GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (2024)

Resources | Insights | GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business?

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (1)Nov 10, 2022 |Thomson Reuters

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (2)

Most businesses report financial performance using U.S. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP). However, the income-tax-basis format can save time and money for some private companies. Comparing GAAP vs. tax-basis is essential for a company’s success. Here’s information to help you choose the financial reporting framework that will suit your situation.

The Basics of Gaap and Accounting Methods

GAAP is the most common financial reporting standard in the United States. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) requires public companies to follow it — they don’t have a choice. Many lenders expect large private borrowers to follow suit because GAAP is familiar and consistent.

However, compliance with GAAP can be time-consuming and costly, depending on the level of assurance provided in the financial statements. So, some private companies report financial statements using an “other comprehensive basis of accounting” (OCBOA) method. The most common OCBOA method is the tax-basis format.

Key Differences Between Gaap and Tax-Basis Reporting

Departing from GAAP can result in significant differences in financial results. Why? GAAP is based on conservatism, which prevents companies from overstating profits and asset values. This runs contrary to what the IRS expects from for-profit businesses. Tax laws generally favor accelerated gross income recognition and won’t allow taxpayers to deduct expenses until the amounts are known, and other deductibility requirements have been met. So, reported profits tend to be higher under tax-basis methods than GAAP.

Terminology

There are also differences in terminology. Under GAAP, companies report revenues, expenses, and net income. Conversely, tax-basis entities report gross income, deductions, and taxable income. Their nontaxable items typically appear as separate line items or are disclosed in a footnote.

Capitalization and Depreciation

Capitalization and depreciation of fixed assets is another noteworthy difference. Under GAAP, the cost of a fixed asset (less its salvage value) is capitalized and systematically depreciated over its useful life. For tax purposes, fixed assets are depreciated under the Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS), which generally results in shorter lives than under GAAP. Salvage value isn’t subtracted for tax purposes, but Section 179 and bonus depreciation are subtracted before computing MACRS deductions.

Allowances

Other reporting differences exist for inventory, pensions, leases, start-up costs, and accounting for changes and errors. In addition, companies record allowances for bad debts, sales returns, inventory obsolescence, and asset impairment under GAAP. But these allowances generally aren’t permitted under tax law.

Departing From GAAP

GAAP has become increasingly complex in recent years. So, some companies would prefer tax-basis reporting if it’s appropriate for financial statement users. For example, tax-basis financials might work for a business owned, operated, and financed by individuals closely involved in day-to-day operations who understand its financial position.

However, GAAP statements typically work better if the company has unsecured debt or numerous shareholders who own minority interests. Likewise, prospective buyers may prefer to perform due diligence on GAAP financial statements — or they may be public companies that are required to follow GAAP.

Choosing Your Accounting Method

Tax-basis reporting makes sense for certain types of businesses. But for other businesses, tax-basis financial statements may result in missing or misleading information. We can help you evaluate GAAP vs. tax-basis and choose the appropriate reporting framework for your situation. Contact us with questions.

© 2023

Related Resources

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (4)

Social Security Wage Base Updates for 2024

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (5)

‘Tis the Season for Holiday Gift and Party Tax Breaks

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (6)

R&D Capitalization and Amortization Changes Take Effect

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (7)

R&D Payroll Tax Credit Election for Small Businesses

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (8)

Changes to Federal Form 6765 for Clients Claiming the R&D Tax Credit

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (9)

Farm Tax Deductions and Planning Strategies for 2024

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (10)

From 529 to Roth IRA: New Opportunities for Families

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (11)

Cash vs. Accrual Accounting: What’s Best for Your Business?

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (12)

The Importance of Sustainability in R&D

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (13)

Is an LLC Right for Your Business?

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (14)

Divorce Tax Implications for Business Owners

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (15)

Reducing Taxes by Using an S Corporation

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (16)

The Trust Fund Recovery Penalty

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (17)

Business Travel Tax Deductions

Insight

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (18)

CO and MN Take Action on Retail Delivery Fee – NY May Follow Suit

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? (2024)

FAQs

GAAP vs. Tax-Basis: Which is Right for your Business? ›

So, reported profits tend to be higher under tax-basis methods than under GAAP. There are also differences in terminology. Under GAAP, companies report revenues, expenses and net income. Conversely, tax-basis entities report gross income, deductions, and taxable income.

What is the difference between GAAP and income tax basis? ›

Under GAAP, businesses report revenues, expenses and net income. Tax-basis entities report gross income, deductions and taxable income. Their nontaxable items typically appear as separate line items or are disclosed in a footnote.

