Crowdfunding Platforms - Kickstarter vs GoFundMe vs Indiegogo (2024)

The world is changing. That means you have more and better options when it comes to funding your small business. Crowdfunding continues to grow each year, putting the opportunity to fund businesses we’re passionate about into everyone’s hands.

It’s a great option for many small businesses, but there are so many platforms out there. How do you know which one to choose?

We’ve compared three of the biggest crowdfunding platforms to help you pick the right option for you and your business:

  • Kickstarter: a platform that focuses on creative projects like art, music, film, etc. Funding is all or nothing and fees are fairly reasonable.
  • GoFundMe: a crowdfunding platform designed for individuals and personal causes. No all or nothing requirement and reasonable fees
  • Indiegogo: a unique platform that accommodates many, diverse campaigns. No all or nothing requirement, but fees can be higher.

When comparing each platform, it's essential to keep your industry in mind, in addition to what sort of plan to receive funds you're comfortable with. We explain more below.

Plans and Pricing

Kickstarter is a crowdfunding platform that’s heavily focused on catering to creative projects like art, music, film, technology, etc. The site boasts higher pledges to date than every other major crowdfunding platform combined. While it’s hard to argue with that kind of success, only about 65% of projects on Kickstarter get fully funded within the campaign timeline.

Funding on Kickstarter is all or nothing. That means if you don’t reach your funding goal within the designated timeline, you won’t receive any of the funds that were pledged to your project. Kickstarter views this as a benefit – oftentimes backers still expect full results on a project even if it isn’t fully funded. All or nothing funding alleviates the pressure and unrealistic expectations this sets upon the project creators. There are also no fees if your campaign is unsuccessful.

GoFundMe’s crowdfunding platform is super welcoming to individuals and personal causes. Campaigns to fund life events like education, medical treatment, and sports teams are prevalent on the site. The platform itself doesn’t have the independent community that some other crowdfunding sites have, but campaigns are extremely shareable, which can make up for the lack of community.

Funding on GoFundMe is not all or nothing. That means you keep whatever money you raise regardless of whether or not you reach your designated funding goal. Unlike some other crowdfunding sites, fees are the same whether you get fully or partially funded. Keep in mind that this may lead to donors expecting 100% results even if you get less than 100% funded.

Indiegogo is a crowdfunding platform that doesn’t specialize in any type of campaign. All kinds of projects are accepted for fundraising on the site. That means the regulations about who’s on the site are very lax, which can be good or it can mean lots of competition for the attention of donors. Campaigns on Indiegogo have a lower average funds raised than some other crowdfunding sites, but its diverse base is a huge plus.

Indiegogo is unique in that you, the campaign owner, can choose whether or not to go with all or nothing funding. With two plans (Flexible and Fixed), users can decide how this works. However, if you elect to go with the Flexible Funding plan (keep whatever you raise), you’ll be paying fees regardless of whether you reach your goal or not.

Crowdfunding Platforms - Kickstarter vs GoFundMe vs Indiegogo (1) Crowdfunding Platforms - Kickstarter vs GoFundMe vs Indiegogo (2) Crowdfunding Platforms - Kickstarter vs GoFundMe vs Indiegogo (3)
All or nothing? Yes Yes & No No
Costs
  • 5% fee from funding total if campaign is successful
  • 3-5% processing free from each pledge
  • Free to create and share campaign
  • 5% fee from each donation
  • 3% processing fee from each donation (USA & Canada)
  • No set-up fees
  • 5% overall platform fee
  • 3% plus 30¢ per credit card transaction
  • 3-5% for PayPal transactions
Best for Creative projects like art, music, film, technology, etc. Personal causes and life-events (e.g. education, medical treatment, sports teams, etc.) Campaigns across a wide variety of industries with lower funding goals

Reviews

If you’re an artist, writer, designer, or performer, Kickstarter is a great option to crowdfund your project. Whether or not you choose the site will depend on how you feel about all or nothing funding. It’s a big factor, but Kickstarter is also a huge platform for your campaign and carries a high likelihood of success. If you’re confident in your pitch and believe your creative project will speak to people, Kickstarter may be for you.

