Disaster Manual: Section 3 - Falling Trees, Flying Limbs, and Related Noises (2024)

Q. 3-1 -- My neighbor’s tree fell into my yard during the disaster. It smashed my fence and took out my landscaping. Can I make my neighbor pay for the fence repairs and landscaping?

If the tree was healthy before the disaster and the storm’s high winds caused the tree to fall over and damage your property, you likely cannot hold your neighbor liable, as this damage qualifies as an “act of God.” However, if the tree was decayed, diseased, dead, or in an otherwise dangerous condition before the disaster, you may be able to hold your neighbor liable for damages, because your neighbor was negligent in maintaining the tree. If the tree posed an unreasonable risk of harm, your neighbor had a duty to trim the branches or remove the tree before the storm to prevent it from falling over. See Luther Transfer & Storage, Inc. v. Walton, 296 S.W.2d 750, 753–754 (Tex. 1957) (“It is established in our law that damages resulting from an act of God are not ordinarily chargeable to anyone. However, for a defendant to be relieved of liability for an unprecedented flood, there must be no negligence on his part concurring with the acts of God to cause the damage.”); Hutchings v. Anderson, 452 S.W.2d 10, 15 (Tex. App.—Dallas 1970, no writ).

Note that homeowners’ insurance generally covers this type of damage.

Q. 3-2 -- What if my neighbor’s tree hits my house?

Same as above. If the tree was healthy and it fell due to high winds during the disaster, your neighbor is likely not responsible. If the tree was in poor condition prior to the disaster, your neighbor probably should have had the tree removed or taken other reasonable measures prior to the storm. The dispute over who should cover this damage is likely one about home insurance—if your neighbor is not responsible, your insurance should cover you; if your neighbor is responsible, your neighbor’s insurance should cover you.

As a practical matter, it may be easier to claim on your insurance and let your insurance company pursue any claim that may exist against your neighbor.

Q. 3-3 -- No trees came down during the disaster, but I’m sick of picking up limbs out of my yard from my neighbor’s tree, and I’m worried about the next storm; that tree looks awful. What can I do?

You can cut limbs that grow onto your property, but you cannot kill the tree. The tree owner may be responsible for removing a dead or diseased tree prior to a storm, but you cannot take on that responsibility yourself. Rather, you should inform your neighbor of the dangerous condition of the tree and request that your neighbor address the problem. If your neighbor fails to do so and you end up with damage (as in the examples above), you will likely be able to recover damages from the tree owner.

Contact your local government. Certain city departments are responsible for cleaning up neighborhoods using building codes, sign codes, nuisance violations, and beautification projects. If the city determines that the tree is dangerous, it may issue a notice requiring removal.

Q. 3-4 -- Can I make my neighbor trim the tree branches that hang on to my property?

No. If the tree is healthy, you can trim branches that hang onto your property up to the boundary of your property line, but you cannot make your neighbor trim them. If you trim branches, you cannot kill thetree, and if the tree dies, your neighbor can attempt to recover damages from you for trespass. If the tree is dead, diseased, or dangerous, contact local government—if the city determines that the tree is dangerous, it may issue a notice requiring removal.

Q. 3-5 -- My neighbors are freaking out after the disaster and want to cut down all their trees. They provide the only shade in my yard. Can I stop my neighbors?

No. The trees belong to your neighbors, and thus are their property to do with as they wish, even if the trees provide shade to your yard or if the trees’ branches hang into your yard. However, if the tree is located right on the property line itself, you may have an ownership interest that would require your approval to remove the trees. Additionally, restrictive covenants or a tree ordinance pertaining to your subdivision that protects the trees if they are a certain size may apply. Check with your homeowner’s association for any applicable restrictive covenants and with your local government for any applicable ordinances.

Q. 3-6 -- My neighbors had a lot of trees fall on their property. They keep running a chainsaw long after I’ve put my kids to bed. Can I stop them?

Some cities have noise ordinances that may prevent sounds above a certain decibel level at different times. A typical chainsaw has a volume of around 100 adjusted decibels (dB(A)). Check with local government for noise requirements and time restrictions.

