Dividend Growth vs. High Yield: Advantages & Disadvantages (2024)

Dividend growth and high yield are well-liked approaches to investing in stocks that pay dividends. Companies that continuously raise their dividends over time are known as "dividend growth companies" because they give investors a steady source of cash. In contrast, high-yield stocks give more significant dividends, but they could be artificially inflated as a result of monetary issues or a drop in stock price. In this article, we will look at the advantages and disadvantages of each method and help you choose which one is ideal for your financial goals.

What Are Dividend Growth Stocks?

Dividend-growing corporations are often mature, well-established companies with a solid financial foundation and a long track record of profitability. Because of their consistent and reliable cash flow, they can pay dividends to shareholders and raise them over time.

Growth in dividends can be a sign of a company's financial health, soundness, and capacity for cash flow. Companies with growing dividends may be less risky than other investments since they have a history of doing so, which has the potential to boost stock prices.

Also, businesses with growing dividends may be suitable long-term investments because their dividends can add up over time and provide a source of income even when the market is down.

Dividend aristocrats are a perfect example of dividend growers. Companies in the Dividend Aristocrats group have a strong track record of steadily raising their dividend payments to shareholders. A company must have raised its dividends for at least 25 years in a row and be an S&P 500 index member to qualify as a dividend aristocrat.

Dividend blue chip companies are often big, well-established businesses with sound financial foundations. They are typically regarded as less risky investments since they have a history of profitability and the capacity to provide steady cash flow, which they employ to raise their dividends gradually.

Investing in Dividend Growth Stocks

Investors should have realistic expectations for dividend growth strategies because these assets aren't usually among the highest-yielding ones on the market. Investors looking for quick profits might not be happy with a dividend growth portfolio's yield.

So what is the appeal? Companies that are concentrated on increasing dividends typically have higher-quality, cash-rich operations that perform well in both up and down markets and can provide excess returns throughout a complete market cycle.

For income-focused investors, investing in dividend-growing firms can be a beneficial strategy because it offers the possibility of a consistent flow of dividends. Companies that raise their dividends are usually well-established, mature businesses with a solid financial base and a long history of success.

Companies that are increasing their dividends offer some protection from inflation in addition to being essential defensive holdings. The ability of investors to maintain purchasing power with their holdings depends on a rising dividend.

Additionally, dividend-growth stocks are likely less vulnerable to losses when interest rates are rising. For instance, as bond yields climb, high-yielding utility stocks, a less risky asset class, logically become a less desirable income source. However, dividend climbers were never the first pick for yield hounds in the first place because they typically have relatively moderate yields.

What Are High Dividend Yield Stocks?

High dividend-yielding stocks pay a higher dividend yield than the stock market in general or their industry sector. The dividend yield is calculated by dividing the annual dividend payment by the stock price. As a result, a stock with a high dividend yield will pay a greater proportion of its stock price in dividends than a firm with a lower yield.

The annual dividend payment is divided by the stock price to determine the dividend yield. For instance, a stock with a $1 dividend and a $50 stock price has a 2% yield.

Several sectors and businesses, including utilities, real estate investment trusts (REITs), and telecommunications, have high dividend-yielding equities. These industries typically have cash flows that are more steady and predictable, which enables them to distribute a larger dividend. These businesses typically have better-developed business models and depend less on expansion to produce returns.

It's crucial to remember that high dividend yields are only sometimes sustainable and could be artificially high due to falling stock prices or other monetary problems. Therefore, when searching for high-dividend-yielding companies, it's crucial to consider the firm's core fundamentals, such as earnings, cash flow, and debt.

Investing in High Dividend Yield Stocks

Unfortunately, the highest-yielding stocks are not usually the healthiest, with the most cash available to return to investors. Due to the possibility of money problems, picking only the stocks with the highest dividend yield can often lead to risky stocks that aren't little much compared to how much they pay out.

That's not to say investing in companies with higher dividend yields is a terrible idea. However, your investment criteria should take into account more than just the yield when investing in dividend payers. Focus on stocks of businesses that are financially stable enough to keep or even raise their dividends. This will help you figure out if a company can keep paying a high dividend yield.

Investors should look at high-dividend-yielding companies and take into account things like profitability, cash flow, and debt. Ensure that the business model is sustainable and that the company's underlying financial performance can support the dividends paid out. Also, it's essential to look at the company's dividend history since a company that has steadily raised dividends over time may do so again in the future.

The business sector and industry are other crucial factors to take into account. As was previously said, some industries, like utilities, real estate investment trusts (REITs), and telecoms, have more consistent and predictable cash flows, allowing them to pay bigger dividends. These businesses typically have better-developed business models and depend less on expansion to produce returns.

Pros of Dividend Growth Stocks

Regular Income

Companies that pay dividends offer owners a consistent source of income, which can be especially helpful for retirees or other people who depend on a constant income. For instance, if a corporation pays a $0.25 quarterly dividend and an investor holds 100 shares, they would each receive $25 as a dividend payment each quarter. Investors who need to augment their income can use this as a dependable source of income.

Financial Stability

Companies that pay dividends on a regular basis have a proven track record of financial stability and success. Dividends are traditionally only from profits, never from borrowing money or other sources. This implies that a business that pays dividends is making steady earnings and is in good financial standing.

