B Com Exam>B Com Notes>Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art
Economic is not a science. Discuss?
Ref: https://edurev.in/question/560449/Economic-is-not-a-science-Discuss-
There is a great controversy among the economists regarding the nature of economics, whether the subject ‘economics’ is considered as science or an art.
If it is a science, then either positive science or normative science.
Economics as a Science:
Before we start discussing whether economics is science or not, it becomes necessary to have a clear idea about science. Science is a systematic study of knowledge and fact which develops the correlation-ship between cause and effect. Science is not only the collection of facts, according to Prof. Poincare, in reality, all the facts must be systematically collected, classified and analyzed.
There are following characteristics of any science subject, such as;
(i) It is based on systematic study of knowledge or facts;
(ii) It develops correlation-ship between cause and effect;
(iii) All the laws are universally accepted
(iv) All the laws are tested and based on experiments;
(v) It can make future predictions;
(vi) It has a scale of measurement.
On the basis of all these characteristics, Prof. Robbins, Prof Jordon, Prof. Robertson etc. claimed economics as one of the subject of science like physics, chemistry etc. According to all these economists, ‘economics’ has also several characteristics similar to other science subjects.
(i) Economics is also a systematic study of knowledge and facts. All the theories and facts related with both micro and macro economics are systematically collected, classified and analyzed.
(ii) Economics deals with the correlation-ship between cause and effect. For example, supply is a positive function of price, i.e., change in price is cause but change in supply is effect.
(iii) All the laws in economics are also universally accepted, like, law of demand, law of supply, law of diminishing marginal utility etc.
(iv) Theories and laws of economics are based on experiments, like, mixed economy to is an experimental outcome between capitalist and socialist economies.
(v) Economics has a scale of measurement. According to Prof. Marshall, ‘money’ is used as the measuring rod in economics. However, according to Prof. A.K. Sen, Human Development Index (HDI) is used to measure economic development of a country.
However, the most important question is whether economics is a positive science or a normative science? Positive science deals with all the real things or activities. It gives the solution what is? What was? What will be? It deals with all the practical things. For example, poverty and unemployment are the biggest problems in India. The life expectancy of birth in India is gradually rising. All these above statements are known as positive statements. These statements are all concerned with real facts and information.
On the contrary, normative science deals with what ought to be? What ought to have happened? Normative science offers suggestions to the problems. The statements dealing with these suggestions are coming under normative statements. These statements give the ideas about both good and bad effects of any particular problem or policy. For example, illiteracy is a curse for Indian economy. The backwardness of Indian economy is due to ‘population explosion’.
Now an important question arises whether economics is a positive science or a normative science? The economists like Prof. Senior (classical economist) and Prof. Robbins, Prof. Freight-men (modern economists) claimed that economics is a positive science. However, Prof. Pigou (classical economist). Prof. Marshall (neoclassical economist) etc. are of opinion that economics is a normative science.
Economics and Positive Science:
The following statements can ensure economics as a positive science, such as;
(i) Logically based:
The ideas of economics are based on absolute logical clarifications and moreover, it develops relationship between cause and effect.
(ii) Labour Specialisation:
Labour law is an important topic of economics. It is based on the law of specialisation of labour Economists must concern with the causes and effects of labour-division.
(iii) Not Neutral:
Economics is not a neutral between positive and normative sciences. According to most economists, economics is merely positive science rather than normative science.
Economics and Normative Science:
The following statements can ensure economics as a normative science, such as,
(i) Emotional View:
A rational human being has not only logical view but also has sentimental attachments and emotional views regarding any activity. These emotional attachments are all coming under normative statements. Hence, economics is a normative science.
(ii) Welfare Activity:
Economics is a science of human welfare, All the economic forwarded their theories for the development of human standard of living Hence, all the economic statements have their respective normative views.
(iii) Economic Planning:
Economic planning is one of the main instruments of economic development. Several economists have given their personal views for the successful implementation of economic plan. Hence, economics is coming under normative science.
