Traders work on the floor of the NYSE in New York.
NYSE
BEIJING — For Americans looking to play the China growth story, investing in the country's U.S.-listed stocks now bears a political risk that could lead to delisting.
That means a Chinese company traded on an exchange like the Nasdaq would lose access to a broad pool of buyers, sellers and intermediaries. The centralization of these different market participants helps create what's called liquidity, which in turn allows investors to quickly turn their holdings into cash.
The development of the U.S. stock market over the decades also means companies listed on established exchanges are part of a system of regulation and institutional operations that can offer certain investor protections.
Once a stock is delisted, the company's shares can keep trading through a process known as "over-the-counter." But that means the stock is outside the system — of major financial institutions, deep liquidity and the ability for sellers to find a buyer quickly without losing money.
watch now
VIDEO0:0000:00
The NYSE delistings are likely to have a limited impact on China's markets: JPMorgan
"The most practical thing for a typical investor to worry about is price," said James Early, CEO of investment research firmStansberryChina.
"You're probably going to have to give (a soon-to-be-delisted stock) up sooner or later, so make your bet now," he said. "Are you better off selling now, or wait for some kind of a bounce?"
The New York Stock Exchange announced last week it would delist three Chinese telecommunications giants named in President Donald Trump's executive order that banned U.S. investment in companies with alleged ties to China's military.
Assuming trades would be settled through a third-party system on Jan. 7 and 8, the exchange said it would suspend local trading in shares of China Mobile, China Unicom and China Telecom before the market open on Jan. 11.
The three companies' shares fell in New York trading on Monday. Trading volume for the day neared that of the entire previous month, according to data from Wind Information.
But the companies' Hong Kong-traded shares rose during Tuesday's session after the New York Stock Exchange reversed its delisting decision, citing additional conversations with regulators on the executive order.
Trump's executive order gives U.S. investors until Nov. 11 to divest, or sell out, of affected holdings. The majority of the companies named, if publicly traded, are not listed in the U.S.
Tensions between the U.S. and China have escalated under the Trump administration. A dispute that focused on trade just over two years ago has since spilled into technology and finance.
It is unclear how U.S. President-elect Joe Biden will handle financial flows between the two countries. Analysts expect his administration will rally traditional U.S. allies to work together on putting greater pressure on Beijing to address longstanding complaints about the country's unfair business practices.
Delisting is not the end
Chinese stocks have been delisted from U.S. exchanges for reasons other than politics.
About a decade ago, a regulatory crackdown on accounting fraud led to a slew of removals. Other Chinese companies chose to return to their home market where they could potentially raise more money from investors who were more familiar with their businesses.
Last summer, Chinese coffee chain operator Luckin Coffee was delisted from the Nasdaq after the company revealed the fabrication of 2.2 billion yuan ($340 million) in sales. The stock hit a 52-week low of 95 cents a share.
But shares rose even after going "over-the-counter" and closed at $8.64 each on Monday.
Most of the Chinese start-ups that have listed in New York in the last few years are consumer-focused technology companies.
Chinese businesses remain keen on the New York market for the prestige, while global investors are still buying in. China-based companies raised $11.7 billion through 30 initial public offerings in the U.S. last year, the most capital since 2014, according to Renaissance Capital.
The firm's analysis found that in 2020, the Chinese companies that raised at least $100 million had an average total return of 81%.
As an expert in financial markets and investment strategies, I bring a wealth of knowledge and experience to the table. My extensive background includes in-depth research, analysis, and a track record of making informed investment decisions. I've closely followed the dynamics of global markets, regulatory frameworks, and geopolitical influences on financial assets.
Now, let's delve into the key concepts presented in the article about the potential delisting of Chinese stocks from U.S. exchanges:
-
Political Risk in Investing: The article highlights the political risk associated with investing in Chinese stocks listed on U.S. exchanges. The risk stems from the possibility of delisting due to geopolitical tensions and executive orders, such as the one issued by President Donald Trump, banning U.S. investment in companies with alleged ties to China's military.
-
Impact of Delisting on Liquidity: Delisting implies that a Chinese company traded on a U.S. exchange, like Nasdaq, would lose access to a broad pool of buyers, sellers, and intermediaries. This centralized market participation creates liquidity, enabling investors to quickly convert their holdings into cash. The absence of this liquidity can impact the ease of trading.
-
Over-the-Counter (OTC) Trading: Once delisted, a stock can continue trading through the OTC market. However, OTC trading is outside the established system of major financial institutions, deep liquidity, and rapid buyer-seller transactions. This shift poses challenges for investors who prefer the structured environment provided by major exchanges.
-
Market Reaction and Investor Decisions: The article discusses the reaction of the market to the New York Stock Exchange's announcement of delisting three Chinese telecommunications giants. It quotes James Early, CEO of investment research firm Stansberry China, advising investors to consider the practical aspects, particularly the stock price, when deciding whether to sell immediately or wait for a potential rebound.
-
Role of Executive Orders and Regulatory Environment: The delisting decision is linked to an executive order by President Trump, indicating the influence of political decisions and regulatory measures on the stock market. The article touches on the deadline set by the executive order for U.S. investors to divest from affected holdings.
-
Historical Precedents of Delisting: The article mentions historical instances of Chinese stocks being delisted from U.S. exchanges, including a regulatory crackdown on accounting fraud about a decade ago. Some companies chose to return to the Chinese market, while others continued trading over-the-counter.
-
Potential Biden Administration's Approach: The article discusses the uncertainty about how President-elect Joe Biden's administration will handle financial relations with China. Analysts expect a focus on rallying traditional U.S. allies to address longstanding complaints about China's business practices.
-
Chinese Companies' Interest in U.S. Markets: Despite delisting concerns, Chinese businesses remain interested in the prestige of listing on U.S. exchanges. Global investors also continue to invest in Chinese companies, as evidenced by the significant capital raised through IPOs in the U.S.
In conclusion, the article paints a comprehensive picture of the intricate relationship between political developments, regulatory actions, and their impact on the investment landscape, particularly in the context of Chinese stocks listed on U.S. exchanges.
