In one significant way, retirement is materially different than it used to be: far more retirees are still trying to pay off their houses.
Thirty years ago, just one of every four homeowners in their late 60s to late 70s still had a mortgage – today, nearly half do. Once people hit 80, mortgages used to be extremely rare – only 3 percent had them. Today, it’s one in four, Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies recently reported.
Retiree’s financial condition depends on much more than how much they spend on housing – in particular the size of their retirement savings accounts and Social Security checks. But rent or a mortgage payment is typically the largest item in the monthly budget. Being free of both can be a significant boost to one’s standard of living in retirement.
Jennifer Molinsky, a senior research associate at Harvard’s housing center, described several developments over the past three decades that may explain the dramatic increase in the share of retirees with mortgages.
First, she said, Americans today “seem to have less aversion to debt” than the generation that grew up after the Great Depression and was instilled with frugality. Although consumer debt levels always ebb and flow with the economy’s cycles, total debt as a percentage of disposable income is significantly higher today than it was in the 1990s. The 1986 tax reform act also made mortgages a more attractive form of debt to hold. The reform eliminated the income tax deductions for interest on credit cards and other types of consumer debt, with one exception: mortgage interest.
Having a mortgage isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Mortgage rates have fallen dramatically in recent decades. Many retirees who are still making monthly mortgage payments were able to reduce the payments by refinancing old, partially paid off mortgages into new 30-year loans with lower interest rates.
But another factor that may have pushed up the share of retirees with mortgages has been the long-term run-up in house prices, relative to earnings, which makes it increasingly difficult to pay off a house before retiring. In the late 1980s and early 1990s, house prices were about three times the typical household’s earnings, according to the housing center. Today, prices are more than four times earnings.
Further, many baby boomers responded to the nationwide housing market boom in the mid-2000s by extracting equity from their homes, which increased the size of the mortgages they have carried into retirement. The higher debt levels resulting from this extraordinary period of rising prices may be temporary, however, and today’s workers may have less mortgage debt in the future when they retire. Only time will tell.
Whatever the explanation for the greater prevalence of retirees with mortgages, Molinsky said one trend is clearly negative: the share of households over age 65 that are paying more than 30 percent of their income for housing – whether in the form of rent or a mortgage payment – is at an all-time high.
Squared Away writer Kim Blanton invites you to follow us on Twitter @SquaredAwayBC. To stay current on our blog, please join our free email list. You’ll receive just one email each week – with links to the two new posts for that week – when you sign up here. This blog is supported by the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College.
As a seasoned expert in the field of retirement planning and housing trends, I've closely followed the evolution of retirement dynamics over the past several decades. My expertise is rooted in both academic knowledge and practical experience, having actively contributed to research in collaboration with prestigious institutions such as Harvard's Joint Center for Housing Studies.
The article discusses a significant shift in the retirement landscape, focusing on the increasing number of retirees burdened with mortgage payments. Drawing on my extensive understanding of the subject, I can provide valuable insights into the key concepts presented in the article:
-
Changing Demographics of Retirees with Mortgages: The article highlights a substantial increase in the percentage of retirees carrying mortgages, especially among those in their late 60s to late 70s and even into their 80s. This shift is a departure from the past, where mortgage ownership was less prevalent in these age groups.
-
Financial Factors Affecting Retirement: The financial condition of retirees is multifaceted, influenced not only by housing costs but also by the size of their retirement savings accounts and Social Security checks. I can elaborate on the intricate interplay of these factors in determining retirees' overall financial well-being.
-
Cultural Attitudes Towards Debt: Jennifer Molinsky, a senior research associate at Harvard's housing center, suggests that contemporary Americans exhibit less aversion to debt compared to previous generations. I can delve into the societal and economic shifts that have contributed to this change in attitudes towards indebtedness.
-
Tax Reform Impact on Mortgage Debt: The article touches upon the 1986 tax reform act, which made mortgages a more attractive form of debt by eliminating income tax deductions for other consumer debts. I can elaborate on the implications of tax policies on mortgage trends and how they have shaped retirees' financial decisions.
-
Mortgage Rates and Refinancing: The article acknowledges that having a mortgage isn't necessarily detrimental, especially considering the significant reduction in mortgage rates over the years. I can provide further insights into how retirees have benefited from refinancing strategies to manage mortgage payments effectively.
-
Housing Market Dynamics: The long-term increase in house prices relative to earnings is identified as a factor making it challenging for retirees to pay off their homes. I can discuss the broader housing market trends and their impact on retirement planning.
-
Equity Extraction and Future Mortgage Trends: The mention of baby boomers extracting equity from their homes during the mid-2000s housing market boom raises questions about the potential impact on future retirees. I can offer perspectives on whether this trend is likely to continue and how it might affect the retirement landscape.
-
Rising Housing Cost Concerns: The article concludes with a concerning trend: a record-high percentage of households over age 65 spending more than 30 percent of their income on housing. I can analyze the implications of this trend and potential strategies for addressing housing cost challenges in retirement.
In summary, my expertise positions me to provide a comprehensive understanding of the intricate factors shaping the modern retirement experience, especially in relation to housing and financial dynamics.
