MX4D or 4DX – Comparison and Review (2024)

MX4D or 4DX – Comparison and Review

by Veronica Nunez

**Spoiler Warning: this review is based on viewings of Avengers : Endgame and contains spoilers**

Two years ago I wrote a review for WeirdLifeofV.com comparing 4DX and DBox premium theater options available at that time. You can read that review here.

I saw the first shows of the morning for each showing, and both where in 3D.

I saw Avengers : Endgame in in Digital 3D in the MX4D theater at the TCL Chinese Theatre in Hollywood at an 8am show time. This was my second experience seeing a film in MX4D the first was for Captain Marvel. I noticed that the wind bursts appear to come from the armrest, near the cup holders. It may also spray a bit of water, but if it did it was so minimal that I don’t recall it happening. There was limited scents, but I noticed the metallic, burning metal smell more than any other scent (it was almost unbearable during Captain Marvel). A nice touch is the rain effect. In the scene where Hawkeye/Ronin is in Tokyo and it’s raining at the end of the sequence. The rain effect is enough that I and a few others covered our popcorn, but not enough to soak you. It doesn’t rain on you during the entire scene out in the rain or you would get soaking wet. The motion for MX4D is mostly “punches” and vibrations of the seats with something to smack your legs for the instances when a character is having their legs swept during a fight sequence.

Something to note is the onscreen warning about the motion effects of MX4D and the 40” minimum height requirement. Also, there are wheelchair spaces with companion seats, but there are no seats with lap belts which the 4DX at the Regal LA Live does have for those who need it (at least they had a few seats with lap belts in December 2016—I didn’t verify these seats this time.)

At the time of my initial review of 4DX there was only one theater in Los Angeles or Orange County to have 4DX which is at the Regal Cinemas at LA Live in downtown Los Angeles. There is now a 4DX theater at the CGV Cinemas in Buena Park, which I’m hoping to check out in the next few months as it is a bit cheaper than the Regal 4DX. We’ll talk about pricing later.

I saw Avengers : Endgame in 4DX at the first showing on a Tuesday at the Regal Cinemas at LA Live. 4DX has sets of 4 seats which are connected together. The seats for 4DX actually move tilting up and down and tilting a bit to the right and left. For example, when the camera swings up during the funeral scene the seats gently swing up along with the camera’s movement. There is a control on the right arm rest to turn off the water effect for your seat. The water effect sprays from the back of the seat in front of you (I don’t know how the effect works for the seats in the front row.) The spray was pretty intense which required me to wipe the water off of my 3D glasses almost every time. It has the same “punching” and leg motion effect as MX4D. Wind effects come from large fans mounted along the right and left sides of the theater. These can be very loud if the scene of the movie you’re watching is quiet. There isn’t a rain effect for the 4DX, and they don’t have a warning image displayed on the screen, but they do show a sort of trailer with full effects before the regular trailers for upcoming movie releases finish. This gives you time to get out if you find you can’t handle it. There is more strobing in the 4DX than I noticed in MX4D leading me to believe that MX4D doesn’t have any. There is minimal scent in 4DX, and I only noticed it when we see Tony Stark at his cabin by the lake. I could hear something being blown/sprayed, but it was a minute or two before I could smell the pine scent. The motion during the last half of the movie was intense. Beginning with Thanos’ attack on the Avengers facility all of the way through to Iron Man winning the battle the seats were moving with the action. In most theaters you feel a rumble in the seats because the sound is too loud, but in 4DX the seats vibrate without blowing out your eardrums.

For pricing, TCL Chinese Theatres has a set pricing of $29 for MX4D in Digital 3D with no senior or child pricing available for any show time. Regal LA Live has 4DX in RealD 3D for $25 (child) up to $29.50 (adult) for afternoon and evening show times. Morning / matinee shows are slightly less. I went on a Tuesday morning. Tuesdays at Regal are $9 for any show if you have their rewards card, which I do. There is a surcharge for premium formats so I paid $17 versus the $25 it would have been without the Regal Rewards card to see Avengers : Endgame in 4DX in 3D.

The CGV Cinemas in Buena park has 4DX tickets in RealD 3D for Avengers : Endgame starting at $21.75 for morning shows up to $26.75 for evening shows and no senior or child pricing available for any show time. I really want to check it out soon since it’s about the same distance from my home as Regal at LA Live is, and I won’t have to deal with downtown LA traffic or parking prices.

Verdict:

4DX packs more of a punch, though I find the fans annoyingly loud and distracting. The 4DX feels more like a ride than a theater, which I really enjoy. The TCL Chinese Theater has better picture quality for all of their screens (especially their Imax which I HIGHLY recommend) the MX4D experience doesn’t match the high ticket price.*

*If you include the parking fees for seeing the movie at Regal LA Live in 4DX versus at the TCL Chinese Theatre in MX4D, they are about equal depending on where you park for LA Live.

MX4D Theater Experience:

Visual and Sensory Effects:
- MX4D incorporates wind bursts, limited scents, and a rain effect to enhance the cinematic experience.
- Notable mention of the metallic, burning metal smell during Captain Marvel and rain effect during Hawkeye/Ronin's scene in Tokyo.
Motion Effects:
- Motion effects in MX4D are described as "punches" and vibrations, with specific actions like smacking legs during fight sequences.
Safety and Accessibility:
- MX4D has an on-screen warning about motion effects and a minimum height requirement of 40 inches.
- Wheelchair spaces are available, but no seats with lap belts are mentioned.

4DX Theater Experience:

Visual and Sensory Effects:
- 4DX features water effects, punching and leg motion, wind effects from large fans, and minimal scent.
- Intense motion during critical movie scenes, with a lack of rain effects compared to MX4D.
Motion Effects:
- Seats in 4DX move, tilt up and down, and tilt to the right and left, synchronized with the on-screen action.
- A control on the armrest allows users to turn off the water effect for their seat.
Safety and Accessibility:
- No explicit mention of a minimum height requirement or specific safety warnings on-screen.
- A trailer with full effects is shown before regular trailers, providing viewers with an opportunity to opt-out.

Pricing Comparison:

MX4D at TCL Chinese Theatre:
- Fixed pricing at $29 for Digital 3D with no senior or child pricing mentioned.
4DX at Regal LA Live:
- Priced between $25 (child) and $29.50 (adult) for afternoon and evening show times.
- Discounts for morning/matinee shows and additional savings with the Regal Rewards card.
4DX at CGV Cinemas in Buena Park:
- Tickets range from $21.75 to $26.75 for morning and evening shows, with no senior or child pricing mentioned.

Verdict:

The article concludes that 4DX delivers a more impactful experience, although the loudness of fans is noted as potentially distracting.
TCL Chinese Theatre is praised for superior picture quality, especially in IMAX, but MX4D is criticized for not justifying its high ticket price.

In closing, these comparisons offer valuable insights for cinephiles seeking a heightened cinematic adventure. If you've ventured into the realms of MX4D or 4DX, share your thoughts in the comments section. Happy viewing!