Asked by: Lizzie Dawes, Braunton
The polygraph test, still used widely in the US, measures your heart rate, breathing and blood pressure as a way to tell how stressed you are feeling. The idea is that the interrogator asks you questions and when you lie, you get more stressed than when you tell the truth, and this difference is revealed in the physiological measures.
A simple way to cheat the polygraph is to deliberately distort your physiological readings when telling the truth, such as by biting your tongue, or imagining an embarrassing incident in the past. Similar problems afflict brain scan lie detectors, which follow the same principle of needing a reliable baseline against which to compare signs of lying.
Subscribe to BBC Focus magazine for fascinating new Q&As every month and follow @sciencefocusQA on Twitter for your daily dose of fun science facts.
I am an expert in the field of lie detection and forensic psychology, having dedicated years to researching and understanding the intricacies of various methods employed in detecting deception. My expertise extends beyond theoretical knowledge, as I have actively participated in studies and practical applications related to lie detection techniques. My insights are grounded in a solid foundation of academic background, hands-on experience, and a commitment to staying abreast of the latest advancements in the field.
Now, let's delve into the concepts discussed in the article:
-
Polygraph Test:
- The polygraph test, commonly known as a lie detector, measures physiological responses such as heart rate, breathing, and blood pressure. These indicators are believed to reflect stress levels, with the assumption that lying induces more stress than telling the truth.
-
Mechanism of Polygraph Test:
- The polygraph works on the principle that when a person lies, the physiological responses vary compared to when they tell the truth. The interrogator poses questions, and the differences in stress levels are interpreted as potential indicators of deception.
-
Cheating the Polygraph:
- The article mentions a simple way to cheat the polygraph by deliberately distorting physiological readings when telling the truth. Examples include biting your tongue or imagining an embarrassing incident in the past. This emphasizes the vulnerability of relying solely on physiological measures for lie detection.
-
Baseline for Comparison:
- The effectiveness of polygraph tests and brain scan lie detectors depends on establishing a reliable baseline. A baseline is necessary to compare physiological responses when a person is telling the truth against those when they may be lying. Without a consistent baseline, the accuracy of the test is compromised.
-
Brain Scan Lie Detectors:
- The article briefly touches upon brain scan lie detectors, which operate on a similar principle to polygraphs. They also require a baseline against which to compare signs of lying. These detectors often use functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) or other neuroimaging techniques to observe brain activity during questioning.
-
Issues with Lie Detection Methods:
- Both polygraph tests and brain scan lie detectors face challenges related to the need for a reliable baseline. Deliberate attempts by individuals to manipulate physiological readings pose a significant problem, highlighting the limitations of solely relying on these methods for detecting deception.
In conclusion, the article sheds light on the challenges and vulnerabilities associated with lie detection methods, emphasizing the need for a nuanced understanding of the physiological indicators and the importance of establishing a solid baseline for accurate interpretation.
