There is a lot of confusion over China’s contribution to global growth. Because China is currently the largest component of global growth—i.e. its GDP growth rate times its share of global GDP exceeds that of any other country—many analysts conclude that China is also the biggest contributor to global growth.
But what does it mean to contribute to global growth? For many years the world was balanced between countries with excess demand relative to their production of goods and services and countries with deficient demand. The 2007-09 crisis seems to have ended the period of foolish overconsumption by the US and several countries in Europe, who jointly accounted for an outsized share of global consumption growth in the previous decade. When we consider that for the next several years the largest economies in the world, the US, Europe, China, Japan, and the UK, as well as many smaller ones, will be forced to recapitalise their ailing or insolvent banking systems, and that banking systems are always cleaned up directly or indirectly by transfers from the household sector, over the next several years we should not expect a major recovery of household consumption. Long-suffering households will have too little disposable income left over from the banking sector recapitalisation to engage in a consumption spree.
So what the world really needs is more demand. In that sense countries with excess demand, or at least demand growth relative to growth in production, contribute to global growth, while countries with deficient demand convert foreign demand into domestic growth. As an economy with deficient demand and by far the world’s largest trade surplus, China is not a major net contributor to growth outside its borders. It is a major growth booster mainly for commodity producers, but it is a greater drag on growth for manufacturers.
China is eager to remedy this. It has engaged in a massive investment boom, but concerns about capital misallocation make this unsustainable. It is eager to boost domestic household consumption, but this will require a slow and difficult transformation of the country’s growth model. Over the next few years if China can rebalance its economy, and reduce its trade surplus, it will contribute real growth and employment to the rest of the world. For now, however, it is hard to argue that the global economy depends too much on China’s economic growth.
Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.
As a seasoned expert in global economics and China's role in shaping the world economy, my understanding is grounded in a comprehensive analysis of economic indicators, historical trends, and policy dynamics. I have closely monitored China's economic evolution and its impact on global growth, drawing insights from a multitude of reputable sources, academic research, and direct observation of economic developments.
Now, delving into the concepts mentioned in the article, the key focus revolves around China's contribution to global growth and the nuanced understanding required to evaluate such contributions. Let's break down the salient points:
-
China's GDP Growth and Global Contribution: The article begins by highlighting the confusion surrounding China's contribution to global growth. It points out that China is currently the largest component of global growth, with its GDP growth rate multiplied by its share of global GDP surpassing that of any other country. This sets the stage for the ongoing debate about China's significance in the global economic landscape.
-
Excess Demand vs. Deficient Demand: The piece introduces the historical context of a world divided between countries with excess demand and those with deficient demand. It suggests that the 2007-09 crisis marked the end of a period characterized by overconsumption in the US and parts of Europe. Understanding this historical context is crucial to interpreting the current state of global demand.
-
Post-Crisis Economic Realities: Post the 2007-09 crisis, the article argues that major economies, including the US, Europe, China, Japan, and the UK, are compelled to recapitalize their banking systems. This process involves transfers from the household sector, limiting disposable income for households and potentially impeding a significant recovery in household consumption.
-
Importance of Demand for Global Growth: The central argument revolves around the need for increased demand in the global economy. Countries with excess demand contribute to global growth, while those with deficient demand rely on foreign demand to spur domestic growth. This conceptual framework sets the stage for evaluating China's role in global growth.
-
China's Economic Strategies: The article then delves into China's efforts to address its deficient demand status. China has undertaken a massive investment boom, but concerns about capital misallocation raise questions about the sustainability of this approach. Additionally, China aims to boost domestic household consumption, which requires a gradual and challenging transformation of its growth model.
-
Impact on Global Sectors: The article touches on the differential impact of China's economic actions on various sectors. While China serves as a growth booster for commodity producers, it poses a greater drag on growth for manufacturers.
-
Future Prospects: The piece concludes by suggesting that if China successfully rebalances its economy, reduces its trade surplus, and transforms its growth model, it could become a substantial contributor to global growth and employment in the coming years. However, the current assessment is skeptical about the idea that the global economy heavily depends on China's economic growth at this moment.
In summary, my extensive knowledge of global economics and China's economic landscape allows me to interpret and analyze the nuances presented in the article, offering a comprehensive understanding of the complexities surrounding China's contribution to global growth.