GoFundMe is great for personal causes and life events. However, because there’s no existing community on the site, it’s likely that donors will only be your friends, family, and personal network. Depending on how much money you’re looking to raise – and how confident you are in marketing your campaign – GoFundMe is a perfectly adequate option for fundraising your campaign.

Indiegogo is a good option if your project doesn’t fall into the specific categories that other crowdfunding sites cater to. Without the high traffic and brand recognition of a big name platform, you’re likely to raise less money on Indiegogo, so if your funding goals are relatively low, it may be for you. The site is also great for nonprofits because of the flexibility with tax-deductible campaigns.

All three platforms allow you to raise money without taking on debt or giving up equity. There's also a social aspect of fundraising which can help you gauge market interest if successful. You will, however, have to pay taxes on any funds you receive on any of the platforms.

Crowdfunding Platforms - Kickstarter vs GoFundMe vs Indiegogo (4) Crowdfunding Platforms - Kickstarter vs GoFundMe vs Indiegogo (5) Crowdfunding Platforms - Kickstarter vs GoFundMe vs Indiegogo (6)
Pros
  • Pledges to date are more than every other crowdfunding site combined
  • Backers on the site are looking for creative projects
  • Offer resources to help you build the best project
  • No deadlines or goal limits
  • 5-minute support guarantee
  • Optimized for sharing
  • Personal causes are encouraged
  • Flexibility for tax-deductible funds
  • Data driven insights help you run the most effective campaign
  • More liberal project regulations
  • No all or nothing requirement
Cons
  • Fees up to 8-10% if project is successful
  • All or nothing funding
  • Difficult to integrate with offline efforts
  • Relatively short campaign time
  • Fess of up to 8% on each donation
  • Facebook account req’d
  • Inconsistent customer support
  • Mixed reviews from users
  • Fees up to 8-10% of total funds
  • Less traffic and brand recognition
  • Lower average raised funds
  • Questionable reputation
App Yes (for backers) Yes Yes
Customer service
  • Help Center
  • Help Center
  • Email submission form
  • 5 minute support guarantee
  • Help Center
  • Email submission form
  • Response within 24 hours

What are customers saying?

“I liked showing the world our product and am glad that we are funded. I would recommend Kickstarter to anyone who is wanting to launch a product, but stress the importance of preparation.”

“I tried using another crowdfunding site a few years ago and it was a total loss. I found this site to be easy to use, and fairly successful. It is up to the person trying to raise money for a cause to make it work.”

“Indiegogo can work well, if you aggressively solicit your friends and social network for money.”

More Options:

RocketHub

  • Simple educational resources to help you along the way
  • Opportunity for a TV spot on A&E
  • 4% commission free plus 4% credit card handling fee (if you reach your goals)

Razoo

  • Nonprofit and charity focused
  • Allows you to collaborate and fundraise as a team
  • 4.9% platform fee and 2% + 30¢ payment fee

Fundify

  • Focused on startups
  • Get connected with an industry veteran to help you succeed
  • No fees for the startup or the investor
Crowdfunding Platforms - Kickstarter vs GoFundMe vs Indiegogo (2024)

FAQs

Is Indiegogo better than Kickstarter? ›

Established to provide more opportunities to backers than Kickstarter, Indiegogo is usually perceived as a less strict and more flexible platform. It is available in over 230 countries and provides more categories (28 in Indiegogo vs Kickstarter 15).

Which is better Kickstarter or GoFundMe? ›

When you compare GoFundMe vs Kickstarter in terms of fees, GoFundMe charges 5% for each donation and a 3% processing fee for each donation in both USA and Canada. Kickstarter charges a 5% fee of the total funds raised, plus a 3-5% payment processing fee from each pledge.

What percentage of Indiegogo campaigns succeed? ›

If you have a good product and know what you're doing, you are set up for success. Indiegogo, on the other hand, has around a 9% success rate.

Can you do both Indiegogo and Kickstarter? ›

It can be done. So, the short answer is yes, you can launch a crowdfunding campaign on both Kickstarter and Indiegogo.

What is the disadvantage of Indiegogo? ›

Indiegogo is another popular crowdfunding platform, but it operates on a different model than Kickstarter. With Indiegogo, you can keep the money that you raise even if you don't reach your goal. The downside of this is that you might not raise as much money as you would on Kickstarter.

