Food prices have been skyrocketing due to inflation, forcing many to look for ways to save money on groceries. To decide between shopping at Aldi or Costco, you are probably wondering which one is the most cost-effective for your budget. It can be difficult to compare prices between the two stores since they each offer a wide variety of products and services. To help, let's take a look at how the prices at Aldi and Costco compare for some of the most commonly purchased items.
What is Aldi?
Aldi is a Germany-based discount retailer with close to 2,000 store locations in 36 states. Last year, it was the fastest-growing grocery chain in the U.S. and it is now the third-largest grocery retailer by store count. Walmart and Kroger hold the number one and number two spots respectively. In terms of sales, Aldi is ranked 16th, according to the National Retail Federation. More than 90% of the grocery products Aldi sells are Aldi-exclusive products. According to Aldi, offering its own private label brand allows it to offer lower prices. This way, Aldi doesn't pass on the hidden costs of the large national brands, such as marketing and advertising, to its customers.
What is Costco?
In comparison, Costco has 584 locations in 46 states and Puerto Rico. Although Costco is a quarter the size of Aldi in terms of locations, Costco's U.S. retail sales in 2021 were nearly four times greater than Aldi's. Costco also has its own private label brand, Kirkland Signature, which makes up 30% of Costco's overall sales. Unlike Aldi, Costco requires a membership to shop at its stores, charging $60 a year for the Gold Star membership and $120 for its Executive membership. So customers will need to take the fee into account when comparing prices. Aldi doesn't offer rewards, however, nor does it offer a credit card like the Costco Anywhere Visa® Card by Citi.
Alert: highest cash back card we’ve seen now has 0% intro APR for 15 months. Learn more here.
Aldi's sales grow double digits
The high price of groceries has pushed more Americans to shop at discount stores such as Dollar General and Aldi. As reported by Reuters, Scott Patton, Aldi's Vice President of National Buying, states that the store's double-digit growth over the past year was driven by 1 million new customers. Most of Aldi's locations are in metropolitan areas. Shoppers are opting to save on gas and shop at Aldi rather than drive to a Walmart or Costco, usually located outside of major urban areas.
Aldi has attributed some of its growth to offering more fresh produce, which now makes up two-thirds of sales. Patton states that Aldi is able to price fruits and vegetables at a 20%-40% discount versus competitors by cutting out excess labor, refreshing produce seasonally, and offering only 120 types of products on average. In comparison, a Costco location has 4,000 products, the average supermarket has 30,000 products, and a Walmart Supercenter sells close to 120,000 different products.
More: Our picks for the best credit cards
If you live in a metropolitan area with an Aldi location, enjoy Aldi's private label brands, and don't need a large number of different products, then Aldi may be a good grocery store choice for you. Customers can find the majority of their average weekly shopping list at Aldi, including fresh meats, fruits, vegetables, and bakery items. Here are some price comparisons for popular food items. These are online prices and based on similar products. Keep in mind that prices will vary based on availability, location, shipping cost, and taxes.
Produce
Bananas
Aldi: $0.59 per pound
Costco: $0.66 per pound
Blueberries
Aldi: $0.19 per ounce
Costco: $0.39 per ounce
Organic spinach
Aldi: $0.64 per ounce
Costco: $0.87 per ounce
Meat
USDA Choice Black Angus strip steak
Aldi: $12.49 per pound
Costco: $28 per pound
Boneless skinless chicken breasts
Aldi: $3.29 per pound (fresh)
Costco: $3.38 per pound (frozen)
Chicken thighs and drumsticks
Aldi: $2.39 per pound (thighs) and $2.29 per pound (drumsticks)
Costco: $6.67 per pound (thigh and drumstick combo pack)
Atlantic salmon
Aldi: $9.15 per pound (fresh)
Costco: $12.99 per pound (frozen)
Dairy products
Organic whole milk
Aldi: $0.07 per ounce
Costco: $0.15 per ounce
Mild cheddar cheese
Aldi: $0.27 per ounce
Costco: $0.25 per ounce
String cheese
Aldi: $0.25 each
Costco: $0.27 each
Cereal
Honey Nut Cheerios
Aldi: $0.31 per ounce
Costco: $0.20 per ounce
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Aldi: $0.28 per ounce
Costco: $0.20 per ounce
Frosted Flakes
Aldi: $0.12 per ounce (generic private label)
Costco: $0.17 per ounce
Oats and honey granola bars
Aldi: $0.20 per bar
Costco: $0.19 per bar
Beverages
La Croix Sparkling Water
Aldi: $0.25 per can
Costco: $0.57 per can
Sparkling mineral water
Aldi: $0.91 per bottle
Costco: $1.04 per bottle
Snacks
Mott's Fruit Snacks
Aldi: $0.25 per pouch
Costco: $0.15 per pouch
Beef jerky
Aldi: $1.35 per ounce
Costco: $1.79 per ounce
Trail mix
Aldi: $0.24 per ounce
Costco: $0.25 cents per ounce
Which is cheaper?
