Owning a rental property in addition to your primary residence can be a way for you to build wealth, especially if you may be averse to investing in the stock market. Data released in 2017 shows that 47% of rentals were owned by individual investors. In theory, it seems to make sense. With a rental property, someone else pays your mortgage, and over time your equity grows. You can eventually own a physical piece of property outright that also produces income. However, rental property investments aren’t always a sure thing.
Real Estate Investment Isn't Always a Good Deal
The first home my wife and I bought was a condo in 2004 in Stamford, Conn., which we then in turn rented out when we bought our first single-family home. Our situation didn’t work out for a number of reasons, mainly because 1) the property, after a rising as high as 30%+ over our purchase price, ended up selling for only a 5% gain. 2) We needed to make updates (kitchen countertops and floors) and repairs (HVAC system) that ate away at our profit. 3) With the great recession rental prices dropped and lowered my expected return, and we also had a few months where the property was empty.
So, as you can see, things that seem too good to be true often are. So, before you decide to invest in a rental property, consider calculating the return on your investment to see if investing in a rental property is really the deal you thought.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
How to Calculate the Return on Investment of a Rental Property
Like any investment, you need to understand the expected return on investment (ROI). ROI = (Net Profit/Cost of Investment) x 100. Therefore, before you purchase a rental property, ask what return is reasonable to expect on your money, and what do you need to earn in order for the investment to be worthwhile?
Calculating the ROI of a rental property can be complex. While there are many different ways to do this, the point of this exercise is to provide you with a “back of the envelope” calculation to help you quickly assess whether or not a rental property has a return potential that is worth pursuing. If your calculation reveals that the return is small on paper, it’s likely going to be small in reality, too.
Before you can calculate the true ROI of a rental property, you have to factor in all the costs associated with holding that property, not just the purchase amount.
For illustrative purposes, I’ve put together a rental property ROI calculation to demonstrate how complex this mathematical exercise actually is.
(Image credit: Getty Images)
What to Factor into a Rental Property ROI Calculation
While the initial cost of investment should be straightforward (purchase price, closing costs, renovations to get it ready), determining your net profit (revenue — expenses) can get tricky. When calculating your own net profit, don’t forget these variables:
Revenue
- Rental Income: How much you can charge for rent each month.
- Mortgage paid down: How much of the property you own.
- Change in property value: How much additional equity you have beyond the amount of the mortgage you have already paid down, based on current housing and rental market prices.
Depreciation's Tax Break Has Consequences for Real Estate Investors
Expenses
- Financing: If you didn’t buy the property with cash and took out a mortgage, the amount you pay per month in principal and interest.
- Homeowner’s association dues: Fees you pay for community amenities.
- Property insurance: The insurance you carry on your property.
- Property taxes: What you pay in state and local taxes. And remember, property taxes don’t typically stay the same each year. They typically continue to rise unless an economic downturn allows you to have the property reassessed (typically for a fee) and readjusted downward.
- Vacancy: The amount of cash you need to cover expenses when you don’t have a tenant. The standard vacancy rate is 5% to 8%, meaning that’s the percentage of the year that the property can be expected to sit empty.
- Your time: The one item many people forget to account for is the cost of their own time. Whether it’s time spent as the handyman or finding a renter, your time is money, and anytime you put into managing the property reduces the return on your investment.
My “back of the envelope” calculation doesn’t even account for any management or maintenance costs of the property. Properties always require maintenance. This number is hard to generalize, as every property is different, but just know that something will break, appliances will need to be upgraded, and ongoing resources will be required to keep your property maintained and competitive in the rental market.
In addition, this calculation should be done for every year you anticipate owning the property, as your return will change over time.
Conclusion
Rental properties can generate income, but the return on investment doesn’t typically happen right away. Rental property investments are also risky because of how many variables can affect its performance, like the housing market or your ability to keep it rented. So, if you are wondering if you should invest in real estate, really consider how appropriate this type of investment would be for you and your situation first.
As with any investment, rental properties should be viewed as a long-term investment, not an instant cash cow. If your goal is to grow wealth, I will tell you that there are other ways to generate a return on your income with less risk and headache, like investing in a globally diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds.
What has been your experience with rental properties and being a landlord? Do you agree that, as an investment, it takes a while to reap a reward, or has your experience been different? Write to me at paul@lakeroadadvisors.com and tell me about it!
I'm a Landlord: Can I Ever Truly Retire?
Topics
Building Wealth
As an experienced real estate investor and enthusiast, I have actively engaged in property ownership and rental investments for over a decade. My journey began with the purchase of a condo in Stamford, Conn., in 2004, which my wife and I later turned into a rental property when we acquired our first single-family home. This first-hand experience has provided me with valuable insights into the complexities and challenges of real estate investment.
The article rightly highlights the potential benefits of owning a rental property, such as mortgage payment coverage by tenants and the growth of equity over time. However, it also emphasizes the inherent risks and challenges associated with real estate investments, drawing on personal experiences during the Great Recession.
The assertion that "things that seem too good to be true often are" aligns with my own experiences, where unexpected market fluctuations, property maintenance costs, and periods of vacancy significantly impacted the expected returns. For instance, the property's resale value did not meet the initial expectations, and necessary updates and repairs further diminished profits.
The article underscores the importance of calculating the return on investment (ROI) before diving into rental property ownership. I fully endorse this approach and emphasize that understanding the expected ROI is crucial for making informed investment decisions.
The formula provided in the article for calculating ROI, i.e., (Net Profit/Cost of Investment) x 100, is a fundamental tool for investors. It serves as a starting point for assessing whether a rental property has the potential for a worthwhile return. This formula aligns with my own methodology in evaluating investment opportunities, ensuring a comprehensive understanding of the financial implications.
The complexity of calculating ROI for rental properties is acknowledged, and the article wisely advises investors to consider various factors beyond the initial investment cost. This includes revenue components such as rental income, mortgage paid down, and change in property value. On the expense side, considerations like financing, homeowner's association dues, insurance, property taxes, vacancy rates, and personal time investment are crucial in arriving at a realistic net profit.
Moreover, the article touches upon the ongoing costs of property management and maintenance, emphasizing the need to account for these factors in a comprehensive ROI calculation. I wholeheartedly agree, as maintenance costs are inevitable, and effective property management is essential for long-term success.
In conclusion, the article rightly advises potential investors to view rental properties as a long-term investment, acknowledging the potential for delayed returns and the inherent risks involved. It also suggests that alternative investment options, such as a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds, may offer comparable returns with less risk and complexity.
My extensive experience in real estate investment aligns with the cautionary tone of the article, emphasizing the importance of thorough analysis and consideration of all relevant factors before embarking on a rental property investment journey.
)