For example, the Houston Noise Ordinance (Section 30-5) limits noise to 65 dB(A) during daytime hours cand 58 dB(A) at night. Daytime hours are defined as between the hours of 8 a.m. and 10 p.m. Nighttime hours are defined as 10:01 p.m. to 7:59 a.m. the following day. Houston, Tex., Code of Ordinances, Ch. 30, §§ 30.1, 30.5(a)(1)(2017). But even that Ordinance has two exceptions. One exception is for “emergency pwork,” which is defined as “any work performed for the purpose of: (i) preventing or alleviating the physical trauma or property damage threatened or caused by an emergency, (ii) restoring property to a safe condition following a fire, accident, or natural disaster, (iii) protecting persons or property from exposure to danger, or (iv) restoring public utilities.” Houston, Tex., Code of Ordinances, Ch. 30, §§ 30-1, 30-16(3)(2017). While this exception is probably intended for the city and its contractors, it is not clear and your neighbor may successfully argue that emergency work is being performed in cutting the trees.

Another exception in that Houston ordinance exists for “the operation of any mechanically powered saw, drill, sander, router, grinder, lawn or garden tool, lawnmower, or any other similar device used between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 8:00 p.m., provided the device does not produce a sound exceeding 85 dB(A) when measured from the property line.” See Houston, Tex., Code of Ordinances, Ch. 30, § 30-16(7). The equipment must be used for the maintenance or upkeep of the property on which the equipment is being operated.

The analysis is likely the same if your neighbor is starting a new business selling firewood from all the downed trees brought to the property.

Q. 3-7 -- The fence between my property and my neighbor’s property is down. Who has to pay to replace it?

If a fence is located entirely on your neighbor’s property, the fence is considered to be the exclusive property of your neighbor. Consequently, unless you have entered into an enforceable agreement withyour neighbor or certain deed restrictions mandate that fences be erected and divide responsibilities among neighbors, you are not obligated to fix the fence on your neighbor’s property, nor can you compel your neighbors to fix their fence. On the other hand, if the fence is on your property, it is your responsibility to fix it, though your neighbor cannot compel you to replace the fence. If the fence was originally installed on your neighbor’s property but fell on to your property as a result of the storm, you can remove the fence from your property in the same way you can move trees and limbs from your property.

If the fence is on the boundary line between both properties, both property owners own the fence as long as both “use” it, unless an agreement indicates otherwise. Thus, you and your neighbor would share the cost of repairing and replacing the fence. Check local ordinances for the applicable definition of “use.”

Disaster Manual: Section 3 - Falling Trees, Flying Limbs, and Related Noises (2024)

FAQs

Who is responsible when a neighbor's tree falls in your yard Pennsylvania? ›

If your Neighbor's tree along your property line is a hazard

If all or any portion of a hazard tree falls on your property, and your neighbor was aware of or should have known that it was dangerous, your neighbor is responsible for any damage that you suffered, including your cost of removal.

Can I throw neighbors tree branches back in their yard in Texas? ›

A common question asked is: can I throw neighbors' tree branches back in their yard in Texas? You cannot trespass on a neighbor's property, and it could cause further dispute. Use a tree removal service that can take the trimmed branches away.

Who is liable when a tree falls on a neighbor's property in Texas? ›

When this happens, the neighbor whose yard the tree falls into is responsible for its cleanup and removal. Even if the tree was originally rooted in another neighbor's yard, the property owner of the place where it's fallen is ultimately responsible, and the neighbor whose yard the tree comes from isn't legally liable.

Who is liable when a tree falls on a neighbor's property in North Carolina? ›

The trees belong to your neighbors and thus are their property to do with as they wish. It does not matter if the trees are your shade or if the trees' branches go over into your yard. Although, if the tree is on the property line, you may have an ownership interest.

What two conditions must there be in order for a tree to be considered a risk? ›

Tree Risk Assessment

For a tree to be considered hazardous it must be defective either in some part or as a whole, with risk for failure and a target that is threatened.

What is the boundary tree law in PA? ›

A boundary line can may be marked by a tree. This boundary tree belongs to both neighbors equally, and neither can cut it down without the other neighbor's consent. The encroaching tree can be trimmed up to the boundary line.

Can I rake my neighbors leaves back into his yard? ›

As manners guru Emily Post puts it: "Falling leaves respect no property lines, and the ones that fall in your yard, even from a neighbor's tree, are all yours."

Can you cut tree limbs hanging over your property in Texas? ›

It is common for Texas residents to question whether they have a legal right to remove a neighbor's tree limbs that hang over their property. Texas law generally allows you to remove encroaching branches, so long as you do not harm the health of the tree.

Can I remove neighbors fence on my property in Texas? ›

Under this statute, a person may not remove a fence that is a separating or dividing fence in which the person is a joint owner or that is attached to a fence owned or controlled by another person, absent mutual agreement between the parties.

