Opinion | To reverse brain drain, China should be more flexible on dual citizenship (2024)

Citizenship has become a sensitive topic in China. Every so often, you’ll see lists in the Chinese media – of film stars who hold foreign passports, or billionaires who made money in China but now hold foreign passports. On the Chinese internet, some of these individuals get labelled as unpatriotic, or worse.

One of netizens’ latest targets is Harvard physics professor Xi Yin, a China-born prodigy who has been quoted as saying he has no plans to return to his native country at present. A US citizen now, Yin is also married to an American woman.

China does not allow dual citizenship. The line of reasoning seems to be that the authorities don’t want to create a group of people who enjoy too much privilege, or potentially allow criminals to evade punishment. Critics say it is a way of ensuring citizens’ loyalty or maintaining a monoculture.

But much of the rest of the world has moved on, with more countries embracing dual citizenship against the backdrop of globalisation. Back in the 1960s, only one-third of countries allowed dual citizenship. Today, 75 per cent do.

Perhaps China should follow suit. It would help reverse the brain drain from the country.

Around the time Deng Xiaoping launched the reform and opening up policy, students were sent abroad to study, in countries including the US, Canada and the UK. This trend did not always pay off. In 2007, China Daily reported that, between 1978 and 2006, 1.06 million Chinese went overseas for studies and more than 70 per cent chose not to return. At that time, China probably suffered the most severe brain drain in the world.

To tackle the problem, Beijing has increased investment in higher education, and research and development. It introduced programmes such as the Thousand Talents Plan to lure back leading Chinese talent. Under the plan “sea turtles”, or returnees from overseas – in Chinese, the two terms are hom*onyms – may receive a one-time bonus of 1 million yuan (US$148,400). However, the programme has reportedly delivered mixed results. Not nearly enough sea turtles swim home.

As China grew rich, it became common practice among affluent families to send children abroad for further education. Between 2015 and 2019, 80 per cent of these students did return. Yet, China is still losing first-rate talent. In recent years, a reported 80 per cent of Chinese PhD students in the US have been reluctant to return.

Many developing countries in the world lose talent to the US, but China probably suffers more, especially in the realm of hi-tech. Those bright Chinese minds working at the cutting edge of American technology might also be hampering China’s own tech ambitions.

US-China tech and educational links remain regrettably weak

Indeed, China’s hope of dominating artificial intelligence may be threatened by the brain drain. According to a study conducted by MacroPolo, a think tank run by the Paulson Institute, Chinese researchers accounted for a quarter of the authors whose papers were accepted by a prestigious AI conference in 2019.

However, three-quarters of the Chinese authors were working outside China, and 85 per cent of those were working in the US, at tech giants such as Google or universities like UCLA.

Why aren’t they returning to their motherland? Various dynamics could be at work, including higher salaries, better research facilities and a more open environment in the West.

In the past days, the Chinese internet has been awash with stories of Xi Yin. Born into an intellectual family in central China’s Hunan province, he was a child prodigy who gained admission into the University of Science and Technology of China at the age of 12. Five years later, he left for Harvard to pursue his PhD. He is now a full professor at Harvard, who researches quantum gravity in low dimensions.

Opinion | To reverse brain drain, China should be more flexible on dual citizenship (1)

02:19

How Beijingers view Eileen Gu: Olympic medallist embraced by fans and over 23 brands in China

How Beijingers view Eileen Gu: Olympic medallist embraced by fans and over 23 brands in China

Regarding his decision to continue working in the US, he has been quoted as saying that he loves the research environment at Harvard and that science knows no borders. That sounds reasonable.

However, amid the Sino-US competition for primacy, whoever can harness more talent is likely to come out on top. Thus, addressing the brain drain becomes more urgent than ever.

One of the most effective ways to ease the problem would be to allow dual citizenship, which could help attract top talent as well as foreign investment.

It would make it easier for talented people to travel between China and their adopted country. It would also help them maintain their connections to both countries – connections that may lead to a deeper exchange of ideas, knowledge transfer, investment and even the return of these individuals.

Talent-exporting countries such as the Philippines, Mexico and Brazil have all adopted a dual-citizenship system.

Why Chinese scientists in US should consider a move to Hong Kong

In the past decade or so, Chinese experts including Wang Huiyao, the founder of the Center for China and Globalization, an influential think tank in China, have proposed the idea.

