5 Pros And 5 Cons Of Consolidating Credit Card Debt (2024)

U.S. household debt continues rising as many Americans still struggle with the effects of inflation and rising interest rates. According to the most recent Quarterly Report on Household Debt and Credit, the American household debt level reached a whopping $16.51 trillion as of the third quarter of 2022—a 2.2% increase from the second quarter. This is $2.36 trillion higher than the pre-pandemic U.S. household debt at the end of 2019.

Rising household debt, while mostly comprised of home mortgages, shows no signs of easing up. Credit cards, student loans, and auto loans still make up a large number, although delinquencies are not nearly as high as they were in the last quarter of 2019.

While mortgages are sometimes, “good debt,” if they are affordable and a good investment, credit card debt is never desirable. According to the report, credit card balances showed a $38 billion increase compared to the second quarter of 2022; a 15% year-over-year increase marked the largest in over 20 years.

Unfortunately, a large portion of American consumers get in over their heads with credit card debt. Many are more vulnerable to debt due to a lack of savings, financial education, and money management skills. This type of information is needed to overcome unforeseen financial hardships like a job loss or medical emergency. When faced with this and other unexpected expenses like a new refrigerator or furnace, most will turn to credit cards to get over the financial hump.

As credit card debt piles up, you might be unaware of where this accumulation of debt is leading. If you do not act accordingly and in a timely manner, you could face limited options when it comes to paying off your debt. One tried and true method is a debt consolidation loan—either through a personal loan, a bank or finance company, or a home equity loan.

People Also Read

Credit Card Debt

How to Protect Yourself from Credit Card Scams

Types of debt consolidation loans

Debt consolidation loans generally package all your debt into one loan with one monthly payment. They generally have a lower interest rate than what you’re currently paying on your credit card and other debt accounts.

By reducing the interest you pay, you can create additional cash flow to better manage day-to-day expenses. This will help keep you from depending on credit cards just to get by. The fact is, using another credit card to pay off existing debt is the worst possible scenario.

The right debt relief option for you is dependent upon your individual circ*mstances, such as credit score and loan size, as well as whether you have sufficient home equity.

Home equity lines of credit (HELOC) are commonly used to consolidate debt. Quite simply, it is an approved line of credit up to a certain amount, which you can borrow against when it’s needed. Similar to a credit card, you only pay interest on the amount you use.

You can use the money drawn off a home equity line of credit for any purpose. The low-interest rate and minimal closing costs usually offered by banks and mortgage companies make these loans attractive. If you’re a homeowner with a good amount of equity in your home and an acceptable credit score, you would be a good candidate for a HELOC.

A home refinance with cash out is another type of mortgage loan. In this instance, you refinance your current mortgage with a new interest rate and new terms. Then borrow additional funds on top of your previous mortgage amount to pay off your other debts. Again, you’ll need to have an acceptable credit score, a good amount of equity in your homes, and be gainfully employed.

A personal loan is a third way for you to consolidate your debts. Banks typically issue unsecured personal loans, meaning there is nothing put up as collateral against the loan, such as a mortgage note. Personal loans require very good credit and generally are not ideal if you have a large amount of debt. Banks have traditionally instituted lending caps on personal loans, and while interest rates are good, the terms are usually short. These loans are ideal if you are looking to pay off your debt quickly.

Pros of a debt consolidation loan

A debt consolidation loan can help you get back on the right financial track. Below are five advantages to consolidating your debts:

1. One payment

For many people, the biggest advantage of debt consolidation is simplifying their financial landscape. By reducing all their monthly payments into one, they feel they have a better path to becoming debt free. In addition, only having one payment reduces the chances of missing a payment, making a late payment, or incurring late fees.

Additionally, only having to deal with one creditor eliminates the need to juggle multiple creditors with varying interest rates. This can simplify the process and reduce the stress associated with debt.

2. Lower payment overall

By obtaining a lower interest rate and a longer term, the payments required on a monthly basis are much less than what you are currently paying. With this extra monthly cash flow, you can deposit the extra funds into an emergency account. By creating this type of account and contributing to it on a regular basis, you can avoid relying on a credit card in the event of an unexpected expense.

3. Better interest rate

If market conditions are favorable, there is a good chance you can refinance your mortgage at a lower interest rate. In addition, you can swap your credit card for a lower interest rate or call your credit card company and request a rate reduction. As more of your money goes toward paying the principal balance, you can pay off your loans quicker and for less money.

