Disadvantages of Foreign Direct Investment in India (2024)

Though there are a lot of benefits in a Foreign Direct Investments (FDI), there are still a lot of disadvantages which need attention.

Table of Contents

  • 1 Disadvantages of FDI
    • 1.1 Disappearance of cottage and small scale industries:
    • 1.2 Contribution to the pollution:
    • 1.3 Exchange crisis:
    • 1.4 Cultural erosion:
    • 1.5 Political corruption:
    • 1.6 Inflation in the Economy:
    • 1.7 Trade Deficit:
    • 1.8 World Bank and lMF Aid:
    • 1.9 Convertibility of Currency:

Disadvantages of FDI

Disappearance of cottage and small scale industries:

Some of the products produced in cottage and village industries and also under small scale industries had to disappear from the market due to the onslaught of the products coming from FDIs. Example: Multinational soft drinks.

Contribution to the pollution:

Foreign direct investments contribute to pollution problem in the country. The developed countries have shifted some of their pollution-borne industries to the developing countries. The major victim is automobile industries. Most of these are shifted to developing countries and thus they have escaped pollution.

Exchange crisis:

Foreign Direct Investments are one of the reason for exchange crisis at times. During the year 2000, the Southeast Asian countries experienced currency crisis because of the presence of FDls. With inflation contributed by them, exports have dwindled resulting in heavy fall in the value of domestic currency. As a result of this, the FDIs started withdrawing their capital leading to an exchange crisis. Thus, too much dependence on FDls will create exchange crisis.

Cultural erosion:

In all the countries where the FDls have made an inroad, there has been a cultural shock experienced by the local people, adopting a different culture alien to the country. The domestic culture either disappears or suffers a setback. This is felt in the family structure, social setup and erosion in the value system of the people. Importance given to human relations, hither to suffers a setback with the hi-fi style of living.

Political corruption:

In order to capture the foreign market, the FDIs have gone to the extent of even corrupting the high officials or the political bosses in various countries. Lockheed scandal of Japan is an example. In certain countries, the FDIs influence the political setup for achieving their personal gains. Most of the Latin American countries have experienced such a problem. Example: Drug trafficking, laundering of money, etc.

Inflation in the Economy:

The presence of FDIs has also contributed to the inflation in the country. They spend lot of money on advertisem*nt and on consumer promotion. This is done at the cost of the consumers and the price is increased. They also form cartels to control the market and exploit the consumer. The biggest world cartel, OPEC is an example of FDI exploiting the consumers.

Trade Deficit:

The introduction of TRIPs (Trade Related Intellectual Property Rights) and TRIMs (Trade Related Investment Measures) has restricted the production of certain products in other countries. For example, India cannot manufacture certain medicines without paying royalties to the country which has originally invented the medicine. The same thing applies to seeds which are used in agriculture. Thus, the developing countries are made to either import the products or produce them through FDIs at a higher cost. WTO (World Trade Organization) is in favor of FDIs.

World Bank and lMF Aid:

Some of the developing countries have criticized the World Bank and IMF (International Monetary Fund) in extending assistance. There is a discrimination shown by these international agencies. Only those countries which accommodate FDIs will receive more assistance from these international institutions.

Convertibility of Currency:

FDIs are insisting on total convertibility of currencies in under-developed countries as a prerequisite for investment. This may not be possible in many countries as there may not be sufficient foreign currency reserve to accommodate convertibility. In the absence of such a facility, it is dangerous to allow the FDIs as they may withdraw their investments the moment they find their investments unprofitable.

Disadvantages of Foreign Direct Investment in India (2024)

FAQs

Disadvantages of Foreign Direct Investment in India? ›

It can affect domestic investment, and domestic companies adversely. Small companies in a country may not be able to withstand the onslaught of MNCs in their sector. There is the risk of many domestic firms shutting shop as a result of increased FDI. FDI may also adversely affect the exchange rates of a country.

What are the disadvantages of foreign direct investment? ›

Disadvantages of FDI
  • hinder domestic investments and transfer control of domestic firms to foreign ones.
  • risk political changes, exposing countries to foreign political influence.
  • influence exchange rates.
  • Influence interest rates.
  • Overtake domestic industry if they cannot compete.

What are the negative effects of FDI in India? ›

It can affect domestic investment, and domestic companies adversely. Small companies in a country may not be able to withstand the onslaught of MNCs in their sector. There is the risk of many domestic firms shutting shop as a result of increased FDI. FDI may also adversely affect the exchange rates of a country.

