7 Best Car Insurance Companies Side by Side Comparison | ConsumerAffairs® (2024)

Provides coverage exclusively for AARP members. Features include lifetime repair assurance, 24/7 claims, accident forgiveness and disappearing deductibles. Gives quotes in as little as eight minutes.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Insures all types of drivers, including those with accident history or poor credit. Offers budget-sensitive payment plans. Use the app to make payments, start a claim or get support. Get a free quote in two minutes.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Provides standard car insurance protections and optional coverages like accident forgiveness, roadside assistance, vanishing deductibles and total loss deductible waivers. Save multiple ways. Free annual On Your Side reviews.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers car insurance in 12 states and Washington, D.C., with locked rates, accident forgiveness, diminishing deductibles, roadside assistance, pet coverage and glass repair. Local agents help find discounts and make claims.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Provides car insurance exclusively through independent agents. Standard features include claims-free cashback and diminishing deductibles. Save by enrolling in RightTrack. Use the app to obtain ID cards and pay bills.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Customizes car insurance so you pay only for what you need. Has add-ons for new vehicle replacement, accident forgiveness and deductible savings. Over 15 types of discounts. Use the app to get ID cards, pay a bill or file a claim.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Customized car insurance to fit your needs. Offers accident forgiveness, OEM parts coverage, newer car replacement, deductible dividends, roadside assistance and rental coverage. Manage your account through the app.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Provides auto insurance through regional clubs. May require membership in order to purchase a policy. Provides roadside assistance, discounts and deals, travel planning tools and financial services to over 57 million members.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

One of the largest auto insurers in the U.S. Offers personalized service from agents nationwide. Safe driver, safe vehicle and loyal customer discounts. Manage insurance, get roadside assistance and file a claim using the app.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers car insurance to current and former military members, their spouses and their children. Flexible payment plans with no upfront payment. Free accident forgiveness after five years if you have no at-fault accidents.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Protects drivers with standard and specialty coverages. Policies include claim satisfaction guarantee, Drivewise and Allstate Rewards. Accident forgiveness and roadside assistance add-ons. Offers more than 10 types of discounts.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

AAA club serving 13 counties. Policyholders save with yearly dividends. Get a lifetime workmanship warranty on repairs at qualifying shops. Offers a complimentary policy review to go over coverage options and discounts.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers car insurance and classic car insurance. Masterpiece coverage includes access to specialists, rental insurance up to $15,000, child seat replacement and pet injury payments. Save by combining auto and home policies.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Operates an online insurance marketplace with access to over 100 companies. Fill out a simple application and get connected with up to four car insurance offers in minutes at no cost. Offers online insurance calculators and tools.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers car insurance for as little as $1 a day. Customers have access to 40 insurance carriers. Provides services in Spanish. Also offers tax preparation services. Contact for free quotes and information about discounts.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

See car insurance within your budget with the Name Your Price tool. Get a personalized rate based on your driving with Snapshot. 99% of drivers earn at least one of multiple discounts. Insures over 20 million drivers.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Covers drivers in Alabama, Mississippi and Georgia. Get discounts for insuring multiple vehicles, taking a defensive driving course, having a qualifying occupation or using safety features. Alfa2Go app helps manage policies.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers auto insurance in 26 states, with Protect Your Wallet, Protect Your Sanity and family protection coverage options. Multiple discounts available. Choose from various payment plans. Get a quote in just minutes online.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers roadside assistance and new car replacement as standard coverage. Add-on options include rental car reimbursem*nt. More than 12 discount opportunities available. Provides resources through its online learning center.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers insurance for drivers in Illinois, Indiana, Pennsylvania and Tennessee. English- and Spanish-speaking agents. Accepts drivers licensed in Mexico and unlicensed drivers. Multiple discounts available.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers auto insurance with 24/7 customer service. Choose from various payment plans. Provides a range of discount options. Pay your bill, get digital ID cards and file claims on the app. Insures over 28 million vehicles.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Provides car insurance backed by the company’s Pledge of Assurance in Northeastern states. Offers valet claims service, Get Home Safe coverage, rewards for loyal customers and benefits for sports fans. Free quotes online.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers car insurance through independent agents in 26 states. Save by getting a quote in advance, purchasing multiple policies, paying on time, going paperless or being a good student. Promises “No Problem” claims service.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Provides auto insurance to drivers in California and Oregon. Offers discounts for good drivers, mature drivers, loyal customers and those insuring multiple cars. 24/7 claims service. Get a quote online or over the phone.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Covers all types of vehicles, with options for replacement cost coverage and roadside assistance. Save up to 30% through the Driveology safe driving program. Offers discounts for bundling, being claim-free and low mileage.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Hispanic-owned company with over 700 offices in 11 states. Provides quotes to all customers despite poor driving or credit history. Low down payments and convenient monthly payment plans. Claims department open six days a week.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers auto insurance with local agent support. Use MyAmFam app to set up payments, view proof of insurance, get roadside assistance and track claims. Save up to 20% with KnowYourDrive usage program. Over 15 kinds of discounts.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers car insurance for customers in 42 states, including those with no or poor credit, little driving history, accidents or DUIs. Get 24/7 policy access online. Set up a flexible monthly payment plan with a low down payment.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Insures collector and classic cars, trucks and SUVs. Includes instant new purchase coverage, spare parts coverage and auto show medical reimbursem*nt. Responds to claims within one business day and pays most claims within 15 days.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Offers car insurance backed by Allstate. Make claims and pay bills using the mobile app. Gives discounts for using the DriveSense app. Repairs from E-star facilities are guaranteed for life. Get a quote online in six minutes.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Car insurance for all types of drivers. Accepts low down payments and offers flexible payment options. Claims service is available 24/7. Tailors coverage to customers’ needs, working closely with independent agents.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Part of the Farmers family. Provides car insurance in California. Offers driver and vehicle discounts and online tips and resources. Mobile app lets you view ID cards, review and pay bills and make claims. Quotes in minutes.

Focuses on car insurance for Spanish-speaking communities in Illinois, Indiana, Nevada, Arizona and Texas. Works with individuals with Mexican, international or no driver’s licenses. Low down payments and flexible payment plans.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Provides customized policies with 24/7 customer service and flexible payment options. Available services include roadside assistance, replacement coverage for total loss and identity theft protection. Offers multiple discounts.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Specializes in insuring classic cars. Also protects modern muscle cars and exotic vehicles. Agreed value insurance gives you 100% of agreed car value in case of total loss. Combine all vehicles on one policy with “MVP” coverage.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Compares insurance offers from various providers. Requires some personal information, vehicle details and insurance and driving history for quotes. Over 50 million people use its free online service.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Covers drivers and vehicles in Connecticut, New Jersey, Ohio and Pennsylvania. Physical damage coverage includes limited pet coverage, transportation expenses and new car replacement. Offers more than 10 types of discounts.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide

Free online marketplace that matches you with car insurers in minutes. Works with more than 160 insurance companies. Has handled over 35 million quote requests. Offers online resources on car insurance topics.

Chat with a ConsumerAffairs decision guide