Is Yogurt As Effective As Probiotic Supplements? (2024)

Is Yogurt As Effective As Probiotic Supplements? (1)

When you hear the word probiotics, you’ll usually think first of yogurt. Yogurt is often touted as a health food and a good source of probiotic bacteria to improve digestion and immune function.

There’s certainly some truth to that, but it’s not the whole story. Yogurt does indeed contain some probiotic bacteria, but those bacteria are less beneficial than you think. Most importantly – not all yogurts are the same.

Why Do You Need Probiotics Anyway?

First, a quick recap! Your gut is home to trillions of microorganisms that include both good and bad microorganisms.

The ‘good’ bacteria play important roles in maintaining your overall health. They’re involved in digestion, immune system function, hormone production, and much more.

Supporting your gastrointestinal environment by introducing good bacteria into your digestive system will help to keep these bacteria in good shape, which means they can do their job properly. One of the best ways to do this is by consuming probiotic bacteria.

So, what are probiotics?

Probiotics are ‘friendly’ bacteria that provide numerous benefits to your health. They support your body’s existing population of good bacteria and help them to function more efficiently.

Probiotics are available in supplement form but are also present in a range of fermented foods, including yogurt, kimchi, kefir and sauerkraut. (1)

Of course, you can’t expect something to improve your health just because it contains probiotic bacteria. It all comes down to the amounts of probiotic bacteria in the product, the variety of strains, whether they survive passage through your stomach, how ‘live’ the bacteria are, and many other factors.

In most cases, probiotic supplements are more effective than yogurt for providing the health benefits you require. Here’s why.

Why Yogurt May Not Be Enough

Yogurt is a great health food with plenty of nutritional benefits, including calcium and protein. It’s even more famous for being a ‘probiotic food’ – and yes, it does indeed contain probiotic bacteria as a result of the fermentation process.

However, while yogurt can provide health benefits to some degree, it simply can’t be relied upon as an effective source of probiotics.

There are several factors that can cause yogurt to fall short of delivering the quality of probiotics that would actually benefit your gut.

1. An uncertain collection of strains

Every yogurt containsLactobacillus bulgaricus and Streptococcus thermophilus, but the other strains in your yogurt are not standardized in the same way that probiotic supplements are. They may or may not include various forms of Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium, or even yeast.

Every species and strain of probiotic bacteria has its own unique role to perform in your body. You may be missing out on some of the most beneficial strains if you stick to yogurt.

2. No standardized potency

Probiotic supplements are carefully standardized to contain certain amounts of each strain of bacteria. That means that you can reduce or increase your dose as necessary. For example, if you start a course of antibiotics you might find that doubling your daily probiotic dose will help to reduce the digestive side effects.

3. High Sugar Content

Many of the yogurt products you’ll find in supermarkets are not health foods at all; they’re just sweet treats loaded with added sugar, high fructose corn syrup, and other undesirable ingredients that may have more of a detrimental effect on your gut than a beneficial one. (2)

The strains of probiotic bacteria in these yogurt products are supposed to benefit conditions such as indigestion and irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), but the high sugar content may completely cancel out those benefits.

4. High levels of histamine

Yogurt and other fermented dairy products tend to be quite high in histamine. For histamine-sensitive individuals, large amounts of dietary histamine can cause hives, itching, and inflammation.

If you suspect that you are histamine-sensitive, probiotic supplements are a way to boost your gut health without increasing your exposure.

5. Poor Survivability

Your yogurt may contain lots of probiotic bacteria, but how many of those will survive the passage through your stomach?

Your stomach is a highly acidic environment, and this acidity is a crucial part of your digestion and immunity. But that very same acidity will destroy the vast majority of probiotic bacteria in your food.

Probiotic supplements can use technologies like delayed-release capsules and time-release tablets that protect bacteria on their journey to the gut.

Yogurt May Not BeThe Right Choice For Your Gut

Bottom line? Your pot of yogurt, while certainly beneficial for your health, may not deliver the boost to your gut flora that you thought it did.

Even yogurts with “Live and Active Cultures” will struggle to deliver those bacteria safely to your gut, and you have little control over the strains and quantities of bacteria that they contain.

While it’s certainly worthwhile to eat yogurt as a healthy snack and a good source of protein, you’re much better off getting your daily dose of probiotics from a quality supplement.

Our probiotic uses patented time-release tablets that deliver 15 times more bacteria past stomach acid, compared to other probiotic supplements. We include 15 billion CFUs of bacteria and 12 different strains, and we use rigorous quality control to ensure that every batch we produce meets the very highest standards.

Here are a few key benefits of our probiotic:

  • Time-release tablets that deliver 15 times more bacteria past stomach acid, when compared to regular probioticcapsules.
  • Probiotic bacteria are released slowly over 8-10 hours.
  • 12 probiotic strains chosen for their effect on gut health and immunity.
  • 15 billion CFUs of probiotic bacteria.
  • 60 tablets per bottle (enough for 2 months).
  • Free of nuts, dairy, gluten, soy. Non-GMO and vegan. Made in the USA.

