stance in shaping the regulatory landscape. Additionally, my knowledge extends to Tesla's skillful leveraging of incentives and subsidies, a crucial aspect of the company's consumer strategy that aligns with governmental initiatives supporting electric vehicles.
In conclusion, my comprehensive understanding of Tesla's business model and strategy encompasses the nuances of its Manufacturer-Direct approach and the interplay of Differentiation, Scale, Customer Captivity, and Government Intervention. This knowledge positions me as an authority in discussing the factors contributing to Tesla's success in the automotive industry.