All these lead us to the conclusion that ‘Economics’ is both positive and normative science. It does not only tell us why certain things happen however, it also gives idea whether it is right thing to happen.
Economics as an Art:
According to Т.К. Mehta, ‘Knowledge is science, action is art.’ According to Pigou, Marshall etc., economics is also considered as an art. In other way, art is the practical application of knowledge for achieving particular goals. Science gives us principles of any discipline however, art turns all these principles into reality. Therefore, considering the activities in economics, it can claimed as an art also, because it gives guidance to the solutions of all the economic problems.
Therefore, from all the above discussions we can conclude that economics is neither a science nor an art only. However, it is a golden combination of both. According to Cossa, science and art are complementary to each other. Hence, economics is considered as both a science as well as an art.
The document Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art - B Com is a part of B Com category.
All you need of B Com at this link: B Com
FAQs on Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art - B Com
| 1. What is the nature of economics? |  |
Ans. The nature of economics can be described as both a science and an art. As a science, economics uses empirical data and mathematical models to analyze and explain the behavior of individuals, firms, and economies. It applies the scientific method to test hypotheses and make predictions. On the other hand, economics is also considered an art because it requires subjective judgment and interpretation. Economic policies and decisions often involve value judgments and trade-offs based on societal norms and goals.
| 2. How does economics qualify as a science? | |
Ans. Economics qualifies as a science because it follows the scientific method to study and understand economic phenomena. It formulates hypotheses, tests them through observation and experimentation, and uses data analysis to draw conclusions. Economics relies on empirical evidence and mathematical models to make predictions and explain economic behavior. It aims to establish causal relationships and theories that can be verified and replicated, similar to other natural and social sciences.
| 3. In what ways is economics considered an art? | |
Ans. Economics is considered an art because it involves subjective judgment and interpretation. Economic policies and decisions often require making choices based on values, societal norms, and goals. For example, determining the allocation of resources, setting tax rates, or formulating social welfare programs involves making trade-offs based on ethical considerations and political priorities. Economic analysis may provide insights, but ultimately, it is up to policymakers and individuals to make value-based decisions.
| 4. How does economics use empirical data? | |
Ans. Economics uses empirical data to study economic phenomena and test economic theories. Empirical data refers to real-world observations and measurements. Economists collect data on variables such as prices, quantities, incomes, and employment from various sources like surveys, government reports, and statistical agencies. They analyze this data using statistical methods to identify patterns, correlations, and trends. Empirical data helps economists validate or reject hypotheses, estimate economic relationships, and make predictions.
| 5. What is the role of mathematical models in economics? | |
Ans. Mathematical models play a crucial role in economics by providing a formal framework to analyze economic behavior and relationships. These models use mathematical equations and formulas to represent economic variables and their interdependencies. They enable economists to quantify and measure the impact of various factors on economic outcomes. Mathematical models help in making predictions, understanding complex economic systems, and evaluating the effects of policy changes. However, they also have limitations and assumptions that should be carefully considered when interpreting their results.
About this Document
This document is useful for B Com
 | 4.85/5 Rating |
| Nalini Iyer |
Document Description: Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art for B Com 2024 is part of B Com preparation. The notes and questions for Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art have been prepared according to the B Com exam syllabus. Information about Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art covers topics like and Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art Example, for B Com 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, notes, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art.
Introduction of Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art in English is available as part of our B Com preparation & Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art in Hindi for B Com courses. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for B Com Exam by signing up for free. B Com: Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art - B Com
Description
Full syllabus notes, lecture & questions for Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art - B Com - B Com | Plus excerises question with solution to help you revise complete syllabus | Best notes, free PDF download
Information about Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art
In this doc you can find the meaning of Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides explaining types of Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art tests, examples and also practice B Com tests.