Is foreign direct investment good or bad for India? ›

Foreign direct investment can enhance the economy of the country where it is produced, encouraging local firms while also improving the investor's environment. Emerging economies benefit from foreign direct investment.

What are the challenges faced in bringing FDI to India? ›

A restrictive FDI regime, high import tariffs, exit barriers for firms, stringent labour laws, poor quality infrastructure, centralized decision-making processes, and a very limited scale of export processing zones make India an unattractive investment location.

What is foreign direct investment What are the advantages and disadvantages? ›

Comparison Table for Advantages and Disadvantages of FDI
AdvantagesDisadvantages
FDI helps to boost the economy of a country.FDI can cause interference in domestic investments.
FDI aids in the expansion of human capital by subsistence of workforce.Sometimes, investments can result in negative values.
3 more rows
Mar 31, 2023

What is the impact of FDI on environment in India? ›

The effect could be negative, in the sense that increased FDI inflows could lead to increased environmental emissions. This is in line with the PHH that argues that “dirty” production could accompany foreign capital that is invested especially in developing countries.

What is the impact of FDI on India's economic development? ›

FDI India plays a major role in the economic development of India by being the main monetary source. We assist foreign companies invest directly into private Indian Business and act as bridge between Indian Entrepreneurs who are looking for foreign funds with the foreign investor that is the right fit.

How does FDI affect exchange rate in India? ›

However, we find no discernible link from FDI to RER and its volatility in the short run. Thus, the study concludes that depreciation in exchange rate level leads to increase in inflow of FDI, and an increase in FDI is due to decreases in exchange rate uncertainty in the short run.

Why is FDI less in India? ›

Foreign investment in India declined on the back of high inflation and weak demand in the US and Europe, while Indian companies also lowered investments in other countries during the financial year 2022-23.

Is FDI prohibited in India? ›

The present policy prohibits Foreign Direct Investments (FDI) in the following sectors: Gambling and Betting; Lottery business (including government/ private lottery, online lotteries etc); Activities /sectors which are not open to private sector investment (eg, atomic energy /railways);

Why is FDI high in India? ›

“The government has implemented an investor-friendly FDI policy under which FDI up to 100% is permitted through automatic route in most sectors,” it said adding India continues to open up its sectors to global investors by raising the investment limits, removing regulatory barriers, developing infrastructure, and ...

What is the FDI situation in India? ›

In terms of foreign equity inflows, as per government data, India received US$52.34 billion in 2022, marking an increase from the US$51.34 billion recorded in 2021 but falling short of the US$64.68 billion recorded in 2020. In FY 2023, India received equity inflows worth US$46.03 billion.

What is the FDI trend in India? ›

Despite the ongoing pandemic and global developments, India received the highest annual FDI inflows of USD 84,835 million in FY 21-22 overtaking last year's FDI by USD 2.87 billion. Earlier, FDI inflows increased from USD 74,391 million in FY 19-20 to USD 81,973 million in FY 20-21.

Why is foreign direct investment negative? ›

Negative values of FDI net outflows show that the value of direct investment made by domestic investors to external economies was less than the value of repatriated (disinvested) direct investment from external economies.

What affects foreign direct investment? ›

Foreign direct investment has an element of risk. Countries with an uncertain political situation, will be a major disincentive. Also, economic crisis can discourage investment. For example, the recent Russian economic crisis, combined with economic sanctions, will be a major factor to discourage foreign investment.

Is foreign direct investment good for the economy? ›

Foreign direct investment impacts the U.S. economy in many positive ways. For example, FDI: Creates New Jobs: U.S. affiliates of foreign companies (majority-owned) employ approximately 5.3 million U.S. workers, or 4.6% of private industry employment.

Which of the following is not a benefit of FDI? ›

Expert-Verified Answer

The FDI does not stimulate domestic enterprises.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Patricia Veum II

Last Updated:

Views: 6558

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Patricia Veum II

Birthday: 1994-12-16

Address: 2064 Little Summit, Goldieton, MS 97651-0862

Phone: +6873952696715

Job: Principal Officer

Hobby: Rafting, Cabaret, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Inline skating, Magic, Graffiti

Introduction: My name is Patricia Veum II, I am a vast, combative, smiling, famous, inexpensive, zealous, sparkling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.