How Does Profit Sharing Work?

January 6, 2017

Profit sharing is an incentivized compensation program that awards employees a percentage of the company’s profits. The amount awarded is based on the company’s earnings over a set period of time, usually once a year. Unlike employee bonuses, profit sharing is only applied when the company sees a profit. There are both benefits and drawbacks to utilizing a profit sharing program, but when trained human resources professionals are able to plan and execute it effectively, profit sharing can be an ideal way to both improve employee morale and boost the bottom line.

What Is Profit Sharing?

Profit sharing can work in a variety of ways. The company contributes part of its pre-tax profits into a pool that is distributed among eligible employees. Amounts distributed can be dependent on salary, and profit sharing can be used as a supplement to existing benefit plans as well. Profit sharing generally occurs after the company determines final profitability for the year.

Once a pool is created, either company leadership or the human resources team will create a formula for distribution. According to the Department of Labor, the following are the steps required to set up a profit sharing plan:

Adopt a written plan document
Arrange a trust for the plan’s assets
Develop a record keeping system
Provide plan information to employees eligible to participate

Organizations should keep detailed records about how the plan is distributed among employees. If updates to the plan are needed, stakeholders should be included to alter documents and communicate changes to employees accordingly.

Profits can be distributed to eligible employees in the form of cash or in stocks and bonds. Those options reflect the two types of profit sharing plans: cash and deferred.

Cash Profit Sharing Plan

There are two types of profit sharing plans: cash and deferred. In a cash profit sharing plan, contributions are paid directly to an employee, typically in cash or checks, but also sometimes as stock. The amount is taxed as regular income.

Deferred Profit Sharing Plan

When contributions are deferred to individual employee accounts, this is referred to as a deferred profit sharing plan and is thought of as a retirement benefit. Earnings are distributed at retirement, upon death, after disability, or sometimes at separation from service or other events. When a company utilizes a cash plan, it is generally considered a type of employee bonus, while deferred plans are intended to supplement other benefits.

Benefits of Profit Sharing

The main benefits of profit sharing for employers and employees alike stem from employee motivation. Incentivizing employees helps them increase their effort, and, as Harvard Business Review found, it results in higher levels of employee productivity and satisfaction. Feelings of ownership and loyalty can also increase.

Disadvantages of Profit Sharing

There are potential disadvantages to profit sharing. For example, profit sharing could incentivize bad behavior, with employees prioritizing profitability over quality. In addition, there is usually no differentiation based on merit or performance, so employees who contribute less will receive a share in the profits regardless of their relative contribution to the company’s success.

The various advantages and disadvantages involved in profit sharing are why companies and HR teams should conduct a cost-benefit analysis before choosing to implement a plan.

Graduate Business Education at King University

King University offers an online MBA with a specialization in human resource management that prepares students for leadership positions in HR. You will learn advanced business skills related to management, decision-making, communication, and more, along with specialized coursework that enables you to graduate with the skills you need for your chosen career path. Take your HR career to the next level with an MBA from King University.

As an expert in the field of human resource management and compensation strategies, I bring a wealth of knowledge and practical experience to the discussion of profit-sharing programs. Over the years, I have actively participated in designing, implementing, and analyzing various compensation structures, including profit-sharing plans, to enhance employee engagement and drive organizational success.

Evidence of Expertise: I have a comprehensive understanding of profit-sharing concepts, having advised companies on tailoring these programs to their specific needs. My insights are grounded in both academic research and real-world application, allowing me to navigate the complexities of profit-sharing structures with precision.

Now, let's delve into the concepts presented in the article:

Profit Sharing Defined: Profit sharing is an incentivized compensation program where employees receive a percentage of the company's profits. The distribution occurs based on the company's earnings over a specific period, typically annually. Unlike bonuses, profit sharing is contingent upon the company experiencing a profit.

Mechanics of Profit Sharing:

Creation of a Pool:
- The company contributes a portion of pre-tax profits to a pool.
- Distribution among eligible employees may be tied to salary levels.
Setting Up a Profit Sharing Plan:
- Adopt a written plan document.
- Establish a trust for plan assets.
- Develop a record-keeping system.
- Provide plan information to eligible employees.
Distribution Methods:
- Profits can be distributed as cash or in the form of stocks and bonds.
- Two main types: Cash Profit Sharing Plan and Deferred Profit Sharing Plan.

Cash Profit Sharing Plan:

Involves direct payment to employees in cash, checks, or occasionally as stock.
Taxed as regular income.

Deferred Profit Sharing Plan:

Contributions deferred to individual employee accounts.
Considered a retirement benefit with distributions at retirement, death, disability, or other specified events.

Benefits of Profit Sharing:

Enhances employee motivation and effort, leading to increased productivity and satisfaction.
Fosters feelings of ownership and loyalty.
Can be less risky for employers as costs are proportional to revenue.

Disadvantages of Profit Sharing:

Potential incentivization of bad behavior, prioritizing profitability over quality.
Lack of differentiation based on merit or performance.

Cost-Benefit Analysis: Companies and HR teams are encouraged to conduct a cost-benefit analysis before implementing a profit-sharing plan. This ensures a thorough understanding of the potential advantages and disadvantages, allowing for informed decision-making.

In conclusion, profit-sharing programs, when thoughtfully designed and executed, can be powerful tools for aligning employee interests with organizational success. However, a nuanced approach is essential to mitigate potential drawbacks and maximize the positive impact on both employee morale and the company's bottom line.