4. Get caught up

If you are struggling to keep up with your payments or you have fallen behind, you can get a fresh start through debt consolidation. Taking a break from the stress of making multiple payments to multiple creditors is sometimes enough to put you back on the road to good financial management. If you’re struggling every month and having a difficult time making ends meet, this type of loan can get you back on your feet.

5. Avoid damage to your credit

If you’ve been struggling for some time with debt and have missed or made late payments, you can avoid further damage to your credit by having your debt consolidated. The quicker the better, as missed and late payments can affect your ability to qualify and hurt your credit score. Your credit score can quickly recover from a late payment here or there, but an established history of inconsistent payments can hurt your eligibility for new credit.

Cons of a debt consolidation loan

There are some very good upsides to taking out a debt consolidation loan. However, some potential drawbacks exist that you should be aware of before taking this important step.

1. High closing costs

Many mortgage-based debt consolidation solutions such as a home refinance with cash out can carry significant closing costs. These can often run into thousands of dollars and add significantly to the balance of your new loan. You have the option of paying these fees upfront but if you’re looking to consolidate your debt, you probably won’t have this kind of cash lying around.

2. You could end up running up more debt

If you aren’t committed to making the debt consolidation process work due to a lack of spending discipline, the chances are slim that you’ll suddenly stop racking up debt—which will only make your situation more critical. It’s important that you close your credit card accounts and change your spending habits to avoid putting yourself and your finances in an even worse situation.

3. You pay more interest over the long term

If you choose to tap into the equity in your home, there is a good chance you could pay more interest over the life of the loan. Mortgage notes usually have long terms, typically 30 years. Even though the interest rate is much lower than that of your credit cards, you could pay more interest in the end because you will be paying off your balance for a much longer term.

4. You don’t learn the hard lessons

When you put in the hard work of paying off your debts through sacrifice and determination, you’ll probably learn a valuable lesson along the way. Your chances of falling back into debt are slim compared to those who have essentially swept their debt under the rug through other methods that simply let you borrow more money.

5. You put valuable assets at risk

When you roll your credit card debt into your home mortgage, you are essentially putting your home at risk if you don’t keep up with your monthly payments. The lender “secures” your debt with the property to protect themselves if you default on the loan. They have the right to sell your house to collect what you owe.

When the pros outweigh the cons

Debt consolidation can be a good solution if have good credit and the discipline to make monthly payments. Working with a debt relief company such as National Debt Relief can help you determine the best solution to settle your debts with your creditors and get back to living your good life.

5 Pros And 5 Cons Of Consolidating Credit Card Debt (2024)

FAQs

5 Pros And 5 Cons Of Consolidating Credit Card Debt? ›

Debt consolidation might lower your monthly payments, make managing your monthly payments easier, decrease your interest rates and save you money overall. But there are also potential drawbacks, such as upfront fees and the risk of winding up deeper in debt.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of consolidation? ›

Debt consolidation might lower your monthly payments, make managing your monthly payments easier, decrease your interest rates and save you money overall. But there are also potential drawbacks, such as upfront fees and the risk of winding up deeper in debt.

What are 4 things debt consolidation can do? ›

Four types of debt are commonly consolidated: credit card debt, student loan debt, medical debt and high-interest personal loan debt. You may reduce the overall cost of repayment by securing better terms and interest. You'll also have a single payment to keep track of instead of several.

What are some disadvantages to consolidating your loans? ›

Consolidation has potential downsides, too:
  • Because consolidation can lengthen your repayment period, you'll likely pay more in interest over the long run. ...
  • You might lose borrower benefits such as interest rate discounts, principal rebates, or some loan cancellation benefits associated with your current loans.

What impact did consolidating credit card debt have on individuals? ›

Debt consolidation — combining multiple debt balances into one new loan — is likely to raise your credit scores over the long term if you use it to pay off debt. But it's possible you'll see a decline in your credit scores at first. That can be OK, as long as you make payments on time and don't rack up more debt.

What are the negative effects of consolidation? ›

Cons
  • You may not get approved for a lower interest rate. The interest rate you receive for any new loan or line of credit will depend on your credit score and credit report. ...
  • You can face additional damage from late payments. ...
  • Debt consolidation won't keep you out of debt.

