Negotiating Your Salary? Don’t Forget to Ask for Employee Benefits (2024)

Don't be distracted by the dollar signs on your new job offer.Just because your employer-to-be offers a nice round number when you talk salary doesn’t mean you shouldn’t take a second look at the benefits the company’s offering alongside that paycheck.Employee benefits aren’t just a small side bonus that a company is throwing out to you---they’re a key part of your total compensation. Benefits add up to just over 30 percent of a typical compensation package, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.From retirement plans to sick days to telecommuting, savvy job seekers know they can negotiate far more when talking to potential employers. And don't forget to take advantage of any perks the company may offer.Before you go out and negotiate your benefits package, make sure to follow these tips.

Time your negotiation right

Generally, the best time to negotiate your offer is after you've received the offer but before you have accepted the position. Once you've agreed to a salary and benefits package, it's poor form to negotiate, but once they've made you an offer, the ball is in your court. But be sure not to be too off-the-wall with your requests. If you ask for something truly outlandish, the company may decide you're not the best fit for the position after all.

Do your homework

Research the company to make sure what you're asking for is reasonable. If your position involves handling hard copies of confidential information, telecommuting may not be a reasonable request.Likewise, if a company is having widely known financial trouble, asking for non-monetary compensation (such as unpaid vacation days) may be an easier sell than asking for a huge bonus twice a year.

Ask for benefits that benefit the company

If you're asking for software upgrades or for the company to foot the bill for you to attend a professional event, be sure to highlight the benefits to the company instead of what you gain from the deal.Saying “I've always wanted to go to the conference in Portland! My sister lives there!” makes you look a bit silly, but when you mention that you have special insight to offer on a speaker's panel and the networking from the conference may bring in business, that's a much better sell.

Get it in writing

Make sure anything you negotiate is clearly explained in writing and is part of your offer letter or contract. It's easy for things to slip through the cracks or for a verbal agreement to be forgotten or “mis-remembered” after the fact.

What can You negotiate?

With the basics above in mind, what types of benefits are up for negotiation? Just about all of them, depending on the company.While some companies may have set-in-stone rules for certain benefits (such as retirement contributions, or a paid time off structure based on years of service), at other organizations, anything and everything is up for negotiation.So, how do you know what to ask for? Do your research on the company, ask contacts who work there, and do your best to find out what is reasonable at that particular location before you ask. Below are a few common benefits you can use as negotiation tools to get yourself the best offer possible.

Retirement plans

While a company may offer a choice of a few different retirement plans, you may be able to negotiate a higher matching percentage on your 401(k) or an additional annual contribution from your company. While many firms have a company-wide policy for retirement plans, it never hurts to ask.

Vacation and sick days

Everyone loves paid time off, so why not ask for more? Whether you long for a lengthy beachside retreat when the gloom of February sets in, or have kids who catch every bug going around school and you may need extra sick days to stay home with them, you may want to ask for more paid time off.If the company has a rigid policy about PTO, or they simply don't want to pay you for any more time off, consider asking for unpaid time off -- but only the time is worth more to you than the money. Some companies may agree to this, but they may also impose certain restrictions on this unpaid time off, like stipulating that you must take it during the industry's slow season.Another PTO benefit you can negotiate is how long you have to wait to take advantage of your time off. If the norm is a year before any time off, see if you can persuade them to let you take some time after six months. Be sure to only ask for things you really want, though. You don't want a reputation for being difficult, so strategize and choose the things that matter most and ask for those.

Telecommuting

If skipping the commute, brewing a pot of coffee at home, and hopping on your laptop in your pajamas sounds like a heavenly day of work to you, consider asking for telecommuting privileges.Working remotely is becoming more common, though some fields are more receptive to this idea than others. Consider asking to telecommute one day a week or one day every other week to start. Once you prove that you're a productive and engaged employee no matter where you are, you may find yourself in a position to incorporate more telecommute time into your schedule.Of course, this is tricky if you're very early on in your career, without an established reputation. It's also important to have enough face time at a new company, so be sure to consider the best options for your situation.

