How the 2008 Lehman Brothers Collapse Affects You Today (2024)

On Monday, September 15, 2008, at 1:45 a.m., Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. filed a bankruptcy petition in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York. It was the largest bankruptcy proceeding in U.S. history. The 164-year-old firm was the fourth-largest U.S. investment bank, and its bankruptcy kicked off a global financial crisis.

Lehman used a high-leverage business model that required it to raise billions of dollars every day to keep the doors open. In 2006, it had invested heavily in high-risk real estate and subprime mortgages. When these markets turned south, Lehman couldn’t raise enough cash to stay in business.

Key Takeaways

  • The Lehman Brothers bankruptcy was the largest in U.S. history.
  • It invested heavily in risky mortgages just as housing prices started falling.
  • The government could not bail out Lehman without a buyer.
  • Lehman’s bankruptcy kicked off the 2008 financial crisis.
  • The financial crisis impacted millennials heavily.

How the Government Tried To Save Lehman Brothers

U.S. Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson and Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke grew concerned over a potential Lehman Brothers bankruptcy in March 2008. That was after the Fed rescued investment bank Bear Stearns. The expectation was that Lehman would be the next to need help.

Paulson urged Dick Fuld, Lehman’s president, to find a buyer as Bear Stearns had done, and Paulson personally encouraged the only two banks who were interested: Bank of America and British Barclays. He warned both that neither the Treasury nor the Fed could help with government funds.

Note

The U.S. Treasury had no legal authority to invest capital in Lehman Brothers, as Congress hadn’t yet authorized the Troubled Asset Relief Program.

Since Lehman Brothers was an investment bank, the government could not nationalize it like it did government enterprises Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. For that same reason, no federal regulator, like the FDIC, could take it over.

Moreover, the Fed couldn’t guarantee a loan as it did with Bear Stearns. Lehman Brothers didn’t have enough assets to secure one.

Bank of America didn’t want a loan, anyway. It wanted the government to cover $65 billion to $70 billion in anticipated losses. Paulson said no. Instead, he and Federal Reserve of New York President Tim Geithner sponsored a weekend retreat with the nation's top bankers to find funding for Lehman Brothers.

The bankers spent the next two days trying to find a way to make it work. But before they could, Bank of America backed out of the deal.The next day, Barclays announced its British regulators would not approve a Lehman Brothers deal. Everyone spent the rest of the day preparing for Lehman's bankruptcy.

Causes of Lehman’s Bankruptcy

Lehman’s bankruptcy had four underlying causes:

  1. Risk: The bank had taken on too much risk without a corresponding ability to raise cash quickly. In 2008, it had $639 billion in assets, technically more than enough to cover its $613 billion in debt. However, the assets were difficult to sell. As a result, Lehman Brothers couldn’t sell them to raise sufficient funds. That cash flow problem is what led to its bankruptcy.
  2. Culture: Management rewarded excessive risk-taking. Lehman’s chief risk officer said that top management ignored many of her risk-management strategies. Top managers wanted to stay ahead of competitors that also used high-risk strategies, and they also thought the company was too smart to fail.
  3. Overconfidence: The firm relied on complicated financial products based on quick real estate growth just as the real estate market began to decline. Between 2000-2006, its revenue grew 130% thanks to early successes with mortgage-backed securities. In 2003-2004, Lehman Brothers bought five mortgage lenders, which allowed it to originate and underwrite subprime loans, increasing its profitability. In March 2006, Lehman bought heavily into commercial real estate and risky loans and instead of selling them right away, it kept them on its books. Management thought it would make more money owning these assets but its timing couldn’t have been worse, as real estate prices were falling.
  4. Regulator inaction: The Securities and Exchange Commission and other regulators didn’t take action. As early as 2007, the SEC knew Lehman Brothers was taking on too much risk, but the agency never required Lehman to do anything about it. It also didn’t publicly disclose to rating agencies that the bank had exceeded risk limits.

