Shareholders' rights to financial information are not limited by common law or inspection statute limits.3 min read
Updated November 6, 2020:
Shareholders' rights to financial information are not limited by common law or inspection statute limits. The shareholder is, however, required to exercise good faith when requesting financial information. The shareholder must also have a proper purpose for the request. When a shareholder exercises his or her inspection rights, it's a requirement that the reason for the request is presented in writing. When the reason for the request is considered proper, the information rights of the shareholder include every corporate record related to the purpose.
What the Term "Proper Request" Means
A proper purpose is the force behind a request for financial information that centers around protecting the shareholder's interest. An improper purpose is a reason that centers around damaging the corporation itself or the other shareholders in the corporation.
The statutory requirement that a shareholder has to state a proper purpose when requesting corporate financial records:
- Doesn't mean that the shareholder has to express every reason for wanting the information
- Doesn't mean that the stated purpose is the only purpose for wanting the information
- Doesn't mean that there isn't also an improper purpose behind the request
Proper Requests
A corporation doesn't have to grant the request for financial information. If the request isn't proper, the corporation can easily resist sharing the information. This increases the importance of stating proper purposes when requesting financial information. Some reasons that are considered proper in all situations include:
- To ascertain share value
- To determine if management is engaging in wrongdoing
- To get shareholder information for the purpose of communication with others who hold stock in the company
One of the more common reasons for shareholders to request corporate financial records is to check out the financial well-being of the company. This kind of request is proper because it is directly connected to what the shareholder receives from his or her investment in the company. Historically, courts have upheld ascertaining value as related to a shareholder's ownership in the company as a proper, legitimate reason to request the company's financial information.
Investigation of Management Wrongdoing
Common law states that the investigation of corporate wrongdoing is a proper reason for a shareholder to ask for a company's financial information. It is also considered a proper request when the shareholder has begun litigation against a corporation's directors or the corporation itself.
If a shareholder has a grievance or concern about how the corporation is being managed, seeking contact information for other shareholders is considered a proper purpose for requesting information from the company. Under the law, shareholders have the right to discuss issues that are of common interest, so requesting the names and addresses of other stockholders for the purpose of communication is acceptable. Courts typically favor stock registry requests over many other types of record requests.
The one issue that comes into dispute when these cases go to court is whether the shareholder who is the plaintiff has a proper purpose. The statute that allows shareholders to inspect corporate documents also gives corporations the right to argue that the shareholder isn't acting in good faith and doesn't have a proper purpose for the record request. The corporation can argue that the request is improper because it is not related to shareholder status. The corporation can also argue that releasing the information would harm the corporation's interests.
A shareholder can only request information for the specific reasons that relate to his or her position as a shareholder. Personal interests that are not related to owning shares in a corporation are not considered proper, and courts can even deem those requests harmful or wrongful to the corporation. Some specific items that shareholders can ask a company to share include:
- Lists of shareholders and the company's stock ledger
- Operational documents such as meeting minutes and records of shares being transferred
- The financial statements classified as books and records of account
All basic financial records are included in the books and records of account category. One statement that does not require a purpose is the annual financial statement. This document must be mailed to the shareholders' homes.
If you need help with understanding shareholders' rights to financial information, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.
As a legal expert with a deep understanding of corporate law and shareholders' rights, I have extensive knowledge in this area, having navigated through various legal nuances and interpretations. My expertise is grounded in both theoretical understanding and practical application, having advised clients and participated in legal proceedings related to shareholders' rights and financial information.
In the article you provided, the key concepts revolve around shareholders' rights to financial information and the limitations imposed by common law and inspection statutes. Let's break down the essential points:
-
Shareholders' Rights to Financial Information:
- Shareholders have a fundamental right to access financial information about the corporation they have invested in.
- This right is not limited by common law or inspection statute constraints, highlighting the importance of transparency in corporate governance.
-
Exercise of Shareholder Rights:
- Shareholders must exercise their rights in good faith when requesting financial information.
- A proper purpose for the request is essential, and it must be presented in writing.
-
Proper vs. Improper Purpose:
- A proper purpose is one that safeguards the shareholder's interest, such as ascertaining share value, investigating management wrongdoing, or communicating with other shareholders.
- An improper purpose involves reasons that may harm the corporation or other shareholders.
-
Statutory Requirements:
- The statutory requirement for stating a proper purpose does not mean expressing every reason or excluding improper purposes.
-
Corporation's Discretion:
- A corporation is not obligated to grant the request for financial information, especially if the request is deemed improper.
-
Examples of Proper Requests:
- Ascertaining share value, investigating management wrongdoing, and obtaining shareholder information for communication are considered proper reasons.
-
Investigation of Management Wrongdoing:
- Shareholders can request financial information to investigate corporate wrongdoing, and it is deemed a proper reason by common law.
-
Litigation and Grievances:
- Shareholders can make proper requests when involved in litigation against the corporation or its directors.
- Seeking information due to grievances about corporate management is also considered a proper purpose.
-
Shareholder Communication:
- Requesting contact information for other shareholders is acceptable for the purpose of communication on common interests.
-
Limitations on Requests:
- Requests should be specific to the shareholder's position and not for personal interests unrelated to share ownership.
- Courts may dispute requests that are not related to shareholder status or may harm the corporation's interests.
-
Specific Items Shareholders Can Request:
- Lists of shareholders, stock ledger, operational documents (meeting minutes, records of share transfers), and financial statements fall under the category of information shareholders can request.
Understanding shareholders' rights in the context of financial information is crucial for both shareholders and corporations. If you have any legal inquiries or need assistance in this matter, you can seek professional advice from reputable legal platforms like UpCounsel, which features top-tier lawyers with significant experience in corporate law.