Download as PDF
Download as PDF
"); var html = ""; html += "
"; $(".trnd_tst").append(html); $(".trnd_tst").append("
"); if (data.length == 0) { $(".trnd_tst").remove(); } } catch (e) {} } GetTrendingTest = function () { try { $.ajax({ type: "POST", //data: "{catId: '" + catId + "'}", url: "/Quiz/TrendingTest", contentType: "application/json;charset=utf-8", dataType: "json", success: function (data) { if (data.length > 0) { var html = ""; //console.log(data); GetQuizLikeSearchSideBar_trending(data); } else { $(".trnd_tst").remove(); } }, error: function (a, b, c) { console.log(a + "," + b + "," + c); _HideLoader(); } }); // } catch (e) {} } trendTestHTML = function (data) { var qlink = ""; qlink = "/course/quiz/-1_test/" + data.guid; var html = ""; try { html = "
- "; html += "
- "; html += "" + data["title"] + ""; html += " "; if ( (data.totalTime != null && data.totalTime != "" && data.totalTime != "518400") || (data.ques != null && data.ques != "" && parseInt( data.ques )>0) ) { html += "
- "; html += "
"; html += "Test | " + data.ques + " Questions"; var time = ""; if (data.totalTime != null && data.totalTime != "" && data.totalTime != "518400") { time = " | " + data.totalTime + " min"; html += time; } html += "
"; html += " "; } html += "
"; } catch (e) { console.log(e); } return html; };
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
Continue with Google
10M+ students study on EduRev
Download the FREE EduRev App
Track your progress, build streaks, highlight & save important lessons and more!
Related Searches
Exam
,
Summary
,
video lectures
,
shortcuts and tricks
,
Sample Paper
,
Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art - B Com
,
Previous Year Questions with Solutions
,
study material
,
MCQs
,
Free
,
practice quizzes
,
ppt
,
,
Semester Notes
,
Important questions
,
mock tests for examination
,
Objective type Questions
,
Extra Questions
,
past year papers
,
Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art - B Com
,
Nature of Economics: Economics as a Science and an Art - B Com
,
Viva Questions
;
Join with a free account
Get Instant Access to 1000+ FREE Docs, Videos & Tests
10,000,000
Users
100+
Exams
3,25,000
Docs and Videos
75,000
Tests
I have an EduRev Account • Sign Up with Email
Attempt this test on App!
Get detailed analysis along with solutions of each question.
Open in App
Not Now
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); } else if (catId != null && catId != '' && catId == '48') { var ht_ml = "
UPSC is the most crucial stepping stone for aspirants, and the right platform can make all the difference. Get access to high-quality study material including notes, videos,tests & all famous books summaries along with expert guidance, and a community of like-minded individuals.Take the first step towards success by signing up on EduRev today.
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); } else if (catId != null && catId != '' && catId == '69') { var ht_ml = "
CAT is the most crucial stepping stone to your dream MBA college, and the right platform can make all the difference. Get access to high-quality study material including notes, videos & tests with expert guidance, and a community of like-minded individuals.Take the first step towards success by signing up on EduRev today.
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); } else if (catId != null && catId != '' && catId == '32') { var ht_ml = "
JEE is a crucial stepping stone for IIT aspirants, and the right platform can make all the difference. Get access to high-quality study material including notes, videos & tests along with expert guidance, and a community of like-minded individuals. Take the first step towards success by signing up on EduRev today.
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); } else if (catId != null && catId != '' && parseInt(catId) >= 18 && parseInt(catId) <= 29) { var ht_ml = "
Want to become a " + catName + " topper? The right platform can make all the difference. Get access to high-quality study material including notes, videos, tests & sample papers along with expert guidance, and a community of like-minded individuals. Take the first step towards success by signing up on EduRev today.
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); } else { var ht_ml = "
Are you preparing for " + catName + " Exam? Then you should check out the best video lectures, notes, free mock test series, crash course and much more provided by EduRev. You also get your detailed analysis and report cards along with 24x7 doubt solving for you to excel in " + catName + " exam. So join EduRev now and revolutionise the way you learn!