Flex time

While not every employer is eager to add telecommuting into the mix, flex time may be another scheduling option to consider asking for. Working 10 four-hour days per week is a very common flex time arrangement, though different companies offer different options (including taking a day off every other week).Or, see if you can have an off-peak schedule to come into work. Say, come in at 9:30 a.m. or 10:00 a.m. to skip a notoriously difficult rush hour, or show up each day at 7:00 a.m. and leave in time to pick the kids up at 3:30 p.m. or train for your triathlon after work.Focus on what would work best for you and be sure to frame this in a way that emphasizes benefits to the company, such as being available for early and late meetings on a 10-hour work day or doing an important task that must be done daily at 7:00 a.m. when you're in an office of night owls.

Health benefits

If you have benefits from a spouse or some other form of medical coverage, consider whether or not it makes sense to take advantage of the company health plan.If it doesn't, see if you can receive a higher salary (or a higher 401(k) contribution, etc.) in exchange for turning down this benefit. Small businesses who pay high premiums for employee health coverage may be especially willing to take you up on this offer.

Conferences, continuing education, and professional development

If you'd like to finish your Master's degree or obtain an advanced certification, see if your company is willing to contribute. Or, see if your company may be willing to pay for your attendance at conferences, classes, and workshops, as well as any professional memberships that may be useful in your field.With all these things, be sure to emphasize how all of these investments help the employer and not just you as one employee.

Timing of salary review

If your company normally reviews salaries at, say, six or 12 month intervals, consider asking for an earlier review as a term of employment. If an annual review is the norm at your company, see if a nine-month review may be possible.If you're satisfied with your salary offer, don't ask for this. This is only a useful tool if you are unsatisfied with your starting salary.

Equipment and software

If a laptop or tablet would help you do your job better (by, say, being able to bring it to client meetings and conferences), or a new version of software would help you do your job, this is a good time to ask. Also, if you think you’ll need to field frequent after-hours calls, you may want to see if a company phone would be available.What elements have you negotiated into a job offer?Kristen Pope is a freelance writer and editor in Jackson Hole, Wyoming.

Negotiating Your Salary? Don’t Forget to Ask for Employee Benefits (2024)

FAQs

What is the best answer for salary negotiation? ›

You can try to skirt the question with a broad answer, such as, “My salary expectations are in line with my experience and qualifications.” Or, “If this is the right job for me, I'm sure we can come to an agreement on salary.” This will show that you're willing to negotiate. Offer a range.

Can I negotiate a higher salary if I don't need benefits? ›

Most companies are not willing to negotiate extra pay for people who forego benefits. If you bring this up before your offer is firm, it might even hurt your chances a little to bring this stuff up.

How do you negotiate salary with benefits? ›

Here are some tips to help you better negotiate benefits to your advantage.
  1. Don't Be Afraid to Ask. ...
  2. Think Outside of the Paycheck Box. ...
  3. Get a Better Title. ...
  4. Seek Out Learning Opportunities. ...
  5. Get Everything in Writing. ...
  6. Make Compromises Between You and Your Career.

Can you negotiate employee benefits? ›

Can you negotiate benefits? Employees often focus on salary during the negotiation process, but you can also negotiate benefits or other job perks. Benefits contribute to your overall compensation, so keep that in mind when reviewing a job offer .

How do you politely counter offer salary? ›

How to Negotiate a Salary Counter Offer
  1. Pause before responding.
  2. Ask a follow-up question.
  3. Turn the salary expectation question around.
  4. Get the salary range.
  5. Conduct comparative salary research.
  6. Prepare an organized argument.
  7. Ask for a 10-to-20-percent bump.
  8. Look for non-salary levers to pull.

What should I ask about salary and benefits? ›

Questions to Ask About Employee Benefits
  • Does the company offer health insurance?
  • Will it cover members or my family as well as myself? ...
  • How much of the premium costs do I have to pay for myself? ...
  • Can I choose different levels of coverage? ...
  • What kind of coverage is there for dental, vision and disability insurance?

Should I take a higher paying job with less benefits? ›

With higher pay, you will have greater immediate purchasing power. On the other hand, better benefits may improve your lifestyle in ways that the additional purchasing power cannot compensate for. In the end, the main thing to consider is how important having more money in your paycheck is compared to other perks.