Who is responsible for neighbor's tree falling on my fence in Texas? ›

The trees belong to your neighbors, and thus are their property to do with as they wish, even if the trees provide shade to your yard or if the trees' branches hang into your yard.

Who pays for fence between neighbors in Texas? ›

A common dispute among neighbors is who owns, as well as who is responsible for maintaining the fence between their properties. Texas does not have a specific state law that addresses boundary line fences.

Do you need a permit to cut down a tree in Texas? ›

You will need a permit to cut down or impact a regulated tree. Step 1: Identify regulated trees on your property. Before beginning your project, make note of any trees on or near your worksite, and determine whether they are regulated. Protected and Heritage Trees are regulated on residential property.

Who is responsible for a leaning tree? ›

The legal line of property and anything vertically above that determines who is responsible for the tree. For example, if the tree is planted in your yard, but it leans over into your neighbor's, then your neighbor is responsible for the leaning portion.

What is the encroachment law in North Carolina? ›

North Carolina law allows people who trespass and encroach on other's land for a minimum 20 year time period to develop an ownership claim to the property.

What is the tree encroachment law in NC? ›

Tree Trimming Rules

A landowner is generally not liable for healthy tree limbs that fall on a neighbor's land due to a natural occurrence or Act of God. A neighbor is entitled to trim encroaching tree branches up to the property line.

What constitutes a hazard tree? ›

A "hazard tree" is a tree that has a structural defect that makes it likely to fail in whole or in part. Falling trees are an ever-present hazard when traveling or camping in the forest, yet too often we are unaware of the risks associated with defective trees. Trees are defective from age, fire and disease.

How do you tell if a tree is a hazard? ›

There are dead branches, particularly those greater than about 4” in diameter (these can do extensive damage when they fall) The tree has multiple deep cracks or splits in the bark, or a deep crack on a large branch. There are large, decayed areas on the trunk, branches, or root flare. The tree is leaning.

What is considered a danger tree? ›

Hazard/Danger Tree Definition

Tree hazards include dead or dying trees, dead parts of live trees, or unstable live trees (due to structural defects or other factors) that are within striking distance of people or property (a target).

Can a neighbor plant big trees next to the fence between our houses? ›

Hedges, trees, flowers. All these can be planted on property lines as long as an agreement is reached between the property owners about care, costs, and maintenance.

Can I cut my neighbors tree branches in PA? ›

With regard to self-help, an aggrieved landowner is entitled to trim the branches back to the property line, and this is true even if the overhanging branches do not damage the property.

How close to my property line can I put a fence? ›

How Close To The Property Line Can I Build? Fences are typically built between 2 and 8 inches from the line between properties. Some areas will allow the building of fences directly on the property line, but in this case, you'll have to cooperate with your neighbor and potentially share the cost of the fence.

Am I responsible for the leaves from my tree that fall in my neighbors yard? ›

Under the law, falling leaves are considered a natural product of trees and not something for which the owner of the tree can be held liable. Homeowners, whether they own the tree or simply live next to it, are responsible for the cleanup of natural debris that enters their yard, no matter the source.

Is it bad to dump a pile of leaves in my yard? ›

Instead of being used to improve soil and tree health, organic matter in landfills produces methane, a greenhouse gas. This harmful gas collects below the surface in landfills and is released into the air as landfill piles are bulldozed to make room for more waste.

What happens if you leave a pile of leaves in your yard? ›

Leaving the leaves alone is a good way to support native pollinators and other insects and wildlife. These valuable insects rely on the habitat fallen leaves provide, especially over the winter months. Dead leaves also decompose creating compost that can improve soil structure and fertility.

What is the law regarding trees over property line in Texas? ›

Trees forming the actual boundary line between properties can't be removed without the consent of both landowners. A landowner has the right to trim limbs or branches of boundary trees that reach onto his/her property so long as no damage to the other property owner.

How close to property line can I cut trees? ›

By law, you have the right to trim branches and limbs that extend past the property line. However, the law only allows tree trimming and tree cutting up to the property line. You may not go onto the neighbor's property or destroy the tree.

Can you cut down a live oak tree in Texas? ›

Georgetown, TX: In Georgetown, oaks including Live Oak, Post Oak, Shumard Oak, Bur Oak, Chinquapin Oak and Monterey Oak that have a DBH of more than 26 inches are called “Heritage Trees.” They can be pruned between July 1 and January 31, but you need a special permit first.

What can you do if your neighbor encroaches on your property in Texas? ›

Go to court. Show that the land is yours, that your neighbor had no right to use it, and that the court needs to order him or her to remove the encroaching structure. Sell the land to your neighbor.

