Dear Sugar: When You Try to Be Ethical In Adoption, But You're Still Human (2024)

Dear Sugar: When You Try to Be Ethical In Adoption, But You're Still Human (1)

One of my most popular posts in recent months was on falling in love with a baby who wasn’t mine.Waiting for five months to find out if the little girl I wasslowing falling for would become my daughter or not was one of the hardestseasons of my life. And I certainlymade it much harder on myself---but willingly (and without regret). Why?Because we are an ethical family.

Let me explain.

When I was in grade school, we had a music teacher who wasvery hard to please. We had to preparefor two concerts a year: Christmas andspring. We would practice the songs shehad chosen over and over and over and over again. When we sang, she’d yell, “Sing louder! I cannot hear you!” When we obliged, she would then stop usabruptly, mid-song, and yell, “Stop screaming!”

This went on for years.Years.

We just didn’t know to strike a balance and make the womanhappy. It seemed like no matter what wedid, even when we were collectively attentive and obedient (or so we thought),we were met with disapproval and a scowl.We spent a lot of time just feeling terrified, so I’m certain that wasreflected in our performances.

Essentially, music, which is supposed to moving and magicaland joyful, just wasn’t what I thought it would be.

Each time we adopted, we had learned more and more and moreabout ethics. We learned to lead withour minds, not with our hearts, because as the Bible reminds us, the heart is deceitful above all. Adoption isemotionally draining by nature. It takesa toll on one’s heartstrings, and oftentimes, one’s heart pieces (since many ofus have had heart-shattering moments along the journey). We couldn’t count on our hearts, which leftus too vulnerable and too disillusioned.

Relying on one’s foundation, that of ethics, is truly theway to go. But when doing this, it meantshushing heart whispers and pushing down emotions. That’s not healthy really either,right? I mean, we’re still human!

It goes a little something like this!

Elation: We arematched!

Ethics: Mom has everyright to parent her baby. We will waitand see what happens. We will not getour hopes up. We will stay in ourlane. Respect mom’s space. It’s not our pregnancy. It’s hers.

Elation: Baby wasborn last night!

Ethics: Mom maychoose to parent. That is her decisionto make. We must give her space. We must not claim a baby who isn’t ours. We must not call the baby “our” baby. We must continue to stay in our lane.

Elation: TPR mighthappen today!

Ethics: TPR issomething that is both incredibly hard and sad.The thought of no TPR is also hard and sad. But the sadder/harder is a mom who places whor*ally doesn’t want to. So we still stayin our lane. We remain respectful.

Elation: Baby isours!

Ethics: Mom and babyare now separated, legally. Baby mayexperience feelings of sadness, rejection, loss. Mom may, too.We are trying to bond with our new baby while remaining respectful tomom and keeping our promises.

Do you see it? Tooloud! Too quiet! Too sad!Too happy! Too far away! Too close!Too serious! Too joyful!

It’s hard to find a balance that satisfies both the heartand the mind. The emotions and theethics.

It is very easy to become overwhelmed during a match, duringa birth, post-placement (if the placement happens). You feel like you are the tennis ball in avery strange match, bouncing between two extremes, and expected, despite thatwild game, to always do the right thing, have the correct reaction, and remainsane.

If you have been in this place, or you are in this placenow, know that this is normal. Is itenjoyable to have such a grounding in ethics that you are in a state of walkingthe tight rope for fear of losing balance?No. It is not. It is hard.It is difficult. It is challenging. It is confusing. It is frustrating. It is exhausting.

I implore you to keep going.And when it feels like too much (and it often will), here are somethings you can do:

1: Take it one stepat a time. I know this sounds cliché,but sometimes the future is too big and unknown and unpredictable for you tomake big plans. What is the nextdecision? Take that on. Then go to the next, and the next, and thenext.

2: Take a break. It’s hard to take a step back when you’re inthe midst of trying to stay balanced.But moving positions (taking that step back) gives you freshperspectives, rejuvenation, and space to breathe and just be. Remember that Bible verse where we’recommanded to “be still” and know our place?

3: Take onchange. Remaining stagnant IS adecision, and it does have consequences.You can either create the change or be part of demanded change. As a type A control freak, I want to be thechange. The initiator. The decider.

4: Take theopportunity to experience the joy that comes with change. Whether there’s a change in your opennesswith your child’s birth family, a change in your openness to adoptionsituations, or change in the way you educate yourself on adoption, there is joyto be had. It’s there waiting to bediscovered. So many of us fear change,seeing it as our enemy, when really, change offers gifts that only come withembracing rather than shutting out.Change is inevitable anyway, so why not go forth in joy?