Impact of Lehman’s Bankruptcy

Lehman’s bankruptcy sent financial markets reeling. The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 504.48 points, its worst decline in seven years. Losses continued until March 5, 2009, when the Dow closed at 6,594.44. That was a 53% drop from its peak of 14,164.53 on October 10, 2007. Investors fled to the relative safety of U.S. Treasury bonds, sending prices up.

Investors knew that Lehman’s bankruptcy threatened the financial institutions that owned its bonds. On September 16, 2008, the Reserve Primary money market fund "broke the buck." That meant its shares, normally worth at least $1, were only worth $0.97. Investors lost confidence in the money market fund when it announced losses of $785 million in Lehman’s commercial paper.

On September 17, 2008, the collapse spread. Investors withdrew a record $196 billion from their money market accounts. If the run had continued, businesses wouldn’t have been able to get money to fund their day-to-day operations. In just a few weeks, the economy would have collapsed. For example, shippers wouldn’t have had the cash to deliver food to grocery stores.

On September 18, 2008, Paulson and Bernanke met with congressional leaders to explain that credit markets were only a few days away from a meltdown. They asked for $700 billion to bail out the banks, which would allow the Treasury Department to buy shares of troubled banks; It was the fastest way to inject capital into the frozen financial system.

On September 29, 2008, Congress rejected the proposal. That sent the ​Dow down 777.68 points, the most in any single day in history until 2018.

How the Bankruptcy Affects You Today

The Lehman Brothers bankruptcy kicked off the 2008 financial crisis and the recession that followed. The millennial generation was just entering the workforce and therefore were the most heavily impacted.

Note

Millennials are those born between 1981 and 1996.

Unemployment rates skyrocketed, but millennials suffered the most—unemployment rates for those aged 16-24 rose from 9.9% in May 2007 to a record 19.5% by April 2010. Unemployment was at 8.8% for 25-54-year-olds and 7.0% for those 55 and older. By December 2017, unemployment had fallen to 8.9% for millennials, but the damage had already been done.

The recession’s impact on millennials is striking when compared to previous generations at the same age.

  • They have less wealth.
  • They have more student debt.
  • They are more likely to live with their parents.
  • They are slower in forming families.

The one positive impact is that millennials are more highly educated than in past generations. Since jobs weren’t available, Millennials went to school, which has paid off for those with a college degree. Their median household income is double that for those with only a high school degree.

Lehman’s bankruptcy also set the stage for the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Act. It was the most comprehensive financial reform since the Glass-Steagall Act. Glass-Steagall regulated banks after the 1929 stock market crash, but it was repealed in 1999. That allowed banks to once again invest depositors' funds in unregulated derivatives like mortgage-backed securities.

Dodd-Frank established the Financial Stability Oversight Council, which identifies risks that affect the entire financial industry. If any firm becomes too big, the FSOC will turn them over to the Federal Reserve for closer supervision. For example, the Fed can make a bank increase its reserve requirement, making sure they have enough cash on hand to prevent bankruptcy.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Who bought Leman Brothers?

Barclays ended up buying Lehman Brothers' U.S. operations the day after it filed for bankruptcy, and Normura purchased the firm's Asian and European operations a week later.

What happened to Lehman Brothers stock?

Lehman Brothers stock peaked at over $86 per share in February 2007. It began plummeting in September 2008 before becoming basically worthless when Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy.

How the 2008 Lehman Brothers Collapse Affects You Today (2024)

FAQs

How does Lehman Brothers affect us? ›

Impact of Lehman's Bankruptcy

On September 17, 2008, the collapse spread. Investors withdrew a record $196 billion from their money market accounts. 10 If the run had continued, businesses wouldn't have been able to get money to fund their day-to-day operations. In just a few weeks, the economy would have collapsed.

How did the collapse of Lehman Brothers affect the world? ›

Bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers and the global economic and financial crisis. The bankruptcy of U.S. investment bank Lehman Brothers on September 15, 2008 accelerated the global financial crisis caused by the U.S. subprime mortgage crisis. The financial turmoil caused serious dysfunction in financial and capital markets.