What is the new fence law in Texas? ›

NEW TEXAS LAW FOR HOMEOWNERS AND HOA'S BEGINNING SEPTEMBER 1, 2022: Senate Bill 1588: Homeowners anywhere in Texas will be allowed to put up a perimeter fence around their property for added security (front, sides, and/or back of homeowner's property).

Can I build a fence right next to my neighbors fence? ›

As a rule, if a fence is not a boundary fence, it must be built at least two feet inside your property line. The best options for building near a neighbor's existing fence are placing the new one right up against the current one or leaving enough space between the fences for someone to mow.

What are the property boundary laws in Texas? ›

Texas has no specific laws regarding fences directly on the boundary line between neighbors, though your city or HOA might have more specific instructions. In general, if it's on your side of the property line, you own it. If it's directly on the property line, then you and your neighbor probably own it jointly.

Are cypress trees protected in Texas? ›

Protected Species:

Texas Ash, Bald Cypress, American Elm, Cedar Elm, Texas Madrone, Bigtooth Maple, ALL Oaks, Pecan, Arizona Walnut, and Eastern Black Walnut.

Do I need a permit to cut down a tree in San Antonio? ›

Under the Tree Preservation Ordinance, prior to any development of property, a tree permit must be obtained. Development activities that remove trees and disturb vegetation require a Tree Preservation Plan be submitted with the Tree Permit application.

Do you have to give your Neighbour the good side of the fence? ›

If you're the courteous type and enjoy getting along with your neighbours, it would be generous to show the smooth side of the fence towards them, but this is far from being an established convention and there's absolutely no obligation to do so if you don't want to.

How tall can a fence be in Texas? ›

Under Section E of City Code 25-2-899 you can build a "solid" fence up to 8 feet in height along a property line, the homeowner will be required to obtain written authorization from the adjacent property owners that are affected by the fence where the fence exceeds 6 feet in height.

Which side of the fence is my responsibility Texas? ›

The answer: Fence ownership is determined by where your fence lays on the property line. If your fence is right on the property line between your neighbor's property and your property, neither you nor your neighbor owns a side; it's a shared fence responsibility.

Can I throw neighbor's tree branches back in their yard Texas? ›

A common question asked is: can I throw neighbors' tree branches back in their yard in Texas? You cannot trespass on a neighbor's property, and it could cause further dispute. Use a tree removal service that can take the trimmed branches away.

How much does it cost to cut down a tree? ›

Average Tree Removal Price by Size of the Tree
Tree TypeAverage Mature Height*Total Cost to Remove
Medium tree (e.g., black spruce)30 feet to 50 feet$420–$700
Large tree (e.g., white oak)50 feet to 80 feet$700–$1,120
Very large tree (Douglas fir)More than 80 feet$1,120–$2,000
1 more row

Should leaning trees be cut down? ›

Leaning trees are more of a hazard than those growing vertically. A sudden lean indicates breakage or weakening of roots and the tree should probably be removed immediately. A tree leaning more than 15% from vertical probably should be removed.

Who holds up the branches of a tree? ›

Functions: A tree's trunk has two primary functions. The first job of a tree trunk is to give it its size and shape. It's the pillar of strength that provides the tree with the structural support for its branches and leaves to grow upward and outward.

Can you right a leaning tree? ›

In cases where a small tree leans only slightly, you might not need to do anything at all. For more significant leaning that could adversely affect the tree's growth, you can straighten it up and stake it in place to temporarily provide support until its root system becomes established.

What is an act of wrongful or illegal encroachment? ›

u•sur•pa•tion (yo̅o̅′sər pā′shən, -zər-), n. an act of usurping; wrongful or illegal encroachment, infringement, or seizure.

How do you deal with encroachment of a neighbor? ›

Below are three steps you can pursue when dealing with an encroachment issue.
  1. Talk With Your Neighbor.
  2. Sell Your Land, Or An Easem*nt On Your Land, To Your Neighbor.
  3. Take Your Neighbor To Court.
Feb 27, 2023

What is an encroachment or violation of a law? ›

Encroachments are situations in real estate when part of the property extends beyond its borders and onto another property. It can also be referred to as the violation of contractual property rights by illegally building or extending structures onto neighboring properties without approval.

Who owns a tree on a property line in NC? ›

If the tree is on a neighbor's property, then the neighbor is the owner of the tree and responsible for any branches that extend over the boundary line. The opposite is true if the tree is on the property owner's land. The property owner is then responsible for any branches that overhang the neighbor's property.

