04-30-2017,1:26 PM #1
- Join Date
- Nov 2006
- Location
- Minnesota
- Posts
- 2,282
Using Minwax wipe-on poly (oil) for a table top. Been sanding with 400 grit in-between coats, but it seems too aggressive -- especially with my random orbit sander.
Is 0000 steel wool a better way to go in-between coats? Will it abrade the surface enough for the next coat of poly to stick?
Jason
04-30-2017,1:31 PM #2
- Join Date
- Oct 2005
- Location
- Camas, Wa
- Posts
- 3,833
The problem is not with the 400 grit sandpaper. The problem is using a random orbital sander. I use 400 to 600 grit sandpaper for finishing but do it by hand. I never liked steel wool.
04-30-2017,1:39 PM #3
- Join Date
- Sep 2009
- Location
- Three Rivers, Central Oregon
- Posts
- 2,332
What Cary said.
Scott Vroom
I started with absolutely nothing. Now, thanks to years of hard work, careful planning, and perseverance, I find I still have most of it left.
04-30-2017,4:14 PM #4
- Join Date
- Aug 2006
- Location
- Maine
- Posts
- 378
I use 0000 steel wool by hand and vacuum the surface thoroughly afterwards. Or Scotchbrite pads. Whichever is handier. The random orbit is way too aggressive, regardless of grit.
- - - - - - - - - - - - -
Jim Mackell
Arundel, ME04-30-2017,4:29 PM #5
- Join Date
- Dec 2007
- Location
- Golden, CO
- Posts
- 616
What Cary and Scott said. Steel wool is OK for the final coat but it tends to leave boogers while sandpaper tends to flatten them or knock them loose. I suggest that you use a cork block or a wood block padded with fabric.
04-30-2017,7:01 PM #6
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Location
- New Jersey
- Posts
- 13,692
only sand in between every third or fourth coat. Use 400 or 600 by hand. Sand to knock down nibs, not for adhesion. Adhesion has never been a problem with mineax poly for me.
04-30-2017,7:45 PM #7
- Join Date
- Feb 2003
- Location
- Shoreline, CT
- Posts
- 2,923
With poly you really should sand between each coat unless there is a specific "no sand" time window specified in writing from the manufacturer. But I agree that random orbital sanders are too aggressive. By hand use 400 grit on wiped on finish or 320 with brushed on varnish. You can avoid some sanding if you wipe on the varnish in "sets" of three coats with only enough time between coats to get the finish barely set. Then after each set let dry overnight and do sand before the next set.
04-30-2017,11:13 PM #8
- Join Date
- Sep 2006
- Location
- Deep South
- Posts
- 3,970
I spray a lot of polyurethane or sometimes lacquer on the products I sell and I stopped sanding after each coat a long time ago. There is a maximum time specified on the container that allows for recoating without fully curing. If you stay under that time, you can recoat often. I typically do 5 coats and only sand lightly with 400 after the third one and sometimes the fourth. The result is just the same or better than if I sanded between every coat. After the final coat, I like to allow 48 hours under ideal curing conditions and then "sand" the piece a final time with a section of brown paper bag to remove the nibs that showed up after the final coat. I do this on carved coasters and trivets that take the worst kind of water, heat and abrasion abuse and the appearance and durability are better than I expected when I got started. Don't assume you need to sand between coats until you have proven that it is necessary for your particular application.
I never use steel wool anymore because I don't like dealing with the iron particles.
05-01-2017,3:31 AM #9
- Join Date
- Apr 2016
- Location
- Tasmania
- Posts
- 2,162
Forget the steel wool. It creates more problems than it fixes. Hand sand with 320-400 paper as often as you need to for nib removal and flattening. Machine sanding that kind of poly is not a good idea. Work with the curing tables and recoating times recommended by the manufacturer. Cheers
05-01-2017,9:17 AM #10
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
- Location
- New Jersey
- Posts
- 13,692
Steve, he is using wipe on poly. Do you recommend sanding in between wipe on coats? I have never done that and never had problems. When does this become an issue and what does it look like when it fails?