What lesson can be learned from Lehman Brothers? ›

Lesson: Profitably predicting a bear market or financial crisis is very difficult. Instead of attempting to time the market, a better practice is to create an all-weather portfolio that will grow in bull markets and provide relative preservation during bear markets.

What is the Lehman lesson how do you relate this to the roles? ›

So, the principal lesson from Lehman experience has to be that one should not rely on regulations, enforcement or expected interventions to protect their interests. Those who want to survive will have to learn how to protect themselves. If everyone learns this lesson, the system will survive longer.

What is the most important reason for the Lehman Brothers failure? ›

Lehman's ultimate end came as a result of being utterly overwhelmed by mortgage-backed securities (MBS) that were mostly backed with subprime loans, many of which went into default.

What lessons can be learned from the subprime mortgage meltdown? ›

One of the main lessons to learn from the financial crisis is the importance of holding institutions - large and small, and including the federal government –accountable for their actions.

Why did the US not save Lehman Brothers? ›

In the years since the collapse, the key regulators have claimed they could not have rescued Lehman because Lehman did not have adequate collateral to support a loan under the Fed's emergency lending power.

Did the Lehman Brothers cause the Great Depression? ›

Over the next century and a half, the company underwent numerous changes and engaged in several alliances and partnerships. While the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy did not cause the Great Recession or even the subprime mortgage crisis, its downfall triggered a massive selloff in the global markets.

What did Lehman Brothers do that was unethical? ›

Ethical malpractices were core in the fall of the Lehman Brothers' investment company. The firm invested without a proper analysis as required by ethics. Failure to conduct useful marketing research led to excess leveraging of mortgage firms.

What lesson did you learn from the big short? ›

Lesson 1: Question Authority

One of the main themes of the film is the importance of questioning authority. The film portrays the characters as as outsiders to the financial industry, who question the conventional wisdom that the housing market is stable and will continue to grow.

What is the biggest lesson you have learned in regard to getting into debt? ›

The Most Important Lesson of All

Unfortunately, the only way out of debt is through your own efforts, whether that means cutting your spending in order to free up extra income to pay it down or starting a side hustle or business to improve your financial situation over time.

Could Lehman have been saved? ›

Based on a meticulous four-year study of the Lehman case, he shows that the Federal Reserve could have rescued Lehman, but officials chose not to because of political pressures and because they didn't understand the damage that the Lehman bankruptcy would do to the economy.

What is the Lehman effect? ›

The term Lehman Wave refers to an economy-wide fluctuation in production and economic activity, with a wavelength of between 12 and 18 months, driven by a sudden major disruption of the economic system. The Lehman Wave is a damped, wave-like fluctuation around equilibrium.

What risk management failures led to the collapse of Lehman Brothers? ›

The factors that accounted for this failure were poor management choices coupled with unethical actions; repeal of the Glass- Steagall Act of 1933; liquidity crisis; financial leverage; excessive losses; Repos 105, massive credit default swaps, subprime mortgage crisis, complex capital structure, unsuccessful bail-out ...

Who were affected in Lehman Brothers scandal? ›

The bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers indicated that over 25,000 employees of the Firm had lost their jobs. Also, these employees had substantial investments in the stock of the Firm. The unprecedented fall of the Firm's stock price had a dire impact on their investments.

How can the problem of too big to fail be avoided? ›

The proposed solutions to the "too big to fail" issue are controversial. Some options include breaking up the banks, introducing regulations to reduce risk, adding higher bank taxes for larger institutions, and increasing monitoring through oversight committees.

What was the biggest lesson from the financial crisis of 2008? ›

1.Patience and perseverance in investing

Almost all the investors lost 30-40% of their portfolio's value. As the market started to crash, people began to panic, selling stocks even in India without adequate due diligence. Some of the investors took a step back to analyse its cause and its effects on their stocks.