What percentage of kickstarters are successful? ›

Over $5.8 billion has been pledged to Kickstarter projects, with a success rate of around 39%. The category with the highest success rate is dance, at 62.1%, and as of February 2021 there have been over 204,000 successfully funded projects on the platform.

What is the most successful crowdfunding campaign? ›

10–50 million
RankProjectCategory
1The David MovieMovie
2Surprise! Four Secret Novels by Brandon SandersonPublishing
3Basic Attention TokenBlockchain
4Polybius BankBlockchain bank
27 more rows

Is there a better option than GoFundMe? ›

DonateKindly is a free year-round giving alternative to GoFundMe. This customizable donation form can be embedded directly into your nonprofit's website with little effort to start raising funds quickly. It's known for being user-friendly for your staff and donors alike.

What happens if Kickstarter doesn't get funded? ›

In summary, if a Kickstarter marketing project fails then:

The pledges stay with its backers. Refunds are returned automatically back to backers' debit/credit cards.

What happens if Indiegogo fails? ›

With a fixed funding campaign, you only keep the funds you raise if you meet your funding goal. If your campaign does not meet its goal by its deadline, all your backers will be refunded by Indiegogo within 5-7 business days.

Can you get your money back from Indiegogo? ›

You can request a refund directly from your confirmation email or from your Indiegogo account.

How long can an Indiegogo campaign last? ›

If you're using Indiegogo, the standards for maximum and minimum are the same as Kickstarter. Campaigns can be as short as a day and, while Indiegogo allows for a one time extension, the maximum length of their campaigns is 60 days.

Do people still use Kickstarter? ›

Kickstarter is considered the OG of crowdfunding platforms launching in 2009. It is still one of the most used and visited crowdfunding platforms in the world today. Businesses get the funding they need for their ideas.

Can you make money by backing Kickstarter? ›

Project creators keep 100% ownership of their work, and Kickstarter cannot be used to offer equity, financial returns, or to solicit loans.

Can you overfund a Kickstarter? ›

Any funds raised beyond the goal will help the creator to cover any manufacturing or shipping costs related to their add-ons. In other cases, overfunding leads to better margins and the creator may even profit from the project.

How long does it take to get money from Indiegogo? ›

Indiegogo will send a disbursem*nt to your bank account within 15 business days after your campaign ends, provided your bank account information is correct and accurate.

Do you have to pay taxes on Indiegogo? ›

That's because any funds raised on websites such as Kickstarter, Indiegogo and GoFundMe are considered taxable income. Creators can, however, write off supplies they use to make products to offset costs.

What are the main drawback of crowdfunding? ›

Compare crowdfunding pros and cons
Pros of crowdfundingCons of crowdfunding
Funds often come from many investorsFees can be steep
Build a customer base earlyYour business idea may get swiped
Likely no credit checkTime requirements may be significant
Possible feedback channelYou may not have as much guidance
5 more rows
6 days ago

What is the most highly funded Kickstarter? ›

The Pebble Time is the most funded Kickstarter ever, even though the campaign was launched in 2015.

What is the most successful Kickstarter company? ›

In March 2015, Pebble's second smartwatch project completed its crowdfunding and publicity run with 20.34 billion dollars raised in Kickstarter pre-order funding, becoming the most successful Kickstarter project as of July 2021. In 2022, however, the crowdfunding project Surprise!

What is the average Kickstarter donation? ›

A wee reality check: The most common donation on Kickstarter is $25. Since launching on April 28, 2009, Kickstarter has seen almost 2.5 million pledges of $25. The next most common donation size is $50, with the crowdfunding platform clocking 1.6 million of those.

What month is best for crowdfunding campaign? ›

Success rates (on average) are significantly lower if you end your campaign during the months of August, September or December and significantly higher if you end your project during the months of February, March and May. Again, further analysis is needed to determine how the holiday seasons effect success rates.

Who has funded Indiegogo the most? ›

$24M in Two Campaigns: MATE Raises More Money Than Any Other Team in Indiegogo History. The team behind MATE eBikes shattered records by raising over $24 million with their campaigns for MATE and MATE X.

What is the biggest challenge with crowdfunding? ›

One of the challenges every entrepreneur faces when it comes to raising capital via crowdfunding is figuring out how much money they should raise. While you might think this is just a simple matter of deciding how much money you need to invest in your startup, other things also come into play.

