Foreign direct investment in developing countries: A blessing or a curse? (2024)

It is very likely that Inner Mongolia, France, Korea and Italy all played a part in creating your smartphone. Our global, ever-growing system of consumption and production has created intricate networks of transnational cooperation. Foreign direct investment (FDI) has facilitated this interconnectedness. While FDI is often seen as an engine of growth for emerging economies, recent research is telling a different story.

Foreign direct investment can be described as money that a company invests in buildings, factories, machines or other infrastructure outside of the company’s home country. By investing internationally, a company can obtain the raw materials it needs for its production processes. Investing in a developing country is profitable, because prices are often low and regulations lenient. The influence of FDI on the developing world has been studied extensively. However, until recently, it had not been linked to natural resource depletion.

In an article published in the journal Society & Natural Resources, Michael Long and Paul Stretesky from the University of Newcastle and Michael Lynch from the University of South Florida investigated the influence of FDI on natural resource depletion in developing countries. They hypothesized that FDI leads to an increase in natural resource depletion, while fostering dependency on income generated from that depletion. An example of income generated from resource depletion would be the money earned off of unsustainable forestry practices. After analyzing data from 125 developing countries between 2005 and 2013, they found both hypotheses to be correct.

There are two types of environmental degradation: ecological addition and ecological withdrawals. Ecological addition is pollution added to the environment through byproducts from production processes, such as carbon dioxide emissions from factories. Ecological withdrawals are literally “withdrawals” from the environment, like mining or cutting down trees. Increasing ecological withdrawals of nonrenewable resources leads to natural resource depletion. The article focuses on natural resource depletion, specifically in the energy (coal, gas and oil), forest and mineral resource sectors.

The researchers found that annual increases in FDI enhance the depletion of energy, forest and mineral resources in developing countries. This finding suggests that FDI can promote unsustainable resource use. It also implies that FDI allows supply chains to expand by turning developing countries into “supply depots.” To make matters worse, more resource depletion means more ecological addition in the form of pollution and waste. The researchers relate this phenomenon to the “treadmill of production” theory, which describes how the globally expanding economy promotes resource depletion and pollution. Developing nations are left to deal with the consequences of the production treadmill, while wealthy nations can continue to enjoy high levels of consumption.

Foreign direct investment was also found to enhance the dependency on income generated from the forest and mineral sector. In other words, increases in FDI make developing countries more dependent on the depletion of natural resources to keep their economy running. The authors describe a positive feedback loop: FDI increases, leading to financial dependence and resource depletion, which in return enhances FDI as the natural resource sectors grow. In addition, the developing nation may be forced to steer economic policy in the direction that suits the investing nation. This could hinder the developing nation from making decisions that are the most beneficial for economic development. Thus, FDI might not be the engine of growth it is often assumed to be.

The authors suggest that policymakers should be wary of making decisions that increase their country’s dependency on income from natural resource sectors, which might prevent a country from losing its economic decision-making autonomy. They also call for more research to help understand the exact dynamics at play. Examining specific case studies using historical data on FDI, resource depletion and economic development would help to better understand the long-term effect of FDI on emerging economies.

Foreign direct investment in developing countries: A blessing or a curse? (2024)

FAQs

Foreign direct investment in developing countries: A blessing or a curse? ›

Foreign direct investment is often seen as an economic blessing for developing nations. However, new research reveals that it stimulates resource depletion, while fostering dependency on the income generated from that depletion.

Is FDI good or bad for developing countries? ›

Also, they find large differences in the growth effect of FDI across countries. Thus, the overall picture that emerges from these studies is that FDI tends to have a positive effect on economic growth in developing countries, but this growth effect is very heterogeneous. Yet, these studies are limited by two factors.

How does foreign direct investment affect developing countries? ›

FDI contributes to economic growth by augmenting capital and interacting with the host country's conditions. Infrastructural development is the channel that allows FDI to have the most impact. FDI tends to crowd out domestic investment at certain levels.

What are the benefits of foreign investment in developing countries? ›

Economic growth

FDI boosts the manufacturing and services sector which results in the creation of jobs and helps to reduce unemployment rates in the country. Increased employment translates to higher incomes and equips the population with more buying powers, boosting the overall economy of a country.

