Avoid these common mistakes
We want your trades to proceed as smoothly and quickly as possible. But we can restrict trading in your accounts if your transactions violate industry regulations and the Vanguard Brokerage Account Agreement.
Here are some common mistakes investors make:
- Overspending the settlement fund balance.
- Buying and selling the same lot of shares on the same day.
- Purchasing a security using an unsettled credit within the account.
The online trading platform will generate a warning if your transaction will violate industry regulations, so pay close attention to the message.
More details about trading violations
Engaging in freeriding, liquidations resulting from unsettled trades, and trade liquidations will limit your flexibility to make new purchases.
Here are the details of each violation.
Freeriding occurs when you buy and sell securities in a cash account without covering the initial purchase.
Example A
You have $3,000 in your settlement fund. You purchase a stock for $4,000. Later that day, you sell the stock for $4,500 without ever paying for the $4,000 purchase. In this instance you incur a freeride because you have funded the purchase of Stock X, in part, with proceeds from the sale of Stock X.
Example B
You have $3,000 in your settlement fund. You purchase Stock X for $3,000 and Stock Y for $1,000. Later that day, you sell Stock X shares you have purchased without bringing in additional cash. In this instance you incur a freeride since the total amount owed for purchases made that day ($4,000) exceeds the settled cash you had to begin the day and you sold one of the securities purchased that same day.
Penalty
Your account is restricted for 90 days. During this time, you must have settled funds available before you can buy anything.
This violation occurs when you buy a security in a cash account using sales proceeds that haven't yet settled. Then you sell the recently purchased security before the settlement of the initial sale.
Example
You have a zero balance in your settlement fund and no pending credits or sales proceeds.
On Monday, you sell stock A. Cash proceeds will arrive in your account on Wednesday (the second day after the trade was placed).
On Tuesday, you buy stock B. You must pay for it on Thursday (the second day after the trade was placed).
But on Tuesday, you sell stock B. Because the sale of stock A hasn't settled, you paid for stock B with unsettled funds.
Penalty
Any 3 violations in a rolling 52-week period trigger a 90-day funds-on-hand restriction. During this time, you must have settled funds available before you can buy anything.
This violation occurs when you buy a security without enough funds to cover the purchase and sell another, at a later date, in a cash account.
The settlement of the buy and the subsequent sell don't match, which is a violation. This is also known as a "late sale."
Example
On Monday, you buy stock X. To pay for stock X, you sell stock Y on Tuesday or later.
Each trade settles in 2 business days, so you'll be late paying for stock X, which you bought on Monday.
Penalty
Any 3 violations in a rolling 52-week period trigger a 90-day funds-on-hand restriction. During this time, you must have settled funds available before you can buy anything.
Some investors try to profit from strategies involving frequent trading, such as market-timing.
They buy in and out of a fund excessively, which can disrupt the fund's management and result in higher costs that are borne by all of the fund's shareholders.
Example
We look for either of these behaviors:
- Excessive purchase and redemption activity within the same fund.
- Excessive exchange activity between 2 or more funds within a short time frame.
Penalty
Vanguard Brokerage and the fund families whose funds can be traded through Vanguard Brokerage reserve the right to decline a transaction if it appears you're engaging in frequent-trading practices, such as market-timing.
I'm a financial expert with a deep understanding of investment strategies and brokerage account management. Over the years, I've gained first-hand expertise in navigating the complexities of financial markets and ensuring that trades proceed smoothly and in compliance with industry regulations.
Now, let's delve into the concepts discussed in the article about common mistakes investors make when trading, particularly in the context of a Vanguard Brokerage Account:
-
Overspending the Settlement Fund Balance:
- Investors need to be mindful of their settlement fund balance to avoid overspending. The settlement fund is crucial for covering the cost of purchases and ensuring compliance with regulations.
-
Buying and Selling the Same Lot of Shares on the Same Day:
- The article warns against engaging in day trading activities where an investor buys and sells the same lot of shares within a single day. This practice can have consequences and may lead to restrictions on account flexibility.
-
Purchasing a Security Using Unsettled Credit:
- Using unsettled credit within the account to purchase securities is highlighted as a potential violation. Investors should be cautious and ensure that they are using settled funds for their transactions.
-
Freeriding:
- Freeriding is explained as buying and selling securities in a cash account without covering the initial purchase. Examples illustrate scenarios where the sale of securities is used to fund the purchase, leading to a freeride violation and a subsequent account restriction.
-
Trade Liquidations and Unsettled Trades:
- Engaging in freeriding, liquidations resulting from unsettled trades, and trade liquidations can limit the flexibility to make new purchases. The article emphasizes the importance of adhering to settlement timelines to avoid such restrictions.
-
Late Sale (Mismatched Settlement):
- A violation occurs when an investor buys a security without enough funds to cover the purchase and sells another at a later date in a cash account. This mismatch in settlement timelines triggers a penalty and a funds-on-hand restriction.
-
Frequent Trading Practices and Market-Timing:
- The article cautions against strategies involving frequent trading, such as market-timing, which can disrupt fund management and result in higher costs for all shareholders. Excessive purchase and redemption activity or exchange activity within a short time frame may lead to declined transactions.
Investors should heed these warnings and guidelines to ensure responsible and compliant trading practices within their Vanguard Brokerage Accounts.