What is the fastest way to make money on GoFundMe? ›

10 Fast Fundraising Ideas to Boost Donations
  1. Fast fundraising is easy with these tips.
  2. Focus on the 'why' ...
  3. List your individual expenses. ...
  4. Reach out to your inner circle first. ...
  5. Add special dates within the fundraiser. ...
  6. Reach out to different types of donors. ...
  7. Get creative with how you share your fundraiser.

Do you get 100% of GoFundMe? ›

How much does GoFundMe charge for the transaction fee? GoFundMe charges one transaction fee—that's it. So, what percentage does GoFundMe take for transaction fees? A transaction fee of 2.9% +$0.30 is automatically deducted from each donation, so you never have to worry about paying a bill.

Why do most Kickstarter fail? ›

Here are some of the top reasons why Kickstarter projects fail: Bad pricing plan (e.g., the product is being sold too cheap and is expensive to produce). Components of the final product are bad quality. Creators of the project don't have the required experience or understanding.

Do I have to pay taxes on Kickstarter donations? ›

Funds raised on Kickstarter are generally subject to taxes. How much you owe can vary based on a number of factors, including the deduction of project-related expenses. We highly recommend talking to an accountant or tax advisor.

Can you sue a failed Kickstarter? ›

Yes, you may be able to sue the creator of a Kickstarter product. If you are a backer of a project who doesn't get their reward, you may be able to sue for breach of contract, fraud, or for violation of a state consumer protection statute.

How often do Indiegogo campaigns fail? ›

How much easier does it get? The flip side is that for every successful Kickstarter campaign, two fail and in the case of Indiegogo it gets worse: About 9 out of 10 Indiegogo campaigns fail to reach their goal.

How many borrowers has Indiegogo lent to? ›

Today, our group of backers is more than 9 million strong, representing 235 countries and territories.

What is the minimum amount for Indiegogo? ›

Please note that the minimum goal amount for a campaign, regardless of whether you choose fixed or flexible funding, is 500 (USD/CAD/GBR/EUR/AUD). It's also important to keep in mind Indiegogo's fees, as well as our Reserved Funds feature when deciding on your goal.

Can Indiegogo be trusted? ›

Indiegogo is a platform to enable fraud, one of the greatest consumer threats in our modern world. Their corporate policy on fraud is improving but is still highly irresponsible.

Do you have to return money in crowdfunding? ›

To safeguard investors, crowdfunding platforms usually hold onto the money (in a separate dedicated bank account) until the funding target is reached. This means that investors should get their money back if the venture has to be called off due to insufficient funds.

What day of the week is best to launch Indiegogo? ›

We find that successful campaigns launch on a Monday or Tuesday as backers are more engaged with their email early in the week. Launching at the start of the week helps campaigns gain momentum in the following days. To increase your odds of success, consider a soft launch.

How much does it cost to start an Indiegogo campaign? ›

Indiegogo charges a five percent (5%) platform fee on all funds raised for your campaign. Fees are calculated and deducted from the funds you actually raise (not the goal you set). Our payment processor also charges a processing fee that varies according to your location and currency.

How long can you run a Kickstarter for? ›

Projects on Kickstarter can last anywhere from 1 day, to a maximum of 60 days. We've done some research, and found that projects lasting any longer than 60 days are rarely successful. When planning your project, we recommend setting it to run for 30 days or less.

What is the failure rate of Kickstarter? ›

Kickstarter campaigns have a success rate of around 36%, so not reaching your funding goal is a realistic outcome.

Why is a Kickstarter suspended? ›

Why would a project be suspended? A project may be suspended if our Trust & Safety team uncovers evidence that it is in violation of Kickstarter's rules, including but not limited to: Misrepresentation of support, through self-pledging or artificial inflation of the number of backers or amounts pledged.

Why Kickstarter is better? ›

Flexible funding means if you do not hit your campaign goal within the campaign duration, you do keep the money and the backers are charged. The platform also takes its fee. Kickstarter only offers the Fixed Funding model which is why it's known as the “all-or-nothing platform.”

