PsychLaw » Are There Different Degrees of Parental Alienation? (2024)

Yes. PA is generally broken down into three symptom levels: mild, moderate, and severe.

How is mild Parental Alienation characterized?

In mild cases of PA, the alienator parent seeks to strengthen his or her position through subtle programming. In some cases, the parent realizes that alienating the child from the other parent is not in the child’s best interest and therefore engages in no programming at all. Nonetheless, anger can be present, perhaps even some desire for vengeance. Unlike parents in the severe category, the parent in this category suffers from no paranoia.

Kids in the mild category are often motivated to strengthen one parent’s position in an attempt to maintain a psychological bond with that parent. On the other hand, children in this category are often receptive to visitation and are the most likely to express affection for the other parent, even in the presence of the mild alienator.

How is moderate Parental Alienation characterized?

Alienators in the moderate category aren’t as fanatical as those in the severe category, but rage is nonetheless an important factor. Consequently, the moderate alienator can wage an intense campaign of deprecation in an attempt to alienate the children from the other spouse. The moderate alienator will often be very creative in obstructing visitation but will usually comply when faced with a fine or possible change in custody. A parent who is a moderate alienator was most likely a good parent prior to divorce, and this differentiates the moderate from the severe alienator. Because of his or her good parenting skills, the moderate alienator often retains primary custody.

Children in a moderate alienation situation aren’t as severe in their criticism of the targeted parent as severely alienated children, and they tend to stop their criticism when alone with the targeted parent. Younger children in the moderate category usually need the lead of an older sibling to maintain their half of an alienation campaign. Therefore, if a younger child develops Parental Alienation, it is usually the result of imitating an older brother or sister. Though alienation in this category is by definition moderate, court-ordered therapy is warranted. Only one therapist should conduct the therapy, and he or she must report directly to the judge. For its part, the court must be willing to respond to obstructionism with all the means it has at its disposal, including fines, jail, or a threat of losing primary custody.

How is a severe case of Parental Alienation characterized?

Severe alienators are fanatics who are obsessed with hate for their former spouses. Severe alienators are often paranoid, and their paranoia involves projection. The severe alienator sees something in her- or himself and sees the same objectionable characteristic in the targeted parent. This projection allows the severe alienator to assume the role of innocent victim. False accusations of sexual abuse often arise in severe alienation scenarios, and the severe alienator will exaggerate and twist almost anything a child says in order to support such allegations. Severe alienators exhibit the hallmark of paranoid thinking in that they don’t respond to reason, logic, or the obvious.

Severely alienated children are similarly fanatical and often share the same paranoid fantasies as the alienator parent. The mere thought of visiting the targeted parent is enough to terrify them. Severely alienated children are often so fearful and hostile that they will try to run away if placed in the targeted parent’s home. Despite this, however, some severely alienated children may settle down somewhat if required to stay with the targeted parent over an extended period.

PsychLaw   » Are There Different Degrees of Parental Alienation? (2024)

FAQs

PsychLaw » Are There Different Degrees of Parental Alienation? ›

Yes. PA is generally broken down into three symptom levels: mild, moderate, and severe.

What are the levels of parental alienation? ›

Parental Alienation May be Mild, Moderate or Severe

Severe Cases: Occur when the child adamantly refuses contact, may hide, threaten to harm himself /herself, and/or runs away. In severe cases court orders are blatantly ignored by the favored parent.

What is extreme parental alienation? ›

Parental alienation is a strategy whereby one parent intentionally displays to the child unjustified negativity aimed at the other parent. The purpose of this strategy is to damage the child's relationship with the other parent and to turn the child's emotions against that other parent.

What are the criteria for the diagnosis of parental alienation? ›

Criteria For The Diagnosis Of Parental Alienation

Campaign of denigration against the target parent. The child often presents complaints in a litany, some trivial, many false or irrational. The child often denies ever having experienced good times with the target parent when that is clearly not the case.

How do judges look at parental alienation? ›

A: California does not consider parental alienation a crime. However, evidence of parental alienation can impact custody and visitation court orders. California courts do not favor parental alienation and will change court orders in favor of the alienated parent.