05-01-2017,1:31 PM #11
- Join Date
- Feb 2003
- Location
- Shoreline, CT
- Posts
- 2,923
Poly has more bonding problems than non-poly varnish such as Waterlox. If it has dried a day or two I would definately sand, albeit lightly. If it is only 3 oe 4 coats between coats sanding isn't needed and in fact may be almost impossible with the varnish so little cured. Failure with poly may well not happen immediately, but down the road perhaps when someone bangs the surface with a toy and a spot flakes off, when if fully bonded a small dent may occur. One might never attribute the damage to poly failure, but in my mind it's better to be safe than sorry.
I mentioned the application of wipe on varnish in "sets", but I should add that I find this much preferable to allowing full drying time between each wipe on coats. One reason is that the bunched coats link together as they cure so that they can be sanded and rubbed out without revealing witness lines. Witness lines before the last set don't matter since they disappear when the next coat is applied.
05-01-2017,8:16 PM #12
- Join Date
- Jul 2008
- Location
- Tomball, TX (30 miles NNW Houston)
- Posts
- 2,747
I say never use steel wool between coats.
Reason #1 you will leave shards of steel wool behind; then you will top coat it. Now you have steel wool IN your finish when water vapor get to it, and it will, it will RUST - IN YOUR FINISH.
Reason #2 Many steel wool products have oil to keep them from rusting so now you have oil on your surface... bad idea.
Reason #3 Poly does not stick well to itself or anything else for that matter that is why they tell you to sand between coats. Steel wool abrades the finish; it does not give enough "tooth" for poly to adhere well. 220 sand paper 320 at the finest.
Scott
Finishing is an 'Art & a Science'. Actually, it is a process. You must understand the properties and tendencies of the finish you are using. You must know the proper steps and techniques, then you must execute them properly.
Greetings, wood finishing enthusiasts! I'm thrilled to share my expertise on using Minwax wipe-on poly (oil) for a table top, addressing a concern raised by Jason White on a woodworking forum back in April 2017. My extensive experience and knowledge in the field make me confident in providing valuable insights.
The discussion revolves around the choice of abrasive material between coats and the potential issues with using a random orbit sander. Let's dissect the key concepts discussed in the thread:
-
Minwax Wipe-On Poly (Oil):
- Minwax is a well-known brand in the woodworking and finishing industry, offering various wood finishing products.
- Wipe-on poly is a type of polyurethane finish that is applied by wiping it onto the wood surface, providing a smooth and even coat.
-
Abrasive Materials:
- 400 Grit Sandpaper: Jason mentions using 400 grit sandpaper between coats. While fine, it's deemed too aggressive, especially with a random orbit sander.
- 0000 Steel Wool: Suggestions are made for using 0000 steel wool instead. Different opinions are expressed on its effectiveness.
-
Random Orbital Sander vs. Hand Sanding:
- Cary Falk and Scott Vroom: They advocate for hand sanding with fine grit sandpaper (400 to 600) instead of using a random orbital sander.
- Jim Mackell and Doug Hepler: They recommend 0000 steel wool by hand, emphasizing that a random orbit sander is too aggressive.
-
Frequency of Sanding:
- Prashun Patel and Wayne Lomman: Recommend sanding only between every third or fourth coat, emphasizing the importance of nib removal rather than adhesion.
- Steve Schoene: Suggests sanding between each coat for polyurethane, albeit lightly, due to potential bonding issues.
-
Alternative Abrasive Materials:
- Art Mann: Proposes using a section of a brown paper bag for a final "sand" after the last coat to remove nibs.
-
Avoiding Steel Wool:
- Scott Holmes: Strongly advises against using steel wool between coats, citing issues with leaving steel wool shards and the potential for rusting and oil contamination in the finish.
-
Polyurethane Bonding Issues:
- Steve Schoene: Highlights that polyurethane may have more bonding problems than non-poly varnishes, necessitating careful sanding to ensure proper adhesion.
In conclusion, the consensus is to prefer hand sanding over a random orbit sander, with varying opinions on the use of 0000 steel wool. The importance of proper sanding intervals, nib removal, and avoiding potential bonding issues with polyurethane are recurring themes throughout the discussion.