What was one of the lessons learned from the 2008 financial crisis? ›

The single most important lesson of the Great Recession is the importance of a stable monetary regime. In my view, inflation targeting is not the most reliable guide to monetary policy.

Why is the 2008 housing crisis important? ›

In summary, the 2008 housing market crash had a profound impact on U.S. housing prices, causing them to fall significantly and leading to widespread foreclosures and financial hardship for homeowners. While the market has since recovered, the effects of the crash are still being felt today.

What did Lehman Brothers lie about? ›

Thanks to the bankruptcy examiner's report, we now know this was not true. Lehman's deleveraging was largely an accounting fiction. Fifty billion of it's supposedly $70 billion reduction in assets was produced entirely through the Repo 105 transactions. The importance of this deception cannot be overstated.

Who owns Lehman Brothers now? ›

Its collapse led to much debate over whether and in what circ*mstances companies should be allowed to fail. Barclays Plc (BARC. L) bought most of Lehman's U.S. brokerage assets early in the financial crisis.

Was Lehman Brothers too big to fail? ›

The government stepped in with a massive bailout package to prevent these institutions from going under and further damaging the economy. Though a few of these institutions were allowed to fail, such as Lehman and Bear, the government prevented the collapse of other large banks, all of which continue to thrive today.

How did the 2008 financial crisis affect the world? ›

The Great Recession didn't just affect the United States; all countries with rapid credit growth and large account deficits were impacted. Global trade nearly collapsed, declining by 15% between 2008 and 2009. Global unemployment rose by 3 percent between 2007 and 2010 for an astounding 30 million total jobs lost.

What are the 5 factors which causes Lehman Brothers to collapse? ›

Many factors have been identified as contributing to the demise of Lehman Brothers and its ultimate failure. These include (1) high leverage, (2) poor controls and risk management, (3) high real estate concentration, (4) questionable accounting and poor disclosure, and (5) weak government oversight.

Did the Lehman Brothers go to jail? ›

On the tenth anniversary of the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers, the media is full of articles questioning why nobody went to jail for the Great Financial Crisis that followed. Take, for instance, A crisis nobody went to jail for.

How much toxic assets did Lehman Brothers have? ›

Valukas, Bankruptcy Examiner). At that time, Lehman allegedly had $639 billion in assets and $619 billion in debt. These amounts made it the largest bankruptcy filing in history and caused Lehman to become the largest victim of the sub-prime mortgage crisis. This bankruptcy rocked the fabric of global society.

What crime did the Lehman Brothers commit? ›

Lehman misused an accounting trick called Repo 105 to temporarily remove the $50 billion from its ledgers to make it look as though it was reducing its dependency on borrowed money and was drawing down its debt.

How many jobs were lost due to Lehman Brothers? ›

Twenty-five thousand Lehman employees lost their jobs, and the landscape of Wall Street shifted as a storied 158-year-old bank closed its doors.

What did you learn from the lesson my big brother? ›

Conclusion of My Elder Brother

This story teaches us that no matter how intelligent we become, we must not forget to respect our elders and listen to their scolding if it is for the right reason as they want our goodwill.

What is the main point of The Big Short? ›

Directed by Adam McKay, The Big Short chronicles the years leading up to the 2007-08 global economic crisis, focusing on several financial professionals (based on actual individuals) who predicted and profited from the collapse.

Who benefited from The Big Short? ›

Michael Burry is an investor who profited from the subprime mortgage crisis by shorting the 2007 mortgage bond market, making $100 million for himself and $700 million for his investors.

Why is the student debt crisis important? ›

Many experts and policymakers agree that both the rising cost of college and the existing volume of loans need to be addressed. They acknowledge that surging student debt is harming younger generations of students by preventing them from reaching their financial goals while exacerbating racial inequality.