What are examples of severe parental alienation? ›

Signs by the Alienating Parent
  • Badmouthing the targeted parent.
  • Withholding medical, academic, and other important information.
  • Referring to the targeted parent by first name instead of “mum” or “dad”
  • Confiding in the child.
  • Telling the child that the targeted parent does not love him or her.
  • Forcing the child to choose.
Mar 9, 2023

What is the order of alienation? ›

Inverse order of alienation doctrine is a principle that when collecting on mortgagor lien on a property sold off in successive parcels, it should be first collected from the parcel still held by the original owner, then proceed against the other parcels in the inverse order in which they were sold until the mortgage ...

What are the 8 manifestations of parental alienation? ›

The 8 Symptoms of parental alienation
  • A campaign of denigration. ...
  • Weak, frivolous and absurd rationalizations. ...
  • A lack of ambivalence. ...
  • The “independent thinker” phenomenon. ...
  • An absence of guilt. ...
  • Support for the alienating parent. ...
  • Borrowed phrases and scenarios. ...
  • Rejection of extended family.
Oct 18, 2020

What does a severely alienated child look like? ›

As much as they criticize you, your child will staunchly defend their other parent. They have extreme “black and white” thinking. Everything you do is bad, and everything their other parent does is good. They will deny that the alienating parent has influenced them and claim their feelings are all their own.

How do you prove narcissistic parental alienation? ›

Some of the evidence that might help to prove parental alienation include:
  1. Therapist or Counselor Testimony. If your child visits a therapist or counselor, a professional can provide factual testimony about what they observe. ...
  2. Witnesses to the Alienation. ...
  3. Social Media Posts. ...
  4. Text Messages, Emails, and Voicemails.

Is parental alienation easy to prove? ›

But proving parental alienation is difficult because you are often having to prove a negative – that you did not do something, that you did not behave in particular ways, or that your child does not have reason to hate you.

How do you beat parental alienation? ›

To stop parental alienation, work to maintain a positive, loving relationship with the child so that the child feels safe with you. Consider speaking with the other parent about behaviors you've noticed. If the alienation continues, consider parenting classes, therapy, and going to the Court for help.

How do you treat severe parental alienation? ›

* A fourfold strategy for very difficult cases: reverse the situation, reopen attachment to the alienated parent, teach the child new skills, and proceed to a two-parent solution. Successful treatment of parental alienation or denial-of-attachment is very difficult. Alienation is a very potent family symptom.

Do judges believe in parental alienation? ›

According to the judges, there is a consensus that Parental Alienation really exists, but the controversy around the name also led to the comment “it's a very real, very present reality, yet it's a term we avoid …” One judge commented “it's a term that people use without due rigor, where everything fits!

What is malicious parent syndrome in court? ›

Malicious Parent Syndrome in Court: Understanding and Defending. Malicious Parent Syndrome refers to situations in which a divorced or divorcing parent deliberately aims to harm the other parent. In some extreme cases, the offending parent may even mistreat their children to tarnish the reputation of the other parent.

What is vengeful father syndrome? ›

Malicious parent syndrome refers to a pattern of deliberate vengeful behavior exhibited by the custodial parent towards the non-custodial parent to punish or alienate him/her from the child.

Is parental alienation hard to prove? ›

Proving parental alienation is difficult. It can be done, but oftentimes attorneys and parents will give up too soon. In Attorney Kelly Peterson's opinion and experience, one of the most powerful tools to help prove parental alienation is to depose the other party.

How does parental alienation end? ›

To stop parental alienation, work to maintain a positive, loving relationship with the child so that the child feels safe with you. Consider speaking with the other parent about behaviors you've noticed. If the alienation continues, consider parenting classes, therapy, and going to the Court for help.

What is the difference between parental alienation and parental alienation syndrome? ›

The key difference between this definition and the way PAS has been understood is that PA recognizes the different factors that can cause a child to be alienated from a parent. These researchers have also found that the disliked parent often contributes to a childs alienation.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dong Thiel

Last Updated:

Views: 6028

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dong Thiel

Birthday: 2001-07-14

Address: 2865 Kasha Unions, West Corrinne, AK 05708-1071

Phone: +3512198379449

Job: Design Planner

Hobby: Graffiti, Foreign language learning, Gambling, Metalworking, Rowing, Sculling, Sewing

Introduction: My name is Dong Thiel, I am a brainy, happy, tasty, lively, splendid, talented, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.