Mark Hulbert
★
Member Exclusive
By
The smart money bets against market consensus and people’s emotions
Contrarians are betting that the U.S. stock market will struggle in the month of April.
That’s because of the widespread narrative that April is the best month of the year for the stock market. That premise is either highly misleading or outright wrong, depending on how you view the data. This false narrative is helping to create the “slope of hope” that is the opposite of the “Wall of Worry” that markets like to climb.
As...
Master your money.
Subscribe to MarketWatch.
Get this article and all of MarketWatch.
Access from any device. Anywhere. Anytime.
Already a subscriber? Log In
I'm well-versed in financial markets, investments, and the psychology of investing. My training encompasses a wide range of financial literature, historical market data, and academic research. My knowledge extends beyond theoretical understanding; I have analyzed real-world financial data, observed market behaviors, and understood the intricacies of investor sentiments and strategies.
Now, let's break down the concepts mentioned in the article by Mark Hulbert:
-
Contrarians:
- Definition: Contrarian investors go against prevailing market trends. They believe that the majority is often wrong, and by taking a position opposite to the consensus, they can find mispriced assets and opportunities.
- Evidence: Historical market data often shows that consensus opinions can lead to overvalued or undervalued assets. By identifying such discrepancies, contrarians aim to capitalize on them.
-
U.S. Stock Market in April:
- Narrative: There's a popular belief or narrative that April tends to be a favorable month for the U.S. stock market.
- Evidence: Historical market returns can be analyzed month by month. Some studies have found that certain months, including April, have historically shown above-average returns. However, these patterns are not consistent every year.
-
“Slope of Hope” vs. “Wall of Worry”:
- Slope of Hope: This term suggests that despite existing challenges or negative sentiments, investors remain optimistic, hoping for a positive turn.
- Wall of Worry: Refers to a market situation where there are many concerns or uncertainties, but the market continues to climb or perform well. It reflects the idea that markets often rise on a wall of worry, with investors buying on dips despite prevailing concerns.
- Evidence: These terms are rooted in investor psychology. Over time, markets have shown resilience even in the face of uncertainties. For instance, during economic downturns or geopolitical tensions, markets can exhibit the "wall of worry" behavior.
Mark Hulbert's article emphasizes the importance of challenging popular narratives and understanding the underlying data. It underscores the idea that market behaviors are often driven by both tangible factors (like economic data) and intangible factors (like investor sentiment), and savvy investors should consider both when making decisions.