What are the disadvantages of FDI for developing countries? ›

Disadvantages of FDI
  • hinder domestic investments and transfer control of domestic firms to foreign ones.
  • risk political changes, exposing countries to foreign political influence.
  • influence exchange rates.
  • Influence interest rates.
  • Overtake domestic industry if they cannot compete.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of FDI to developing countries? ›

FDI Advantages And Disadvantages In Tabular Form
AdvantagesDisadvantages
1. Capital Infusion and Job Creation1. Risk of Political Instability
2. Transfer of Technology and Skills2. Negative Effects on Domestic Firms
3. Increased Competition and Productivity3. Dependence on Foreign Investment
2 more rows
Mar 31, 2023

Does FDI help poverty? ›

FDI reduces poverty through the direct channel by creating jobs in the private sector and when foreign investors invest directly in the provision of some social welfare for the poor (Gohou & Soumare, 2012. (2012).

What are the disadvantages of FDI? ›

  • Hindrance to Domestic Investment. As it focuses its resources elsewhere other than the investor's home country, foreign direct investment can sometimes hinder domestic investment. ...
  • Risk from Political Changes. ...
  • Negative Influence on Exchange Rates. ...
  • Higher Costs. ...
  • Economic Non-Viability. ...
  • Expropriation.

Why is foreign direct investment sometimes controversial in developing countries? ›

Why is foreign direct investment sometimes controversial in developing countries? Developing countries think multinational corporations keep too much of the profit from their investments.

Who benefits from foreign direct investment? ›

FDI can foster and maintain economic growth, in both the recipient country and the country making the investment. On one hand, developing countries have encouraged FDI as a means of financing the construction of new infrastructure and the creation of jobs for their local workers.

What are the examples of FDI in developing countries? ›

FDI has accelerated investment in new infrastructure. E.g. the Addis Ababa – Djibouti road; provides coastal access for land-locked Ethiopia. Other projects include dams and airports, mines and wind farms providing opportunities for African nations to grow capacity in renewable energy.

Is foreign investment good for the economy? ›

Contributes to Rising U.S. Productivity: Inward investment leads to higher productivity growth through an increased availability of capital and resulting competition.

What is the foreign investment risk? ›

As such, foreign investment risk (sometimes known as global investment risk) is defined as the degree of loss likely to occur when investing in countries outside of the United States.

What are the two major concerns about foreign direct investment? ›

The two major concerns about foreign direct investment​ are: who receives the profits and taxes. who controls the assets and who receives the profits.

Which of the following is a disadvantage of globalization for developing countries? ›

1. Growing Inequality. Globalization can increase inequality throughout the world by increasing specialization and trade. Although specialization and trade boost the per-capita income it may cause relative poverty.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of FDI foreign direct investment? ›

Advantages for the company investing in a foreign market include access to the market, access to resources, and reduction in the cost of production. Disadvantages for the company include an unstable and unpredictable foreign economy, unstable political systems, and underdeveloped legal systems.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of foreign portfolio investment? ›

Pros and Cons of FPIs
FPI advantagesFPI disadvantages
Helps companies raise significant capital without incurring massive expenses.Economic turmoil and political instability may have a negative impact on any investment via the FPI route.
3 more rows

What are the three potential costs of FDI to host countries? ›

The probable negative consequences of FDI on domestic competition, negative effects on the balance of payments, and the perceived loss of national sovereignty and autonomy are all potential costs of FDI to a host country.

What is the impact of FDI on poverty and inequality in local economies? ›

The study finds that FDI has contributed to poverty reduction not only directly but also indirectly through human capital. However, FDI has indirectly worsened poverty through international trade. In addition, empirical results from the spatial econometric model show that FDI tends to decrease poverty in provinces.

Why do governments seek FDI? ›

Governments seek to promote FDI when they are eager to expand their domestic economy and attract new technologies, business know-how, and capital to their country.

Can foreign aid reduce income inequality and poverty? ›

For over five decades, foreign aids have been used by the developed world and aid donors/agencies to alleviate poverty, reduce the disparity of income inequality and stimulate growth in Africa but quite surprisingly controversial, the remittances miss targets of poverty cutting in Africa and another developing world.

What factors are affected by FDI? ›

Factors that affect foreign direct investment (FDI)
  • Infrastructure and access to raw materials.
  • Communication and transport links.
  • Skills and wage costs of labour.

What is example of foreign direct investment? ›

An example would be McDonald's investing in an Asian country to increase the number of stores in the region. Here, a business enters a foreign economy to strengthen a part of its supply chain without changing its business in any way.

What does FDI not include? ›

Sectors in the Indian economy where FDI is not allowed are: Atomic Energy Generation. Cigars, Cigarettes, or any related tobacco industry. Lotteries (online, private, government, etc)

Why is foreign direct investment negative? ›

Negative FDI positions largely result when the loans from the affiliate to its parent exceed the loans and equity capital given by the parent to the affiliate.

What is true about the activities of foreign investors in developing countries? ›

What is true about the activities of foreign investors in developing countries? Foreign investors are seen as vital partners in economic development.

