Is Pet Insurance Worth the Money? (2024)

One thing that a lot of pet owners wonder is, ” Is pet insurance worth the money?” I have been asking myself this since our dog, Obi, had to have emergency surgery last week.

I did some research and feel that I have a better understanding of pet insurance and who it can help.

Is Pet Insurance Worth the Money? (1)

When we took Obi to the vet, we discovered that he had a tooth abscess and several teeth had fused together under his eye. Poor baby had to have 5 teeth removed! Turns out that it is no uncommon for small dogs to have dental problems, Obi is half chihuahua half peekipoo.

His surgery cost us a little over $600.

RELATED POSTS:

  • How to Calm your Anxious Dog at the Vet
  • 10 Brilliant Pet Supplies Organization Hacks
  • Bringing Home a New Puppy Tips: How to Survive the First Month

Is Pet Insurance Worth the Money?

After his surgery, I started looking into getting pet insurance in case something like this happened again. I found out that it may or may not be worth it depending on your specific pet.

I found out that pet insurance works a bit differently than human health insurance. You won’t get a coypay like with our insurance, you will have to pay everything up front and then submit a claim to get reimbursed.

So you still need to have a savings account set up for emergencies to cover vet bills. If you have pet insurance you could get reimbursed on average 70-90% of the costs.

Beware of preexisting conditions as pet insurance will not cover those or breed specific conditions. In our case Obi is a chihuahua mix and they are known for having dental problems so pet insurance most likely wouldn’t have covered his surgery bill.

I have found that pet insurance is good for accidents and chronic illnesses. They will cover cancer diagnoses, animal attacks, and if your pet is hit by a car among other things.

What to Look for When Choosing Pet Insurance

When it comes to choosing pet insurance, see if your employer offers any. A few companies do but not very many.

If yours does not, go to your vet. They can point you in the right direction for your specific pet and give you their opinion on different companies. Some vet clinics may even offer their own wellness plans.

If you do want to get pet insurance, it is best to purchase it when your pet is young so they will have less “preexisting conditions”.

There are two plans that most pet insurance companies will offer: Accidental or Accidental and Illness. Some will give you the option of having wellness coverage for things like vaccines and routine exams. I found that having the wellness coverage was not cost effective when you compare how much you will spend on your premium vs. the average cost of a wellness exam.

When reading the fine print of the plan you are interested in purchasing keep some things in mind:

  • See if your premiums will increase as your pet ages.
  • How long will they cover chronic conditions? They may only cover the first year.
  • Is there a maximum annual cost they will cover?
  • Will you be reimbursed a percentage or flat fee for each claim?

I would suggests looking into Healthypaws or Trupanion first for pet insurance. They were the two companies I saw that didn’t raise prices with age and were the most cost effective plans when compared with other companies.

You can compare various pet insurance companies and rates.

Is Pet Insurance Worth It? Final Verdict

As with most things, it depends on your situation. For me personally, I think it would be more cost effective for me to put some money away each month into a savings account instead of paying a premium for pet insurance.

The average premium cost for a dog is around $50 a month. If I put that into my savings I would have $600 a year. Obi will most likely not have an emergency every year so that makes the most financial sense for us at this moment.

Now pet insurance is just like human insurance in that you get the most benefit from it if you actually use it. I hope that you don’t have to use it but it is nice to have in case of an emergency or chronic illness.

Pet insurance won’t cover 100% of the costs but it does lower them and makes things more affordable to you.

You can pay a little bit over time for the premiums. If don’t have pet insurance, you can pay a lot out of pocket at once and not get reimbursed if you have an emergency.

With pet insurance, the bottom line is that the value of it depends on the level of illness and injury claims you make.

You are buying piece of mind knowing that if your dog has a chronic illness, like cancer, you’re covered against the risk of being bombarded by vet bills. You can focus more on how you can make your furbaby feel better, instead of worrying about your finances.

Is Pet Insurance Worth the Money? (2)

Is Pet Insurance Worth the Money? (2024)

FAQs

Does pet insurance actually help? ›

"Insurance helps cover the unanticipated costs of pet ownership and can be a huge relief for owners as they typically cover 80-90% of the costs, depending on the plan," says Dr. Sarah Gorman, managing veterinarian at Small Door Veterinary in New York.

Is it worth making a pet insurance claim? ›

It's usually not too difficult to know when you should claim, and you can always check your policy documents or speak to your insurance provider if you're not sure. The only time it might not be worth claiming is if your policy excess – that's the amount you pay to make a claim – is more than the cost of the treatment.