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); //$(".adbnr3_tb").parent(".cnt_ad_bnr").hide(); //$('.adbnr3_tb').html("
"); } $('.adbnr4_tb').html("
"); } else { $('.adbnr1_tb').html("
"); //$('.adbnr2_tb').html("
"); var catId = '64'; var catName='B Com'; if (catId != null && catId != '' && catId == '33') { var ht_ml = "
NEET is a crucial stepping stone for aspiring Doctors, and the right platform can make all the difference. Get access to high-quality study material including notes, videos & tests along with expert guidance, and a community of like-minded individuals, Take the first step towards success by signing up for on EduRev today.
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); } else if (catId != null && catId != '' && catId == '48') { var ht_ml = "
UPSC is the most crucial stepping stone for aspirants, and the right platform can make all the difference. Get access to high-quality study material including notes, videos,tests & all famous books summaries along with expert guidance, and a community of like-minded individuals.Take the first step towards success by signing up on EduRev today.
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); } else if (catId != null && catId != '' && catId == '69') { var ht_ml = "
CAT is the most crucial stepping stone to your dream MBA college, and the right platform can make all the difference. Get access to high-quality study material including notes, videos & tests with expert guidance, and a community of like-minded individuals.Take the first step towards success by signing up on EduRev today.
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); } else if (catId != null && catId != '' && catId == '32') { var ht_ml = "
JEE is a crucial stepping stone for IIT aspirants, and the right platform can make all the difference. Get access to high-quality study material including notes, videos & tests along with expert guidance, and a community of like-minded individuals. Take the first step towards success by signing up on EduRev today.
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); } else if (catId != null && catId != '' && parseInt(catId) >= 18 && parseInt(catId) <= 29) { var ht_ml = "
Want to become a " + catName + " topper? The right platform can make all the difference. Get access to high-quality study material including notes, videos, tests & sample papers along with expert guidance, and a community of like-minded individuals. Take the first step towards success by signing up on EduRev today.
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); } else { var ht_ml = "
Are you preparing for " + catName + " Exam? Then you should check out the best video lectures, notes, free mock test series, crash course and much more provided by EduRev. You also get your detailed analysis and report cards along with 24x7 doubt solving for you to excel in " + catName + " exam. So join EduRev now and revolutionise the way you learn!
"; ht_ml += `
Sign up for Free Download App for Free
`; $('.adbnr3_tb').html(ht_ml); //$(".adbnr3_tb").parent(".cnt_ad_bnr").hide(); //$('.adbnr3_tb').html("
"); } $('.adbnr4_tb').html("
"); } var hiddenCourseId = $("#hiddenCourseId").val(); if (hiddenCourseId == undefined || hiddenCourseId == null || hiddenCourseId == "") { hiddenCourseId = "0"; } showinfinityDocsAdonPage('cont_faqs_before', '64', 'B Com', 'Content_page_ad', hiddenCourseId); //showinfinityDocsAdonPage('adbnr2_tb', '64', 'B Com', 'Content_page_ad', hiddenCourseId); } //$(window).resize(function () { // SetAdBnr(); //}); courseDetailsAd = function () { var _crs_cnt_html = `
`; _crs_cnt_html+=""; _crs_cnt_html += `
`; debugger; if ('' != "") { var crd_dtl_ad = "
"; crd_dtl_ad += "
| "; crd_dtl_ad += " | This doc is part of " + _crs_cnt_html + " | "; crd_dtl_ad += "Join course for free | "; crd_dtl_ad += "
"; crd_dtl_ad += "
"; $(".adbnr2_tb").html(crd_dtl_ad); } else { $(".cnt_ad_bnr.are_you_even_banner2").hide(); } } $(document).ready(function () { SetAdBnr(); courseDetailsAd(); });