You can read more about our time-release probiotic here.

Is Yogurt As Effective As Probiotic Supplements? (2024)

FAQs

Is Yogurt As Effective As Probiotic Supplements? ›

While taking a probiotic supplement can be more effective than yogurt at introducing all that beneficial bacteria into your digestive system, keep in mind that not all supplements are created equal. Your probiotic supplement can beat yogurt's probiotic benefits if you pick one that displays certain key characteristics.

Is it better to eat yogurt or take a probiotic pill? ›

Well, if you're currently on antibiotics and need to restore your body's balance, or just want to get more probiotics into your system, turns out good old yogurt might still be the way to go: Consuming probiotics with dairy was shown to be more effective than taking a supplement alone in a new study from the University ...

Can yogurt replace probiotic supplements? ›

Yogurt doesn't have a therapeutic CFU

CFU stands for colony forming units, and it's the measure of viable bacteria in yogurt or a probiotic supplement. To be considered a probiotic yogurt, yogurts must have 1 billion CFU – but this is not a therapeutic dose.

Can I get enough probiotics from yogurt? ›

Although one serving a day of yogurt does not likely provide enough probiotics, or variety of probiotic strains, to obtain the health benefits shown in clinical research, a good quality yogurt can offer essential nutrients beyond probiotics. Yogurt is a source of protein, calcium and other minerals.

Does yogurt actually help gut bacteria? ›

Another study showed that four weeks of probiotic yogurt consumption by healthy adults increased gut content of probiotic Lactobacilli and Bifidobacteria strains while not significantly altering microbial community structure [5].

Why do cardiologist warn against probiotics? ›

But, when it comes to pre-and probiotics, cardiologists are warning they aren't a treatment for elevated blood pressure, cholesterol, or other heart health markers. The health benefits of probiotics are also strain-specific, so taking any probiotic off the shelf won't guarantee results.

How much yogurt should I eat a day for probiotics? ›

For individuals over nine, three servings of milk, cheese or yogurt is recommended per day, though as little as one serving of yogurt contains probiotics. Yogurt is often at the top of the probiotic foods list.

Which yogurt is highest in probiotics? ›

Kefir. This type of yogurt contains added probiotics. It has a greater variety of bacteria and yeasts compared to other yogurts. Kefir is fermented with clusters of microbes called kefir grains.

What food has the most probiotics? ›

Here are seven foods high in probiotics:
  • Yogurt. Yogurt is made by culturing milk with bacteria that produce lactic acid, such as Lactobacillus bulgaricus and Streptococcus thermophilus, although more strains can also be added. ...
  • Buttermilk. ...
  • Cottage Cheese. ...
  • Tempeh. ...
  • Sauerkraut. ...
  • Miso Soup.
Jan 17, 2024

Is it better to get probiotics from food or supplements? ›

Although both foods and supplements seem to have been efficient carriers for the beneficial bacteria, to generally promote public health in communities, probiotic foods appear to be preferred to probiotic supplements.

Is apple cider vinegar a probiotic? ›

“From my knowledge and research, because the number of microorganisms found in apple cider vinegar can vary so greatly across the products available for purchase, ACV is not generally considered a probiotic,” Manian says.

What is the best all natural probiotic? ›

Yogurt is one of the best sources of probiotics. Other sources of probiotics include sauerkraut, miso, tempeh, and more.

Does store bought yogurt have probiotics? ›

The United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) requires all yogurt manufacturers to use probiotic bacteria called Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus bulgaricus. These ferment milk and turn it into yogurt.

What is the healthiest yogurt for gut health? ›

So if you're looking for the best yogurt for gut health, try kefir or a yogurt that specifically says “probiotic” on the label. Account for your personal preferences: While many consider low-fat or nonfat yogurt to be healthier, a study found that full-fat yogurt offers similar heart-health benefits.

Does all Greek yogurt have probiotics? ›

Yes, most Greek yogurt contains probiotics, as it's made in the same way as regular yogurt, using the same strands of cultures. The major difference between Greek yogurt and regular yogurt is that it's strained three times (removing more liquid) instead of two times with regular yogurt.

Is it better to eat probiotics or take a supplement? ›

Although both foods and supplements seem to have been efficient carriers for the beneficial bacteria, to generally promote public health in communities, probiotic foods appear to be preferred to probiotic supplements.

What is the best way to take probiotics? ›

The goal is to get the probiotics through your stomach acid as fast as possible. To do this, it's recommended to take probiotics ideally on an empty stomach (i.e., 2-3 hours after your last meal and 30 minutes before the next meal), so the probiotics bacteria can move through the stomach as fast as possible.

Is there a downside to taking probiotics? ›

Possible harmful effects of probiotics include infections, production of harmful substances by the probiotic microorganisms, and transfer of antibiotic resistance genes from probiotic microorganisms to other microorganisms in the digestive tract.

Are probiotic pills effective? ›

Are they beneficial? There is no clear evidence that probiotics are beneficial. While many small studies have been conducted, there has been no standardized way to study probiotics and their effects, making it difficult to compare the results of different studies.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 5953

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.