Can you lose a job offer by negotiating salary? ›

It is simple: you can lose a job offer by negotiating salary if you make unreasonable demands or by going below what is expected of the request.

How do you respond to a low salary offer example? ›

Thank you for getting in touch! I'm excited to review the details when I receive the written offer. The salary is a bit lower than I was expecting, so I'll need a few days to see if I can make it work.

What are 5 tips for negotiating salary? ›

Here are 10 salary negotiation tips that every HR professional and employee should know.
  • Practice Your Salary Negotiation Speech. ...
  • Be Honest and Transparent. ...
  • Negotiating Salary with the Right Mindset. ...
  • Ask Responsive Questions. ...
  • Salary Negotiation in the Right Surroundings. ...
  • Be Firm but Flexible. ...
  • Think About the Total Package.
Apr 19, 2023

How do you negotiate salary and benefits via email? ›

How to write a salary negotiation email
  1. Keep it professional. ...
  2. Create a clear subject title. ...
  3. Select an appropriate greeting. ...
  4. Thank the employer for their offer. ...
  5. Be specific about salary. ...
  6. Reinforce your experience and qualifications. ...
  7. Include other negotiable items. ...
  8. Finish with positive language.
May 22, 2023

Do employee benefits really matter? ›

A solid employee benefits package can help to attract and retain talent. Benefits can help you differentiate your business from competitors. Employee benefits can improve your company's bottom line by engaging employees to participate in wellbeing programs, such as Virgin Pulse.

Can a company fire you for negotiating salary? ›

Although there's no law against it, firing employees simply for asking for a raise isn't a good business practice. You want to keep employees who put their best efforts into their job, and are willing to go the extra mile.

How do I turn down a job offer because of pay and benefits? ›

Tips for declining a job offer due to salary
  1. Be concise. When declining an offer, respond concisely to save time and express your decision clearly.
  2. Think it over. If possible, ask for time to make a decision. ...
  3. Offer to stay in communication. ...
  4. Consider other benefits. ...
  5. Provide a salary range.
Jan 30, 2023

What is a reasonable amount to counter offer salary? ›

Start with a figure that's no more than 10-20% above their initial offer. Remember, you're applying for entry level, and you shouldn't expect something on the higher range. Consider negotiating lower if 10-20% places you above the average.

How do you subtly negotiate salary? ›

Following are more detailed tips on when and how to negotiate salary during an interview.
  1. You need timing and tact. ...
  2. Hold your cards fairly close. ...
  3. Get your figures right. ...
  4. Discuss what's offered. ...
  5. Present a strong case. ...
  6. Never bluff. ...
  7. Think beyond the pay packet. ...
  8. Get it in writing.
May 29, 2023

How do you negotiate a higher salary after a counter offer? ›

How To Negotiate a Counteroffer
  1. Know your value and the industry rate for your position. ...
  2. Don't rush it. ...
  3. Don't forget non-salary benefits. ...
  4. Don't push too hard. ...
  5. Don't say too much. ...
  6. Know what's really important to you. ...
  7. Use a template to frame your request.
Dec 3, 2022

What should I ask for employee benefits? ›

16 Benefits Questions to Ask Before Accepting a Job
  • Is there an insurance waiting period? ...
  • Is the health insurance plan an HMO or PPO? ...
  • What are the yearly deductibles and premiums? ...
  • Will the insurance cover pre-existing conditions? ...
  • Can my family get insurance coverage? ...
  • Do you offer vision and/or dental insurance plans?
Oct 11, 2022

Should salary include benefits? ›

Assess any other benefits you receive

If your employer matches your contributions or puts any funds toward your retirement, this amount should be included in your total compensation. Additional benefits could include tuition assistance, gym memberships, parking or commuting or childcare assistance.