Why would a country prefer foreign direct investment as opposed to portfolio investment? ›

Foreign direct investment tends to be viewed more favorably since they are considered long-term investments, as well as investments in the well-being of the country itself.

Is foreign direct investment good for a country? ›

FDI can also promote competition in the domestic input market. Recipients of FDI often gain employee training in the course of operating the new businesses, which contributes to human capital development in the host country. Profits generated by FDI contribute to corporate tax revenues in the host country.

Who receives the most foreign direct investment? ›

The United States is the top destination of inward foreign direct investment. Source: IMF Data, Coordinated Direct Investment Survey.

How do developing countries benefit from international investment quizlet? ›

How do developing countries benefit from international​ investment? There will be an increase in economic growth.

What are two benefits of FDI to a home country? ›

There are many ways in which FDI benefits the recipient nation:
  • Increased Employment and Economic Growth. ...
  • Human Resource Development. ...
  • 3. Development of Backward Areas. ...
  • Provision of Finance & Technology. ...
  • Increase in Exports. ...
  • Exchange Rate Stability. ...
  • Stimulation of Economic Development. ...
  • Improved Capital Flow.
Jun 12, 2019

What are the 2 most known types of FDI? ›

FDI can take two different forms: Greenfield or mergers and acquisitions (M&As).
  • greenfield investment involves the creation of a new company or establishment of facilities abroad. ...
  • mergers and acquisitions amounts to transferring the ownership of existing assets to an owner abroad.

Is foreign direct investment bad? ›

Foreign direct investment is often seen as an economic blessing for developing nations. However, new research reveals that it stimulates resource depletion, while fostering dependency on the income generated from that depletion.

What are the three 3 motives for foreign direct investment? ›

According to this theory FDI are motivated by three advantages: Ownership advantages; Location advantages; Internalization advantages.

How does foreign direct investment affect the economy? ›

By acquiring a controlling interest in foreign assets, corporations can quickly acquire new products and technologies, as well as sell their existing products to new markets. And by encouraging foreign direct investment, governments can create jobs and improve economic growth.

What happens in foreign direct investment? ›

Foreign direct investment (FDI) is a category of cross-border investment in which an investor resident in one economy establishes a lasting interest in and a significant degree of influence over an enterprise resident in another economy.

What are the top 3 negative effects of globalization? ›

Increased greenhouse gas emissions, ocean acidification, deforestation (and other forms of habitat loss or destruction), climate change, and the introduction of invasive species all work to reduce biodiversity around the globe.

Do developing countries benefit or lose from globalization? ›

Globalization allows companies to find lower-cost ways to produce their products. It also increases global competition, which drives prices down and creates a larger variety of choices for consumers. Lowered costs help people in both developing and already-developed countries live better on less money.

Is globalization good or bad for developing countries? ›

Globalization helps developing countries to deal with rest of the world increase their economic growth, solving the poverty problems in their country. In the past, developing countries were not able to tap on the world economy due to trade barriers.

What are disadvantages of FDI? ›

  • Hindrance to Domestic Investment. As it focuses its resources elsewhere other than the investor's home country, foreign direct investment can sometimes hinder domestic investment. ...
  • Risk from Political Changes. ...
  • Negative Influence on Exchange Rates. ...
  • Higher Costs. ...
  • Economic Non-Viability. ...
  • Expropriation.

Why is FDI good for the US? ›

Increases U.S. Exports: U.S. companies use multinationals' distribution networks and knowledge about foreign tastes to export into new markets. Approximately 19 percent of all U.S. exports ($195 billion) come from U.S. subsidiaries of foreign companies.

What does foreign direct investment affect? ›

FDI can foster and maintain economic growth, in both the recipient country and the country making the investment. On one hand, developing countries have encouraged FDI as a means of financing the construction of new infrastructure and the creation of jobs for their local workers.

Which developing countries receive the most FDI? ›

Although the upward trend in 2021 was experienced across most subregions – South Asia was the only exception – just six countries attracted more than 80% of FDI inflows. China was the main recipient, followed by Hong Kong (China), Singapore, India, the United Arab Emirates and Indonesia.

What is the best example of foreign direct investment? ›

An example would be McDonald's investing in an Asian country to increase the number of stores in the region. Here, a business enters a foreign economy to strengthen a part of its supply chain without changing its business in any way.

Is USA good for FDI? ›

The United States is the top destination of inward foreign direct investment. Source: IMF Data, Coordinated Direct Investment Survey. Note: Chart shows inward FDI positions.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ray Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 5967

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ray Christiansen

Birthday: 1998-05-04

Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

Phone: +337636892828

Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.