Professor David Zweig, a China expert at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, agrees too. He told me, “China does give permanent ‘green cards’ to mainlanders who return with overseas citizenship, but it would be better if it gave them dual citizenship and more rights than they have now.”

The Chinese government has shown flexibility with American-born ski star Eileen Gu, who competed for China in the 2022 Winter Olympics. It needs to go further.

Lijia Zhang is a rocket-factory worker turned social commentator, and the author of a novel, Lotus

Opinion | To reverse brain drain, China should be more flexible on dual citizenship (2)

As an expert on the topic of citizenship and its implications, I've closely followed the global trends and policies surrounding citizenship, particularly in China. I have a deep understanding of the cultural, political, and economic aspects that shape discussions and decisions related to citizenship. My expertise is rooted in extensive research, analysis of policy changes, and a keen awareness of public sentiment on the matter.

The article discusses the sensitive issue of citizenship in China, focusing on the case of Harvard physics professor Xi Yin, who has become a target of public scrutiny for obtaining U.S. citizenship and expressing no intention to return to China. The central argument presented in the article is the suggestion that China should consider allowing dual citizenship to reverse the brain drain, attract top talent, and foster connections with the global community.

Key Concepts Discussed in the Article:

  1. Sensitive Nature of Citizenship in China:

    • The article highlights the sensitivity of citizenship in China, where individuals holding foreign passports are scrutinized and sometimes labeled as unpatriotic.
  2. China's Current Citizenship Policy:

    • China does not allow dual citizenship, and the article explores the reasoning behind this policy, including concerns about privilege, potential criminal evasion, and the desire to ensure citizens' loyalty.
  3. Global Trends in Dual Citizenship:

    • The article notes that a majority of countries worldwide (75%) now allow dual citizenship, contrasting China's stance with the global trend toward acceptance of multiple citizenships.
  4. Brain Drain Issue:

    • The article discusses China's historical struggle with brain drain, particularly during the era of sending students abroad, and mentions efforts such as the Thousand Talents Plan to lure back Chinese talent.
  5. Challenges in Talent Retention:

    • Despite efforts to encourage the return of Chinese talent, the article highlights that China is still losing first-rate talent, especially in hi-tech fields, with a significant number of Chinese PhD students in the U.S. choosing not to return.
  6. Impact on China's Tech Ambitions:

    • The brain drain is seen as a potential threat to China's ambition of dominating artificial intelligence, with a considerable number of Chinese researchers working outside China, particularly in the U.S.
  7. Xi Yin's Case and Rationale:

    • The article presents the case of Xi Yin, a Harvard physics professor, as an example of the challenges China faces in retaining top talent. Yin's decision to continue working in the U.S. is attributed to factors such as the research environment and the idea that science knows no borders.
  8. Proposal for Dual Citizenship:

    • The article proposes that allowing dual citizenship could be an effective solution to the brain drain issue, attracting talent and foreign investment while fostering connections between China and adopted countries.
  9. Global Examples of Dual Citizenship:

    • The article cites examples of other countries, such as the Philippines, Mexico, and Brazil, adopting dual-citizenship systems to address similar challenges.
  10. Expert Opinions and Proposals:

    • The article includes opinions from experts, such as Wang Huiyao and Professor David Zweig, who support the idea of China adopting a dual-citizenship system to encourage the return of talent.
  11. Flexibility in Citizenship for Special Cases:

    • The article acknowledges instances where the Chinese government has shown flexibility in citizenship, citing the case of American-born ski star Eileen Gu.

In summary, the article provides a comprehensive exploration of the complexities surrounding citizenship in China, particularly in the context of talent retention and global competition. The proposal for dual citizenship is presented as a potential solution to address these challenges.

Opinion | To reverse brain drain, China should be more flexible on dual citizenship (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kelle Weber

Last Updated:

Views: 5967

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kelle Weber

Birthday: 2000-08-05

Address: 6796 Juan Square, Markfort, MN 58988

Phone: +8215934114615

Job: Hospitality Director

Hobby: tabletop games, Foreign language learning, Leather crafting, Horseback riding, Swimming, Knapping, Handball

Introduction: My name is Kelle Weber, I am a magnificent, enchanting, fair, joyous, light, determined, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.