A Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) proposal to make listed firms disclose defaults on their loans within a day of it happening is stuck in a turf war between the central bank and the markets regulator, according to two people with direct knowledge of the matter.
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has reservations about the Sebi proposal as it considers banks to be the biggest stakeholders in default data and believes such data is not for public consumption, these people said on condition of anonymity.
Sebi had initially released a circular on 4 August proposing default disclosures within a day, only to withdraw it on 30 September, just a day before it was to become operational. The circular had sought to bring bank loan default disclosure on par with delay in repayments on other kinds of debt instruments such as bonds, as required by Sebi’s Listing Obligation and Disclosure Requirement regulations.
The market regulator’s board had discussed the implementation of this proposal in its 28 December board meeting, but could not reach a conclusion, Sebi chairman Ajay Tyagi said after that meeting.
“While Sebi is seeking disclosures exerting its powers on listed entities, the Reserve Bank of India considers the debt to have severe impact on its regulated entities, ie, banks. They are the biggest stakeholders," said the first of the two people cited earlier. “Sebi’s thought process is to remove information arbitrage."
Spokespersons for Sebi and RBI did not reply to emails seeking comment.
RBI’s objections centres on the fact that loan default data is not for public consumption, said the second of the two people cited earlier.
“The data on loan default should be for regulatory purposes only and not for public consumption. All defaults cannot be attributed to malfeasance. Some of them could be because of the business cycles. Look at the Supreme Court case on defaulters, for example," said the second person.
In March 2017, RBI had submitted a list of big loan default cases (involving more than Rs500 crore each) to the Supreme Court in a sealed envelope. The list was given in response to a public interest litigation on rising bad loans in the economy. RBI declined to make the list public, citing economic interest, fiduciary responsibility and commercial confidence. The apex court is yet to decide whether the information can be made public or not.
According to Sandeep Parekh, managing partner at Finsec Law Advisors, the implementation of the Sebi circular requires a calibrated approach from both the regulators.
“Till now the omerta code that existed between both borrower and lender to suppress information will be challenged by the circular (when implemented)," said Parekh.
“RBI has realized that light shown on 10 years of opacity can have systemic issues and is therefore seeking a calibrated response. Similarly, Sebi itself may need to calibrate both nature of credit—not every operational delay is a default—and period of default—immediately may be too soon—and start with a consensus number. It can then tighten the screws over the next few years," he added.
jayshree.p@livemint.com
Unlock a world of Benefits! From insightful newsletters to real-time stock tracking, breaking news and a personalized newsfeed – it's all here, just a click away! Login Now!
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jayshree P Upadhyay
Jayshree heads a team of reporters focussing on legal, regulatory, investigative stories. She has worked for over a decade, reporting on financial scams, legal stories and the intersection of corporate and regulatory issues. She is based in Mumbai and has previously worked with Business Standard, Mint, The Morning Context and Bloomberg TV India.
Read more from this author
Related Premium Stories
Mint Explainer: What’s behind Maldives’ new defence pact with China
Mint Explainer: What’s at stake during America’s Super Tuesday primary polls
Mint Explainer: How Indian volunteers ended up fighting for Russia
Indian politics is becoming increasingly partisan. We have the data to prove it.
The onion peel that promises a sugar high
A decade of flip-flops on farmers’ issues despite full-majority government
‘Revdi’ or genuine welfare? India gives its verdict
Mint Explainer: Loss-making firms' political donations in focus post SC ruling
The news sources that Indians will trust and distrust this poll season
New avatar likely for GST compensation cess
Explore Premium
Catch all the Politics News and Updates on Live Mint. Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates & Live Business News.
MoreLess
Published: 02 Jan 2018, 12:12 AM IST