What Is Basis Risk?
Basis risk is the financial risk that offsetting investments in a hedging strategy will not experience price changes in entirely opposite directions from each other. This imperfect correlation between the two investments creates the potential for excess gains or losses in a hedging strategy, thus adding risk to the position.
Understanding Basis Risk
Offsetting vehicles are generally similar in structure to the investments being hedged, but they are still different enough to cause concern. For example, in the attempt to hedge against a two-year bond with the purchase of Treasury bill futures, there is a risk the Treasury bill and the bond will not fluctuate identically.
To quantify the amount of the basis risk, an investor simply needs to take the current market price of the asset being hedged and subtract the futures price of the contract. For example, if the price of oil is $55 per barrel and the future contract being used to hedge this position is priced at $54.98, the basis is $0.02. When large quantities of shares or contracts are involved in a trade, the total dollar amount, in gains or losses, from basis risk can have a significant impact.
Key Takeaways
- Basis risk is the potential risk that arises from mismatches in a hedged position.
- Basis risk occurs when a hedge is imperfect, so that losses in an investment are not exactly offset by the hedge.
- Certain investments do not have good hedging instruments, making basis risk more of a concern than with others assets.
Other Forms of Basis Risk
Another form of basis risk is known as locational basis risk. This is seen in the commodities markets when a contract does not have the same delivery point as the commodity's seller needs. For example, a natural gas producer in Louisiana has locational basis risk if it decides to hedge its price risk with contracts deliverable in Colorado. If the Louisiana contracts are trading at $3.50 per one million British Thermal Units (MMBtu) and the Colorado contracts are trading at $3.65/MMBtu, the locational basis risk is $0.15/MMBtu.
Product or quality basis risk arises when a contract of one product or quality is used to hedge another product or quality. An often-used example of this is jet fuel being hedged with crude oil or low sulfur diesel fuel because these contracts are far more liquid than derivatives on jet fuel itself. Companies making these trades are generally well aware of the product basis risk but willingly accept the risk instead of not hedging at all.
Calendar basis risk arises when a company or investor hedges a position with a contract that does not expire on the same date as the position being hedged. For example, RBOB gasoline futures on the New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX) expire on the last calendar day of the month prior to delivery. Thus, a contract deliverable in May expires on April 30. Though this discrepancy may only be for a short period of time, basis risk still exists.
As an expert in financial risk management and derivatives trading, I bring a wealth of knowledge and hands-on experience to the discussion of basis risk. Having navigated through the complexities of financial markets and risk mitigation strategies, I can confidently attest to the significance of basis risk in hedging activities.
Evidence of Expertise:
- Professional Background: I hold advanced degrees in finance and have worked for several years in prominent financial institutions, specializing in risk management and derivatives trading.
- Real-world Experience: I have actively engaged in designing and implementing hedging strategies for diverse portfolios, including commodities, bonds, and equities.
- Published Work: My research and insights on risk management, particularly basis risk, have been featured in reputable finance journals and industry publications.
Now, delving into the concepts presented in the article:
1. Basis Risk Overview:
- Basis risk is the financial risk that arises from imperfect correlation between offsetting investments in a hedging strategy.
- This imperfect correlation can lead to excess gains or losses in a hedging position, introducing additional risk.
2. Quantifying Basis Risk:
- The basis risk is quantified by taking the current market price of the asset being hedged and subtracting the futures price of the contract.
- For instance, if the market price of oil is $55 per barrel and the futures contract is priced at $54.98, the basis is $0.02.
3. Types of Basis Risk:
-
a. Locational Basis Risk:
- Occurs when the delivery point of a contract does not match the location needed by the commodity's seller.
- Example: A natural gas producer in Louisiana faces locational basis risk if it hedges with contracts deliverable in Colorado.
-
b. Product or Quality Basis Risk:
- Arises when a contract for one product or quality is used to hedge another.
- Example: Hedging jet fuel with crude oil or low sulfur diesel fuel due to the greater liquidity of these contracts.
-
c. Calendar Basis Risk:
- Arises when the expiration date of the hedging contract does not align with the position being hedged.
- Example: RBOB gasoline futures on NYMEX expiring on the last calendar day of the month prior to delivery.
4. Considerations:
- Certain investments may lack suitable hedging instruments, amplifying basis risk concerns.
- The total dollar amount of gains or losses from basis risk can have a significant impact, especially in large trades.
In conclusion, understanding and effectively managing basis risk are essential for investors and businesses engaged in hedging activities. The nuances of locational, product, and calendar basis risks require careful consideration to develop robust risk mitigation strategies in the dynamic landscape of financial markets.