How do you ask employees what benefits they want? ›

21 questions to consider asking in your employee benefits satisfaction survey
  1. Which 3 benefits do you need the most? ...
  2. Which 3 benefits are the least important to you? ...
  3. Do you clearly understand the benefits you receive from us? ...
  4. How satisfied are you with your health insurance plan?
Aug 25, 2022

Are employee benefits more important than salary? ›

Salaries are the mandatory remuneration, while benefits are the complementary gains that may or may not be offered by an employer. Even though they are not compulsory, benefits hold utmost importance for employees when deciding on a job. Benefits contribute to the work-life balance sought by the workforce of today.

Are benefits worth more than salary? ›

Benefits make up more than 30% of the typical job's compensation, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. But figuring out what your benefits are worth isn't always easy. You may need to do a little digging to find how much your employer contributes toward health insurance, retirement plans and other perks.

How much more are benefits worth in salary? ›

The average benefits package is around 30% of the worth of a salary. For example, a $65,000 salary would have an estimated benefits package worth $27,855, bringing the total compensation to $92,855.

When should I not negotiate salary? ›

Don't negotiate your salary until you have a firm offer. Don't try to get one company to match another company's offer. Don't rely on the estimates you see on a salary website. Don't fixate only on money.

What not to do when negotiating a job offer? ›

Achieve the Job Offer You Deserve by Avoiding These 10 Salary Negotiation Mistakes
  1. Settling/Not Negotiating. ...
  2. Revealing How Much You Would Accept. ...
  3. Focusing on Need/Greed Rather Than Value. ...
  4. Making a Salary Pitch Too Early. ...
  5. Accepting Job Offer Too Quickly. ...
  6. Declining Job Offer Too Quickly.

Should you accept first salary offer? ›

Don't accept the first offer — they expect you to negotiate and salary is always negotiable.” “That's just not true,” says Weiss. Sure, much of the time there is an opportunity to negotiate, but some hiring managers genuinely give you the only number they can offer. The best way to find out, says Weiss, is to inquire.

How do you ask for a higher salary offer example? ›

Thanks for offering me a promotion to the role of (job name). I'd love to accept, but I would like to discuss my starting salary before I do. I have checked out similar roles externally, and the starting salaries are much higher. Please let me know if there is room for negotiation and how we begin this process.

How do you answer a lowball salary offer? ›

I'm really excited about the company and the role. I want to be upfront with you that the salary is lower than I was expecting based on my skills and experience. I'd like to be at a number more like $X. I'm really interested in this opportunity and would love to make this work with you.”

What is the #1 rule of salary negotiation? ›

So how aggressive should you be when negotiating salary? A good rule of thumb is to counter offer between 10% and 20% above the offer amount.

How do you negotiate salary 3 winning strategies? ›

13 salary negotiation strategies
  1. Research the national average salary. ...
  2. Adjust your salary. ...
  3. Prepare to deal with different kinds of negotiators. ...
  4. Decide on your salary range. ...
  5. Consider other negotiable benefits. ...
  6. Delay salary negotiations for as long as possible. ...
  7. Let the hiring manager make an initial offer.
Feb 16, 2023

How do you negotiate salary examples? ›

"I'm very excited about the position and know that I'd be the right fit for the team. I'm also excited about your offer, and knowing that I'll bring a lot of value to the table based on my experience that we discussed during the interviews, I'm wondering if we can explore a slightly higher starting salary of $60,000.

How do you negotiate salary when you know you are underpaid? ›

Set up a meeting to discuss your pay.

Remind them of your recent wins, and then say, "I've done some research, and it appears I'm underpaid by x percent." Then stop talking. "We always want to fill the awkward moment, but just wait," she says. This will make it clear that the next step is your boss's to take.

What do you answer for expected salary? ›

Consider giving a salary range, not a number

If a job post asks applicants to state their expected salary when applying for the position, then give a range — not a specific figure — you're comfortable with. Answers like “Negotiable” might work, but they can also make you look evasive.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Otha Schamberger

Last Updated:

Views: 6569

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Otha Schamberger

Birthday: 1999-08-15

Address: Suite 490 606 Hammes Ferry, Carterhaven, IL 62290

Phone: +8557035444877

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: Fishing, Flying, Jewelry making, Digital arts, Sand art, Parkour, tabletop games

Introduction: My name is Otha Schamberger, I am a vast, good, healthy, cheerful, energetic, gorgeous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.