What is allowed for GAAP accounting but not for tax accounting? ›

The basis of accounting used to produce financial statements determines how to report transactions and ultimately what information reports on the financial statements. Accrual basis accounting is the only option allowed under GAAP. Tax accounting can use cash, accrual or modified basis accounting.

Why would a company not use GAAP? ›

If GAAP provides a standardized view of most companies' financial standing, it begs the question: why use other methods? Essentially, many organizations find that GAAP accounting doesn't provide a full overview of their financial health, and use non-GAAP to complement their GAAP financial statements.

Do small businesses have to use GAAP? ›

The SEC only requires publicly traded companies to report GAAP-compliant financial statements. Private companies generally do not need to follow GAAP.

Is income tax basis considered GAAP? ›

The most significant difference between generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) and the income tax basis of accounting is that income tax basis allows entities to focus on the actual flow of funds and operations and their impact on eventual tax dollars.

What is the difference between tax basis and capital account? ›

The partner's "capital account" measures the partner's equity investment in the partnership. The "outside basis" measures the adjusted basis of the partner's partnership interest. One of the key differences between capital accounts and outside basis is the effect of partnership liabilities.

In what ways do GAAP and tax law differ? ›

While GAAP is focused on providing accurate financial information to external stakeholders, tax accounting is focused on complying with tax laws and regulations. This difference in objectives can lead to discrepancies between the two accounting methods, making it difficult to reconcile financial information.

What companies don't need to use GAAP? ›

Private companies without bank debt and whose covenants don't require GAAP financial statements can use it. The standard uses a blended approach from traditional accounting methods with accrual income tax methods. It is a simple framework that only has a few deviations from U.S. GAAP.

Do all businesses have to follow GAAP? ›

Although it is not required for non-publicly traded companies, GAAP is viewed favorably by lenders and creditors. Most financial institutions will require annual GAAP-compliant financial statements as a part of their debt covenants when issuing business loans. As a result, most companies in the U.S. do follow GAAP.

What is GAAP disadvantage? ›

Con: Cost of GAAP-Compliant Statements

If you decide to adopt financial accounting practices that use GAAP standards later on, then you'll incur the additional cost of changing your existing bookkeeping and accounting systems, implementing new systems, and updating your financial reports as you go forward.

Do private companies need to use GAAP accounting? ›

Private companies are not required to follow GAAP because they generally keep financial information for tax purposes only. However, it doesn't hurt to follow the accounting principles if you're a private company and plan on providing financial statements to people outside of your business.

Why would a private company use GAAP? ›

Because of the credibility provided by GAAP reporting, private companies may realize greater flexibility in the types of financing available to them. GAAP also may help ease the transition from private to public status.

Do LLCS have to follow GAAP? ›

Small businesses must follow Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP). These give a standard for financial reporting an make sure the financial statements are the same.

Can small businesses use cash basis accounting? ›

So, if your small business is a corporation (other than an S corp) that averages less than $25 million in gross receipts each year, cash accounting is an option for you. That being said, the cash method is usually more suited for small businesses that don't carry inventory.

What happens if a company doesn't follow GAAP? ›

Consequences of not following GAAP

1. Legal penalties, fines, and lawsuits. 2. Loss of trust from stakeholders like investors, lenders, and customers.

What is the income tax basis? ›

Basis is generally the amount of your capital investment in property for tax purposes. Use your basis to figure depreciation, amortization, depletion, casualty losses, and any gain or loss on the sale, exchange, or other disposition of the property.

What is the difference between tax basis and GAAP vs Section 704 B? ›

Section 704(b) accounts reflect a partner's economic interest in the entity, GAAP balances report balances that comply with accounting board requirements, and tax basis balances reflect a partner's capital balance under federal income tax principles.

What is the income tax basis of accounting rules? ›

Income tax basis accounting primarily focuses on compliance with tax laws and regulations. While less common than selecting GAAP as the financial reporting framework, income tax basis presents unique considerations for businesses, particularly in the restaurant industry.

What is the GAAP basis? ›

The generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) are a set of accounting rules, standards, and procedures issued and frequently revised by the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB). Public companies in the U.S. must follow GAAP when their accountants compile their financial statements.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Last Updated:

Views: 5523

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Foster Heidenreich CPA

Birthday: 1995-01-14

Address: 55021 Usha Garden, North Larisa, DE 19209

Phone: +6812240846623

Job: Corporate Healthcare Strategist

Hobby: Singing, Listening to music, Rafting, LARPing, Gardening, Quilting, Rappelling

Introduction: My name is Foster Heidenreich CPA, I am a delightful, quaint, glorious, quaint, faithful, enchanting, fine person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.