There is no guidebook on how to strike a perfectbalance. Each adoption is sodifferent. Each person isdifferent. You can remain forevercommitted to ethics in adoption and still have a heart.

Wherever you are today, you will not betomorrow, because being ethics is an upward journey of empathy, humility, andstrength. And at the very heart ofeverything is a precious child, one who is relying on the adults in thesituation to make the best choices possible.


You can do this. Youhave done this. Just sing a littlelouder, or a little quieter, whatever is best.

Dear Sugar:  When You Try to Be Ethical In Adoption, But You're Still Human (2024)

FAQs

What is the metaphor of the ghost ship? ›

No matter what choices we make in life, we are destined to have a ghost ship. We need not regret our decisions or lament having to make them. Our alternative lives continue on without us, floating adrift in an infinite sea.

What is the quote about sister ships? ›

We'll only know that whatever that sister life was, it was important and beautiful and not ours. It was the ghost ship that didn't carry us. There's nothing to do but salute it from the shore." —Cheryl Strayed.

Is Dear Sugar still going? ›

It's been about eight years since Strayed regularly wrote under the pseudonym Sugar, but she's now brought the column back as a monthly newsletter.

Is the Flying Dutchman a real thing? ›

According to maritime legend, the Flying Dutchman can never be anchored, and anyone who sees the ship is doomed to sail the seven seas for eternity. Although the Flying Dutchman never existed, the story of the cursed ship became a legendary symbol of calamity for sailors.

How scary is ghost ship? ›

Parents need to know that this movie is extremely violent. There are numerous scenes of passengers being shot and killed. Members of the salvage crew are picked off one by one. Scary ghosts, including a ghost-girl named Katie, permeate the film.

What is the famous line of the three sisters? ›

The Three Sisters famously said, "Life's too short to be anything but happy," and this quote embodies the essence of living life to the fullest.

What's Titanic's sister ship? ›

Olympic, British luxury liner that was a sister ship of the Titanic and the Britannic. It was in service from 1911 to 1935. To compete with the Cunard Line for the highly profitable transatlantic passenger trade, the White Star Line decided to create a class of liners noted more for comfort than speed.

Is Dear Sugar Based on a true story? ›

And although the series is generally fictional, it does closely mirror Strayed's own life and experiences, many of which were captured in the advice columns that Cheryl Strayed wrote anonymously under the name Sugar. From the start, Strayed tells us, she knew that Clare, aka Sugar, had to have her past.

Is Dear Sugar a real column? ›

Dear Sugar—the once-anonymous online columnist at The Rumpus, revealed in 2012 as Cheryl Strayed, author of the bestselling memoir Wild—is the person thousands turned to for advice about writing, relationships, and so much more.

Who is sugar from Dear Sugar? ›

Sugar—the once-anonymous online columnist at The Rumpus, now revealed as Cheryl Strayed, author of the bestselling memoir Wild—is the person thousands turn to for advice. Tiny Beautiful Things brings the best of Dear Sugar in one place and includes never-before-published columns and a new introduction by Steve Almond.

What is the metaphor of the ship? ›

The ship metaphor is a positive psychological approach to living life that involves understanding different aspects of the ship and how they relate to our lives. Each of these aspects is critical to living a fulfilling life, and ignoring any of them can result in negativity.

What is a metaphor for the Titanic? ›

It's a metaphor for disaster, for hubris, for bigness, for unpreparedness.

What is the metaphor of the ship in the poem? ›

The central metaphor used in the poem is that of a ship, which symbolizes the nation and the journey that Lincoln led it through during a tumultuous period of American history. The ship in the poem represents the nation, which has just emerged from a long and bloody civil war.

What is the ship in the poem a metaphor for? ›

' The ship is a metaphor for the United States, which has been battered with heavy loss of life and property during the Civil War. Despite the difficulties, the ship is ultimately 'anchor'd safe and sound. ' The United States have stayed together, and having passed through the war, are safe again.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 5817

Rating: 5 / 5 (60 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-03-23

Address: 74183 Thomas Course, Port Micheal, OK 55446-1529

Phone: +13408645881558

Job: Global Representative

Hobby: Sailing, Vehicle restoration, Rowing, Ghost hunting, Scrapbooking, Rugby, Board sports

Introduction: My name is Geoffrey Lueilwitz, I am a zealous, encouraging, sparkling, enchanting, graceful, faithful, nice person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.