How much should you spend on pet insurance dog? ›

We found that, on average, pet insurance costs $66 a month for dogs and $32 a month for cats. However, pet insurance premiums typically range from $15 to $90 a month. Pet insurance is an affordable alternative to paying vet bills out of pocket and can offer financial protection against high-cost emergency vet visits.

Is it okay to not have pet insurance? ›

But without insurance coverage, the cost to treat unexpected pet emergencies can present a financial burden for the majority of pet parents — in fact, six out of 10 Americans have less than $1,000 in savings to spend in an emergency. In the worst cases, a pet medical emergency can lead to long-term expenses .

What percent of pet owners have pet insurance? ›

About half, or 44.6%, of pet owners stated they currently have pet insurance in our survey. On a larger scale, NAPHIA's 2022 State of the Industry Report found that more than 4.41 million pets were insured in North America in 2021, up from 3.45 million in 2020.

Why would you want pet insurance? ›

Having pet insurance allows you to choose treatments for your ailing or injured pet based on the best medical option available and not restricted based on family finances. Most pet insurance policies reimburse up to 80% of costs after deductibles. Provides an easy way to budget pet care costs.

How long does it take for pet insurance to pay out? ›

Processing a pet insurance claim is usually straightforward and your payout should take between seven and 10 working days. If you'd like an estimated date for the payout, call your insurance provider. Depending on who you're with, you may be able to track your claim's progress online.

How soon after getting pet insurance can I use it? ›

Depending on your provider, you can use accident coverage as soon as 48 hours after signing up. Illness coverage usually has longer waiting periods, beginning at 14 days.

What makes pet insurance cheaper? ›

Your deductible and reimbursem*nt level

Choosing a higher pet insurance deductible lowers the cost of your plan but increases your out-of-pocket costs at the vet. A lower deductible increases your plan's price, but you'll be reimbursed more on your claim.

How much of vet bills does pet insurance cover? ›

So, once you've covered your deductible for a condition, your pet insurance will typically reimburse a percentage of any additional cost. That percentage depends on the policy you sign up for. In most cases, you'll be able to choose 70%, 80% or 90% reimbursem*nt coverage.

What does pet insurance typically cost? ›

How much does pet insurance typically cost? Pet insurance costs around $55 per month for an unlimited accident and illness plan for dogs, according to our analysis. The average cost of pet insurance for a cat for the same plan is about $47 per month.

Do pet insurance premiums increase every year? ›

It's true that you can generally expect your pet's insurance coverage cost to increase each year, along with their ever-increasing age. However, this doesn't mean that there aren't things you could—and sometimes should—consider changing about that coverage as time goes on.

Why do people not get pet insurance? ›

Many pet parents overestimate the cost of pet insurance, don't think they'll need it, or have been misinformed about the benefits/effectiveness of pet insurance offerings.

Do indoor dogs need pet insurance? ›

Yes, pet insurance covers your indoor pet for accidents. While you might not like to dwell upon the bad things that could happen to your furry friend, and hope that being at home will keep them safe, accidents can happen.

Is lifetime pet insurance worth it? ›

Is a lifetime policy worth it? If budget is not an issue, lifetime cover is the most comprehensive pet insurance cover for your pet. Lifetime cover is typically seen as a premium option for pet insurance. As it's the most comprehensive type of insurance policy, it also is the most expensive.

What is the loss ratio for pet insurance? ›

Loss ratios vary depending on the type of insurance. For pet insurance companies the average loss ratios range from 50% to 60%. That means that for every $1 paid in premium, $0.50 to $0.60 are being spent on claims.

Should I tell my insurance I have a dog? ›

If you're asked about household pets on a home insurance application, you should always be truthful. Even if the questionnaire you fill out doesn't explicitly ask, it's still your responsibility to let your insurer know if there are any animals in the house.

How does it work with pet insurance? ›

Pet insurance protects you financially if your pet needs veterinary care. With pet insurance, you pay a monthly or annual premium to your insurer. The amount you pay will vary depending on factors like your pet's age, any pre-existing health conditions, and the type of pet insurance you choose.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kelle Weber

Last Updated:

Views: 5635

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (73 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kelle Weber

Birthday: 2000-08-05

Address: 6796 Juan Square, Markfort, MN 58988

Phone: +8215934114615

Job: Hospitality Director

Hobby: tabletop games, Foreign language learning, Leather crafting, Horseback riding, Swimming, Knapping, Handball

Introduction: My name is Kelle Weber, I am a magnificent, enchanting, fair, joyous, light, determined, joyous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.