How can the student debt crisis be solved? ›

  1. Forgive student loan debt.
  2. Streamline existing forgiveness programs.
  3. Cut or lower interest rates.
  4. Condense income-driven repayment.
  5. Fixes to income-driven repayment forgiveness.
  6. Make college tuition-free.
  7. Expand Pell Grants.
Jan 20, 2023

What do you think is the best way to avoid debt? ›

How to avoid debt
  1. Follow the money. If you want to avoid debt, you need to better understand your spending. ...
  2. Practice 50-30-20. Are you spending more on wants or needs? ...
  3. Pay yourself first. ...
  4. Create an emergency fund. ...
  5. A little bit less. ...
  6. Pay your credit card in full. ...
  7. Boost your income. ...
  8. Rinse and repeat.

Who rescued Lehman Brothers? ›

But as the world now knows, no one rescued Lehman. Instead, the firm was allowed to collapse overnight, a decision that, in cool hindsight, let problems at one bank snowball into a full-blown panic. By the time it was over, nearly every other major bank had to be saved.

Who was blamed for Lehman? ›

Fuld was named in Time's "25 People to Blame for the Financial Crisis" list. Fuld at one time served on the board of directors of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, a position he ceased holding shortly before the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers.

Are Lehman Brothers still in business? ›

Lehman Brothers Inc.

(/ˈliːmən/ LEE-mən) was an American global financial services firm founded in 1847. Before filing for bankruptcy in 2008, Lehman was the fourth-largest investment bank in the United States (behind Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and Merrill Lynch), with about 25,000 employees worldwide.

What is the message of the Lehman trilogy? ›

The Lehman Trilogy follows the epic rise and fall of three generations of that infamous family and through them tells the story of American ambition and hubris. After leaving his native Bavaria, Henry Lehman arrives in America determined to make a better life.

Which risk or risks caused the significant failure of Lehman Bros? ›

Key Takeaways. Lehman Brothers had humble beginnings as a dry-goods store, but eventually branched off into commodities trading and brokerage services. The firm survived many challenges but was eventually brought down by the collapse of the subprime mortgage market.

What was the larger impact of the failure of Lehman Brothers? ›

The collapse of Lehman Brothers provoked a broader run on the financial system, leading to systemic crisis. All told, twenty-four countries fell victim to banking crises, and economic activity has still not returned to trend in most of them.

What was the result of the Lehman Brothers scandal? ›

A mass exodus of clients took place, the firm's assets were drastically downgraded by credit agencies, and the U.S. federal government refused to take action to help prevent the firm's collapse. Lehman Brothers was forced to file for bankruptcy in September 2008.

Why did Lehman fail and was the US government right to let it fail? ›

The Fed made a subjective decision to allow Lehman's bankruptcy. They had their reasons why, but a legal constraint was not valid reason among them. Instead, it was a combination of legitimate financial constraints and political and social concerns.

Did people lose money when Lehman went under? ›

More than $115 billion was paid out. Lehman's 111,000 customers received all $106 billion they were owed, and secured creditors also received full payouts. Unsecured creditors recovered $9.4 billion, or about 41 cents on the dollar. They were originally expected to recover about 20 cents on the dollar.

How could Lehman have been saved? ›

Both misfortunes befell Lehman: Its assets lost value, and its short-term lenders deserted. The Fed could have rescued Lehman by lending it the money needed to replace the fleeing short-term lenders, Ball argues.

Is Lehman Brothers still around? ›

Lehman Brothers Inc.

(/ˈliːmən/ LEE-mən) was an American global financial services firm founded in 1847. Before filing for bankruptcy in 2008, Lehman was the fourth-largest investment bank in the United States (behind Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and Merrill Lynch), with about 25,000 employees worldwide.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Errol Quitzon

Last Updated:

Views: 5912

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Errol Quitzon

Birthday: 1993-04-02

Address: 70604 Haley Lane, Port Weldonside, TN 99233-0942

Phone: +9665282866296

Job: Product Retail Agent

Hobby: Computer programming, Horseback riding, Hooping, Dance, Ice skating, Backpacking, Rafting

Introduction: My name is Errol Quitzon, I am a fair, cute, fancy, clean, attractive, sparkling, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.