Potential for Capital Appreciation

Companies that pay dividends may also have the potential for capital appreciation because their stock price may rise over time. The stability and growth potential of a firm are indicated by dividend payments, which draw investors and raise the value of the company's stock. Companies that provide dividends may also be less likely to repurchase stock shares, which can artificially boost stock prices.

Sign of the Company's Health

Since dividend payments are usually only made from profits and not from debt or other sources, they indicate a company's health. Companies that regularly pay dividends are making regular earnings and are in good financial shape. Investors may have more faith in the company's potential to make profits in the future.

Dividend Reinvestment Plans (DRIPs)

Shareholders can automatically reinvest their dividends into the acquisition of further shares through dividend reinvestment plans (DRIPs), which may compound returns over time. This means that dividends are used to purchase additional shares at the current market value rather than being paid out in cash. This could be a great way to move up in a company and make more money at the same time.

Cons of Dividend Growth Stocks

Limited Growth Potential

Companies that pay dividends could have limited room for growth as they prioritize returning earnings to shareholders above reinvesting in the company. For investors searching for businesses with solid growth potential, this may need to be solved.

Risk of Dividend Cuts

This is very rare for a dividend growth company with rich financials, but there's always the possibility of dividend cuts. In times of financial strain, companies may reduce their dividends, which could be detrimental to shareholders. Investors who depend on dividends as a source of income may find this to be concerning.

Diversification

Since you are placing a sizable amount of your money in one sector, investing in dividend-paying companies may limit portfolio diversification. This could be a worry for investors who want to spread their money across different industries and sectors.

Pros of High Dividend Yield Stocks

High Income

Companies that pay out a lot of dividends give their owners a steady stream of money, which can be very helpful for the elderly or other people who need a steady income. Companies with high dividend yields pay out a more significant portion of their stock price as dividends than those with low yields. For instance, a firm with a 5% dividend yield would pay $0.05 in dividends for every $1 in stock price, but a company with a 2% yield would pay $0.02 for every $1 in stock price.

More Focus on Dividends

Based on what has happened in the past, focusing on dividends may actually increase returns instead of decreasing them. For instance, since 1970, 84% of the total returns from the S&P 500 have come through dividends, according to analysts at Hartford Funds. This is based on the idea that shareholders are likely to put dividends back into the S&P 500. This increases their chances of getting more dividends in the future.

Potential for Capital Appreciation

Companies with high dividend yields also have the potential for capital gains because their stock price might rise over time. A company's dividend payments may be a sign of its stability and future growth, which may draw investors and raise the stock price. Businesses that pay out a lot of dividends may also be less likely to buy back their own stock, which could artificially raise the price of the company.

Cons of High Dividend Yield Stocks

Unrealized Capital Gains

Even though high dividend rates are attractive, they could hurt the company's chances of growing. It seems likely that every dollar a company gives its shareholders in the form of dividends is a dollar it doesn't put back into the business to help it grow and make more capital gains. Shareholders may still benefit from better returns even in the absence of dividends if the company's growth results in an increase in the stock value while they hold it.

Declining Stock Prices

When evaluating a stock's dividend yield, investors shouldn't just look at it. Dividend information may need to be updated or based on false information. As their stock is declining, many businesses have very high yields. The amount of the dividend may be decreased or eliminated if a company's stock declines sufficiently.

High Dividend Yields May Be A Red Flag

It can mean that the company is having financial difficulties or that the stock price of the company has plummeted dramatically. Because the dividend yield is so high, you should always research and look at the company's finances before investing. If a company with a high yield gets older or has trouble, the dividend payments could be cut or even stopped in the future.

Which Is Better? Growth or Yield

High dividend yield ETFs are likely to be preferred by older investors and retirees. The benefit of current high yields is that they give a substantial increase in income immediately rather than over the course of several years or decades.

However, healthy companies aren't usually the ones with the best-paying stocks. In truth, a stock's price may occasionally be low in comparison to dividend payouts due to financial difficulties, enhancing the perceived amount of its yield. As a result, choosing companies solely on the basis of dividend yield is insufficient; additional financial measures should be considered.

Younger investors who have the time to hold onto their investments will favor dividend-growth ETFs. Businesses with a history of raising dividends are often growing, financially stable, and in an excellent position to give back to shareholders.

However, dividend growth firms typically have lower yields, which is a drawback. A dividend growth stock may need several decades to outperform a high-yield company's dividend.

Bottom Line

In conclusion, depending on your specific financial objectives and risk tolerance, you should decide whether to invest in dividend yield or dividend growth firms. Companies that pay dividends and increase them constantly are healthy and provide a steady income stream with the possibility of capital expansion. Dividend yield firms, on the other hand, offer a higher income. However, they may have limited potential for growth and an increased risk of dividend reduction.

Dividend growth firms can be the better option for investors who want a stable source of income and are willing to give up some opportunity for capital growth. Dividend-yield businesses might be a better option for people who want a larger income and are willing to assume more risk.

Dividend Growth vs. High Yield: Advantages & Disadvantages (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Last Updated:

Views: 6169

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Saturnina Altenwerth DVM

Birthday: 1992-08-21

Address: Apt. 237 662 Haag Mills, East Verenaport, MO 57071-5493

Phone: +331850833384

Job: District Real-Estate Architect

Hobby: Skateboarding, Taxidermy, Air sports, Painting, Knife making, Letterboxing, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Saturnina Altenwerth DVM, I am a witty, perfect, combative, beautiful, determined, fancy, determined person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.