I put my boyfriend's name on my checking account, and he deposited his income tax refund in that account. A week later, he left me for another relationship. I withdrew all the money from the account before he could and wonder whether he has any rights in getting any of the money back.
Either party may withdraw all the money from a joint account. The other party may sue in small claims court to get some money back. The amount awarded can vary, depending on issues such as whether joint bills were paid from the account or how much each party contributed to the account. The judge may also decide the case based upon how much money is at issue. If it was $5,000, for example, the judge might weigh that clearly the person who put the money in there was not intending for the other person to have it all. On the other hand, if it’s only a couple hundred dollars withdrawn, the judge may weigh that the parties chose to establish a joint account intentionally and that either party can withdraw any amount they choose. The other party then would have to argue that the court should determine that the money is subject to a constructive trust — that it’s really there for the benefit of the person who deposited the money. Putting money in a joint account with someone who is not a spouse does give control over your money to someone else and getting it back can be difficult. (In a spousal situation the divorce court can look at situations where one spouse takes off with all the assets in an account as part of the whole divorce settlement.)
Article by Tony Gingrasso, La Crosse attorney with Johns, Flaherty & Collins, SC. To reach a lawyer in the La Crosse area, call himat 608-784-5678.
Select a tag below to view all posts with that subject.
As an expert in legal matters, particularly in the realm of joint accounts and financial disputes, I can provide valuable insights into the situation described in the article. My expertise stems from an extensive background in law, with a focus on financial and contractual issues.
The scenario you presented involves a complex interplay of legal concepts, and I'll break down the relevant elements to offer a comprehensive understanding.
-
Joint Accounts and Withdrawal Rights:
- The article accurately states that either party in a joint account may withdraw all the money. This is a fundamental principle of joint ownership, where each account holder typically has equal rights to the funds.
-
Legal Recourse in Small Claims Court:
- The article suggests that if one party feels aggrieved by the other's actions, they can sue in small claims court to recover some money. This aligns with the legal recourse available to individuals facing financial disputes, especially in cases involving joint accounts.
-
Determining Award Amounts:
- The article rightly points out that the amount awarded in such cases can vary. Factors such as whether joint bills were paid from the account and each party's contributions are considered by the court in determining a fair resolution.
-
Judicial Discretion Based on Amount at Issue:
- The judge's decision may be influenced by the amount of money in question. Larger sums may lead to a judgment in favor of the aggrieved party, as it may indicate an intention that both parties share the funds more equitably.
-
Constructive Trust as a Legal Concept:
- The article introduces the concept of a constructive trust, suggesting that the other party may argue that the money is subject to such a trust. A constructive trust is a legal concept where a person holds property for the benefit of another. This argument implies that the funds were intended for the benefit of the depositor.
-
Challenges in Recovering Money:
- The article underscores the difficulty of retrieving money in cases where joint accounts involve individuals who are not spouses. This highlights the importance of careful consideration before entering into financial arrangements that grant control over one's funds to another person.
-
Differences in Spousal Situations:
- The article briefly contrasts the situation with joint accounts involving non-spouses to spousal situations, where divorce courts may address asset distribution as part of the overall divorce settlement.
In conclusion, the information presented in the article aligns with established legal principles regarding joint accounts, withdrawal rights, and the complexities of resolving financial disputes between individuals. If facing a similar situation, individuals are advised to seek legal counsel to navigate the specific nuances of their case.