What is the advantage of debt consolidation? ›

The biggest advantage of debt consolidation is paying off your debt at a lower interest rate, which saves money. For example, if you have $9,000 in total debt with a combined APR of 25% and a combined monthly payment of $500, you'll pay $2,500 in interest over about two years.

What risk does debt consolidation bring? ›

You may pay a higher rate

Your debt consolidation loan could come with more interest than you currently pay on your debts. This can happen for several reasons, including your current credit score. If it's on the lower end, lenders see you as a higher risk for default.

Is it best to consolidate credit card debt? ›

Is it a good idea to consolidate credit cards? Consolidate your debt if you can get a better interest rate and/or it will help you make payments on time. Just make sure this consolidation is part of a larger plan to get out of debt and you don't run up new balances on the cards you've consolidated.

Does debt consolidation destroy credit? ›

If you do it right, debt consolidation might slightly decrease your score temporarily. The drop will come from a hard inquiry that appears on your credit reports every time you apply for credit. But, according to Experian, the decrease is normally less than 5 points and your score should rebound within a few months.

Why is it so hard to consolidate debt? ›

Lenders might not advertise it, but most of them have a minimum credit score required to get a loan. If your score is less than 670, you might be out of luck for a debt consolidation loan. Even if you're over 670, a problematic debt-to-income ratio (more on that below) or payment history could derail your loan.

Why should you consolidate your debt? ›

The key advantages are: One single set of recurring repayments that are easier to manage. A clearer timeline of when you can be debt-free. Greater control of your budget and cash flow.

How much debt is too much to consolidate? ›

Debt-to-income ratio

A high DTI can preclude you from qualifying for new debt accounts. Check Out: What Is Credit Card Consolidation? Good to know: A good DTI is generally considered to be anything below 36%, but you can qualify for certain loans with one that's higher.

Who is the most reputable debt consolidation company? ›

Best debt relief companies
  • Best for debt support: Accredited Debt Relief.
  • Best for customer satisfaction: Americor.
  • Best for large debts: National Debt Relief.
  • Best for credit card debt: Freedom Debt Relief.
  • Best for affordability: New Era Debt Solutions.
  • Best longstanding company: Pacific Debt Relief.
6 days ago

Does debt consolidation go against you? ›

Do debt consolidation loans hurt your credit? You might see a small dip in your credit score after you take out the loan because your lender will run a hard credit check. Luckily, this usually only lowers your credit score by five points or less, and after a year it won't affect your credit score at all.

Do you lose your credit cards after debt consolidation? ›

If you get approved for the card, the creditor will not require you to close your other cards. And even with a debt consolidation loan, you may only face an account closure restriction in some cases.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of consolidated financial statements? ›

Advantages & Disadvantages
AdvantagesDisadvantages
It provides valuable information for making an investment, credit, and other financial decisions related to the group.The statements may distort the group's financial performance due to differences in accounting policies or practices between subsidiaries.
3 more rows
Jul 3, 2023

Is it a bad idea to consolidate debt? ›

Debt consolidation can help your credit if you make on-time payments or if consolidating shrinks your credit card balances. Your credit may be hurt if you run up credit card balances again, close most or all of your remaining cards, or miss a payment on your debt consolidation loan.

How long does a debt consolidation stay on your credit? ›

Debt consolidation itself doesn't show up on your credit reports, but any new loans or credit card accounts you open to consolidate your debt will. Most accounts will show up for 10 years after you close them, and any missed payments will show up for seven years from the date you missed the payment.

What are some disadvantages of a consolidated government? ›

The Cons of Consolidation

Changes in Structure: County and city governments are each used to operating with a certain structure. If consolidation occurs that structure will change for both jurisdictions. Counties operate with what is largely a “politically dominated”, fragmented Page 5 5 structure.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Mr. See Jast

Last Updated:

Views: 6467

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Mr. See Jast

Birthday: 1999-07-30

Address: 8409 Megan Mountain, New Mathew, MT 44997-8193

Phone: +5023589614038

Job: Chief Executive

Hobby: Leather crafting, Flag Football, Candle making, Flying, Poi, Gunsmithing, Swimming

Introduction: My name is Mr. See Jast, I am a open, jolly, gorgeous, courageous, inexpensive, friendly, homely person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.