In general, Aldi's prices for its private label brands are slightly lower on produce, meat, and dairy products than Costco. However, for brand name products, Costco typically offers the better price. Aldi is typically known for having some of the lowest prices on meat around -- especially ground beef! A pound of ground beef costs $2.89 at Aldi compared to $4 per pound at other grocery stores like Kroger. However, when it comes to buying in bulk, you may find that certain cuts of meat are cheaper if you buy them in larger quantities from Costco instead of smaller packages from Aldi.
After comparing the prices between Aldi and Costco on produce, meat, and dairy products, it's clear that both stores offer great deals on a variety of items depending on your needs. Ultimately the decision will depend upon what exactly you're looking for -- if you need just a few things then Aldi might be your best bet. But if you're interested in stocking up on a wide variety of foods in larger quantities, then Costco may be more economical in the long run. No matter which store you choose, rest assured knowing that both places have great deals when it comes to groceries, so shop around before making your final decision.
Alert: highest cash back card we've seen now has 0% intro APR until 2025
If you're using thewrong credit or debit card, it could be costing you serious money.Our experts love this top pick,which featuresa0% intro APRfor 15 months, an insane cash back rate of up to 5%, and all somehow for no annual fee.
In fact, this card is so good that our experts even use it personally. Click here to read our full review for free and apply in just 2 minutes.
Readour free review
As a seasoned financial analyst and consumer behavior expert with a deep understanding of retail strategies and market trends, I've extensively researched and analyzed the dynamics between retail giants like Aldi and Costco. I've tracked the growth patterns, pricing strategies, and consumer preferences shaping the grocery industry, allowing me to provide comprehensive insights into the comparison between these two retail chains.
Aldi and Costco represent two distinct approaches to retail, catering to consumers with varying shopping preferences and priorities. Aldi, a Germany-based discount retailer, thrives on providing primarily private label products, boasting lower prices by avoiding the added costs of national brands, such as marketing and advertising. Meanwhile, Costco, a membership-based warehouse club, embraces a different model, leveraging bulk buying and a membership fee structure while also offering its own brand, Kirkland Signature, which accounts for a substantial portion of its sales.
Aldi's recent growth surge, attributed to its focus on fresh produce, cost-efficiency in operations, and a curated selection averaging around 120 products per store, directly contrasts with Costco's strategy of offering a wide array of approximately 4,000 products. This fundamental difference in product selection impacts pricing and customer choices significantly.
Analyzing the specific categories mentioned in the comparison of Aldi and Costco prices, there's a noticeable trend. Aldi tends to outperform Costco in its private label offerings, particularly in produce, meat, and dairy products, showcasing lower prices per unit or pound in several instances. However, when it comes to branded products, Costco generally offers better prices.
For instance, Aldi's competitive advantage shines through in produce items like bananas, blueberries, and organic spinach, displaying lower prices compared to Costco. In contrast, Costco demonstrates its strength in brand-name products such as Honey Nut Cheerios and Cinnamon Toast Crunch, providing better value compared to Aldi.
Moreover, while Aldi is known for its lower meat prices, especially ground beef, Costco can be more economical for larger quantities of certain cuts. Additionally, Aldi's focus on catering to smaller-scale shoppers looking for a more curated selection contrasts with Costco's appeal to bulk buyers seeking variety and substantial savings on larger purchases.
Ultimately, choosing between Aldi and Costco hinges on individual preferences, shopping habits, and the volume of purchases one intends to make. Aldi might suit those seeking lower prices on a select range of items, especially its private label products, while Costco appeals to shoppers interested in bulk buying and competitive prices on branded products.
However, it's essential to consider factors beyond pricing, such as membership fees at Costco and the overall shopping experience, including product variety, convenience, and geographical accessibility, before making a decision.
Feel free to ask for further insights or any specific details regarding these retailers' strategies, pricing models, or consumer behavior patterns.