Do backers pay sales tax on Kickstarter? ›

Sales tax may also be applicable in certain cases depending on the local rules. A creator may have an obligation to register, collect, and remit sales taxes in the states in which the backers are located, depending on the dollar amount received and the number of transactions entered into with backers in each state.

Can you make a living on Kickstarter? ›

These gatekeepers could be record labels, publishers, studios, investors, and others. Now, you can decide to pick yourself. Kickstarter won't make you rich, but it gives you the an affordable ticket to the creative world, where artists, designers, and entrepreneurs are able to make a living off their creations.

What happens if a Kickstarter doesn't deliver? ›

If you can't deliver your Kickstarter project, do you have to pay the money back? You need to know the legal contract you agree to when you start a Kickstarter campaign. If you are unable to complete your project, then yes: you will need to refund your backers if you can't deliver your Kickstarter project.

What is the minimum amount you can borrow on Kickstarter? ›

US-based projects: $1.

What happens after Kickstarter ends? ›

After the 14 days have passed, a payout will be initiated. Please note, the payout will begin initiating at the time your campaign ended 14 days prior. For example, if your campaign ended at 6:00 PM EST on January 1, the payout will initiate at 6:00 PM EST on January 15.

What happens when Kickstarter ends? ›

Kickstarter is an all or nothing platform, which means a project must end at or above its funding goal in order to be successful. If a project does not successfully reach its goal, the creator will not receive any funds, and no backers will be charged for their pledges.

What is the advantage of Indiegogo? ›

Another benefit of Indiegogo is that it allows for flexible funding, as opposed to the all-or-nothing funding model used by platforms like Kickstarter. If you opt into flexible funding, you can still keep the funds you've raised even if you fall short of your goal.

What happens if an Indiegogo project fails? ›

With a fixed funding campaign, you only keep the funds you raise if you meet your funding goal. If your campaign does not meet its goal by its deadline, all your backers will be refunded by Indiegogo within 5-7 business days.

What is the number 1 backed Kickstarter? ›

The Pebble Time is the most funded Kickstarter ever, even though the campaign was launched in 2015. At the time, there seemed to be a massive demand for smartwatches. However, a couple of years later, they struggled with a diminishing demand and poor sales.

What percentage of fees does Indiegogo take? ›

Entrepreneur-friendly pricing

Affordable, easy, and secure. **If you are in our InDemand program and ran your campaign on Indiegogo, your platform fee remains 5%. If you ran your first campaign on another platform before joining our InDemand program, your platform fee is 8%.

What percentage does Indiegogo take? ›

Platform fees in InDemand are 5% if you ran your funding campaign on Indiegogo. The InDemand fee for campaigns that did not originally run on Indiegogo is an 8% platform fee, with a 15% (total) fee on any funds driven by Indiegogo's platform channels. Third party payment processing fees also apply.

Do Crowdfunders get their money back? ›

Loan-based crowdfunding

To safeguard investors, crowdfunding platforms usually hold onto the money (in a separate dedicated bank account) until the funding target is reached. This means that investors should get their money back if the venture has to be called off due to insufficient funds.

What is the lawsuit against Indiegogo? ›

The lawsuit claims that the creator, Doug Monahan, didn't use his raised Indiegogo or Kickstarter funds to develop or deliver the backpack, but instead, he put the cash toward “various personal expenses,” including the purchase of bitcoin, ATM withdrawals, and to pay off credit cards.

What is the most successful Kickstarter project? ›

1) Pebble Time – $20,338,986

According to Business Insider, this updated version of Pebble's smartwatch launched in 2015 and still holds the record for most funded Kickstarter campaign of all time.

What is the best and worst month to launch Kickstarter? ›

Kickstarter Success Rates Based Upon Month Launched

Success rates (on average) are significantly lower if you launch your campaign during the months of July or August and significantly higher if you launch your project during the months of January, February or April.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dong Thiel

Last Updated:

Views: 5845

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dong Thiel

Birthday: 2001-07-14

Address: 2865 Kasha Unions, West Corrinne, AK 05708-1071

Phone: +3512198379449

Job: Design Planner

Hobby: Graffiti, Foreign language learning, Gambling, Metalworking, Rowing, Sculling, Sewing

Introduction: My name is Dong Thiel, I am a brainy, happy, tasty, lively, splendid, talented, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.