What trees are illegal to cut down in NC? ›

Size of the tree: Under the North Carolina tree removal rules, trees with a diameter of at least 6 inches or more measured at the height of 4.5 feet above the ground are protected under state law and cannot be removed without a permit.

How do I claim adverse possession in NC? ›

In North Carolina, to acquire title to land by adverse possession, the claimant must show actual, open, hostile, exclusive, and continuous possession of the land claimed for the prescriptive period under known and visible lines and boundaries.

Who owns a tree on the property line Pennsylvania? ›

The property owner who planted the tree owns it and has the sole right to remove it. Both parties own the tree and either can take it down. The owner of the property upon which a majority of the tree trunk is located owns it. Both parties own the tree, and neither can take it down without the permission of the other.

Can I cut down trees on my property in Pennsylvania? ›

If the tree is larger than 6-inches in diameter (measured at 4.5 feet above the ground) and is healthy or diseased, a permit must be obtained. Permission is not needed to remove a tree that has been deemed dead or a tree under 6-inches in diameter.

How close to a property line can you plant a tree? ›

It is also advisable to plant 15–20 feet away from the property to avoid any problems with the roots causing havoc with the foundations as the tree grows. These minimum distance regulations also protect the house from branches scratching at windows.

How do you know if a tree is dying? ›

8 Signs That Your Tree Is Dying
  1. There are broken sticks all over the ground around the tree. ...
  2. The bark is shedding off of the tree. ...
  3. Rot or fungus is visible on the tree. ...
  4. The tree is no longer standing up straight. ...
  5. Open wounds. ...
  6. No leaves or dead leaves. ...
  7. Termites and other pests. ...
  8. Root damage.
Jul 21, 2022

Does Pennsylvania have a nuisance law? ›

Public nuisances. Whoever erects, sets up, establishes, maintains, keeps or continues, or causes to be erected, set up, established, maintained, kept or continued, any public or common nuisance is guilty of a misdemeanor of the second degree.

How close can you put a fence to property line Pennsylvania? ›

All fences shall be set back at least twelve inches from all front yard property lines and/or sidewalks.

Do you need a license to cut trees in PA? ›

All persons shall first obtain a written permit before doing or having done any work for the care, pruning or trimming of any tree in or upon the public streets, highways, avenues, park, parkways and other public areas, and such work shall be done to the satisfaction of the Commission.

Who is liable when a tree falls on a neighbors property in Michigan? ›

If you, as the property owner, knew or should have known that the tree limb constituted a hazard, meaning the tree was dead and in danger of falling or losing a limb onto the adjacent property, and the limb caused damage – then you, the property owner will likely be liable for the damage.

Can I plant a tree next to my fence? ›

Along with choosing a type of tree that is appropriate for growing next to a fence, you'll also need to make sure your environment can support a tree. The soil next to your fence needs to be well-drained to avoid rot and root fungus, and the area should get plenty of sun so the tree can grow well.

How do you fence around a tree on a property line? ›

Build a box to either exclude or enclose the tree on the property line. Discuss this possibility with your neighbor if you wish to accept responsibility for the tree and the new fence bump out will encroach on your neighbor's property. Run the fence along the property line but allow the trees to interrupt the fence.

How tall can trees be under power lines? ›

When planting within 20 feet of an overhead power line, you should choose large shrubs or small trees that grow no more than 15 feet. Trees planted 20 to 50 feet from a power line should grow no more than 40 feet tall. And trees that grow more than 40 feet should be planted more than 50 feet from power lines.

Does cutting off dead branches help a tree? ›

Eliminating dead branches gives the tree a new chance to rejuvenate itself, directs the nutrients to healthy branches and makes it less vulnerable to pests and diseases.

What happens when a tree dies of old age? ›

When a tree dies naturally or falls due to extreme weather events, new life springs forward. Fungi communities flourish on dead wood, salamanders create breeding grounds, and saplings grow on the nutrient-rich bark. But this doesn't happen overnight.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Chrissy Homenick

Last Updated:

Views: 6481

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (74 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Chrissy Homenick

Birthday: 2001-10-22

Address: 611 Kuhn Oval, Feltonbury, NY 02783-3818

Phone: +96619177651654

Job: Mining Representative

Hobby: amateur radio, Sculling, Knife making, Gardening, Watching movies, Gunsmithing, Video gaming

Introduction: My name is Chrissy Homenick, I am a tender, funny, determined, tender, glorious, fancy, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.